Agree to disagree? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Submissive



Message


stella41b -> Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:01:11 AM)

L:ast night whilst chatting to Mistress on IM something came up which may become a major conflict or it may not..

She expressed views which were racist. This gives me a conflict situation. I had a similar situation in my childhood with my grandmother, my family's Scottish, I was born in West Yorkshire, raised initially in Glasgow (I think I was meant to be born in Glasgow but being me I wasn't born at the right time) and neither my parents nor my grandmother (who others in the family perceived as a real battleaxe but I saw a different side of me) could agree on my name - so I spent the first couple of months of my life as 'it', 'the bairn', 'the baby', 'the wayne'. I was raised by my grandparents in Glasgow until school age, and then returned to my parents in West Yorkshire.

The first couple of years at school was horrible. I had this 'hoots mon' Glaswegian accent and not only would the kids make fun of me, but sometimes the teachers wouldn't understand me. I would get into trouble with my father for claiming to be Scottish as I was born in England, and I would get into trouble for claiming to be English with my mother and grandmother. To them I was a Scot. You could be any nationality, colour, tribe or race for my grandmother, only don't be English.

I grew up through the 1970's in West Yorkshire, in a predominantly white area which was quite racist. We had two Paki shops, there was a Paki bus driver. We would see the odd black person. This was the outer suburbs of Leeds, it was our own UK 'segregation' after the 'banana boat' people had come from the West Indies and the Asian subcontinent in the 1950's and 1960's to fill the labour shortages in Britain after the Second World War. My first contact with people of a different race were the Vietnamese refugees who came into Britain in the late 1970's. You had to be careful that the Pakistani shopkeeper didn't 'jew' you (short change you) or put your cat or small dog in his curry. It was acceptable to talk like this. My father was also deeply racist and prejudiced towards any minority and I grew up learning about hatred and words like 'wog', 'Paki', 'dago', 'poofter', 'faggot', 'beanflicker'. He didn't accept me. Fortunately the old bastard is dead.

In 1979 my parents split up, and I went to live with my mother in Bradford. I only got beat half the time before, I didn't have to hide in my bedroom listening to my parents shouting, screaming, beating each other up or trashing the house (up until the age of 12 I had a very strong phobia of crockery) in the inner city district of Manningham near the city centre. Everybody was a Pakistani. I was the only white child in the class for two years. All the boys I made friends with had the same first name - Mohammed. My mother started having relationships with Pakistani men. We ate Pakistani food. My father went ballistic as I was being 'pakified' (his word) and turned into a Pakistani. I got to know the black people in the neighbourhood, discovered Gregory Isaacs, reggae, caught the second generation of SKA, and through this found jazz.

I'm British, and proud of it, I'm proud to be British because I know that it doesn't matter how you look, you can be black, white, Oriental, Arabic, Asian, even Latino, and still be British. I've travelled extensively throughout Europe, going beyond and have got as far as Irkutsk a station on the Trans-Siberian express route playing meaningless card games with Mongolians, one of the most insane and lovable nationalities in the world. Mongolia is communist, everybody gets a small concrete apartment in a block but everyone lives in a tent outside the block. The Mongolian diet is 95% meat - yak, pork, lamb, chicken, and yes, I've sat with them and chewed the fat as we travelled through a frozen Siberia on a train which took 8 days to get from Kiev.

I am not racist. I love people, no matter where they come from. Ancestry is fascinating. People say Americans don't have much culture, maybe not, I disagree, American culture is rich and comes from everyone having so many different backgrounds and ancestries.

I am not bigoted. I even like heterosexuals. Heterosexuals are nice people, my family is full of them, some of my friends are heterosexual, many of my neighbours, and they don't cause any trouble.

But I do have prejudices, and quite strong ones. Margaret Thatcher should be tried for war crimes, because it is she who started the conflict in Iraq in 1990. I don't like corporate businessmen, people with extreme right wing views. Joseph Stalin had the right ideas with such people, getting his secret police to come round and tell them to shut up or else they would be thrown into prison, sent to a camp, or simply disappear.

I am against the death penalty, but hold unusual views on criminal justice. I think labour camps and gulags are a good idea. I think those that abuse and kill children should be sent to them, for life, and worked to death in hard labour. I feel Pro-Dommes should be part of the criminal justice system. Let's see how much Mr Businessman exceeds the speed limit after being sent to Goddess Bitchface twice for a judicial caning. You want to work illegally in another country? Okay, go ahead. But be sure you have enough raised for the $450,000 fine when you get caught.

I probably would not make a very good political leader. But seeing that George W. Bush has done two terms as US President, I'm not discounting this option.

My question is this. How do you respond when you discover that your partner has opposing views on a subject, and they hold a view which you find to be unacceptable? Has anyone else been in such a situation? What do you do, if anything? And how do you react?

Do you up and walk away? Does it become a taboo subject area for you both? Would you try and seek to change your partner's views? Or do you simply just accept that it's part of them?

