Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Polls and Other Random Stupidity

[Poll]

Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ?


Possible but not adviseable
  2% (2)
Yes it is possible and they can live both as Husband and Wife and Mas
  66% (52)
Yes
  26% (21)
No Not such a good Idea
  1% (1)
ABSOLUTELY NOI
  2% (2)


Total Votes : 78
(last vote on : 8/24/2008 11:49:59 PM)
(Poll will run till: -- )


Message


Master19520061 -> Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 5:56:17 PM)

I recently fell in Love with my slave and wanted to marry her. But as my LOVE for her grew I found it more difficult to treat her as just a slave in other areas.

Unfortunately  this resulted in her asking to be released and us separating and her finding another man but not in the Life Style.  I have heard from her two oldest children she is not as happy as she wants me to believe and has told her oldest daughter she misses the Life Style  and is sorry she pushed me away. we stay in touch, Our communications range from strained ( when I would text message her every day) to better and happier now that I let her contact me first. When we do talk She seems to not want to end the conversation and I can tell she still wants and needs me in her life. She just does not want to hurt the other guys feelings.




AMaster -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:02:27 PM)

I don't see why it can't work. However in your case, I'd advise that you move on.  




RavenMuse -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:07:59 PM)

YMMV but I am a Dominant, that is the way I am wired, that is the way My feelings express themself. The more I care, the more control I want. I can not fathom having any trouble treating her as any less of a slave simply because My feelings deepened for her... quite the opposite. I do wonder that those who find the opposite maybe playing a role, D/s being something they DO rather than something they are. Maybe you need to examine yourself, your motivations and what makes you tick so you can maintain consistency in a relationship wether with her or another.

If they are both compatable and being themselves rather than playing a role then yes it can work, I know many for whom it does.




KnightofMists -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:09:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Master19520061

I recently fell in Love with my slave and wanted to marry her. But as my LOVE for her grew I found it more difficult to treat her as just a slave in other areas.


So.. why was it more difficult for you..  the following is a post I made sometime ago....

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
Some may say Love is a hindrance to the M/s dynamic.  But, I would say that Love is a fundamental aspect of my M/s Relationships.   I couldn't imagine myself having this type of relationship without Love being apart of it.
 
Love and Respect of thy self... the most Powerful of Motivations... it comes from within...It's the intrinsic motivation that is only limited by oneself and dependent on no one but oneself.
Love for me has always been a Choice as much as it has been a Feeling.  My feelings have always been motivated by what I perceive... Be it real or illusion.  The choice is to see the truth of what I perceive from the lies.  Therefore, one must make the effort to Love!  Love will flow like water if you let it.  But, water will flow the easiest path... and this could lead you over a cliff.  Healthy Thoughtful Love is much more than free flowing water, but just as powerful.  We control it, we manage it.  We guide it.  When it is time to allow it to flow, we let it flow.  When must harness its power, we focus it and feel its power.  But we never push it up hill!  Remember the flow well pick up everything and can move anything over the course of time.  But if allowed to flow uncontrolled, it will wander aimlessly and finally dumping in a pool... its power never focused and utilized.
 
Love to me binds the people to a relationship.  It moves the focus from themselves to focus on the other and the relationship itself.  I question when love is not part of the relationship, if the focus ever moves from oneself to the relationship.  Without love, I wonder if the individuals are only using the other and the relationship to serve their self-centered interests.  Taking what they can and maybe draining the lemon dry, then going to find a new lemon.  I wonder if there are some that use the word love, but it is a shallow use of the word instead of the intense devotion that it leads one towards.  Love to me is a powerful word if it used with the feelings that back it up.  It moves one from the self-centered focus to that of a focus to another person and a relationship.  We become givers instead of takers and as result of our giving out of love we receive more than we could ever take.  Instead sucking the lemon dry... We plant an orchard and reap the rewards of that effort
 
I have been in a relationship with Alandra since in summer of ‘87.  It was then as is now without question a relationship that is very much a loving and growing relationship. I am also growing a young loving relationship with Kyra that began in spring of ‘05. I also have a deepening friendship with my bottom Denika and her husband where love is very much a part of the relationship. Frankly, I find it difficult to comprehend how anyone can have an intimate BDSM relationship without love being an important part of that relationship. I suppose it is done, but I have not seen it done successful over a course of many years.
 
