(real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


frenchpet -> (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/14/2005 12:51:49 PM)

I just read in a sig line a factitious quote supposedly from the Marquis de Sade, that said something like"Your honor, I didn't have to practise sexual perversion, I'm very good at it", supposedly said during a trial. I knew it wasn't a real quote because the play on word (between the 2 meanings of "practise") doesn't work in french. Too bad, it's a nice sentence...

Sade was a very high ranked Noble who was sent to jail for torturing Rose Keller (a prostitute). He was of course very bored, in jail, as his fellow prisoners were non kinky, boring people, such as the Marquis de Mirabeau, a boring economist. Which is why he had time to write a few texts where he describes his kinks (Most of his works is boring philosophy) :
-Dialogue entre un prêtre et un moribond (Dialogue Between a Priest and a Dying Man), where he says he's atheist : THAT was kinky !!
-Les 120 Journées de Sodome (One Hundred and Twenty Days of Sodom)
-Les Infortunes de la vertu (an early version of Justine)
-Les Crimes de l'amour (Crimes of Passion)

trivia : he was in the Bastille a few days before it was stormed, then was transfered to Charenton.

So here's some real quotes (or so I hope !) from the Marquis de Sade. I chose those related to his extreme lifestyle, or just to Women (the name of the book is between brackets, if possible, followd by the -personal- translation between parenthesis). Note that these quotes don't mention his specific kinks that he ... practised for real, just general thoughts about the subject :


" Adressez-vous plutôt aux passions qu'aux vertus quand vous voudrez persuader une femme."
[ La Philosophie dans le boudoir, his main philosophical -boring- book ]
(When you want to convince a woman, appeal to her passions rather than to her virtues)


"C'est une chose très différente que d'aimer ou que de jouir; la preuve en est qu'on aime tous les jours sans jouir et qu'on jouit encore plus souvent sans aimer."
[Justine]
(To love and to enjoy are very different things; proof is that one loves everyday without enjoying and that one enjoys even more without loving)
Note : "jouir" means both "to enjoy" and "to have an orgasm" [:D]

"Il n'est nullement besoin d'être aimé pour bien jouir et ... l'amour nuit plutôt aux transports de la jouissance qu'il n'y sert."
[ Juliette ]
(It is absolutely not necessary to be loved to enjoy well and... love rather hinders the transports of joy than it serves them)
same note...


"Il est très doux de scandaliser: il existe là un petit triomphe pour l'orgueil qui n'est nullement à dédaigner."
[La philosophie dans le boudoir]
(It is very sweet to scandalize : there is here a little triumph for prise that should by no mean be overlooked)


"Il est un antre obscur où vont s'isoler les amours pour nous séduire avec plus d'énergie."
[Justine]
(There is a dark den where loves go and isolate to captivate us with more energy)


"Il n'est aucune sorte de sensation qui soit plus vive que celle de la douleur; ses impressions sont sûres, elles ne trompent point comme celles du plaisir."
(There is no kind of feeling as sharp as pain; its feelings are reliable, they do not deceive as the feelings of pleasure)


"Il n'est pas deux peuples sur la surface du globe qui soient vertueux de la même manière."
[Justine]
(There aren't two peoples on the surface of the globe that are virtuous in the same way)


" Il n'y a point de passion plus égoïste que celle de la luxure."
[ Juliette ]
(There is no passion as selfish as lust)


" Je ne sais ce que c'est que le coeur, ... je n'appelle ainsi que les faiblesses de l'esprit."
[ La Philosophie dans le boudoir ]
(I don't know what is heart... I only call like this the weaknesses of the mind)


"L'amour est-il un mal dont on puisse guérir?"
[Justine]
(Is love a sickness of which one can cure ?)


