RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


ProlificNeeds -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 7:25:04 AM)

The 'vague' quality of the original topic starter was partially intentional, partially due to a fresh idea not sticking well inside a sleep clouded mind, for that I apologize. However I have seen some very good responses, most of them encouraging.

Baggage and skeletons in this particular instance I used to encompass all things, vices, limits, any negative reactions you may have, or any past experiences that you know -will- come up if you enter into a deep relationship.

Example: "A family member is very ill but we are still trying to give her/him homecare." A very stressful addition to ones life, emotionally and physically at times. I also consider that baggage because you -haven't- learned to cope yet, it's still in the process. I also don't believe you should 'hold off' and potentially lose a connection you have with someone because you need to go off alone and take care of your problems. If they are willing to accept everything that's going on in your life, even help you with it, then why risk losing the opportunity? If they aren't willing to take that string attached to you, then you know up front and you'll never ask yourself down the road, "Should I have told them?"

Several of the Dom/me's had the answer I was trying to fumble for, knowing the sub. That means all the dark bits in the past. Someone had said to me before, submission, when experiencing it at the hands of another and not just in self exploration alone, is very much different, because suddenly someone else is poking around those dark bits inside your head with you (not an exact quote but the same general idea).

I'll give you a very prime idea of why this topic came to me at such an ungodly hour now. I won't put in specifics so I apologize for any vagueness but the discussion that prompted these thoughts were with an individual who does surf here and I would not want to offend with any direct violation of privacy.

I ended up in a conversation that was not unpleasent, but was definitely far deeper than it had started out, speaking about life experiences has a tendancy to do that. I am unsure why, perhaps because I had already related some of my own life difficulties that I have more than learned to move beyond, it was more of a comparison of human aspects and society. I had ended up asking a question, innocently, almost as a jest really, expecting a simple answer. The one I got was not. It wasn't a bombshell, I didn't want to go fleeing in the other direction, I didn't feel put upon, nor was it an emo-fest. It was a very well phrased answer, that suddenly blew open a portion of his past, that still does effect him, and possibly will for the rest of his life I'm sure. Immediate reaction, comfort somehow, next reaction, 'don't crowd or push' third reaction, 'is he actually still suffering, maybe he's over it' and so on down the list, before I ever made a reply. It was probably more emotional for -me- knowing he would share something so private, than it was for him, but it had direct baring on an inconsistancy within my own personality and behavior. One that potentially could repeat a certain set of emotions or circumstances from his past. To some people it wouldn't be a big deal, for me obviously it was because it was a behavior I hadn't mastered in myself.
So do you let the topic lay, or do you return fire with a volley of your own since the waters seem calm? Again another call based on moods and reactions, I came clean about my own behavioral vice and when it has a tendancy to crop up. There was no drawing away, and he understood perfectly why I had told him, as a means to perhaps reassure him. More importantly I think, though it seems early, revealing two very prominent issues for us helped us find another level of comfort that otherwise may never had come without a more emotional moment attached to it.(I say interest because I wouldn't call it true attachment or investment yet, beyond a friendship level)

Of course afterwards I begin kicking myself in the ass, the intial conditioning is to hide your ugly bits and present all your natural beauty and radiant charm ect. So, hoping to salvage any perception flaws that might have occured, I simply expressed my concern that I didn't want him to think ill of me and I hope I hadn't turned him off to a degree with the revelation. His sentiment was much the same, but as we continued the chat, he made it quite clear, if we do invest in a relationship beyond friendship, things like that will come out in time, because he -wants- to know them. He also made it quite clear he would find personal pride and accomplishment in helping me become a better person, it wouldn't be alone.

Of course, the girl in me goes "awwww" the wiser woman goes "Did he get that perfect response from a text book?!" My obvious desire is to believe this is his true sentiment and not just what we want to hear. We've discussed a great many things outside BDSM related topics, and based on his life views, the response seems to fit, that's just how he is. So as another step in deciding if there's something more to the image I came trolling on over to my internet and started hunting and asking(as most people don't appreciate if you call them at 2am in the morning).

My original comment, about D/s relations starting with the ugly bits was completely out of context, and not a blanket statement but I couldn't display the rest of the conversation so I left it out there to provoke any and all reactions it might recieve as a stand alone comment. The rest of the conversation happened to be about communication and being open with a partner in a relationship. We had been discussing how in many vanilla relationships, it seems people try to hide what they consider 'deviant' behavior until later on, while in BDSM people seem far more willing to be up front, "I want this, and not this." When it comes to their sexual appetites, limits, and even about what they expect from their partner. So often I see very good advice from BDSM communities and sources that could easily apply to vanilla couples or relationships, and I have to wonder, -why- are the relationships so inherantly different. The only conclusion I could come up with is because in BDSM, for safety and sanity, you usually -have- to be upfront and honest about a great many things, the good and the bad.

