Societies (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


Termyn8or -> Societies (2/27/2008 11:32:07 PM)

Well the other thread is too much now, so I thought I'd start another. This is another thought, something I propose as possible, but will not even attempt to prove. The subject is put out to get opinions and have a discussion, not to prove or disprove my assertions, which I state now are assertions not of fact.

Now, if we can all accept that.

To begin, most of mankind are explorative in nature. At least what we know of it. That is my point.

Now were the invaders, or visitors who came upon less developed societies recognized ? No they did not even know we existed. Tribes of the US before it's inception maybe, aborigine tribes in Austrailia, tribes of Africans. Before we came, they did not know of our existence. They may have because of previous excursions, and that, by one source is purported, the the Europeans came to the US long before even the 1400s. But that is neither here nor there.

If a race does not yet explore, I mean by building boats or whatever, how do they know that they are not the only people on Earth ? If Leif Erricson would have come to America, the account of his visit might be mythology. Too much time passes and history can become mythology, given peoples' extreme talent for embellishment. What if Magellen stopped by ? And I mean anywhere, not just (the) America(s). I bet there was quite a stir in any community like that.

Now, following that reasoning, it is known that the northern races built boats and explored. Not all northern either. But went to seek out new places and races. They were not afraid to go out and figure out how to communicate with different peoples'. Actually I admire that. It takes some guts because you could wind up in a soup pot in some places in the world. You have to learn some of their language before you can teach them yours, and that is the best case scenario. Try this with no translators or anything or the sort. Not an easy job.

But now the point of it all this. Suppose, just suppose, please just suppose that there is a society on this Earth that is more advanced than us.

We reach out, they do not, they see us as warlike and basically do not want to have anything to do with us. They have good enough technology that they do not have to fight for natural resources like us, and they just want to be left alone. They have no problem blocking any surveilance method we have. They might live in a heretofore unexplored part of the world. And there are some places the satellites can't see.

So here is the question : How would we know that they exist ?

The tribes and races we have infected with our diseases, put off their land and so forth, they did not know we were coming, they probably did not even know we exist, but they had no concerns about being discovered in alot of cases. Let's say this technologically superior race does not want to be found.

Argue against that if you care to, but satellite images of Antarctica are bit scarce, and with enough technology there could be an entire civilization under the snow anyway. Or under the ocean. Either place would be good for a society that wishes to remain undiscovered to go. Let the rest of us kill each other and then come out.

If they have the technology to survive on the deep part of the ocean floor, we would literally have to destroy this planet itself to hurt them. Just making the environment uninhabitable just means more time under the sea for them. Remember they do not want to find us, or to be found.

I am not talking any secret Masonic cult or any bullshit like that, I am talking an older and more advanced society. Totally seperate, and never discovered. Not Atlantis, nothing of the sort.

But the thing is, who can prove it does not exist ? There is some minor evidence that it does, but nothing even close to solid. But the point still is, prove it does not. Been to every inch of the Earth ? Seen everything on this planet ? If not, you are going to have a hard time disproving it.

I'm sure there will be more detail later, but for now, what effective argument can you give against the existence of a superior society, somewhere on this planet ?

Actually I have some evidence, but it is not yet time. Step by step.

Disprove the existence of a technologically superior society, not among us, just on this planet, in fact specifically NOT among us. Remember I am not talking about cliques of us, like some Bilderberg stuff or anything like that I am talking about people (or beings) we never knew existed.

And if they developed seperately for so long, I guess we would have to call them terrestrial aliens.

OK, it was really good stuff man, but I throw this out there, just don't start tearing each other up again. Keep it up and I'll have to stop, I did not come here to wreck the place.

Remember, THIS IS ALL HYPOTHETICAL. Please try to understand that. I am not saying I am not a nut, but I am not being a nut right now. This came into my mind a long time ago, so here it is. Do not treat this as an assertion that they do exist.

