RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Master



Message


sexyred1 -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 1:29:23 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sweetNsmartBBW

I too agree that consent is the key; but the dom in question seemed to imply that he believed consent was inherent if a woman was submissive.  I told him I'd do no more than meet for coffee at a public place for a first meeting- and he countered with: " (I) met a sweet tender sub once and walked her to her car where I pinned her agains the vehicle and reached in her pants until she came while I held her wrists behind her back - would something like that upset you?" 
.       
"I am a Dom inasmuch as every other recognized Dom says so and ever true sub experiences it as such";  and then continued to accuse me of not being submissive because I disagreed with him.  


My goodness,  I get home from a nightmarish day at work, had a car accident and now just want to relax with the forums, and I read this crap (not you OP, the "Dom" in question).

He is such a moron on so many levels.

A. Just because a woman is submissive, does not make her consent "inherent", jeez.
B. If someone laid their hands on me who I just met for coffee, he would have no hands and probably his balls would ache big time.
C. He is a Dom because other Dom's and subs told him he was? LOL
D. Of course you are not a "true" sub if you disagree with him, I am sure his mama brought him up to believe that crap.

Spare me.




Bobkgin -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 1:37:23 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveish

quote:

ORIGINAL: sweetNsmartBBW

He said that because the men I have met have exercised self restraint they were not 'real' doms.  That of the ~thousands~ of Doms and subs he has met, they have all affirmed that a dom takes what he wants and a REAL sub is submissive to ANY true Dom she meets.  The exact quote was "A sub is a sub". 

<snip> I was told that he would not indulge me with answers because I was not really submissive. He had no notion of the idea of consent being a valid concept- not if the woman in question was submissive.   That not being submissive to ANY 'real dom" makes a submissive  ambivalent or undecided about who she is.  He literally told me that I was the ~one~ exception to the THOUSANDS of subs he knows. 

Oh, and I should mention, when I said I was bringing this to the boards for the opinions of others, I was told that the folks online are "less genuine" than others, and that it would be a futile attempt at self affirmation on my part.

So, my question is this: When is it dominance and when does that cross the line and become abuse/assault?  Do you think a sub female that is NOT in a relationship with you has the right to say no?  (Just playing devil's advocate)



First, what a dipshit. Second, what a blowhard. Third, what a liar.

To answer your questions, it becomes abuse when she indicates "no." A sub female ALWAYS has the right to say no, regardless if she is in a relationship with anyone.

Send this jerkoff my way. I'm feeling kinda fiery and in the mood for a good ... um ... debate.


Careful, Slaveish. With his stunning grasp of 'log-ick' he might prove you're not real either, and then where will you be?

[;)]




Mercnbeth -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 1:38:45 PM)

I guess I had it backward. I never demand or demanded anything from anyone I met. I presented myself, we chatted, and came to a joint decision to move on. Ideally I prefer the idea that a submissive should first display behavior to back up their words that indicated they were suited to my needs. I'm most influence by a good session of begging and pleading by the submissive for the privilege to serve.

The only time there was any 'abuse' during a first meeting was when I met beth - but I forgave her.  




SubOscar -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 2:03:22 PM)

I guess it was abuse when a sub says no.




WillowRain -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 2:12:30 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sweetNsmartBBW

Hi...I have a question that stems from a conversation with a dom that is very active in the local scene and claims to be well respected and accepted.  He gave me the following 'advice':  "...be careful who you meet for coffee as
if they are a true dom and they like you, you wiull not have
a choice about what goes on in your pants by the time you get
back to your car - or are you a sub sho never loses or
control or submits?"

Now, it's good advice, I know- but this Dom was condoning such behavior on the part of  dominants.  He said that because the men I have met have exercised self restraint they were not 'real' doms.  That of the ~thousands~ of Doms and subs he has met, they have all affirmed that a dom takes what he wants and a REAL sub is submissive to ANY true Dom she meets.  The exact quote was "A sub is a sub". 

I'd love to hear some of the views of other Doms, as when I asked for clarification from the one that made the quote- I was told that he would not indulge me with answers because I was not really submissive.  Could be because I accused him of being a sexual predator that hid behind his title and used his dominant orientation as an excuse to victimize women.  He had no notion of the idea of consent being a valid concept- not if the woman in question was submissive.   That not being submissive to ANY 'real dom" makes a submissive  ambivalent or undecided about who she is.  He literally told me that I was the ~one~ exception to the THOUSANDS of subs he knows. 

Oh, and I should mention, when I said I was bringing this to the boards for the opinions of others, I was told that the folks online are "less genuine" than others, and that it would be a futile attempt at self affirmation on my part.

