RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years

RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid

Message

Marc2b -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/28/2008 9:23:29 PM)
quote: Daddy/daughter sex, cages, rape, torture....... all the stuff we crave and emulate daily. But when it happens, oh dear, they should be shot! Angry angry angry! Sick sick sick! Emulate is the key word. There is a difference between fantasy and reality and decent, mentally healthy, people know where the lines are. I don’t care how deeply anyone is into "the lifestyle" – if it is not consensual, then it is criminal. If you’re saying we shouldn’t be surprised that these things happen – well, considering the history of the human race I certainly will not disagree. But that is no excuse not to get pissed off about these things. quote: Oh yeah, and the "men are the bad gender, women are the good gender" idiocy some people feel the need to bring into it. I do appreciate that sentiment. Women can certainly be just as twisted and perverted as men (I would bother with Collarme if they weren’t [:)]). But this man (totally not giving him the benefit of the doubt and presuming him guilty) is definitely bad.

RuheMaus -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/28/2008 9:30:59 PM)
because SOMEONE has to go there.... This doesn't surprise me much, really. After all, we all know who ELSE is from Austria, yes? ... That's right, Wolfgang Puck! Creator of nummy dishes enjoyed the world over! /Wasn't going to go there... //Really! ///Come on, believe me!

Marc2b -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/28/2008 9:43:00 PM)
quote: I am more concerned with the mental and physical health of the daughter and the children, really. What type of future do you think THEY have? There may be hope for the five year old but as to the two older ones, how could they ever be socialized to the larger society around them? What do they even know of it? Cripes, for all we know they may have grown up believing he was God and there was no outside world. The shock from isolation must be terrifying. I believe I will add them to my prayers tonight. Damn it... the more I think about it... [sm=anger.gif]Well, let’s just say I can understand the revenge fantasies. Yeah, a part of me would gladly turn him over to you, MzMia, and all the other lovely dominant ladies here on CM, for sentencing. I need to stop stewing and go to bed.

GreedyTop -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/28/2008 9:44:43 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: RuheMaus because SOMEONE has to go there.... This doesn't surprise me much, really. After all, we all know who ELSE is from Austria, yes? ... That's right, Wolfgang Puck! Creator of nummy dishes enjoyed the world over! /Wasn't going to go there... //Really! ///Come on, believe me! snort

RCdc -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 3:07:32 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: patwi quote: ORIGINAL: MzMia I was thinking you rarely here about women doing this sort of thing. Thats true. I wonder why that is? Oh women do it. The man had a wife/accomplace and I don't buy into the 'she didn't know' line. And there are many female abusers throughout history. So women are far from innocent. the.dark.

Lashra -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 3:21:41 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: lilabbotsfordgrl Daddy/daughter sex, cages, rape, torture....... all the stuff we crave and emulate daily. But when it happens, oh dear, they should be shot! Angry angry angry! Sick sick sick! Oh yeah, and the "men are the bad gender, women are the good gender" idiocy some people feel the need to bring into it. Yes when its not consensual and forced upon a person it is a crime. Yes they should be shot, or even better burned alive in the public square. As far as women being the good gender, well, women are less likely to do this sort of thing. Although you have to admit most women don't need to keep a "sex slave" locked in the basement. I don't believe for a second his wife didn't have some idea it was going on. The article stated he was a dominating and controlling man, she was probably scared of him and went along with it. This is a very sad and tragic thing to happen, this womans life is ruined and I can only imagine what mental state the children will be in. ~Lashra

MissMagnolia -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 3:25:57 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: lilabbotsfordgrl Daddy/daughter sex, cages, rape, torture....... all the stuff we crave and emulate daily. But when it happens, oh dear, they should be shot! Angry angry angry! Sick sick sick! Oh yeah, and the "men are the bad gender, women are the good gender" idiocy some people feel the need to bring into it. YOU might crave and emulate it. I certainly don't. As for the "good/bad gender" comment, how ridiculous. Individuals do bad shit, not an entire gender. Let's hope that the woman and the kids can someday live a normal life, or as close to normal as it can get.

MontrealPhoenix -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 3:39:55 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: lilabbotsfordgrl Daddy/daughter sex, cages, rape, torture....... all the stuff we crave and emulate daily. But when it happens, oh dear, they should be shot! Angry angry angry! Sick sick sick! Oh yeah, and the "men are the bad gender, women are the good gender" idiocy some people feel the need to bring into it. I CANNOT believe you don't see the difference. We *choose* to do those things, that poor woman and certainly her children had none. I really, seriously hope you were being sarcastic here. Phoenix

MzMia -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 4:47:29 AM)
Hello the dark. I don't see where I said that women were "innocent". I do agree, that the wife should have suspected SOMETHING was going on, and how could she not ever see him entering or leaving that dungeon? She never saw him taking food or supplies down there? It is very hard to believe she suspected or saw nothing in 24 years!

kittinSol -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 4:56:35 AM)
We probably won't ever get all the facts... it's a horrible story. It's terrifying that the mother of this young woman supposedly 'never suspected' anything: how can this possibly be? I also wonder where the authorities were and why there wasn't an inquest into the 'disappearance' of the daughter. What can possibly be going on in the mind of a man who does something like this? How mentally ill did he have to be to carry on all these years? And how does such a person envisage life in general? The motivator seems to be a pulsion of death. It's all in the hands of the psychiatrists now... but something went wrong in his head. Will his victims ever recover a modicum of a life?

lilabbotsfordgrl -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 5:04:52 AM)
Yes, of course I see the difference between what he did and the stuff I'm into. I was just drawing attention to some of the surface similarities. I do think it was a horrible crime and I'm glad he's going to pay for it.

