Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


MzMia -> Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 9:28:18 PM)

I am in the process of learning Spanish, as I have mentioned before.
I want to be able to speak Spanish and I enjoy being around people of a
Hispanic culture.
 
The MAIN reason that I have a problem with illegal immigration, IS I have ALWAYS
felt/KNOWN that it would eventually drive wages DOWN and probably put some
Americans out of work.
 
Why should an employer pay you $20 an hour, IF he can pay someone $10 with out paying
taxes, social security, workmen's comp, healthcare, etc.?

At what point will people realize that outsourcing is not only happening in India?
Wake up people, get with the program.


As Popeye said, many people will do almost ANY job for a working wage.

Are we supposed to compete with people escaping 3rd world country poverty and work for
as little as possible?
Is this the new American way?

Again, I don't have to look at the jobs that have been exported to India, Thailand, and other 3rd world
countries.
The 3rd World Country citizens can now also come here and work, for as little as people are willing to pay them.
 
Of course businesses do NOT want to enforce illegal immigration, it is all about money.
If you are here illegally you HAVE to take what people offer you.

Is that the new standard for obtaining orwanting a job?
Be willing to do whatever you can get for whatever people want to pay you?
 
Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.




FangsNfeet -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 9:47:08 PM)

I'm not going to blame illegal immigrants for this situation. I can't blame someone for wanting to come to America from a Third World Country. Instead, I blame the Corporations and Industries for highering these illegals in the first place. Those are the people we have to go after and continously report to Imigration.

I know one hosptial that has a no higher policy on illegal imigrants. When it comes to matainence men, the pay wages of illegal imigrants is calculated into what a legal matainence man should make. It lowers the salery to a point to where no one wants to work for them. The Chief Mantaince man is pissed about this HR decission because he can't keep anybody on his staff.

It's fucked up. 




MzMia -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 9:51:58 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: FangsNfeet

I'm not going to blame illegal immigrants for this situation. I can't blame someone for wanting to come to America from a Third World Country. Instead, I blame the Corporations and Industries for highering these illegals in the first place. Those are the people we have to go after and continously report to Imigration.

I know one hosptial that has a no higher policy on illegal imigrants. When it comes to matainence men, the pay wages of illegal imigrants is calculated into what a legal matainence man should make. It lowers the salery to a point to where no one wants to work for them. The Chief Mantaince man is pissed about this HR decission because he can't keep anybody on his staff.

It's fucked up. 


This post is dead on!
I enjoy being around Hispanic people, I love attempting

to chat in my broken Spanish.
I totally understand WHY they come here.
IF I lived in Mexico, I would be in a tunnel on my way to America now.
 
My problem is with employers that are CERTAINLY going to take advantage
of them, which to me is.....
lowering our standard of living.

I took Economics 101 in college...supply and demand anyone?
This is all pure Economics.
So when wages start to be CUT, and raises are not given, don't sit around and wonder why??




greyangelus -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:21:13 PM)

quote:

 
Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.



Pretty much.  Its called "serfdom".

EDITED:  My mother just became the latest victim of outsourcing.  She's had a job at silicon wafer plant for the last 30 years.  Just yesterday, it was announced to the plant that all the equipment would be moved to a new facility in Kuala Lampur within the next 2 years, with the shipping beginning in 3 months.  30 years of work, basically gone; shes too young to qualify for retirement, and starting over in a new career for her is going to be extremely difficult, maybe impossible




MzMia -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:25:18 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: greyangelus

quote:

 
Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.



Pretty much.  Its called "serfdom".



THAT is the term I was searching for "serfs".
That will be the new future for many people.
 
We are now entering, the Twilight Zone!
 




slaveluci -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:27:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: greyangelus

quote:

 
Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.



Pretty much.  Its called "serfdom".


Yup.  As recently as the 1950's, my grandfather worked as a WV coal miner and was paid in scrip.  If you don't know about, look it up.  It was basically plastic tokens instead of cold, hard cash.  It could only be spent at the coal company owned company store.  Technically, he wasn't a "slave."  More like that "serf" you mentioned, greyangelus.  Workers, American and otherwise, have ALWAYS taken royal screwings from those who own the means of production.  They always will.  Sad fact of life to be bemoaned............luci




GreedyTop -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:33:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: greyangelus

quote:

 
Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.



