RE: In Memory of Bobby (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


blushingflower -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 6:08:06 PM)

quote:

Had the Republicans NOT won the election of 1860, South Carolina would not have seceded in December of that year.

Would probably not have seceded. 
A Civil War was likely going to happen eventually, ever since the Founding Fathers decided to leave the question of slavery to Future!Congress instead of handling it themselves.
There were many things that added together led to the decision of the southern states to secede, and to the Civil War.  If one thing had gone differently, we don't know what the result would have been.




celticlord2112 -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 6:10:14 PM)

Facts are what they are.  Denying the facts is futile.  The facts will win every time.

This is the order of things.




blushingflower -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 6:12:28 PM)

He did, actually (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kennedy).  In the Navy.
Any member of Congress who has served at all in the military is eligable for burial in Arlington National Cemetery, even if they wouldn't be eligable based on their military record.




celticlord2112 -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 6:14:04 PM)

The lack of time and waiting around between the finalization of the election returns and South Carolina's secession convention is powerful evidence that the Republican victory was the catalyst that set events in motion.

Would the south have seceded anyway?  Your point that it might have happened eventually is well taken.  My point was and remains that Lincoln's election catalyzed the secession that did happen.  Remove the catalyst, and that particular event would not happen at that moment.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 6:21:45 PM)

quote:

Slaveboy, if you want to compare education credentials anytime, I'd be glad to oblige. You won't like the comparison though. Btw, see my signature and pay attention if you can.

The fact is that "education" and book learning can only take you so far. One has to learn to use one's head for something better than a hatrack.


I wasn't trying to compare, I was just making the point that I don't need your validation.  See your signature?  Am I supposed to be impressed that you found a overly used quote from Twain?  You called me a fascist, because I don't worship the Kennedy family like you do.  You then went off on some silly little comedy routine and attached Lincoln to it.  You sparked this whole debate, and then you finish with "dumbasses."  Yeah, that's using the old noodle for something better than a hatrack.  [8|]




cjan -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 10:20:01 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: celticlord2112

Facts are what they are.  Denying the facts is futile.  The facts will win every time.

This is the order of things.



You sound, strangely, m'laird, like a recording, and a tonedeaf one  I, for one, am quite tired of. You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile.

All smoke and no fire.




cjan -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 10:25:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

quote:

Slaveboy, if you want to compare education credentials anytime, I'd be glad to oblige. You won't like the comparison though. Btw, see my signature and pay attention if you can.

The fact is that "education" and book learning can only take you so far. One has to learn to use one's head for something better than a hatrack.


I wasn't trying to compare, I was just making the point that I don't need your validation.  See your signature?  Am I supposed to be impressed that you found a overly used quote from Twain?  You called me a fascist, because I don't worship the Kennedy family like you do.  You then went off on some silly little comedy routine and attached Lincoln to it.  You sparked this whole debate, and then you finish with "dumbasses."  Yeah, that's using the old noodle for something better than a hatrack.  [image]http://www.collarchat.com/image/s13.gif[/image]


You, slaveboy, certainly have a point, but a good hat will cover it.

I didn't call you a fascist because you don't "worship the Kennedy family". I certainly don't. I simply give credit and respect where it is due. And I respect peoples' contributions to our society, imperfect as they, and we, all are.
I called you a fascist simply because that is what you seem to be from your expressed opinions.




ModeratorEleven -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 10:30:17 PM)

Folks, chill out.

XI





Daddysredhead -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/1/2008 10:34:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

quote:

Slaveboy, if you want to compare education credentials anytime, I'd be glad to oblige. You won't like the comparison though. Btw, see my signature and pay attention if you can.

The fact is that "education" and book learning can only take you so far. One has to learn to use one's head for something better than a hatrack.


I wasn't trying to compare, I was just making the point that I don't need your validation.  See your signature?  Am I supposed to be impressed that you found a overly used quote from Twain?  You called me a fascist, because I don't worship the Kennedy family like you do.  You then went off on some silly little comedy routine and attached Lincoln to it.  You sparked this whole debate, and then you finish with "dumbasses."  Yeah, that's using the old noodle for something better than a hatrack.  [8|]


Now, now, gents...  let's not misuse the name "hatrack" around these parts.  Nearly two years ago, our dear CrouchingTigress, got my initials all clusterphukt and started calling me DHR, which then morphed into her and several others referring to me as "Hatrack" instead of "Red" or any other alphabetical combination.  So, lest we forget...  I am the only Hatrack around here.

