RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


domahpet -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 8:48:10 AM)

all i can say is if i had been on this site before i began, i may never have began.
my 1st time was amazing, talk about jumping in with both feet!
i was excited, terrified, and did eveything i got the chance to.
*remembering the spanking horse and shackles.....[sm=candles.gif][sm=crop.gif]*




verysweet -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 8:52:27 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Luciferica

To a degree I agree ..to everything there is a season, but I also think Newbies should be comfortable with the play before they get involved in it, otherwise someone could get hurt


I'm not certain how you can be entirely comfortable with the play unless you actually try.  No amount of reading, listening, whatever can compare to real life experience.  It's knowing your limitations (if you have terrible asthma, maybe breath play should be off limits, etc).  What's more important to me is being comfortable with those people I choose to pursue things with rather than my comfort level with the act itself.

If taking risks, going where you've not gone before, etc, is comfortable for you, that's awesome.  That's how it is for me.  And lots of the things we've done required me to simply dive right in without any preproduction.

And you have to admit.....you could have a ton of experience in one area, let's say, with percussion play or whatever.  I'm not certain that 'being experienced' in one thing will necessarily prepare you for another.  Regardless if you're just starting out or not.  Having spent 15 plus years in relationships where the style of play was basically bondage, flogging, spanking, etc... in no way prepared me for needle play or heavy breath play or other more 'edgier' things. 

quote:

I think that if adults are going to play adult games they should be responsible for themselves.  They should learn to listen to their own safety voice and learn when to take a risk and how to manage the risk they take.


This is spot-on, Katy.






faerytattoodgirl -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 8:53:56 AM)

every newbie should know that I STILL WANT BOIJEN.

eh...




LadyHibiscus -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 9:20:53 AM)

I am not the safety police.  When I look back at some of the stuff I've done, and the situations I've been in, it IS rather startling that the most I've ever needed was a bandaid as far as first aid.  And my playmates and I are still alive!

I think the best advice has to be, "Don't be a dumbass".  But yanno?  Some folks are, and always will be.  Horror stories will keep the scaredey ones away from physical experiences, but the people who want to do things are going to do them. 




ownedgirlie -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 9:52:12 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: domahpet

all i can say is if i had been on this site before i began, i may never have began.
my 1st time was amazing, talk about jumping in with both feet!
i was excited, terrified, and did eveything i got the chance to.


Same here. 

And toservez, as usual, I agree with what you wrote.  Nice job.




Corvidae -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 9:55:23 AM)

I agree that the "thou shalt not" format is not a good one for advising people about anything. It sure doesn't work for sex-ed. As a newbie myself, I want to have as much information as possible. I want to hear about the good, the bad, and the ugly in what I am considering trying so that I can make an informed decision for myself. However, I have to say that I appreciate it when a someone tells me that they personally wouldn't reccomend doing x, y, and z as a new person, especially if they have concrete reasons (not scare tactics) for their reccomendations. I also respect it if a top I am going to do a scene with says they aren't comfortable doing something to me (yet) because I am new. I appreciate their sincerity and I personally would trust their judgement, especially since this caution is as much for them as it is for me (I imagine it would feel awful to give someone a bad/scary first experience). If I still really wanted to do that thing I suppose I could try to find another top.




Stephann -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 10:22:18 AM)

I have to say, I think everything that really needed to be said on this topic has already been well touched on.

People new to the lifestyle aren't so different from how I remember cub scouts.  I wanted to try everything, and try it NOW!  It didn't mean I was even remotely ready to; yet after three years of being told "you can have a knife when you're older" I got bored and stopped bothering with it.

Newbies usually need to taste more than just textbooks to stay interested.  If responsible people won't play with them, irresponsible people will. 

Stephan




LadyPact -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 10:57:59 AM)

As hard as it is to understand, jen, you have to realize that not every new person is like you when you were new.  Not everybody is going to take the time to understand themselves enough to know what they're ready for and what they're not.  Not everyone is going to learn how to use a particular toy before deciding the first time they pick it up they are going to use it on a person. 

It isn't about limiting anyone's possible experiences or activities.  Hell, I'm the first person to say get away from the computer and get out into the world.  In the same breath, I tell them to remember what they need for their own safety. 

Personally, I've taken more than a few people's scene cherry and I can tell you two things.  First, I've gone softer on them than what I thought they were able to take.  It's because I would rather err on the side of caution.  A person's first trip to subspace can be a lot to process in and of itself.  Second, once they get that soft taste, it leaves them wanting more, whether that be with Me or another Top.  I've never received any complaints using this method.  Nobody's ever been in danger, and it's become wonderful memories on both sides.