Pretty much.  Its called "serfdom".

EDITED:  My mother just became the latest victim of outsourcing.  She's had a job at silicon wafer plant for the last 30 years.  Just yesterday, it was announced to the plant that all the equipment would be moved to a new facility in Kuala Lampur within the next 2 years, with the shipping beginning in 3 months.  30 years of work, basically gone; shes too young to qualify for retirement, and starting over in a new career for her is going to be extremely difficult, maybe impossible



*hugs* to your Mom, grey..My mom went through this also.  She's currently working in a job she hates, at a wage that is a fraction of a fraction of what she USED to make.
No advice, just *hugs*




GreedyTop -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:36:31 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveluci

quote:

ORIGINAL: greyangelus

quote:

 
Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.



Pretty much.  Its called "serfdom".


Yup.  As recently as the 1950's, my grandfather worked as a WV coal miner and was paid in scrip.  If you don't know about, look it up.  It was basically plastic tokens instead of cold, hard cash.  It could only be spent at the coal company owned company store.  Technically, he wasn't a "slave."  More like that "serf" you mentioned, greyangelus.  Workers, American and otherwise, have ALWAYS taken royal screwings from those who own the means of production.  They always will.  Sad fact of life to be bemoaned............luci


heh. sounds like where I work.  No scrip,  but the wage I earn (especially since they cut my hours to accommodate the Indians (dot) they've employed) no longer gets me from paycheck to paycheck. Thus, I end up borrowing against my NEXT check to cover things like.. oh, groceries, gas, etc.

I'm looking for another job, but the market here SUCKS.




GoddessDustyGold -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:41:21 PM)

[begin rant]
 
I think the biggest problem I have with all the arguments about ""a living wage" is that I am continually shocked at the amount of money people make and then complain about how they can't get along. 
I keep wondering how the hell I do it on a net income of less than $24000 per year.  And I don't live badly, folks! 
I have a paid off car that I do My best to maintain.  I am renting a reasonable 3 bedroom home in a nice community, I have car insurance and life insurance and health insurance.  I eat well for about $300 per month (family of 2) and that includes a few fast food runs and the occasional Starbucks treat.  It also includes My paper goods and cleaning products.  I pay My electric bill (a time of use plan saves Me a bit and I work at that), as well as My water bill, private garbage collection and a separate santitation district quarterly bill.  I have a phone, a cell phone, My daughter's cell phone, a separate fax line, and high speed internet.  I subscribe to Direct TV (no extras like HBO or Showtime and I do not bother with pay-per-view), with 135 channels (several in Espanol).  I paid cash for My lovely TV on sale for $180 2 years ago.  It is only 27 inches and it is housed in a beautiful cabinet I got at a Hotel liquidator for $99.  We have three bedrooms, all furnished, nicely I would say.  My beautiful and comfortable sectional came from Goodwill for $150.  I have a computer and a nice curved desk it sits upon.  I have dishes, and pots and pans, and silverware and even some china and crystal.  I have a washer and dyrer, a refigerator/freezer, and stove and rangetop and a dishwasher.   I enjoy My fireplace on cold winter nights, and I have a tv in My bedroom (13" with a DVD and VCR.  So does My daughter.  The guest room is ready for a guest with bed, dresser and night table.  I have clothes to wear and My daughter'ss closet is full.  She helps with the rent on a flat basis while she also works full time as a pre-school teacher earning less than $10 per hour.  She also babysits, even though she is almost 22 years old and she is a working actress on the weekends.  She continues to save money and attend college and thus far she is debt free as to education.  She is also considered bi-lingual at this point in her education.  She makes a car payment each month and pays for her own gas, clothing and car insurance along with her school tuition and books/fees...kind of a pay as you go plan.  She has friends and a boyfriend.  She goes out and she does not feel a pinch.  Then again, she does not pay $60 or $30 or even $15 for a blouse, or a pair of jeans or a new purse.  She is generous to a fault and I am  proud of her achievement and her responsible attitude toward life and others. 
I raised two daughers as a single parent for many years on less than what I have now.  They did not lack for what they needed and they are both fine and productive members of society.  In fact, I would say they have more resiliency than most of the older folks I know.  And they don't put their hand out.  They earn it or figure out a way to do without.  Yes, I am proud of them.
Yet I read about people who are upset because there is no union contract and they should be making $40 per hour or more by now.  They are suffering along on $31.50 per hour.  Or $120K per year is a pitiful income and it is time for someone to storm the steps of the boss man and right this terrible injustice.  (another thread, and I do not mean to pick on anyone.)  I listened to a man on a local talk radio show a few nights ago complaining that he is being left out of the new stimulas plan since he and his wife earn in excess of $150K per year.  All I could think was,"well what the hell do you care about the lousy $600?"
If I can do it, I think a lot of others can do it also.  I see American people who complain about the wasteful spending of our government, but they can't seem to manage their own budgets.  Consume at all costs.  God help you of you don't have the new plasma tv and you can't trade your car in every other year and pay for those three vacations you have to take because your UM's now get a fall break in additon to the spring break and the summer break.  I no longer want to hear the crying about the fact that you can't make your mortgage payment now that the low payment went away and you took every bit of false equity out of the property you could already.  I have listened to this from more people than I can tell you, and I am not talkng about a message board.  I am talking about daily life and all the moaning and groaning.  Gimme Gimme Gimme...It's not fair! 
Grow up!   
Forgive Me if I am out of sympathy.
 