RCdc -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 5:07:32 AM)
On the bbc news this morning, they mentioned the little boy of 5 and that he had said how fun it was to travel in a 'real car' - so there must have been an understanding of life outside the rooms for the children (maybe via their mother) and that they had postive belief he would be easily integrated into society. The others they had a less than positive belief of. the.dark.

RCdc -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 6:12:04 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: RuheMaus because SOMEONE has to go there.... This doesn't surprise me much, really. After all, we all know who ELSE is from Austria, yes? ... That's right, Wolfgang Puck! Creator of nummy dishes enjoyed the world over! /Wasn't going to go there... //Really! ///Come on, believe me! This is Darcy ...and here's me thinking you meant that iron-willed, stern-faced Mr Schwarzenegger! [:D]

philosophy -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 10:04:54 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Darcyandthedark On the bbc news this morning, they mentioned the little boy of 5 and that he had said how fun it was to travel in a 'real car' - so there must have been an understanding of life outside the rooms for the children (maybe via their mother) and that they had postive belief he would be easily integrated into society. The others they had a less than positive belief of. the.dark. ...reports in Canada have pointed out they had access to a small television. It was how the imprisoned mother knew the hospital had picked up her oldest sick kid.

sirsholly -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 11:42:19 AM)
when this woman went missing at the age of 11 was a police report filed? I am baffled at the mother in this case. The father told her several times that the daughter resurfaced to drop off a child. She knew her daughter, missing since childhood, was out there yet made no move to locate her? Nope. I do not buy it for a heartbeat. Good old mom HAD to know what was going on and, if so, is as guilty as the father.

spinninsweetness -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 12:05:29 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly when this woman went missing at the age of 11 was a police report filed? I am baffled at the mother in this case. The father told her several times that the daughter resurfaced to drop off a child. She knew her daughter, missing since childhood, was out there yet made no move to locate her? Nope. I do not buy it for a heartbeat. Good old mom HAD to know what was going on and, if so, is as guilty as the father. She was 18 when she went missing, 11 when the abuse started. Dissapearing at 18 means legal adult means sadly no-one is able to do much legally... and if a fake letter was sent the mother may have believed Elisabeth could have run away. Its definatly the older children I feel for- how oh how do you get over this? Do you? Its so hard to imagine never going outside for 19 years- and the last baby? The one that died? Obviously the older kids knew Mum was pregnant- they must have seen and heard each birth. I just cant imagine what they went through, after the Gran/dad took the other siblings away to be raised in a 'normal' setting (I'm using the term very losely)

mistoferin -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 12:14:10 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: spinninsweetness and the last baby? The one that died? Obviously the older kids knew Mum was pregnant- they must have seen and heard each birth. The baby that died was a twin.

DomKen -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 1:29:32 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: spinninsweetness Its definatly the older children I feel for- how oh how do you get over this? Do you? Its so hard to imagine never going outside for 19 years- and the last baby? The one that died? Obviously the older kids knew Mum was pregnant- they must have seen and heard each birth. I just cant imagine what they went through, after the Gran/dad took the other siblings away to be raised in a 'normal' setting (I'm using the term very losely) Can you imagine how those kids feel? Three were "good" enough to be raised out in the world while the other 3 were condemned to the same fate as their mother. I'm guessing hate is too mild a word for how those kids likely feel for this man and their siblings who he raised. BTW was which children got raised where determined by gender? I know that reports are that the eldest was an 18 or 19 year old girl. But was he keeping the femalse in the cellar to abuse and raising the boys himself or what?

subtee -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 1:40:43 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: angelikaJ You are unable to differentiate between what he did and WIITWD...? Seriously? I find that very disturbing. I find it disturbing too. In fact, I'm really not loving that it's even on CM as a post and it is also mentioned in "Alternative Lifestyles" Forum. What that "man" did is not a lifestyle, it seems to me. I don't know, maybe I'm just too wacked by this. Hate it.

sirsholly -> RE: Austrian Man Holds Daughter Captive For 24 Years (4/29/2008 1:47:51 PM)
quote: ORIGINAL: DomKen BTW was which children got raised where determined by gender? I know that reports are that the eldest was an 18 or 19 year old girl. But was he keeping the femalse in the cellar to abuse and raising the boys himself or what? just when i thought the story couldn't get any worse.....

Page: << < prev 1 [2] 3 next > >>

Collarchat.com © 2025

Terms of Service

0.0625