The point is, people have to know what's right for them.  For who they are.  Some people can and will jump in with both feet.  Some will only want to dip their toe in the pool.  Either way, there's nothing wrong with telling people who are swimming for the first time, not to drown.




lalbobbilynn -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 11:06:21 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BoiJen

Recently there was a thread about what "every newbie should know..." Okay. I can totally agree with the primary basis of the post. Ad even the intent. What I can't agree with is a post on the thread stating that delving into certain play style isn't something a newbie "should" do.

I mean who wrote the rules on what newbies should and shouldn't do or try or enjoy? If they want to jump in with both feet and go hog wild it's their choice and who's out there that is so worldly and "expereinced" to demand a standard of what new people to SM should and shouldn't try?

Basically, it's not the first time I've seen anyone try to limit the expereinces of someone who wants to experiment. I think people make assumptions based on themselves about what others shoudl try and at what rate, rather than asking the other individuals involved "what do YOU want to do?"

The impression i was given from the thread You speak of was ..... "what You want" and what may actually result vary from person to person, so simply take heed. As has been stated on this thread, is better to go easy then go over the edge.




FRSguy -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 11:15:49 AM)

The way I see it we all try new things at some point. Not really sure how much experience you need in one thing before trying something else out.  I do think that if people are interested in something than they will try it no matter what so I do think its much better to take the Do you know what your getting yourself into aproach rather than telling someone that they cant do it because they havent reached some imaginary point. I really think the whole experience / age and what not are pretty much a bunch of crap. You can pretty much teach someone nearly anything and there are safty stuff all over the web.




SteelofUtah -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 11:24:06 AM)

Jen,

There is a time in peoples lives where they are ready to face the world as it is and discover the things that they never knew about were always there.

You discovered this by jumping in Head first. So did I. However I have also gone back and seen how things changed then, what I was and wasn't really ready for.

As much as giving someone the risks and walking away is effective for people like us. I find it is NOT effective with the fantasy laiden boddice-ripper novel reading rose inted glasses wearing sub who thinks that this lifestyle will play out like it does in the fantasy novels with Fabio on the cover. Thes people *SHOULD* be sat down and given a reality lesson and then once done sent off to do what they will.

I understand that for people like us the only way to meet the horizon is to travel to it and then find ourselves back at the place we started having never gotten closer to the horizon but beliefing that he had found it time and time again and come back wiser for have beliving we could reach something that did not exist. Or as your example puts Come to accept something by diving in and dealing with it and comeing out and knowing we are better for it now.

I do believe however that there are some things that more often than not end poorly and the reasosn it happens at all is usually the same. Someone thinks that something will make thier life better and so they seek it out and do whatever it takes till they get it and once they have it or what they accepted as being is they are miserable but trying to convince themselves that they are happy because they finally have what they thought they wanted.

The Point that Micheal was making in his post was that everyone SHOULD be told that what we do is supposed to be enjoyable to BOTH parties, that is you go to bed PRAYING that it will get better tomorrow then there is something wrong and not worth the effort that is being put in just to maintain the illusion of what you THINK you want.

I have delt with MANY MANY MANY subs who are timid or refrained when it comes to meeting someone who really is on the level because of the ease and quickness thet got involved in something that was NOT good for them. If they go into all relationships knowing they they are supposed to be enjoying themselves maybe less of these women would get AS hurt as they are,

Sure NOTHING can keep everyone safe but if they follow a little GOOD ADVICE then it can only help to make the world a better place.

Where I understand your issue can you see anything NEGATIVE coming from every newbie being given this advice?

I only see it helping, even if they choose to ignore the advice, maybe one of them will take it and it will save them years of misery.

Why not offer a blanket comment that serves to offer a better way just to save the one person who doesn't need it?

Steel




DelilahDeb -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 12:10:23 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyPact

As hard as it is to understand, jen, you have to realize that not every new person is like you when you were new. Not everybody is going to take the time to understand themselves enough to know what they're ready for and what they're not. Not everyone is going to learn how to use a particular toy before deciding the first time they pick it up they are going to use it on a person.

It isn't about limiting anyone's possible experiences or activities. Hell, I'm the first person to say get away from the computer and get out into the world. In the same breath, I tell them to remember what they need for their own safety.