[/end rant]




MzMia -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 10:52:41 PM)

Wow, thanks for sharing slaveluci!
I don't think I will ever forget what you wrote.

Being paid in "scrips", I plan to research "scrips".
You have opened my eyes with this.
 
 
Thank you GreedyTop I hope your mom gets a pay increase or a better job.
 
Thanks for sharing DustyGold, you made some excellent points!
[sm=applause.gif] I am currently paying down whatever debt I owe, and I really applaud

all that you have been able to do!
 
I am fortunate {?} to be in a Union, I am not really big on Unions, but they do
serve there purpose at least for getting us raises.




popeye1250 -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (1/31/2008 11:47:05 PM)

I sent a check today to Target Visa for $2,614.58 to pay off my credit card that was charging me 18.70% in interest! It came out to about $41 in interest every month.
I also put a "hold" on the card so that no more charges can be made until I say so.
You know what banks pay for interest these days, about .50%.
The banks, credit card companies, insurance companies etc keep *raising* their rates and dropping what they pay us in interest or in salaries.
They are squeezing people just as hard as they can!
So fuck 'em, I may be only one person but I am going on a *MAJOR* NO BUYING binge for the next year or so!
I just won't do business with them anymore.
I have enough clothes, underware, socks and footware to last me probably 10 years.
I'll go to the supermarket, out to eat more often and fill my tank HALFWAY like I do now and that's it but NO MORE BUYING STUFF.
We need to start pushing back on all these big companies.
And the best way to do that is to stop giving them any money.
"You Outsource? Fuck You!"
"You hire illegal aliens? Fuck you!"
"You pay your workers substandard wages? Fuck You!"
No Money!




greyangelus -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 1:00:17 AM)

quote:


I think the biggest problem I have with all the arguments about ""a living wage" is that I am continually shocked at the amount of money people make and then complain about how they can't get along.  I keep wondering how the hell I do it on a net income of less than $24000 per year.  And I don't live badly, folks! 
 