"La cruauté, bien loin d'être un vice, est le premier sentiment qu'imprime en nous la nature; l'enfant brise son hochet, mord le téton de sa nourrice, étrangle son oiseau, bien avant que d'avoir l'âge de raison."
[La philosophie dans le boudoir]
(Cruelty, far from being a vice, is the first feeling that nature engraves in us; the child breaks his rattle, bites his nanny's tit, strangles the bird, much before the age of reason)


"La frivolité n'est point mon vice."
[ Juliette ]
(Frivolousness is not my vice)


"La route de la vertu n'est pas toujours la plus sûre, et il y a des circonstances dans le monde où la complicité d'un crime est préférable à la délation."
[Justine]
(The road of virtue is not always the safest, and in som circumstances the complicity of a crime is preferable to denunciation)


"La tolérance est la vertu du faible."
[ La Nouvelle Justine (1795) ]
(Tolerance is the virtue of the weak)


"Le bonheur n'est que dans ce qui agite, et il n'y a que le crime qui agite: la vertu, qui n'est qu'un état d'inaction et de repos, ne peut jamais conduire au bonheur."
[ La Nouvelle Justine (1795) ]
(Happiness is only in restlessness, and only crime is restless: virtue, which is only a state of inaction and rest, cannot lead to happiness)


"Le système de l'amour du prochain est une chimère que nous devons au christianisme et non pas à la nature."
[Justine]
(The system of the love of the neighbor is a chimera due to christianism and not to nature)


"Ne te contiens donc point, nargue tes lois, tes conventions sociales et tes Dieux."
(Do not contain yourself, tount your laws, your social conventions and your Gods)


"Rien n'est affreux en libertinage, parce que tout ce que le libertinage inspire, l'est également par la nature."
[ La Philosophie dans le boudoir ]
(Nothing is ugly in libertinage, because all that the libertinage inspires, is also inspired by nature)


"Tous les hommes sont fous, et qui n'en veut point voir - Doit rester dans sa chambre et casser son miroir."
(All men are mad, and who does not want to see one - Must stay in his room and break his mirror)



"Tout est bon quand il est excessif."
[ La Nouvelle Justine (1795) ]
(Everything is good when it's in excess)


" Tout le bonheur des hommes est dans l'imagination."
(All the happiness of men is in the imagination)


"Une jolie fille ne doit s'occuper que de foutre et jamais d'engendrer."
(A beautiful girl should only keep herself busy fucking and never bearing children)


Several of Sade's books are available for free, legally, in pdf format, at http://gallica.bnf.fr/ (as are 70000 other books).
He wrote a lot about politics, with some thoughts such as :

"Ce n'est jamais dans l'anarchie que les tyrans naissent, vous ne les voyez s'élever qu'à l'ombre des lois ou s'autoriser d'elles."
[ Juliette ]
(It is never in anarchy that tyrans are born, don't you see them grow at the shadow of the laws or use them as an excuse.)


He insisted that his remains should be spread, saying " I flatter myself that my memory will be effaced from the mind of men."


I'm not very happy with some of my translations, but I hope you learnt something about this legendary figure from whom the word "sadism" derived, and that you enjoyed it.


...Actually there was an even more sadistic person in french history (much older) : Gilles de Rais, who was much more crual...




greenie -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/14/2005 5:44:53 PM)

any place where we can get the books in pdf form in english?




frenchpet -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/14/2005 6:15:43 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: greenie

any place where we can get the books in pdf form in english?

There is this google library that they started... until they realized they couldn't copy thousands of books without asking permission, if I understood what happened. I don't know where this thing is going but you might want to try that.

You can also buy them at your local bookshop, or here

Or you can try to find a copy with edonkey or emule or something like this (but it might be an infrigement of the rights of the translator...).

Anyway, I warned you, most of it is pretty boring... useful if you have trouble to fall asleep though.




frenchpet -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/14/2005 6:22:09 PM)

found it http://print.google.com/print?q=sade&btnG=Search+Print [:)]




Lordandmaster -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/14/2005 6:48:13 PM)

You can find PDF's of some vintage editions (in French) at:

http://gallica.bnf.fr/

Just click "Recherche," and search for "de Sade" under author.




frenchpet -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 1:41:26 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lordandmaster

You can find PDF's of some vintage editions (in French) at:

http://gallica.bnf.fr/

Just click "Recherche," and search for "de Sade" under author.

