celticlord2112
Posts: 5732
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: domiguy It is important to have an idea of your subject matter before you start a thread. Florida and Michigan changed the date of their primaries to try and make their states votes more relevant...You can't do it. It only makes sense. So the DNC ruled that both states delegates would not be seated at the party convention. All of the Democratic candidates agreed not to campaign in Florida and Michigan before the primary. There's nothing intrinsically rational about the particular rule the Florida and Michigan Legislatures violated. It is an arbitrary rule and an arbitrary date. That which is arbitrary is inherently irrational by definition. Here is the text of the rule that was broken, straight from the DNC website: quote:
11. TIMING OF THE DELEGATE SELECTION PROCESS A. No meetings, caucuses, conventions or primaries which constitute the first determining stage in the presidential nomination process (the date of the primary in primary states, and the date of the first tier caucus in caucus states) may be held prior to the first Tuesday in February or after the second Tuesday in June in the calendar year of the national convention. Provided, however, that the Iowa precinct caucuses may be held no earlier than 22 days before the first Tuesday in February; that the Nevada first-tier caucuses may be held no earlier than 17 days before the first Tuesday in February; that the New Hampshire primary may be held no earlier than 14 days before the first Tuesday in February; and that the South Carolina primary may be held no earlier than 7 days before the first Tuesday in February. In no instance may a state which scheduled delegate selection procedures on or between the first Tuesday in February and the second Tuesday in June 1984 move out of compliance with the provisions of this rule. Interestingly, in reviewing the actual text of the rules, I came across this interesting tidbit: quote:
20.C.1.A Violation of timing: In the event the Delegate Selection Plan of a state party provides or permits a meeting, caucus, convention or primary which constitutes the first determining stage in the presidential nominating process to be held prior to or after the dates for the state as provided in Rule 11 of these rules, or in the event a state holds such a meeting, caucus, convention or primary prior to or after such dates, the number of pledged delegates elected in each category allocated to the state pursuant to the Call for the National Convention shall be reduced by fifty (50%) percent, and the number of alternates shall also be reduced by fifty (50%) percent. In addition, none of the members of the Democratic National Committee and no other unpledged delegate allocated pursuant to Rule 8.A. from that state shall be permitted to vote as members of the state’s delegation. In determining the actual number of delegates or alternates by which the state’s delegation is to be reduced, any fraction below .5 shall be rounded down to the nearest whole number, and any fraction of .5 or greater shall be rounded up to the next nearest whole number. Curiously enough, this tracks exactly with the course of action taken by the RNC in response to similar rules violations for their primary process. For whatever reason, the DNC Rules and Bylaws Committee exercised their powers under 20.C.5 to impose additional sanctions on Florida and Michigan exclusively. Moreover, by the text of the rule Iowa, New Hampshire, and South Carolina's primaries (caucus for Iowa) were also in violation, and no punishment was meted out at all. If "rules are rules", then the results for Iowa, New Hampshire, and South Carolina should similarly be invalidated. As an interesting side note, such a course eliminates a good chunk of Obama's delegate lead. Shame on the legislatures for not reading the rule book and taking it seriously. Shame also on the DNC for committing the same sin. Double shame on the candidates for not articulating equitable treatment per the letter of the rules to which they agreed.
_____________________________
|