I have a paid off car that I do My best to maintain.  I am renting a reasonable 3 bedroom home in a nice community, I have car insurance and life insurance and health insurance.   I eat well for about $300 per month (family of 2) and that includes a few fast food runs and the occasional Starbucks treat.  It also includes My paper goods and cleaning products.  I pay My electric bill (a time of use plan saves Me a bit and I work at that), as well as My water bill, private garbage collection and a separate santitation district quarterly bill.  I have a phone, a cell phone, My daughter's cell phone, a separate fax line, and high speed internet.  I subscribe to Direct TV (no extras like HBO or Showtime and I do not bother with pay-per-view), with 135 channels (several in Espanol).  I paid cash for My lovely TV on sale for $180 2 years ago.  It is only 27 inches and it is housed in a beautiful cabinet I got at a Hotel liquidator for $99.  We have three bedrooms, all furnished, nicely I would say.  My beautiful and comfortable sectional came from Goodwill for $150.  I have a computer and a nice curved desk it sits upon.  I have dishes, and pots and pans, and silverware and even some china and crystal.  I have a washer and dyrer, a refigerator/freezer, and stove and rangetop and a dishwasher.   I enjoy My fireplace on cold winter nights, and I have a tv in My bedroom (13" with a DVD and VCR.  So does My daughter.  The guest room is ready for a guest with bed, dresser and night table.  I have clothes to wear and My daughter'ss closet is full.  She helps with the rent on a flat basis while she also works full time as a pre-school teacher earning less than $10 per hour.  She also babysits, even though she is almost 22 years old and she is a working actress on the weekends.  She continues to save money and attend college and thus far she is debt free as to education.  She is also considered bi-lingual at this point in her education.  She makes a car payment each month and pays for her own gas, clothing and car insurance along with her school tuition and books/fees...kind of a pay as you go plan.  She has friends and a boyfriend.  She goes out and she does not feel a pinch.  Then again, she does not pay $60 or $30 or even $15 for a blouse, or a pair of jeans or a new purse.  She is generous to a fault and I am  proud of her achievement and her responsible attitude toward life and others. 
I raised two daughers as a single parent for many years on less than what I have now.  They did not lack for what they needed and they are both fine and productive members of society.  In fact, I would say they have more resiliency than most of the older folks I know.  And they don't put their hand out.  They earn it or figure out a way to do without.  Yes, I am proud of them.
Yet I read about people who are upset because there is no union contract and they should be making $40 per hour or more by now.  They are suffering along on $31.50 per hour.  Or $120K per year is a pitiful income and it is time for someone to storm the steps of the boss man and right this terrible injustice.  (another thread, and I do not mean to pick on anyone.)  I listened to a man on a local talk radio show a few nights ago complaining that he is being left out of the new stimulas plan since he and his wife earn in excess of $150K per year.  All I could think was,"well what the hell do you care about the lousy $600?"
If I can do it, I think a lot of others can do it also.  I see American people who complain about the wasteful spending of our government, but they can't seem to manage their own budgets.  Consume at all costs.  God help you of you don't have the new plasma tv and you can't trade your car in every other year and pay for those three vacations you have to take because your UM's now get a fall break in additon to the spring break and the summer break.  I no longer want to hear the crying about the fact that you can't make your mortgage payment now that the low payment went away and you took every bit of false equity out of the property you could already.  I have listened to this from more people than I can tell you, and I am not talkng about a message board.  I am talking about daily life and all the moaning and groaning.  Gimme Gimme Gimme...It's not fair! 
Grow up!   
Forgive Me if I am out of sympathy.



Anywhere from 22-36k is the breakpoint of the living wage, depending on the area of the country you live in.  Fall below that point in income, and you will either need a second job or find someone else to provide a second income.  36.5 million people live well below that breakpoint below the poverty threshold; toss in the in-betweens and I would not be suprised if the total is over 100 million.

I do agree with you that anyone making over 50k single or 90k married (or coupled or whatever) has got about diddly to complain about (at least from my age perspective and group, there might be some additional costs I'm not aware of to being older). 

A few things though, I'd like to point out. 85+% of people do not own thier cars, right about the time they get it paid off they yearly maintenance increase to the point where selling and buying a new/used one makes more financial sense ( I have no idea what model or year you drive, some cars go years past being paid off before its too expensive to fix them). That tacks on about 4-6k a year they need.  Also, living on a single income tacks on about 30-40% percent more that they need (going by your post, I suspect your daughter is a contributor to the household income; 2 income homes need less per income in order to be a living wage).

By making an educated guess that your income is 20-24, I would need to make 30-34 just to match your standard of living.  Actually, toss in student loan repayments, its more like 32-36k. My paticular degree field is electronics, you'll never get rich off of it, but by and large its considered a good paying job field.

My most likely starting yearly will be 22-24k after taxes in my area, and thats assuming a full 40 a week all year.  I'll most likely continue needing a either a second part-time job or mandatory overtime every week along with a roommate to share the bills with, right after graduating from college with an Associates degree in a good paying technical job field.  Hopefully, I'll get cost of living raises too (not a sure thing anymore, many companies do not ) just so I can stay at that level.