So, my question is this: When is it dominance and when does that cross the line and become abuse/assault?  Do you think a sub female that is NOT in a relationship with you has the right to say no?  (Just playing devil's advocate)


Folks are folks. I have no idea what works for this fellow. I do get from what you have written that this totally doesn't work for you. So what it tells me is that you and he are not a match. I don't think that you arn't "submissive" because you don't fall into what he personally wants and needs in a submissive. I don't want to think about the terms "abuse" or any of that. From what you have said I have no ideas about what he does or what he expects. Does he lightly touch their hand and then if their fingers tremble he knows they are his flavor of submissive? I have no clue what he is doing or how healthy it is or isn't.

I DO know that  you not falling into the catagory of what this particular person needs, has nothing at all to do with whether or not you are a submissive. There is a huge range of what it is to be submissive, HUGE, from a person that is a raging dominant except with one specific person, to someone else who lives to serve every person they meet without discression. You could be completely and sincerely a submissive and be anywhere in that range, or heck even somewhere completely outside that range.








Estring -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 2:13:37 PM)

The point of view of this "respected" Dom is probably more accepted than most want to admit. I am not surprised. For the record, he is an idiot in my opinion.




witchywoman313 -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 2:17:49 PM)

I would not ever play with anyone who wouldnt respect a submissives right to go slow.  In fact as submissive as I tend to be; when meeting/chatting with a Dom/ Master for the first time I make a point of saying No or Not yet to something, just to make sure they will respect my decisions.  What I refer to as "high pressure sales tactics" like the ones this "Dom" read "Asshole" gave to you are a huge turn off at best and major Red Flags at worse.  Dont go anywhere alone with this guy.  Especialy not from the coffee shop to your car.  I have heard of some slaves even lived with one who would follow the orders of any Dom/Master unless it confilcted directly with her personal Masters, but I find this a rare situation and a personal choice made by her.  I.E it was still ultimatly her choice not to say no,  In any case the said slave still had a safeword writen into her contract.  Anyway,  I tend to be respectful to Doms/Masters/Mistresses Ect. that arent my own but the choice to Obay is still mine even with my 24/7 lifestyle Master at home.  If I said no or used one of my safewords any Master who has Mastered their own self first would stop and make sure I was OK.




slaveish -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 2:22:29 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Bobkgin

Careful, Slaveish. With his stunning grasp of 'log-ick' he might prove you're not real either, and then where will you be?

[;)]


If he proves I'm not real, I'm not paying my bills any more. I'll tell ya that much. As for where I'll be ... err ... I guess wherever it is I am now, since if he proves I'm not real later then I must not be real now.

But if I'm not real now, how come I want a moon pie? Are moon pies real?




WillowRain -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 2:31:55 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveish

quote:

ORIGINAL: Bobkgin

Careful, Slaveish. With his stunning grasp of 'log-ick' he might prove you're not real either, and then where will you be?

[;)]


If he proves I'm not real, I'm not paying my bills any more. I'll tell ya that much. As for where I'll be ... err ... I guess wherever it is I am now, since if he proves I'm not real later then I must not be real now.

But if I'm not real now, how come I want a moon pie? Are moon pies real?


Clearly, a moon pie is only "real" if it submits to every RC cola it encounters.
:P




PrincessEllie -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 3:55:07 PM)

I laughed out loud. That man is spinning you a pretty tale of lies and bullshit.

The submissive always has the right to say "No." If it was taken away and something was forced on a sub, it would be sexual assualt. You don't have to submit to everyone who goes around saying they are a Dom/me, you are perfectly allowed to only submit to certain ones who prove themselves to you.

I'm a submissive girl too, but I'll only submit to my boy. If I said "No." and someone else still tried it, they'd get a crotch full of boot and an arm full of teeth. And if they still didn't listen to my opinion, I'd break their kneecap and gouge them in the eyes. Just because you're a sub doesn't mean you aren't entitled to self defense.




Cyntilating -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 4:02:26 PM)

sweetNSmartBBW
 
Hi...
ok...moving slowly into this one..because...not sure why, but I  seem to be interperting this
"...be careful who you meet for coffee as
if they are a true dom and they like you, you wiull not have
a choice about what goes on in your pants by the time you get
back to your car -
different than everyone else...
 
I "read"  ...becareful meeting with someone unless youre already establishing a certain amt of trust and boundaries because once there and face to face with someones dominance stroking your submission it might be too late to " set those boundaries then"  (for you the submissive  because of your natural reaction)
.....if thats what he meant tho' ...he did a lousy job of conveying it to you ..sheesh...
 
 
ok  hold the tomatoes and rotten eggs....Im just thinking outloud dambit gumby..
 
but then theres all the other crap that he goes on about  true this and true that..and youre not real this or real that [:'(]frick-that..
 
anyway...
just thought there might be a different interpretation of this than the obvious...
 
about "what happens in your pants part" .......
personally can account for a time when there was something happening in mine[:)] just because of a mindset and words being spoken to me...so  maybe he didnt mean he was gonna acost you.....without consent.
 
shrugs...
Im just sayin......
 
sigh..
::putting on flame-retardant body suit:::

 
 




Stephann -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 4:13:25 PM)

Is there a full moon out or something?  Cripes people, what is with the rants over 'True' Doms/Subs/Slaves/Tops/Jigalos.  Hell, how do I know the graham cracker I'm eating is frigging true?

