keeping the poor in the poorhouse (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


aviinterra -> keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 7:26:11 AM)

        I have an old aquaintance from way back when . Our lives came out radically different. I am comfy in my own house, with little material worries and can persue my interests to a degree that keeps me happy. Her life on the other hand has been constantly on the brink and in a total financial ruin. The fault is not her's, a series of job lay offs, medical issues and a rural area that does not have good pay. But still, her credit is trashed, etc. I help out with the food as much as I can, but I can't pay all of someone else's bills. It was hard for me to realize at first while talking to her that she was denied for a job she was completely qualified for just because of her credit ( and then again and again ), and then a few months later her bank account was closed- because some other unrelated company gave her a negative. Now gone is the car too, because the auto insurance co. can cancel your car insurance if you have two or more negs. So thinking about this, I wonder how a poor person can get back up and take themselves out of a hole if every chance is thwarted by large corps?? Cut off from a good paying job and now made sedatery by being refused car insurance even with a perfect driving record just because of your credit seems to me to be taking this whole credit thing leagues too far. It started out a helpful tool for banks to know their applicants for mortgages and such, now it is absolutely capable of ruining lives. How pathetic that we allow so much control to these multi-billion corps, who are making hungry serfs out of the poorest and helpless of the nation. 




meatcleaver -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 7:35:13 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: aviinterra

       I have an old aquaintance from way back when . Our lives came out radically different. I am comfy in my own house, with little material worries and can persue my interests to a degree that keeps me happy. Her life on the other hand has been constantly on the brink and in a total financial ruin. The fault is not her's, a series of job lay offs, medical issues and a rural area that does not have good pay. But still, her credit is trashed, etc. I help out with the food as much as I can, but I can't pay all of someone else's bills. It was hard for me to realize at first while talking to her that she was denied for a job she was completely qualified for just because of her credit ( and then again and again ), and then a few months later her bank account was closed- because some other unrelated company gave her a negative. Now gone is the car too, because the auto insurance co. can cancel your car insurance if you have two or more negs. So thinking about this, I wonder how a poor person can get back up and take themselves out of a hole if every chance is thwarted by large corps?? Cut off from a good paying job and now made sedatery by being refused car insurance even with a perfect driving record just because of your credit seems to me to be taking this whole credit thing leagues too far. It started out a helpful tool for banks to know their applicants for mortgages and such, now it is absolutely capable of ruining lives. How pathetic that we allow so much control to these multi-billion corps, who are making hungry serfs out of the poorest and helpless of the nation. 


She is ideologically unsound and should be sent to a gulag. Of course such terms are not used in the west because we are free. However, we aren't free, we live in a capitalist society that requires people to be ideologically sound. You friend needs to spend time in a re-education centre until she learns about the value of money and the need not to blame the system for her own ideological failings.




Mercnbeth -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 7:50:17 AM)

quote:

because the auto insurance co. can cancel your car insurance if you have two or more negs.

I think you 'miss-spoke'. Massachusetts has a State insurance plan a/k/a 'assigned risk' pool. Because MA requires insurance they must have a program to cover people who do not qualify for the voluntary market. If she's not in MA, ANY State with a similar mandatory insurance policy has a similar program. Is she so rural as to be outside the route of any public transportation? It would be cheaper than an auto.

However, as you point out, she's not looking for a job - she's looking for a "good paying job", in a rural area that "does not have good pay". That makes sense to you? It's the control of these "multi-billion corps" that made her have medical issues and forces her to live outside a good job market? There's been no decisions that she made that contributed to her situation right? It's the fault of the credit bureaus, reporting truth, that put her in her situation and keep her in it.

Considering the insurance story, it would give me cause to doubt the reason she gave about being turned down for a job. It's amazing how the lack of integrity comes out during an interview. Maybe that's the problem - with her, NOT the people who would hire her. She seems to be seeking sympathy more than a job. I respect how you feel you should help her and want to, but you are also enabling her.

You trust her. You accept her stories because honesty in a friend is expected, especially if you are honest. However, you don't help get to the reason by accepting as fact rationalization.




aviinterra -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 7:59:54 AM)

Wow! People's lack of insensitivity and such is staggering!
How is being turned down for a job make one "idealogically unsound"??? I guess you were never turned down. How is being laid off, having sky high medical bills and unable to feed yourself a lack of education about the value of money???? She had a good job that paid the bills, but when that stopped, and she became stuck making 7 bucks an hour pre-tax and consequently fell behind- I doubt that can be blamed completely on her.




aviinterra -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:05:09 AM)

She's not in MA, and the amount that those programs charge is ridiculous. Yes, she is out of public transport. She is looking for a good job- aka a job that pays the bills and allows you to eat- while she is holding a crappy job now. I never said she was unemployed.
I guess I see that it's easy for those who are not in the situation to judge so harshly and think a person in such a situation is there by there by their own fault or even choice. Let's talk again once you have cancer and can't pay the 15K a month for pills. Until then, perheps you should consider that sometimes, the system is not fair indeed.




sub4hire -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:13:35 AM)

Hmm, this is what I'd do.  File for bankruptcy.  Get all of the bad credit off of me while I could.  Stop more from getting on my credit.