Personally, I've taken more than a few people's scene cherry and I can tell you two things. First, I've gone softer on them than what I thought they were able to take. It's because I would rather err on the side of caution. A person's first trip to subspace can be a lot to process in and of itself. Second, once they get that soft taste, it leaves them wanting more, whether that be with Me or another Top. I've never received any complaints using this method. Nobody's ever been in danger, and it's become wonderful memories on both sides.

The point is, people have to know what's right for them. For who they are. Some people can and will jump in with both feet. Some will only want to dip their toe in the pool. Either way, there's nothing wrong with telling people who are swimming for the first time, not to drown.



There's new, and there's new.

  • The 22-year-old collegiate who said after a mild flogging that he had gone "beyond his wildest dreams of total ecstasy" — could he give informed consent to the extremer forms of play? doubtful. Is he equipped to judge a top's experience with potentially deadly play? Damned unlikely.
  • The 42-year-old Rennie who has played with live steel weapons for decades and who chooses to begin her dommely career with knife play is also new. Is she safe for a bottom to play with? for knife play, almost certainly. for full-body bondage and suspension? who the fuck knows?
  • The 37-year-old disabled stunt double from Coalinga, CA, begins his scene career by teaching ponyplay. Is he safe to play with? Use your horse sense. (pun accidental but retained with malice) [FYI: Coalinga is close enough to Hollywood to get there in an afternoon, and far enough to ranch horses.]

EVERYONE comes to the scene with and without data, information, knowledge, and wisdom (DIKW) about the scene and its risks and rewards.
Unfortunately, the interest and enthusiasm of a newby is rarely proportionate to the DIKW surrounding a given form of play, let alone combining them.
Including me!
Fortunately, many people bring with them all sorts of useful DIKW about rope, tack, steel, leather, machinery, anatomy, physiology, kinesiology, physics, chemistry…which leaves them able to apply some portions of this DIKW to scenes. But the younger the human, the less DIKW they will have aboard—
and often, the more hormonal insanity without leaven of experience.

So. Define NEW.

What newbies need most is information, followed quickly by knowledge. Data is for the statistically minded. Wisdom is in the lap of the gods.

Delilah Deb




SNoB -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 1:13:36 PM)

I suppose I have just listened to jay wiseman too much in the past week and a half.  Hearing about too many people getting killed because someone didnt have proper knowledge on a scene before starting it.




LaTigresse -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 1:24:20 PM)

Using fast reply..........

I like the quote "stupid is as stupid does" in this sort of conversation.






KatyLied -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 1:25:42 PM)

quote:

Hearing about too many people getting killed because someone didnt have proper knowledge on a scene before starting it.


Where are the news reports regarding all of these many people getting killed?  How is it that I miss all of this news?  Is it kept secret?  Publicized as something else?




LadyPact -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 2:16:32 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DelilahDeb


quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyPact

As hard as it is to understand, jen, you have to realize that not every new person is like you when you were new. Not everybody is going to take the time to understand themselves enough to know what they're ready for and what they're not. Not everyone is going to learn how to use a particular toy before deciding the first time they pick it up they are going to use it on a person.

It isn't about limiting anyone's possible experiences or activities. Hell, I'm the first person to say get away from the computer and get out into the world. In the same breath, I tell them to remember what they need for their own safety.





There's new, and there's new.
  • The 22-year-old collegiate who said after a mild flogging that he had gone "beyond his wildest dreams of total ecstasy" — could he give informed consent to the extremer forms of play? doubtful. Is he equipped to judge a top's experience with potentially deadly play? Damned unlikely.
  • The 42-year-old Rennie who has played with live steel weapons for decades and who chooses to begin her dommely career with knife play is also new. Is she safe for a bottom to play with? for knife play, almost certainly. for full-body bondage and suspension? who the fuck knows?
  • The 37-year-old disabled stunt double from Coalinga, CA, begins his scene career by teaching ponyplay. Is he safe to play with? Use your horse sense. (pun accidental but retained with malice) [FYI: Coalinga is close enough to Hollywood to get there in an afternoon, and far enough to ranch horses.]

EVERYONE comes to the scene with and without data, information, knowledge, and wisdom (DIKW) about the scene and its risks and rewards.
Unfortunately, the interest and enthusiasm of a newby is rarely proportionate to the DIKW surrounding a given form of play, let alone combining them.
Including me!
Fortunately, many people bring with them all sorts of useful DIKW about rope, tack, steel, leather, machinery, anatomy, physiology, kinesiology, physics, chemistry…which leaves them able to apply some portions of this DIKW to scenes. But the younger the human, the less DIKW they will have aboard—
and often, the more hormonal insanity without leaven of experience.