Your thoughts and views please.




southernhart -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:15:57 AM)

If you are in a real life relationship with someone and are in love with them and want to spend your life with them. Then i would suggest that you say as nicely, but seriously as possible. i believe that we are all God's children and God wants us to love one another. Racial remarks directed at anyone is etremely offensive to me and if you would be so kind as to respect my feelings and not bring these cetain subjects up. Of course you should us your own words. You may have to say it a few times, for people that are reacist are usualy quite ignorant. That's why they are predjudice in the first place.

If it is just a casual thing. i would noticably change the subject so that she gets the hint that this is the last thing you want to hear from her. For instance. She says don't you think jews are _____. And you say. i had a great dinner dinner last night, and proceed to talk about that. Either she will get the point or she will get so frustrated that this happens everytime she brings up negative issuses that she will stop. If not i would tell her straight out and see what she says.

Remember predjudice is ignorance at it's highest form. f she is ignorant about that she is probably ignorant about a lot of things and you could be hurt. So be careful and good luck.




ShiftedJewel -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:16:54 AM)

Opposing political views can almost be overlooked so long as the subject is known to be a "do not bring up" topic. The same with many other topics. But racism is one of those things that cannot be ignored. To me, it's a deal breaker.
 
Jewel




SunNMoon -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:39:15 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ShiftedJewel

Opposing political views can almost be overlooked so long as the subject is known to be a "do not bring up" topic. The same with many other topics. But racism is one of those things that cannot be ignored. To me, it's a deal breaker.
 
Jewel


I very much agree with Jewel. There are just certain things which are deal breakers. Racism and other forms of discrimination being one of them (for me).





Deboyce -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:45:30 AM)

I think if there is a deal breaker, its a woman riding a honbda, nothng else would I consider a deal breaker I could not work through




julietsierra -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:50:15 AM)

Racism is a HUGE deal breaker for me. Do not pass go, do not collect anything more than your belongings. Good bye.

juliet




eroticangel -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 8:52:51 AM)

i am by no means saying i am racist, because i am not, but, don't we all have a right to our preferences? i mean maybe you like red hair or blue eyes....so i don't think it makes you a racist to prefer one color skin over another




southernhart -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 9:37:36 AM)

a racisist does not prefer a skin color over another. He hates the person with the different skin color. Some kill because of it. It's all about hatred and not preference.




agirl -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 9:49:49 AM)

That isn't being racist. Being racist is a belief that certain races are better than others. It's discriminating and being hostile toward other races. It's not about preferences in terms of attraction.

agirl 




grlneedstolearn -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:03:07 AM)

i personally do not associate with anyone who is a racist, though i know we all are in some way or another, but i'm meaning more of an extreme racist. My Dom and i disagree on a few things but that's him and i won't change him and vice versa. When we do disagree on something like money issues for me, i'll change the subject or get upset and walk off.




agirl -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:11:52 AM)

It takes me a long time to form attachments of any kind (years) and these type of things tend to make themselves apparent because of that. (racism and/or bigotry)

Those things aren't something I can agree to disagree on; I'd find the person rather ugly and my attraction would be tempered by it. The likelihood is that I'd lose interest in someone that held views that were fundamentally different to my own.

agirl



 




agirl -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:15:46 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: grlneedstolearn

i personally do not associate with anyone who is a racist, though i know we all are in some way or another, but i'm meaning more of an extreme racist. My Dom and i disagree on a few things but that's him and i won't change him and vice versa. When we do disagree on something like money issues for me, i'll change the subject or get upset and walk off.


No, we aren't. I think disliking someone because of their race IS extreme.






LadyChef -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:31:11 AM)

I could not pass this one and not answer.To start- I LOVE ALL PEOPLE,COLOR,CREED, RELIGION,DISABILITY,WHATEVER.
 I recently lost my brother to a racist witch. My only brother is dead (age 28), the witch tried to get custody of my nephew (not her child).
She proved to us she she only wanted to marry my brother for money by all the insurance policies she took out on him in the last 18 months( they were only married 18 months). My brother had a top security highly hazardous job which he could hace died on any day. But the way he died has only been linked to suspicion and an inconlcusive cause of death (witchcraft). The racism- the way her entire family has been towards our family since my brother has passed and we had to be in court all summer to get custody of my nephew.
 
 Oh by the way...she's white,(and we found out this summer has ties to white supremacy groups) and we're not. We have a very mixed family, she does not. A well known fact came to us through one of her"friends"; my brother was the first black man she ever dated....and the first black person to be married into her "family" they were married 11/12/2005....and as of  7/1/07 (the day my brother was found dead) they are back to their pure white supremacist, racist ways. I pray that God has mercy on the entire family. Our family lost one of the most loving, kind, generous,sweethearts' you could ever meet. And he was a big,black teddybear.And I miss him soo much. Nothing can replace your brother,friend, and childhood playmate.  He was my mother's only son. He was the best baby brother a sister could ask for.
 