I live in a somewhat rural area of the midwest now.  I can tell you that while yes there are poor paying jobs here.  There are also jobs that pay far more than the big cities do.  What is even more odd about it all is..for the high paying jobs you don't need experience like you would in a larger city.

I think Nebraska's minimum wage is something like 5 dollars an hour.  I have a friend who runs a bar, she pays her people 2 dollars an hour.  If you want to work for the city, county you may make 10 dollars an hour.  Yet, if you work in the private sector you're going to make so much more money..its crazy the way things are set up.

I've also noticed that companies in the midwest ask for references and they actually check them out.  Many do ask for credit checks.  A problem if you have poor credit.  Although you can still apply for the job making 200,000 grand a year and they won't ask you.  So, my advice is...tell her to keep looking.  Something will come around. 

First and foremost though I'd get the bad credit off of my record. 




aviinterra -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:19:43 AM)

Thank the advice, I will forward it to her. I don't know crap about bankrupcy or such,  but I will certainly let her know what you wrote. In her area they always check the credit reports for almost everything, which keeps her down, and believe me she is looking.




LaTigresse -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:21:55 AM)

It has been my personal experience that, more often than not, poor people are the ones responsible for their own long term poverty.

Where there is a will, there is almost always a way. I guaranfuckintee it.




meatcleaver -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:27:02 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: aviinterra

Wow! People's lack of insensitivity and such is staggering!
How is being turned down for a job make one "idealogically unsound"??? I guess you were never turned down. How is being laid off, having sky high medical bills and unable to feed yourself a lack of education about the value of money???? She had a good job that paid the bills, but when that stopped, and she became stuck making 7 bucks an hour pre-tax and consequently fell behind- I doubt that can be blamed completely on her.



Have you no sense of irony?




mhawk -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:35:47 AM)

i actually understand what you are saying.part of that being is last year(winter/spring07) i had taken a job on a ship.because of being that we didn't have permante residence anywhere we had to open bank accounts for direct deposits.in as such i have a small credit issue,most of the banks i went to refused me an account because of that.at the last minute i ended up going to a credit union(they tend to be more helpful). i can understand credit checks for things such a applying for a credit card and such.but, i do not see why some employers do them as well.i've run into that myself.a job should be based on skills and what can be offered on the possible employees part not their credit history.

another source to possibly look into would be seeing about agencies that may be able to help with lower rental costs,don't get me worng not the crappy places.there are some really good apartments that agencies can help with.

i truly do hope things do get better for you friend and i wish the best of luck.




Mercnbeth -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:48:06 AM)

quote:

Let's talk again once you have cancer and can't pay the 15K a month for pills. Until then, perheps you should consider that sometimes, the system is not fair indeed.


What you don't know can fill an encyclopedia.

2001 - $0 income, home in foreclosure, no job, every penny of assets used to try to save a business located in the ruble that was once the WTC II, and/or pay creditors. I dare say it would be impossible to have had a worse credit report than I did. Put the house on the market while the Bank, (the banker was a personal friend of mine) was putting it through foreclosure. For work, I got at job at FedEx loading trucks in the middle of the night for $10/hour. After that was done, I went to day job working as a clerk for minimum wage. Sold all the cars, used mass transit, eventually saved up for a MC, which was packed along with everything else that was 'free & clear' and would fit into a 19' U-Haul which I drove 3000 miles to CA in Feb 2002 because I had a commitment for 6 weeks of work, and a "we'll see after that". Lots of effort and cases of Raman noodles later, here I am. No complaint and certainly no desire for sympathy should be taken by that representation of my past. I look back on the past 6 years with pride.

It's my sincerest hope you DO NOT have to experience any of that nor get cancer.
I do wish however that you become informed.

Edited to add (Color change): Note how quickly the story changes. It went from the evil insurance company not making coverage available to this:
quote:

She's not in MA, and the amount that those programs charge is ridiculous.
Symptomatic of a person looking, using, and in need of excuses and not solutions. You wonder why I question and fundamentally don't trust people. Here's an example of a valid why.