So. Define NEW.

What newbies need most is information, followed quickly by knowledge. Data is for the statistically minded. Wisdom is in the lap of the gods.

Delilah Deb

I'm trying to figure out which part of My post you found that disagreed with your point of view.  I'm very lost at the introduction of the acronym, or the need of the application.

In the three examples you gave above, I will oblige, and say the answers are a resounding 'no', but I think something was skipped.  That would be the common sense factor of those who would chose to play.  Would it be your position to suggest that the person on the other end of the kneel in these situations would be as foolish as the examples you site?  Good Lord, I hope not! 

Just because a person is new, doesn't mean their common sense has, or should be, thrown out the window.  No one here is saying that learning a thing or two before participating in activity is a bad idea.  I'll grant you that obtaining some information prior is a good planning method, but how would you suggest they go further and get the knowledge?  If anyone out there is like Me, they aren't going to get it through osmosis. 

In no part of My post, nor in the OP's, if I am remembering right, was it suggested that anyone should go into an activity blindly, without regard for safety or common sense.






SNoB -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 2:24:49 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: KatyLied

quote:

Hearing about too many people getting killed because someone didnt have proper knowledge on a scene before starting it.


Where are the news reports regarding all of these many people getting killed?  How is it that I miss all of this news?  Is it kept secret?  Publicized as something else?



Check out jay's blog if you want some stories of things gone wrong.  There are many others, you just have to look. http://jay-wiseman.livejournal.com/  I dont know about you, but I dont want to be charged with seccond degree murder for leaving someone alone in bondage or doing a breath play scene.




AMaster -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 2:28:40 PM)

The limits of a newbie are to be tested and expanded.  This is also true of an experienced sub/slave..........  that is why I always use a safe word. 




colouredin -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 2:33:18 PM)

My first play/scene was at a fetish club actually the first time I had met people into D/s it took place at the after-show party I hardly knew the people, it went fine until after we left because I "went feet first" into it I was chocked, we hadnt spoke about limits or any of that I did have a safe word but it took me by surprise and I had a full on panic attack. Luckily i learnt from it and I am fairly resilant still it put me off for a while. I became almost over cautious about specifing limits. Now i am far more balanced. That kind of situation could have put people off for a long time and caused serious issues.

I now tell people that story and I advise people based on what i have experainced, I guess as you are doing in your own way. All things said on these boards are based on personal opinion and what we know worked for us, thats how it is, however some things can be applied more generally to many differant types of people, terms that can be used as an umbrella.

Of course at the end of the day people can make their own decisions, you know yourself better than anyone, and you can make that choice based on how you think you would react, but we have all heard the term sub frenzy and all that. It can work both ways advice can be a help and a hinderance depending on who you listen to, but that shouldnt mean that there is no advice, most people who happen upon sites like this happen upon them because they are drawn to it but want to read about it. Advice and personal experiance is what this site is about. But you are right in that at the end of the day its down to the individual to make the final call.




BoiJen -> RE: Newbies should/shouldn't...says who? (4/8/2008 4:18:24 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SNoB

quote:

ORIGINAL: KatyLied

quote:

Hearing about too many people getting killed because someone didnt have proper knowledge on a scene before starting it.


Where are the news reports regarding all of these many people getting killed?  How is it that I miss all of this news?  Is it kept secret?  Publicized as something else?



Check out jay's blog if you want some stories of things gone wrong.  There are many others, you just have to look. http://jay-wiseman.livejournal.com/  I dont know about you, but I dont want to be charged with seccond degree murder for leaving someone alone in bondage or doing a breath play scene.


I am not Jay Wiseman's biggest fan for the fact that he is a perfect example of being the safety police. I have nothing against the guy. He's an ex-EMT...his life was based solely around the negative and worst case scenarios. And he frequently states the biggest issue with what we do and injuries is NOT the activity itself. It's secondary stuff we forget about that casues problems. Like tieing someone up in a precarious position and falling rather than in a firm stance.

Breath play for example...a 180lb female top who is doing breath play on an unbound male who can bench 300lbs...the chances of issues ocurring are slim. Incredibly so.

So rather than trying to scare the shit out of someone try to inform them.

And I for one LOVE breath play.




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875