So take it for what you may but I thank all of you for the responses, I got to see both sides of the fence on the topic which was perfect.

------edited for typos, though I'm sure some still got away -----




LuckyAlbatross -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 7:25:04 AM)

quote:

quote]
prolific_needs: I've suddenly come to realize... in vanilla, people try to hide their baggage, and form a relationship based on only the good parts.

Do not fool yourself with that outright lie.  Plenty of vanilla people have open and honest relationships based on reality.

And PLENTY of people in Ds form relationships based only on the good parts.
quote:


prolific_needs: .... in D/s... you start by hauling out all the baggage and negativity first... and working from there to improve...

I agree with Dark- what gave you this idea?  This certainly isn't how I've started any of my relationships, or how most people I know have.
quote:


It's 2:30am when this realization decided to force it's way into my head, is it accurate? Do many D/s relationships start off with dredging up the ugly bits first and working from there? (After the obvious get-to-know-you period, but before/during the drawing of terms and expectations).

It's a process over time.  You know more and more and more, as you know more, the pieces fall together better.  You're dealing with a fairly well formed decades old conscious being- no short cuts apply.  Personally I find it people want to dredge stuff up right away on either end, it makes me back WAY off from them.  I'm not someone's cup to fill or to fill another's.  For me, we're all here for eachother.




gypsygrl -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 7:54:07 AM)

Just a thought:  What someone considers 'skeletons' or negative is relative to their experience.  Some people's lives are simpler than others and if you've led a pretty straight forward existence without a lot of challenges, it may seem like someone's dumping their shit on you and unloading all their personal issues, when they're only scratching the surface of what could possibly be said.

My life's not simple.  There's things I deal with on a daily basis that would probably shock most whitebread folks.  The good side is that its hard to shock me.

When all is said and done, its a compatibility issue.  If one person feels overwhelmed by the other, its important information.  I often feel underwhelmed.   That's important information too.






LuckyAlbatross -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 7:59:32 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ProlificNeeds
Of course, the girl in me goes "awwww" the wiser woman goes "Did he get that perfect response from a text book?!" My obvious desire is to believe this is his true sentiment and not just what we want to hear. We've discussed a great many things outside BDSM related topics, and based on his life views, the response seems to fit, that's just how he is. So as another step in deciding if there's something more to the image I came trolling on over to my internet and started hunting and asking(as most people don't appreciate if you call them at 2am in the morning).

Those are great words.  But it will still take months or years to discover if that is how it can be, or if he's really good FOR YOU.

quote:

So often I see very good advice from BDSM communities and sources that could easily apply to vanilla couples or relationships, and I have to wonder, -why- are the relationships so inherantly different. The only conclusion I could come up with is because in BDSM, for safety and sanity, you usually -have- to be upfront and honest about a great many things, the good and the bad.

The problem is that you're assuming:
a) vanilla relationships are crap a lot of the time
b) bdsm relationships are not crap a lot of the time

The reality is:
c) there's no difference between vanilla or bdsm relationships regarding their crap level, just as many are great, and just as many are crap

Each type of relationship needs good strong communication to make it worth in the long term.




ProlificNeeds -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:05:32 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LuckyAlbatross

quote:

So often I see very good advice from BDSM communities and sources that could easily apply to vanilla couples or relationships, and I have to wonder, -why- are the relationships so inherantly different. The only conclusion I could come up with is because in BDSM, for safety and sanity, you usually -have- to be upfront and honest about a great many things, the good and the bad.

The problem is that you're assuming:
a) vanilla relationships are crap a lot of the time
b) bdsm relationships are not crap a lot of the time

The reality is:
c) there's no difference between vanilla or bdsm relationships regarding their crap level, just as many are great, and just as many are crap

Each type of relationship needs good strong communication to make it worth in the long term.


Ha fair enough I'll conceed that, my perceptions are obvious weighted by what I see and experience directly.




LuckyAlbatross -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:15:56 AM)

Prolific, so you haven't seen the two dozen threads since you've gotten here talking about all the relationship problems, lack of honesty, conflicts and other issues people are having in their relationships?

I mean that's why we keep GIVING all this advice, because so many people have all these problems.  You said yourself that all this advice could be applied just as it is to vanilla relationships- that's because all these threads are people having problems JUST like vanilla relationships do.




slaveish -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:29:54 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ProlificNeeds

the intial conditioning is to hide your ugly bits and present all your natural beauty and radiant charm ect. I simply expressed my concern . His sentiment was much the same, but he made it quite clear things like that will come out in time, because he -wants- to know them. He also made it quite clear he would find personal pride and accomplishment in helping me become a better person, it wouldn't be alone. Of course, the girl in me goes "awwww" the wiser woman goes "Did he get that perfect response from a text book?!" My obvious desire is to believe this is his true sentiment and not just what we want to hear.