Griswold -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 4:35:25 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MzMia

I am in the process of learning Spanish, as I have mentioned before.
I want to be able to speak Spanish and I enjoy being around people of a
Hispanic culture.
 
The MAIN reason that I have a problem with illegal immigration, IS I have ALWAYS
felt/KNOWN that it would eventually drive wages DOWN and probably put some
Americans out of work.
 
Why should an employer pay you $20 an hour, IF he can pay someone $10 with out paying
taxes, social security, workmen's comp, healthcare, etc.?

At what point will people realize that outsourcing is not only happening in India?
Wake up people, get with the program.


As Popeye said, many people will do almost ANY job for a working wage.

Are we supposed to compete with people escaping 3rd world country poverty and work for
as little as possible?
Is this the new American way?

Again, I don't have to look at the jobs that have been exported to India, Thailand, and other 3rd world
countries.
The 3rd World Country citizens can now also come here and work, for as little as people are willing to pay them.
 
Of course businesses do NOT want to enforce illegal immigration, it is all about money.
If you are here illegally you HAVE to take what people offer you.

Is that the new standard for obtaining orwanting a job?
Be willing to do whatever you can get for whatever people want to pay you?

Slavery ended over 100 years ago, I guess since slavery was abolished, this is the
next best thing.


Unemployment is at 5%.

Employers cannot pay less than a set wage established by the govt.

The industry wage for the industry where I employ people is between $15.00 and $25.00 hr.

Half of my production staff is Mexican/Hispanic.  They all make a similar wage as their white/non Hispanic counterparts, within 2 bucks an hour of the top people.

Because they earn it, and because they work very hard.

When they can speak and understand English as well as their coworkers, they'll make more than the other guys because they actually work harder than the other guys and I won't have to spend 10% of my time preparing special documents so they have extra details, or sending an extra (costly) English speaking other guy out to a job to make sure they fully understand all the details properly.

The percentage of American employers hiring Hispanics solely to get a cheaper wage is not only infintesimally (sp?) small...it's a myth. 

The reason they hire them is because these guys know how to work hard and do it with an all day smile.




subrob1967 -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 4:40:30 AM)

I'd like to point out that employers ARE paying SS taxes on their illegal immigrants, which is why the U.S. government isn't doing a damn thing to stop illegal immigration.

It's money the U.S. NEVER has to pay out, and they're using it as a crutch to fill the fund that pays legit accounts.

The IRS knows full well that they're collecting taxes on one SS number multiple times.

We no longer have a manufacturing economy, it's now a service economy, so it shouldn't surprise anyone that manufacturing jobs are going to developing nations.




Griswold -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 4:46:42 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GoddessDustyGold

[begin rant]
 