First off, I think the OP had more to do with soliciting a horrified reaction of "I can't believe that!" than any genuine concern over the advice dispensed. 

quote:

Thanks folks...and I'm very much in agreement with all of you.


Well, naturally you are.  Were you expecting a resounding "stop whining and obey!" or something?  More to the point, I have a hard time imagining anyone well respected in the NJ community advocating this kind of schlop.  Are you sure you have his advice right?  If you do, why does it matter?  You're obviously not interested in it. 

LA was square on; some submissives seek exactly this kind of dynamic.  It's reckless, it's foolish, but by golly people do reckless and foolish things all the time.  Hell, maybe she'll even have sex with the guy....without a condom! The horror!

To answer the question bluntly, it's abuse when the submissive doesn't consent.  If she does, than it's submission.  Period.  If you're trying to crucify some nameless faceless dom, why not buy a voodoo doll?

Stephan






EclipseAbove -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 4:37:01 PM)

[sarcasm]
Gee, I don't see why everyone has a problem with this guy.  He is a True Dom, so everything he says and does is absolutely correct.  Hell, every woman in the world (especially dominant females) should bow down before his great Trueness and thank him for the experience.  How could it ever be abuse if it is a True Dom who is doing it?  And one that is also very highly regarded in the community based on his own True reports.
[/sarcasm]
Seriously, what a total and complete ass.  No consent = abuse.  It is that simple.




Bobkgin -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 5:09:40 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Cyntilating

sigh..
::putting on flame-retardant body suit:::



If it makes you feel better, Cyndi. I was also looking for an alternative explanation (always a good thing to do before launching a condemnation).

But it was abundantly obvious he was seeking insecurities he could exploit, and I just don't warm up to that kind of thinking.

Now, may I ask what kink you're into that you'd be packing a flame-retardant body suit?

[;)]




sweetnurseBBW -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 6:23:03 PM)

Thats all crap. You have a right to consent then its submission if it isn't consensual then its abuse. You have rights as a person and don't have to take crap like that, and don't let anyone manipulate you into believing you don't have a right to say no. You're not a submissive to everyone and being submissive doesn't make unable to say no.




EternalInferno -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 6:51:31 PM)

lol  Now this is a dom I would love to meet in person! lol

Let me at'em!

Edited to include the following:

Self professed anythings, in the local community, should be a warning unless the credit {whatever it is} is coming from one in the local community and not the self professer.




RRafe -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 7:18:29 PM)

He's a self serving bullshit artist.

The surrounding culture has laws that control males if they cannot control themselves. Let's see how he how likes his cellmate treating him the way he wants to treat women.




MellowSir -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 7:22:17 PM)

A dom should practice restraint until the sub's trust is given, then he must still retain respect.....




arayofsunshine55 -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 7:22:48 PM)

I am just not taken with other people accolades.  I really do judge them by my own interactions and the words out of their mouth.   What this guy has said is not my experience.  At all.  And Daddy would probably tell you this guy's a tool, so I'm speaking for him here.   The accusations back and forth, whose real and who is not, etc. I really have zero interest in it. Makes no difference in my life. for me it is about connections with someone compatible.  Now if a guy is seductive enough to get in my pants?  Great. But that is because I entered into the seduction. I made a conscious choice to do so.  But I am all about being clear about my choices as I make them.  And therefore my responsibility.

Doms who spout a lot pf philosophy about other doms just aren't my cup of tea. Let's talk about us. That's what matters.





NControlofU -> RE: When is it submission and when is it sexual abuse? (9/4/2007 8:12:43 PM)

Good advice- be careful who you meet for coffee.

Bad advice - a real dom doesn't exercise self restraint.

If I don't exercise control over my self, how am  I qualified to exercise control over anyone else?  How can I expect someone I just met to treat me respectfully if I don't treat them respectfully?  If I meet someone for coffee and she lets me get in her pants by the time she gets back to her car that doesn;t say to me that she is submissive, it says to me that she is a slut.  That isnt something I think is bad and sometimes thats just what I want but you dont have to be submissive to be a slut and you dont have to be a slut to be submissive, unless you become my submissive, then you will be my slut.  Ther are plenty of sluts who arent submissive.

Everyone even subs have the right to say no any time they feel its the right thing to say.  If they are owned and they say no they will have to answer to their dom or master but unowned dont need to answer to any one.  Its sexual assault any time there is no consent from the other person and anytime they say no or stop and instead of stopping its ignored. 




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
3.100586E-02