~ giggles ~   [;)]

Warmly,
DaddysHatRack

My credentials:

http://www.collarchat.com/m_467379/mpage_3/key_hatrack/tm.htm#482454
http://www.collarchat.com/fb.asp?m=1613692&key=hatrack
http://www.collarchat.com/m_642839/mpage_70/key_hatrack/tm.htm#761401
http://www.collarchat.com/m_760333/mpage_1/key_hatrack/tm.htm#760352
http://www.collarchat.com/m_333200/mpage_513/key_hatrack/tm.htm#536957
http://www.collarchat.com/m_523253/mpage_13/key_hatrack/tm.htm#524116
http://www.collarchat.com/m_514025/mpage_2/key_hatrack/tm.htm#516766
http://www.collarchat.com/m_493968/mpage_13/key_hatrack/tm.htm#511168
http://www.collarchat.com/m_333200/mpage_307/key_hatrack/tm.htm#495882

edited to correct the number of years I've been the CM HatRack and add my credentials   [:D]




Level -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 3:58:13 AM)

Hello, credentialed one. [;)]
 
From the admittedly-little I've seen, Bobby Kennedy seemed like he earnestly wanted to help others, and I'll wonder how he might have done as president.




Daddysredhead -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 5:28:06 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Level

Hello, credentialed one. [;)]
 

Hi Levelicious.

Sorry 'bout the brief hijack, but a girl can't let her monicker be bantied about so carelessly, yanno...  [:D]




angelikaJ -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 6:51:21 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: blushingflower

quote:

Had the Republicans NOT won the election of 1860, South Carolina would not have seceded in December of that year.

Would probably not have seceded. 
A Civil War was likely going to happen eventually, ever since the Founding Fathers decided to leave the question of slavery to Future!Congress instead of handling it themselves.
There were many things that added together led to the decision of the southern states to secede, and to the Civil War.  If one thing had gone differently, we don't know what the result would have been. ...

He did, actually (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kennedy).  In the Navy.
Any member of Congress who has served at all in the military is eligable for burial in Arlington National Cemetery, even if they wouldn't be eligable based on their military record.



Thank you for introducing facts as a counterpoint to the mess that this thread degraded into.

[sm=goodpost.gif][sm=flowers.gif]




Dominatist -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 4:40:20 PM)

Wrong forum




MrRodgers -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 4:44:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

quote:

First of all, Lincoln did serve in combat versus the indians. Not exactly sure when, under or whom or against whom he fought...but he did and then went home.


Actually no he didn't.  He served as a Captain in the Illinois Militia during the Black Hawk War, but he never saw combat. 

quote:

Lincoln SAVED the republic from those who would attack it and reduce our country down to either have the north and national government surrender or sue for peace under a nation with slavery spreading out as one if its paramount social values.

Lincoln did NOT ruin the economy of the south. The economy of the south suffered when the planter's son could no longer STEAL the labor of 3 to 4 million people as they and their ancestors had for about 200 years. Do you or any miscreants here understand or have any concept at all of how much money and overall wealth that is ?


How did he save it?  He suspended Habeus Corpus during the war.  He refused to allow the southern states to succeed as is the right of a state under the Constitution.  He did ruin the economy of the South.  He allowed Union troops to conduct a scorched earth campaign and wage war against civilians.  He allowed Northern indistrialists and buisnessmen to exploit Southernors.  If you think the South are the only ones that benefited from slave labor, than you haven't read much about the time period.  Where do you think all that cotton went?  It went to textile mills in the north or overseas to Europe. 

quote:

As for the Kennedy boys...they contributed a whole lot more than most all the sloth we see in celebration and politics today.


It's easy to sacrifice when you've never had to work a day in your life. 

quote:

The two oldest Kennedy sons Joseph and John (Jack) VOLUNTEERED for WWII. Joseph died a hero trying out a bomber that was a bomb in itself. He and the crew were to parachute out BEFORE the plane was to fly on to its target unpiloted. (reduce crew casualities) The plane blew up before planned. He was awarded a medal posthumously.


15 million Americans served during the Second World War.  A lot of people volunteered, including George Bush I, Ronald Reagan, and Bob Dole.  The Kennedys aren't special.

quote:

Ted Kennedy has submitted over 2500 bills to congress with over 600 passing into national law. That is a record that may never be broken...NEVER.   


Yeah, it's easy to do that when you've never had a real job.  He also allowed a woman to drown to death, and helped cover up a rape by his nephew. 

quote:

The Kennedys have always been champions of the poor devout Catholics, love this country and proved it and yes, there may never be another family like that one...in a long time. 


Champions of the poor, huh?  None of them ever had to work, EVER.  The Kennedys don't help the poor, they make them government dependents.  As for them being devout Catholics...Why the hell would I care if that were true?  If they are such devout Catholics, they wouldn't support legalized abortion. 


See what happens when you bring emotion to a debate ?  You revise history to save your hate.

*Lincoln DID see combat and thought he'd seem enough and resigned the Illinois militia.

*I don't give flying fuck about habeus corpus...the south took up arms against the north...just who would deserve to as Lincoln said himself...hide behind it.