I think the biggest problem I have with all the arguments about ""a living wage" is that I am continually shocked at the amount of money people make and then complain about how they can't get along. 
I keep wondering how the hell I do it on a net income of less than $24000 per year.  And I don't live badly, folks! 
I have a paid off car that I do My best to maintain.  I am renting a reasonable 3 bedroom home in a nice community, I have car insurance and life insurance and health insurance.  I eat well for about $300 per month (family of 2) and that includes a few fast food runs and the occasional Starbucks treat.  It also includes My paper goods and cleaning products.  I pay My electric bill (a time of use plan saves Me a bit and I work at that), as well as My water bill, private garbage collection and a separate santitation district quarterly bill.  I have a phone, a cell phone, My daughter's cell phone, a separate fax line, and high speed internet.  I subscribe to Direct TV (no extras like HBO or Showtime and I do not bother with pay-per-view), with 135 channels (several in Espanol).  I paid cash for My lovely TV on sale for $180 2 years ago.  It is only 27 inches and it is housed in a beautiful cabinet I got at a Hotel liquidator for $99.  We have three bedrooms, all furnished, nicely I would say.  My beautiful and comfortable sectional came from Goodwill for $150.  I have a computer and a nice curved desk it sits upon.  I have dishes, and pots and pans, and silverware and even some china and crystal.  I have a washer and dyrer, a refigerator/freezer, and stove and rangetop and a dishwasher.   I enjoy My fireplace on cold winter nights, and I have a tv in My bedroom (13" with a DVD and VCR.  So does My daughter.  The guest room is ready for a guest with bed, dresser and night table.  I have clothes to wear and My daughter'ss closet is full.  She helps with the rent on a flat basis while she also works full time as a pre-school teacher earning less than $10 per hour.  She also babysits, even though she is almost 22 years old and she is a working actress on the weekends.  She continues to save money and attend college and thus far she is debt free as to education.  She is also considered bi-lingual at this point in her education.  She makes a car payment each month and pays for her own gas, clothing and car insurance along with her school tuition and books/fees...kind of a pay as you go plan.  She has friends and a boyfriend.  She goes out and she does not feel a pinch.  Then again, she does not pay $60 or $30 or even $15 for a blouse, or a pair of jeans or a new purse.  She is generous to a fault and I am  proud of her achievement and her responsible attitude toward life and others. 
I raised two daughers as a single parent for many years on less than what I have now.  They did not lack for what they needed and they are both fine and productive members of society.  In fact, I would say they have more resiliency than most of the older folks I know.  And they don't put their hand out.  They earn it or figure out a way to do without.  Yes, I am proud of them.
Yet I read about people who are upset because there is no union contract and they should be making $40 per hour or more by now.  They are suffering along on $31.50 per hour.  Or $120K per year is a pitiful income and it is time for someone to storm the steps of the boss man and right this terrible injustice.  (another thread, and I do not mean to pick on anyone.)  I listened to a man on a local talk radio show a few nights ago complaining that he is being left out of the new stimulas plan since he and his wife earn in excess of $150K per year.  All I could think was,"well what the hell do you care about the lousy $600?"
If I can do it, I think a lot of others can do it also.  I see American people who complain about the wasteful spending of our government, but they can't seem to manage their own budgets.  Consume at all costs.  God help you of you don't have the new plasma tv and you can't trade your car in every other year and pay for those three vacations you have to take because your UM's now get a fall break in additon to the spring break and the summer break.  I no longer want to hear the crying about the fact that you can't make your mortgage payment now that the low payment went away and you took every bit of false equity out of the property you could already.  I have listened to this from more people than I can tell you, and I am not talkng about a message board.  I am talking about daily life and all the moaning and groaning.  Gimme Gimme Gimme...It's not fair! 
Grow up!   
Forgive Me if I am out of sympathy.
 
[/end rant]


Beautiful :)

Nicely done :)

I concur entirely.




PhilaMale1958 -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 5:43:47 AM)

Griswold,

I don't question what your experience is; however, there is a huge number of illegal aliens here, and they are not coming here for the fun and the sun. They are coming here, one assumes, because they expect that life will be better for them here, and while they are here, whether temporarily or permanently, they need to work in order to earn money to live. That means that somewhere some way they are going to do that, and if they accept lower wages to do so then they will. The cleaning, landscaping, and construction industry, to name a few, are awash in day and seasonal labors who get paid either in cash or by a check form the company. It makes no difference how they get paid, they still can hold a job even if they are illegal because it becomes an impossible task for an employer to police who is legally here and who is not, and for the government to track them down in a year or two is also impossable. In addition, though there can be many factors involved, it does drive labor cost down. How can company 'A' bid on a job if his labor cost are higher because his employees pay income taxes, have health care, pay car insurance, pay into social security, get workman's compensation coverage, etc. while company 'B' only has a few key people officially working for the company while the rest are paid by the day, week, or what ever, but who may not incur some or all of the cost. The labor force that doesn't have those cost can get those jobs by working for less and still have the same take home pay. Hence, company 'B' can bid less on a job and still have the same profit margin as company 'A'.

One more thing, the unemployment number does not accurately reflect those who do not have a job but may want one. It only reflects the number of people who have recently lost a job and filed for unemployment. Those who have been out of work for an extended period of time are assumed to not be looking and are dropped form the unemployment figures. 




popeye1250 -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 10:27:05 AM)