I mentionned that, but I had trouble to find were I did, so it wasn't very clear [8|]. Anyway,yeah, the document "L'œuvre de Sade" is a 10 MB document, 310 pages, that contains most of (all ?) his works, plus a long introduction. It is short. I guess he didn't have much paper in jail...
Oh, another cool thing about the gallica website (it is the download website of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France) is that you can resume download by ftp, and you can also get tiff format, if you want.
gallica rules[8D]




darkinshadows -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 1:58:31 AM)

I have never liked his 'quotes' nor any of his writings. I find them no different to poor porn. It is all down to personal taste. and I find most of his quotes weak and pretty mainstream. I wonder how many people would actualy tolerate his behaviour if he were here on the boards today? Very few - I think most people would consider him nothing more than a troll and an abuser. To that effect, his words are meaningless.

Peace and Love




frenchpet -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 4:51:36 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: dark~angel

I have never liked his 'quotes' nor any of his writings. I find them no different to poor porn. It is all down to personal taste. and I find most of his quotes weak and pretty mainstream. I wonder how many people would actualy tolerate his behaviour if he were here on the boards today? Very few - I think most people would consider him nothing more than a troll and an abuser. To that effect, his words are meaningless.

Peace and Love


It is very different from poor porn, for at least two reasons. The first reason is that he really tortured women, and in this aspect some parts are closer to snuff movies than poor porn, the other reason is that his writings are mostly a philosophical rant aimed at the catholic church, the christian principles and religions in general. I never heard of any other book justifying scatology saying that it is not worse than the adoration of the god of flour (Eucharist), as there is little time between flour and excrements. And no, it's not poor porn, it's very very sick porn. I haven't heard of any other porn were someone uses a machine designed to kill sixteen persons at the same time.

If he were on on these boards, he would manage to seduce many submissive women, have them come to his mansion where he would torture them, eating them afterwards to hide the bodies. Just my opinion.

But anyway His sexual abuse and torturing of prostitutes, and his later affair with a 12 year old were not tolerated. I made this post to inform a bit about who he really was, as there are so many myths about him. Of course he didn't have a normal trial, as this didn't exist at this time (or should I say, the norm was different), and also because he was an aristocrat, and his mother in law was powerful enough to send him back to jail with a lettre de cachet.




LadyAngelika -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 5:24:37 AM)

Since you seem to be someone an expert on the Marquis, can you tell me if you believe the following, which has always been one of my favorites, is truly his? I have never been able to find the French equivalent.

"One must do violence to the object of one's desire; when it surrenders, the pleasure is greater."

Merci ;-)

- LA




darkinshadows -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 8:13:07 AM)

quote:

It is very different from poor porn, for at least two reasons. The first reason is that he really tortured women, and in this aspect some parts are closer to snuff movies than poor porn, the other reason is that his writings are mostly a philosophical rant aimed at the catholic church, the christian principles and religions in general.


There is no way that the stories themselves are similar to porn at all, just the writing style. I never said it was porn at all, but if you read the words in the context given -

quote:

I have never liked his 'quotes' nor any of his writings. I find them no different to poor porn. It is all down to personal taste. and I find most of his quotes weak and pretty mainstream.


In other words, badly executed, badly written, and kind of crass.
Like bad porn, badly executed, badly written and kind of crass.
Like snuff movies, badly executed... etc - I think you may get my point by now.

Amature - I think that is a good description.

My point of view is that I dont think he would have wanted to seduce any submissive women here - his thirst was for corruption, and that which is taken, not given. I doubt he would have even frequented these boards, other than to laugh at everyone in their uniformity. He would rather pillage and rape than have a girl begging to submit at his feet. To that end he would have probably focused on the stronger, non accessable subs and slaves, rather than seduce.