The system is fair if you consider yourself a part of the system. The most important part and the primary reason why you are in the situation you, or anyone else is in, is YOU. Choices are obvious; rationalize that its someone else's fault, or use your ability and personal assets to do what you can and not quit. Obviously quiting and/or blaming someone else an easier path and your friend chose to take it. You provide the enabling.

The sensitivity you show by wishing cancer on someone represents your morals.




faerytattoodgirl -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 8:58:46 AM)

quote:

having sky high medical bills


a reason i will never live in the usa.  here in canada i dont have a single medical bill ever.






Archer -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:01:43 AM)

40 years ago th solution to no jobs locally to be found was "Move to where the jobs are"  however this has become an unpopular piece of sound advice. 40 years ago you could count on the job being there for life if you got into one of the areas big employers, however getting into the mill, factory etc often depended on someone dieing and the job opening up.

Health issues are often indiscriminate in nature but not always, I sympathise with folks who get the raw end of the deal when it comes to them for the most part. But the idea that someone is not responsible for the outcome of their decissions they make also applies. School< choose to continue and lose short term gains for long term later gains? choose to take a job in a field that is obviously shrinking (textiles for the past 30 years have been shrinking, and other fields have had historic indicators that they would eventually fade). Choices to have children before being financially able to handle them, certainly sets many people back financially. Choices to work a a job and not look for better opportunities until you hear about an impending layoff, etc

There are things that we choose that effect our future and there are unknowable variables that effect them as well.
But to say we are not responsible at all for our own current situation is as wrong as saying that everything is predicatable.






pahunkboy -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:01:48 AM)

My advice-  use a credit  union, not a bank.

2 shop around on car insurance.   there is a huge difference.  mine did not go up with iffy credit. 

navigating the system can be hard- no doubt.

ild guess that this isnt hugely commen.     i have not heard of it happening a lot.  




pahunkboy -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:04:17 AM)

The lady needs a workable plan.

pity doesnt solve her problem.

some tho- are not happy unless everyone lives their pain. 




sub4hire -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:07:05 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: aviinterra

Thank the advice, I will forward it to her. I don't know crap about bankrupcy or such,  but I will certainly let her know what you wrote. In her area they always check the credit reports for almost everything, which keeps her down, and believe me she is looking.


I've never filed for bankruptcy either.  I do know people who have.  People correct me if I am wrong. 
It stays on your record for 7 years...though after those 7 years your record is wiped clean.  My best friend in high school filed a year after she got married.  Lost their house..everything.  They moved here to Nebraska and within a span of about 3 years they had a house again. 
It's a rough road to take but if you weigh the options it may be the way to go.  Here professionals get paid well less than the regular person.  So, if she does file for bankruptcy it should be far cheaper than it would be in a large area. 
For instance...I have had reason to hire an attorney in 4 states now.  In California I was paying 600 an hour.  In Colorado I paid 400 an hour.  In Oklahoma I paid 100 an hour.  Here in Nebraska my only reason was to update my will, I paid 60 an hour. 
So, depending on the state it may be pretty cheap to file as well for her. 





pahunkboy -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:11:59 AM)

neg blotches 7 years bunkruptsy  10 years.




Archer -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:15:03 AM)

Step 1 workable plan, contact a Credit Counselor. get as much of it repaired as possible and find out what your options are.

Step 2 continue the job looking but consider the fact that moving someplace with better job markets although tough may be the best idea.

Step 3 Get knowedgeable about the job market predictions and change fields to something that is not on the downward slide.




pahunkboy -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 9:47:31 AM)

nursing homes always need people.   wait staff is needed.   as far as a low wage... being that our money buys so little today- many jobs are not worth my time.  that may sound pompous- ild rather cut items of spending then to be a wage slave.   some jobs it literally would cost me more to work then to not.[work]




Termyn8or -> RE: keeping the poor in the poorhouse (4/15/2008 10:15:00 AM)

Not agreeing or disagreeing here, but Merc might have a point. People have a tendency not to tell the full story. Like my buddy who is always bellyaching about his ex not letting him see his kids, one day he calls me from jail. It was for an old domestic viiolence charge he had skipped on.

People are responsible for 90% of their problems, but that's not to imply she is lazy or stupid or anything of the sort. People make wrong decisions all the time. Many are totally unaware of it at the time, and it bites them in the ass. Of course there is that other 10%, and sometimes that has some pretty big teeth.

Just one thing happens and it all comes crashing down, why ? Brcause people are overextended and do not realize it.