PhilaMale, yeah, the criminal company that's breaking Federal Laws would presumably get more contracts and drive wages down further for American workers.
But, if I were in business and I found out that my competition was hiring illegals I'd not only report them to the Feds but also local and especially State police and state ATTY General's office.
If they're not paying into State Taxes and workers' comp the state *will* go after them and the owners have a very good chance of doing prison time for tax evaision. States *really* don't like it when you try to screw them by not paying taxes.
Also, you can call OSHA on them at that point and,..... the I.R.S......no more "competition!"
You're business gets all their business because the State puts them out of business and the principals go to State prison.
Then, the Feds catch up with them for hiring illegals and they can go to Federal prison.
People say that if you report someone or a business for hiring illegals, "nothing happens."
That's not true at all! If someone makes a formal complaint the State and Feds have to investigate!
The legal fees alone on a state and federal case like that will bankrupt them plus they go to jail.
And as a *bonus* the I.R.S. will pay you a certain percentage of the taxes they collect from these bums!
Some States Revenue Dept's will too so it can be lucrative to turn in companies and individuals who do this!
Depending on the size of the company or individuals business you could be looking at a lot of money in "rewards!"




Stephann -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 10:37:31 AM)

See, personally, I'm for amnesty (I know Popeye, we're probably not going to agree here.)  The reason for this, is I believe that we should let anyone who wants to work here, work here.  Not because they'll steal 'good American jobs' but because if they're legal then the companies will have to pay them at least minimum wage.  It'd actually create a trickle effect.  You pay Pablo 2000$ a month, he's not going to send $1400 home; he's going to spend a good chunk of it on clothes, food, gas, rent, and all the other little commodities that hard working people need.  It would actually boost the economy.  There'd be some balancing out; food costs would make a marginal leap (I'd guess %15) as workers who were once exploited would pass the cost back on to the consumer.  Yet, it would also mean that Americans who struggle hardest to find jobs would no longer be forced to compete with illegals for their jobs. 

It also means that the now illegal workers would be forced to pay taxes on their (currently untaxed) income.  It would mean they really are 'entitled' to the same services that they're already receiving, since they're now helping to pay for them.

This country grew strong a century ago because it embraced foreigners.  I think it's a crime that we turn away the people who want to work here the most, and hardest.  I have more thoughts on it, but I'm off to an interview myself

Stephan




popeye1250 -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 11:02:16 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Stephann

See, personally, I'm for amnesty (I know Popeye, we're probably not going to agree here.)  The reason for this, is I believe that we should let anyone who wants to work here, work here.  Not because they'll steal 'good American jobs' but because if they're legal then the companies will have to pay them at least minimum wage.  It'd actually create a trickle effect.  You pay Pablo 2000$ a month, he's not going to send $1400 home; he's going to spend a good chunk of it on clothes, food, gas, rent, and all the other little commodities that hard working people need.  It would actually boost the economy.  There'd be some balancing out; food costs would make a marginal leap (I'd guess %15) as workers who were once exploited would pass the cost back on to the consumer.  Yet, it would also mean that Americans who struggle hardest to find jobs would no longer be forced to compete with illegals for their jobs. 

It also means that the now illegal workers would be forced to pay taxes on their (currently untaxed) income.  It would mean they really are 'entitled' to the same services that they're already receiving, since they're now helping to pay for them.

This country grew strong a century ago because it embraced foreigners.  I think it's a crime that we turn away the people who want to work here the most, and hardest.  I have more thoughts on it, but I'm off to an interview myself

Stephan


 
Ah Stephann, lol, "trickle down economics" doesn't work!
Remember Reagan?
It's a federal felony to enter the country other than through a Legal Port of Entry.
Enforcing and Obeying our laws is not "optional."
I don't know why some politicians think so.
 




Stephann -> RE: Undermining American Workers? Is this the New American Way?? (2/1/2008 3:04:16 PM)

I'm not arguing that it should be made 'ok' to enter the country illegally.  I'm saying it should be 'ok' for anyone who wishes to come here to work, to come here to work.  I also think that part of that 'ok' means they can afford a $2,000 bond which; in the event that they do not find work, or cannot support themselves, or end up in jail for anything over a minor misdemeanor, will pay for their deportation.

When they come up with another $2,000, they can try again.  Remove the incentive for people to enter the country illegally (often at costs exceeding $15,000) and you'll find it much easier to track and manage those who do.  Addtionally, since they're here legally, they won't be obligated to take jobs that pay less than minimum wage, or hide from the police.  They won't have the right to vote, but they would have the right to earn citizenship.  Let hard working people, work hard, and be rewarded for their efforts.

Stephan




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625