Trust can be difficult indeed; however, if you give him a false impression, trying to be the person you ~think~ he wants you to be, you are only going to frustrate yourself and confuse him. Be who you are with no apology for it. Stand strong in yourself. It is all you can do to maintain a healthy relationship - a relationship built on lies will crash down around your ears eventually, and for any number of reasons. Be honest and true to yourself and expect the same from him.




RavenMuse -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:37:05 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: dawntreader
i don't feel i have baggage so much as life experiences that have shaped me...some for the good, others not so good. Baggage appears to me something that you carry with you into each new relationship hoping someone will not only accept it but help you fix it. i did this once or twice until it became clear that it was up to me to fix myself so the end result is not baggage but hopefully a stronger more complete person.


I am not arrogant enough to assume I can 'fix' everything, for one thing you can't help someone if they don't honestly work with you.... but with the kind of dynamic I look for, she does work with Me. But what I can't 'fix' I can support, help and advise her in 'fixing' herself.

But more importantly than 'fixing' is 'understanding'. Much baggage tands to skew reactions to certain events, oft adding emotional weight beyond what would normaly be encountered from a certain event. Something seemingly small can evoke a huge reaction because it triggers off something in her past. If I am well aware of that past, fully informed, whilst I might not spot everything of that nature comming, I can normaly spot the type of reaction and have a good idea where it maybe comming from rather than being totaly blindsided by some new major problem.

When such thing hits, isn't often a good time to be able to get the relevant info from her, not when she has just been bit in the arse by some of her baggage issues, but being familiar with her issues, her baggage I have a much better handle on how to help her.... which is good for her, good for Me and good for the relationship as a whole. The situation gets dealt with far smoother and at a later, calmer time, it can be gone into more deeply and find out WHY this new trigger maybe there AND increasing My knowledge and understanding of My girl.




Emperor1956 -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:38:22 AM)

FR:

I find it interesting how many people here can make absolute statements about "baggage" (both re: never hiding or immediately exposing) without having a clue what the OP was talking about (and I admit, I don't know what she was talking about, either).

Is "baggage" that you feel a bit insecure in your chosen role as a Top or a bottom?  Or you hate to be seen naked?  Or that you get embarassed when you cum?

Or is your form of luggage that you are HIV+, or have herpes, or have a colostomy hidden under that Elizabethan gown?

Is it that you forgot you are married?

Is it that Interpol warrant?  You might remember that piece of luggage BEFORE your new love of your life whisks you off to Paris for the weekend.

It seems to me that "baggage" is no different than anything else:  Either you are a liar, or you are honest.  As it is relevant, you talk about yourself.  If you are self-aggrandizing (and trotting out the worst possible things about yourself too early is a perverse sort of self-aggrandizement) or if you are lying by omission, you are still being dishonest.

E.





mstrjx -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:42:29 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Emperor1956

Is it that you forgot you are married?



DAMMIT!!! I just KNEW there was something that wasn't coming up in chat.  Thanks for the reminder.

Jeff 




Emperor1956 -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:53:25 AM)

quote:


quote:

ORIGINAL: Emperor1956

Is it that you forgot you are married?




DAMMIT!!! I just KNEW there was something that wasn't coming up in chat.  Thanks for the reminder.

Jeff 


This is like the question my wife had to edit once that began with "I've been seeing a girl for about 5 months now, and she told me the other day that she was married to a man who left her over two years ago.  She said she meant to tell me sooner, but she was always so happy to see me that she forgot..."

Of course my FAVORITE was "This guy I work with and I sort of accidentally had sex one day and..."      

How did this happen?  Well, you see, it was No Pants Friday in the office, and I was standing on a step stool reaching up for a toner cartridge when I slipped and fell on him and...well....

E.




dawntreader -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:56:43 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: RavenMuse

But more importantly than 'fixing' is 'understanding'. Much baggage tands to skew reactions to certain events, oft adding emotional weight beyond what would normaly be encountered from a certain event. Something seemingly small can evoke a huge reaction because it triggers off something in her past. If I am well aware of that past, fully informed, whilst I might not spot everything of that nature comming, I can normaly spot the type of reaction and have a good idea where it maybe comming from rather than being totaly blindsided by some new major problem.



Greetings RavenMuse,
 
Again, i appreciate your explanation and believe your girl is a very fortunate girl.
 
This has not been my past experience and i have always been expected to deal with and resolve my own issues...even those things one does not realize are issues until the "trigger" reveals them. Perhaps i am jaded - but as one learns from experience ... all mine thus far have taught me to handle my own issues and then present a "better package" for consideration. i certainly believe honesty is key, but i assure you, i use a great deal of discretion these days in what i will reveal~
 
And the funny thing about it is i have no real skeletons or major issues... i suppose my choices have all been bigger perfectionists than myself...




mythi -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 8:58:13 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: mstrjx

quote:

ORIGINAL: Emperor1956

Is it that you forgot you are married?