 So when it comes to deal breakers- I could not be with someone who I know is a racist- either way. He may only want to marry me to kill me, my family, or quite possibly to prove to his racist family that he could trick me into marrying him for some sacrificial purposes. I also could not be with a militant person of color- any color. I especially could not be with someone who hates his own race- reverse racism- that's crazy- but I know people like that. I have learned to tolerate a lot of different types of people- but we don't have realtionships because of their racism and/or bigotry.




tsatske -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:36:43 AM)

I, too, have to agree with Jewel.
I have been telling a funny but sad story about work to my friends lately. I work in school age child care. There is this one guy - really nice guy. Great dad (to a handful of kids who I care for - got that big family thing goin on). very involved in the program. Smart. Funny. Patient. Kind. Generous. And handsome, to boot. If he wasn't the parent of some of my kiddos, I'd have asked him out ages ago. If He'd have ever asked me out, I'd have jumped on that. As far as I know, vanilla - but I never minded converting a vanilla.
a few weeks before I met my current Master, I had an issue with one of his daughters which I had to take to him. Suffice it to say, it became abundantly apparent that he is a racist. And it matters to me. It just does.
A couple weeks after becoming Master's, I was interacting with his kids while he was there, and it came up in conversation that I am a widow. Suddenly he looked at me different. Now, I understand this. There's a connection there. Someone who would understand. Plus, I'm good with his kids.
Now, he's flirting. Toching my hair. Calling me joking little nick names, (like, 'Hot Mama'). He has even hinted to asking me out. I am quite sure he will eventually ask me out. Fortunatly, I will be able to say, "I'm so sorry, I'm seeing someone."
But the truth is, I wouldn't go out with him now. It matters to me. As Jewel said, it's a deal breaker.




LadyChef -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:39:27 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: agirl

quote:

ORIGINAL: grlneedstolearn

i personally do not associate with anyone who is a racist, though i know we all are in some way or another, but i'm meaning more of an extreme racist. My Dom and i disagree on a few things but that's him and i won't change him and vice versa. When we do disagree on something like money issues for me, i'll change the subject or get upset and walk off.


No, we aren't. I think disliking someone because of their race IS extreme.




AND EVEN AFTER ALL THAT I HAVE BEEN THROUGH, I AGREE WITH YOU agirl...DISLIKING SOMEONE BECAUSE OF THEIR RACE IS EXTREME ...
IF I SUCCUMBED TO THAT BEHAVIOR, IT WOULD MAKE ME NO BETTER THAN THE PEOPLE WHO ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MY BROTHER'S DEATH




slavekal -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 10:45:41 AM)

It depends.  Sometimes disagreeing and debating can be enlightening and even fun.  I would need to know exactly what was said for you to conclude that the person was racist.  I have sound that in today's PC world, some people are quick to throw that label on anyone who is not on the ultra left bandwagon.




agirl -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 11:12:27 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slavekal

It depends.  Sometimes disagreeing and debating can be enlightening and even fun.  I would need to know exactly what was said for you to conclude that the person was racist.  I have sound that in today's PC world, some people are quick to throw that label on anyone who is not on the ultra left bandwagon.


I agree with that. My sons use black idiom at times when they banter with each other. They hear it in the music they listen to, and love. They aren't the slightest bit racist but all the same, I'm sure it wouldn't go down well with some people.

I like debating things, but I wouldn't go very far with someone that was obviously racist or a bigot. It really depends how staunch someone's views are. Bigots rarely debate.

agirl







lauren0221 -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 11:42:36 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slavekal

It depends.  Sometimes disagreeing and debating can be enlightening and even fun.  I would need to know exactly what was said for you to conclude that the person was racist.  I have sound that in today's PC world, some people are quick to throw that label on anyone who is not on the ultra left bandwagon.


I think racism is like porn, you know it when you see it. And I don't think there are degrees here. "A little racist" is still racist.




laurell3 -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 12:43:56 PM)

My dentist recently told me a racist joke and I'm considering leaving him after I finish the work he's in the middle of.  My partner?  Not a chance in hell I would stay.  I'm sorry but racism makes the person totally unattractive to me.




kittengirl8 -> RE: Agree to disagree? (11/23/2007 12:56:31 PM)

I was thinking through the question, and realized: You know, some people consider me racist, simply because of some things I said, but I definitely DON'T think a single race is better than another. Nor do I discriminate against a person based solely upon the race/ethnicity. So I'm going to have to say, seriously, some comments seem racist to some people, but aren't really.

"There were so many Mexicans at the mall! When did the demographic change so strikingly?" Is not a racist comment, and yet, some people seem to think it is. Uh, why? *shrug* So, talk about it before you completely end a relationship. If it's a blatantly obvious racist comment "Uh, did you see that stupid <insert demeaning comment about someone of another race>?" (That was racist because it was specifically insulting someone because of their race, without knowing the person.)
Now, if I were to jokingly say "Hey my <insert random odd race-related word>! How're you going stupid?" That's not racist, that just silliness. (Though... I don't talk like that. I usually use names, or "Hey you!" but that's not the point.)   The moral of this story: Talk, communicate, analyze!




Page: [1] 2 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.09375