Yes, he wasnt tolerated - but yet is he so now? He is widely regarded as a figurehead of Sadism (which is one of the reasons I believe that sadism is such a misunderstood concept) and nobody bats an eyelid at the mention of his name, yet he should be regarded in the same light as hitler or myra hindly. In fact his works and himself are objectified in some quaters, when in fact his books are no better written than John Normen, who is looked down upon by many BDSM practitioners.

I think you started a good post and highlighted some good points. I hope more people here might contribue their thoughts to it. Thanks frenchpet.

Peace and Love








frenchpet -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 2:41:39 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyAngelika

Since you seem to be someone an expert on the Marquis, can you tell me if you believe the following, which has always been one of my favorites, is truly his? I have never been able to find the French equivalent.

"One must do violence to the object of one's desire; when it surrenders, the pleasure is greater."

Merci ;-)

- LA


Yes, it is in the The 120 days of Sodom that is available on print.google.com. Simone de Beauvoir (who with JP Sartre formed imho the most brilliant couple that ever was ), in her introduction "Must We Burn Sade ?" quotes this sentence. But only a part of this book is available on google, so I don't know where it is exactly. You'll have to read the french version on gallica.bnf.fr to know more. The only problem with gallica is that the pdf files are not searchables, they are only photocopies.




frenchpet -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/15/2005 2:55:54 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: dark~angel
Yes, he wasnt tolerated - but yet is he so now? He is widely regarded as a figurehead of Sadism (which is one of the reasons I believe that sadism is such a misunderstood concept) and nobody bats an eyelid at the mention of his name, yet he should be regarded in the same light as hitler or myra hindly. In fact his works and himself are objectified in some quaters, when in fact his books are no better written than John Normen, who is looked down upon by many BDSM practitioners.

I think you started a good post and highlighted some good points. I hope more people here might contribue their thoughts to it. Thanks frenchpet.


Well, yes, he was a monster, this is why I mentionned Gilles de Rais. Gilles de Rais was a hero of the hundred year war between two french families for the control of France, a companion of Jehanne d'Arc (the crazy girl that heard voices). But he was also a monster whose young victims were by the hundreds.

It's interesting that you mention John Norman because, although I know nothing about him, I think I read that it claims to be about the natural order. Well, Sade claimed "Je suis l'homme de la nature avant d'être celui de la société." (I am the man of nature before being the man of society).

Thanks *blush*




LadyAngelika -> RE: (real) quotes of the Marquis de Sade (9/16/2005 4:25:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: frenchpet

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyAngelika

Since you seem to be someone an expert on the Marquis, can you tell me if you believe the following, which has always been one of my favorites, is truly his? I have never been able to find the French equivalent.

"One must do violence to the object of one's desire; when it surrenders, the pleasure is greater."

Merci ;-)

- LA


Yes, it is in the The 120 days of Sodom that is available on print.google.com. Simone de Beauvoir (who with JP Sartre formed imho the most brilliant couple that ever was ), in her introduction "Must We Burn Sade ?" quotes this sentence. But only a part of this book is available on google, so I don't know where it is exactly. You'll have to read the french version on gallica.bnf.fr to know more. The only problem with gallica is that the pdf files are not searchables, they are only photocopies.


Actually I've been looking online and here's what I found: the whole text in HTML and even downloadable word in French.

From the main page you can find all his books and from the search page you can search a word and find a quote from him.

En français seulement ;-)

And I found it in english here and here. I searched both all and I still can't seem to find this quote within the text. Yes I've found a site with an excerpt from Simone de Beauvoir where she writes:

quote:

In practice, it is difficult to indulge in cruelty, except within very modest limits; and in theory, it implies a contradiction which is expressed in the following two passages: "The most divine charms are as nothing when submission and obedience do not come forth to offer them," and "One must do violence to the object of one's desire; when it surrenders, the pleasure is greater." But where is one to find free slaves? One has to be satisfied with compromises. With paid and abjectly consenting prostitutes, Sade went somewhat beyond the limits that had been agreed upon. He allowed himself some violence against a wife who maintained a certain human dignity in her docility.


But I can't seem to find the passage in the book!

- LA




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125