DAMMIT!!! I just KNEW there was something that wasn't coming up in chat.  Thanks for the reminder.

Jeff 


No, we covered that too.  Very early in the negotiations in fact. *g*




bliss1 -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 10:58:41 AM)

Speaking from experience here. With the help of a therapist I thought I had worked on some of my baggage (molested by my father's brother before I was six.) and had it all taken care off.

I didn't share this with my then husband because I thought it had all been dealt with. One night he touched me in a manner that caused all that old hurt, shame, and fear to come rushing back at me. Almost 30 years after the events. It totally freaked us both out.

Had I shared this with him, he could of been more supporative and less fearful. I would of known how to speak to him without shame after my "breakdown".

Baggage does stay with you, even with help. If nothing else - in the proper time - let your partner know about ALL events in your life, good and bad. You just never know when there may be more under the surface.

Blessed Be




viperess -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/23/2007 2:44:23 PM)

Greetings all,
i will admit to not reading all the responses before posting this but it is a good topic. As a slave of many years i will admit to carrying some baggage around. One of the things i noticed that to me set Master above many i have know is He wished and demanded to know of it for a few different reasons. For one to get to know me and the workings of my mind, for another for saftey reasons, and third to help me work through it. It made me have even more respect for Him than i already did. A good example is i was hospitalized due to a major beating with a cane a few years back...so for me while i love flogging, cats, whips, cane i shy from...no they are not a hard limit as i have none with Master but when He had me answer some questions of what i have and have not done, things i liked and disliked, We then talked about the whys of it. If He would have just started whipping me with a cane it would have been hard to take even though i would take it...but since He knew of this it was something we could work on. There are other things and some which triggered nightmares in the past but since He took the time to get to know me He has lead me through those. To me that is just the sign of a good and caring Master, one who cares about His property.
Respectfully




ennaozzie -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/24/2007 7:49:04 PM)

I guess its not baggage if you have accepted what happend in the past, then again you are not doing yourself a favour if you hang on to what has happend, then you are letting that person that did you a wrong in some way ruin your life, and i can not think of a better way than to waste your life than to let baggage hang around.

I am not saying that all things can be got rid of, but you can move on enough to have a happier life.

beanie




domtimothy46176 -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/24/2007 9:21:17 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ProlificNeeds

prolific_needs: I've suddenly come to realize... in vanilla, people try to hide their baggage, and form a relationship based on only the good parts.
prolific_needs: .... in D/s... you start by hauling out all the baggage and negativity first... and working from there to improve...

It's 2:30am when this realization decided to force it's way into my head, is it accurate? Do many D/s relationships start off with dredging up the ugly bits first and working from there? (After the obvious get-to-know-you period, but before/during the drawing of terms and expectations).


Ours did.  I felt it was my responsibility to ensure that toy understood who I was as a complete person, warts and all, before things got serious.  Anything less would not be satisfactory to me. 

She still claims she would never have entered into my service if she understood I was really  that neurotic about how the towel should be folded.  [sm=ofcourse.gif]

Timothy




AquaticSub -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/24/2007 10:04:12 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ProlificNeeds

prolific_needs: I've suddenly come to realize... in vanilla, people try to hide their baggage, and form a relationship based on only the good parts.
prolific_needs: .... in D/s... you start by hauling out all the baggage and negativity first... and working from there to improve...

It's 2:30am when this realization decided to force it's way into my head, is it accurate? Do many D/s relationships start off with dredging up the ugly bits first and working from there? (After the obvious get-to-know-you period, but before/during the drawing of terms and expectations).


D/s, vanilla, BDSM, or mint chocolate chip - it doesn't make a difference. There are certain things you don't get to know until I think you are going to stick around for a reasonable period of time.




shyinini -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/24/2007 10:34:43 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ProlificNeeds

prolific_needs: I've suddenly come to realize... in vanilla, people try to hide their baggage, and form a relationship based on only the good parts.
prolific_needs: .... in D/s... you start by hauling out all the baggage and negativity first... and working from there to improve...

It's 2:30am when this realization decided to force it's way into my head, is it accurate? Do many D/s relationships start off with dredging up the ugly bits first and working from there? (After the obvious get-to-know-you period, but before/during the drawing of terms and expectations).


As we got to know each other, my baggage came out...he accepted it and has helped me work on it step by step....
maybe I am just very blessed with this man

That was most excellent Timothy.... I am quite sure my ex Dom still has the exact morning routine he had back "then"....nerotic ....[:D]




minnetar -> RE: Baggage, when do you pull your skeletons out? (5/24/2007 11:13:30 PM)

i like to be honest upfront so the Master knows where i am coming from

minnetar




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125