Petronius -> RE: Maybe leaving CM.. A warning (7/15/2007 7:44:36 PM)
|
Synergy wrote quote:
Im still waiting for [Petronius] to clarify why he brought diagnostic methods and DSM-IV into this discussion. (to help us all track posts: RE: Maybe leaving CM.. A warning - 7/15/2007 6:50:10 PM, p. 14. post 278.) I thought she was the one who brought up DSM IV and, inferentially, diagnostic methods. I brought up the notion of paranoid behavior, a concept that existed before DSM IV and even DSM I. The references to DSM IV were, I think, first in a post by Synergy to which I responded. Some terms have meaning in a variety of ways, as with "paranoid" and "paranoia" that may have a very specific definition in places like DSM as well as a broader definition in the English language. Other terms, once used by the psychiatric community cease to be used, but they still have meaning in English. "Hysteria" is, I seem to recall, one of them. I haven't looked over DSM IV in quite a while. But if my memory is correct, the old 'hysterical neurosis" is now "conversion disorder" or "disassociative disorder" and the "histerical personality" has become "histrionic personality disorder." But "hysterical" and "hysteria" are sill in the English language even if they're not in DSM IV. Other terms may no longer appear as a formal diagnostic category in DSM IV but have no real meaning anymore aside from being old psychiatric diagnostic terms. I don't think DSM IV lists "Korsakoff's psychosis" anymore, preferring instead "Alcoholic amnesiac syndrome" but, unlike people seen as hysterical or paranoid, I don't think anybody has every been labeled Korsakoffistic aside from formal diagnostic categorization. But here's a more generic hint to Synergy: if I brought up the term "paranoid" and "paranoia" it is probably because I wanted to state in public that I thought those terms accurate in describing some thing, group, concept, or person. Of course I could always weasel out of the thing by claiming "it was a joke." But I leave that form of dishonesty to others.
|
|
|
|