I have a mixed opinion on hiring based on a credit report. I think if you are going to be in a position to handle the company's money, don't you think it would be reasonable for them to expect that the applicant is capable of handling money responsibly ? I suspect that's how my Mom got her last job as a purchasing agent. I could see it now "Lesse here, you were divorced when and had two kids X and X age ? And they let you have a credit card ? Hell, when can you start?". I remember too well the days when the three of us lived on $75 a week, and $25 of that went for afterschool sitting and that was only a couple of hours a day. No wonder the company did well !

She waited until in her 50s to buy her first new car.(and paid it off in record time, she was getting ready to retire and I asked her how much longer will she have a car payment, she replied "It's been paid off over a year now, where you been ?") 

Which brings us to the car. Always get the car paid off early. You can never get your money out of it and you need it anyway. And keep the extended warranty for as long as they offer it. One transmission job can literally put you in the poorhouse.

Your friend's problem is that she did not hedge herself well enough. As much as I know money is one of the worst things to have, you should still have 4-6 months worth of bills put away. An exception can be made when you can use the money to eliminate a bill, such as paying off a car or a CC.

Perhaps she did have some backup money, perhaps she was the best employee at the company but the boss was fucking someone else. Perhaps her record is clean and her credit used to be 790. In that case her mistake was not being pessimistic enough.

Someone mentioned bankrupcy. That is an option but it is not for everybody for a couple of reasons. For one understand that when you get that elusive chapter seven, a discharge, you still owe that money. All the discharge does is put an estoppment on collection efforts. And that's if you can get it. Under the new law it will be a thirteen, which is a reorganization and it is a different animal. In a thirteen it goes more like they got your creditors in court, or via correspondence and it is understood "You gave these people too much money, now do you want to play nice or do you want to get nothing ?".

Once it is all hammered out you do pay, and at the end you really do not owe the money. If an employer won't hire you with bad credit, I'd bet dollars to donuts that most of them will frown on a recent bankrupcy as well.

I do see what you mean though, dammed if you do damnned if you don't. And that is not a typo or a misspelling if you noticed the spelling. Of course it may be the other way around :-)

Whether bankrupcy is a good move depends on her situation entirely. Warn her to go to a credit counsellor first, if she asks for advice from a bankrupcy lawyer, of course he wants to make some money. He has a vested interest in advising her to go ahead with such action, even if it is not her best move.

There are credit couselling agencies all over the country. That should be her first stop. These agencies do what the court does with the creditors, figures out what the person can pay and plays let's make a deal. While a court can coerse the creditors to accept a deal and the agency cannot, if they can get you suitable terms the creditors might just lift some of the negative reports. If they agree to new terms, you are no longer in default. If you file bankrupcy you are still in default. Tell her this, because it is one of those things people do not realize about this whole issue.

And to add to the original post, I hope she doesn't live in Utah. Because in Utah when you lose your car insurance your license is automatically suspended. Imagine them apples !

Now this is more general and am not implying it applies to your friend. So many people are in trouble because of have to have the biggest and best, and right now. Many have a hard time waiting until they can afford that palacial estate, or on a smaller scale let's say a plasma TV. So there's four grand gone.

Consumers fuel these prices. If people could wait, the price comes down and the bugs are worked out. Instead everyone has to have it now, and they still cost the same to build. Thing is right now all the fat cats are getting rich. If we rufused to pay the price, their markup would go down, down, down. What is four thou would come down to less than two. They would still be making money, but think of what they're making now at twice the price.

The main problem is that people go shopping. I go to the store get what I need and that is it. I do not look around much. Food shopping is different, even real Men have to do that, mainly at the meat counter and beer cooler, well a few other aisles, but that is a necessary evil.

If she can manage to live a while and be uncollectable, which means check cashing places, using money orders all that, she could buy some time. The first place to go is to the creditors themselves. If she has a good way about herself and can think on her feet she can probably take care of this herself. Whether by phone or whatever means, she has to know what she is doing. Need facts and figures, "If this keeps adding up this way I'd never be able to pay it even if I made twice what I made when you gave me the loan". Things like that. If she is not confident or competent to swin with the sharks, use an agency.

Many of these agencies are free to the consumer. As much as I hate to say it, governments run some and they are ironically probably the best choice. Their best interest is to see the fewest foreclosures and repossesions in the region. No matter how far I like to stay away from the governmant, that is not the best choice for all.

If she ,,, well let's be optimistic here and say WHEN she pulls herself out of this quagmire, she needs to be more careful next time around. We ALL need to realize that it could happen to any of us at any time. If it does, are you ready ? Am I ? If not we only have ourselves to blame.

T




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875