* The south had NO economy without the slaves and the north was what...obligated to buy that cotton. Even Europe cut off importing their cotton. The south ruined their own economy when they chose war. Once a party starts war...fuck them.

*Please point out chapter and verse all of the 'consitituional' terms for succeeding from the union ? There are none. The south thought they had a right to yet no one ever took succession to the federal courts...they would have lost their case. They had no case. 9 states voted internally to succeed before Lincoln was even inaugurated. Texans unconstitutioally (Texas constitution) threw Sam Houston out of office (telling them they would lose) so they could then succeed. The whole consitutional argument about the civil war against Lincoln and the north is bogus as hell.

*Lincoln himself and his policies likewise allowed no such industrial policy or exploitation...recall he was shot to death. Andrew Johnson was almost impeached for wanting to pursue Lincoln's reconstruction policy. Instead, in the great southern tradition of the time...we got Jim Crow. Who exploited who ? Taking the fruits of the labor of 3-4 million people for 200 years...which was almost the entire southern economy.

*Being wealthy and not doing anything for anybody seems to be the norm for most of the American aristocracy...at least the Kennedys did something (of course gave millions to charity) and out of the people you have listed, Reagan never left the country and while Bob Dole did serve...his wounds were self inflicted. None of them could carry Joe's or John's briefcase if still alive both of which were war heroes. It's obvious you never served.

*Please point out another rich family that didn't have to work a day in their lives and produced two war heroes. Add the Rockefellers for instance to the Romneys and the Bushes for that matter with the partial exception of Bush I being shot down in the Pacific.

As for ALL those volunteers...I too had earlier family members join up in WWII, so what ?? Bush I (for whom I have almost as much respect) did no more than a few of my families old friends and fathers of some old friends did in WWII. The older Kennedy brothers did a whole lot more.

Your whole beef with the Kennedys seems to be that they were rich and famous. You should have a beef with most of those who are, yet most of them...haven't done a damn thing and nothing close to the Kennedys.

Once and for all, Ted Kennedy did not help cover-up a rape that wasn't. Once the defendant testified that she participated, the jury could not possibly convict. 
 





kdsub -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 4:49:53 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: celticlord2112

The lack of time and waiting around between the finalization of the election returns and South Carolina's secession convention is powerful evidence that the Republican victory was the catalyst that set events in motion.

Would the south have seceded anyway?  Your point that it might have happened eventually is well taken.  My point was and remains that Lincoln's election catalyzed the secession that did happen.  Remove the catalyst, and that particular event would not happen at that moment.



There were plenty of warnings of secession at the time...I believe most people voting knew the possible consequences of their vote and it was simply the will of the majority...And if that is true...which I believe...then it made no difference except perhaps in timing of when the southern states would secede.

No doubt however the secessionist used the election as an excuse.

Butch




Alumbrado -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 5:05:42 PM)

quote:

and while Bob Dole did serve...his wounds were self inflicted.


Really?  Bob Dole fired the German artillery shell that cost him the use of his arm, and led to losing a kidney during recuperation?  

Love to see the source for that one  (and don't bother try to pass off the first Purple Heart for shrapnel from his own grenade in combat as the source of all of his wounds).




corsetgirl -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 5:21:25 PM)

I was only 9 years old and yet, I still remember what happened.  One can only imagine what the world might have been if he had lived to be president.




Alumbrado -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 5:38:07 PM)

quote:

Once the defendant testified that she participated, the jury could not possibly convict. 


Participated?  You can't rape someone who isn't there...or did you mean to claim that the victim testified that she willingly participated in the sex?

Once again, I'd love to see your sources on that...I seem to recall a juror claiming afterward that she voted to acquit because Kennedy was too good looking to have to rape someone, while others claimed that the victim 'cried too much' and still others were swayed by her not crying enough...nothing at all about the victim testifying that the final sex act was consensual.




celticlord2112 -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 5:43:21 PM)

quote:

Please point out chapter and verse all of the 'consitituional' terms for succeeding from the union ? There are none. The south thought they had a right to yet no one ever took succession to the federal courts...they would have lost their case. They had no case. 9 states voted internally to succeed before Lincoln was even inaugurated. Texans unconstitutioally (Texas constitution) threw Sam Houston out of office (telling them they would lose) so they could then succeed. The whole consitutional argument about the civil war against Lincoln and the north is bogus as hell.


There is nothing bogus about the 10th Amendment to the Constitution.




Alumbrado -> RE: In Memory of Bobby (6/2/2008 6:16:06 PM)

quote:

See what happens when you bring emotion to a debate ?  You revise history to save your hate.

*Lincoln DID see combat and thought he'd seem enough and resigned the Illinois militia.




Siiigh... Source?  So many of the histories say he never saw combat.




Page: <<   < prev  2 3 [4] 5 6   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
4.785156E-02