T




CuriousLord -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 12:09:12 AM)

Intelligence segregates people enough already.  You don't find many stupid people in a science graduate's hall, afterall.

Sadly, there aren't that many technological secrets.  Most of those are sold for goods and services.  And, why not?




Muttling -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 12:18:34 AM)

First you have to come up with a definition of the term "superior society".   It seems to me like there was a time in recent history where a nation tried to establish itself as just that....the superior society.

If one sticks to your argument of technological advancements, Nazi Germany was by FAR the superior society on the planet in the late 1930's.  They, of course, sought to establish the aerian race as far superior and fully believed that it was.   


hmmm.......Does technology REALLY seem like a good measure of social superiority?




luckydog1 -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 12:42:10 AM)

The premise is kind of silly, you can't prove that something like you describe doesn't exist.  I can't proove there isn't an invisible martian probe following me around either

IF such a society existed, and it was mankind based, ie started with us, it would seem that they would have had to follow a similar path of development to get to the advanced technology you describe, and that would leave evidence, old mines, a carbon record, depleted oil wells.  Also the idea that they would have cleaned up all of thier relics seems unlikely, and we would be finding things that are way out of the time line fairly often.  Manufactured steel from the pre bronze age for example, they managed to collect the stuff from meteorites back then, but its not machined.  An extra terrestial under sea base would be a lot more plausible.

BTW not just white people sailed the seas or explored.  And many cultures knew there were others out there.  The Meso Americans had prophecies of the Whites coming back.  The polynesians were among the greatest explorers ever known.  They landed in South America thousands of years ago.  The spread over the Oceans of the San peoples was amazing.  Europe is simply lucky that China decided to not colonize America, they found it long ago.  What was unique about the Northern Europeons is that they developed Modern Science, which created a population boom, and they had to export the surplus people, displacing others in the process (which the weopons from Science made much easier).




pahunkboy -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 5:23:58 AM)

--I wonder what time the pilgrams landed.  8:18 Eastern, 7:18 ceentral. EST ?

1/2 of the fun is the journey.

American culture is different at 1981, then 2007.   and varies from region to region.

T, your question begs another question. Where can one go today to live- where ads are not in the face where person is a tribe- not a USB for the red tape machine.  why does it piss me off to go to store?  The barriers to walk thru it fast- the people clogginng standing in the way w all the time in the world.  Lately I started being verbal- as in beep beep; I said excuse me loudly and I got a sarcastic reply. While that folk might have all the time in the world- I dont.  Then there was the hacking coughing the day before. I mean like a freight train coughing.I said I dont want your cold- the lady said "i dont have a cold" I said "ohh okk".  clogged people, fat people- me stooped to select cereal w whole wheat not enrreiched. 

I guess I am a bitch.or maybe a product of a disfunctional soociety.

which made me wonder on all these shootings - how is this ultra tight security- funds for graphitti removal cut- see the show no logo- and it explains how the peon has no voice.




subtee -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 10:59:19 AM)

Term, what you smoking? Do you share?

I do think the idea of a society that would reject us is a cool idea.

"I don't want to belong to any club that will accept me as a member."
--Groucho Marx




ottRopesandKnots -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 12:54:01 PM)

While I can't prove it does or doesn't exist, I think we can agree that the likelyhood of the scenario described is very small.  So small in fact that it isn't worth worrying about.  Besides which, if they meant us any harm they'd have done it by now.

You may also wish to add to the scenario the thought that maybe we do know of another sentient group on the planet, but our leaders hide it from us.




seeksfemslave -> RE: Societies (2/28/2008 1:02:54 PM)

Didn't read Termy's post but if I were Supreme Commander of a truly civilised society and my intelligence sources told me that you dangerous Earthlings were heading my way, I can tell you now you would be in big trouble.

Expect cosmic bombs and space torpedoes to be launched in your direction forthwith.
Our bombs and torpedoes never miss.
Go home Earthlings




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125