I thought I was in love with Alandra years ago... but I kept finding that day by day our depth of love just kept growing and never stopping.  It's to the point that I look to tomorrow with excitement because my experience has showed me that I will be loved and love her even more than I do today.  My experience with alandra has also had an extremely positive effect on my relationship with kyra.  When I first touched her gently on the cheek that first time we saw each other... I felt a deep sense of love... but today that love seems pale in comparisons to the way I feel now... god I can hardly wait for tomorrow.

My approach is simple in the relationships I am in. Out of love, We become open to be who we are. I seek not to make my girls what they are not... I only seek to support them to shed that which is illusions of them selves, as they support me in doing the same thing. A relationship with me is about bringing the inner self out into the open and being this person. Out of love we accept what comes. This line of thought is nothing new. A noted psychologist termed the word "congruence" Essentially it means that the more we are able to demonstrate that inner self to the world/relationships, The more content/stable and at peace we become. We are happier. The deeper we hid this inner aspect of our self, well it is a path of unhappiness. I see love as a vehicle to facilitate this path towards happiness.  It is not only path that I use. For I believe there are many strategies in building our personal happiness with our self and our relationships.

The path I describe is one of Self-Awareness leading to Self-Acceptance leading to Self-Actualization. The interesting aspect of this path is that it is actually circular. As we Self-actualize we are destine to become more aware of aspects of our inner self... which will lead us to need to Accept this new found awareness in order for further actualization to occur.

It is my beliefs that if we stop this cycle at any point we stop to grow in ourselves and in our relationships. We stop to bringing that inner self into the light of day and thus we establish a ceiling to our individual happiness. I suspect that many of us do this from time to time and can actually live very happy lives to the end of our days.  Being in a relationship that is fundamentally a loving relationship promotes trust, security, validation and whole array of things that promote this cycle of growth.

I am loved not for what I do for them, "but for who I am".  To push and bring my full awareness of my inner self to the open to those that love me can only grow this love.  So I choose to be "Me" and enjoy the great happiness it gives me. Just as I love my girls for them are being who they are. However, I do not believe I could ever enjoy the love that is given to me, nor give love my girls to the depth I do unless we first love ourselves.
 
However, It is so much easier to love another than to accept the love from another.  We know what is in our hearts and minds, but we only think we know what is in theirs.   The difference is subtle but significant.  To accept the love of another when we don't love our self is never an easy path.  When we fail to love ourselves it begs to question the motivations of another that express love towards us.  It is therefore my thoughts that “Awareness, .Acceptance & Actualization” is to grow our love of self and not just our relationship.
 
Some may say Love is a hindrance to the M/s dynamic and I would have to agree in some cases.  In comparison, Many parents who love their children very much are blinded by that love to make the choices and decisions that are best for raising their children. They are blinded by "my children do no wrong" and I suspect everyone can think of examples of such. Because this, are they good parents? Should they be parents? Should parents not love their children?

I see no difference between the Master that allows his/her love to negatively affect his/her responsibilities towards the slave as the parent that allows love to negatively affect their responsibilities towards their children.   It is my opinion we choose to love and as Masters we choose to exercise our authority.  One need not conflict with the other.

To me it is not a question if Love should be in the relationship... It is should they be a Master?

 
If love causes a person not to fulfill their responsibilities... then let them never know what love is.
 
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++




NumberSix -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:10:36 PM)

OK, couple of questions..

can she lick the morning dew of your morning woodie?

maybe it is all one question.





SoulPiercer -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:18:14 PM)

Kim is my slave. I know it sounds cliche, but I can honestly, I have never been as deeply in love with anyone as I am with her.

My current plan is to marry in April (shhhh .. it's a birthday surprise).

My being in love with her in no way affects the dynamics of our relationship.




kiwisub12 -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:20:24 PM)

My Sir loves me - and i am still his sub/slave - and his love doesn't change that.   thank goddess!




Mercnbeth -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:23:02 PM)

[sm=wtf.gif]
quote:

Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ?
[sm=wtf.gif]

[sm=hellno.gif]    [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]           [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]

[sm=noway.gif]               [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]               [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]


[sm=hardlimit.gif]       [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]        [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]                   [image]http://www.collarchat.com/upfiles/smiley/liar.gif[/image]




DiurnalVampire -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:23:09 PM)

Fox is my slave and wil be my husband eventually. For US it will not be affecting our dynamic. For you, though, obviously it did. There is no one size fits all answer, but you did say originally that your groeing love made it harder to treat her as a slave. In that acse, then, yes it is impossible for you to marry and keep her as a slave. You have already discovered that. Whether or not that is the case for anyone else anywhere doesnt chage your reaction.

DV




RedMagic1 -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:33:04 PM)

In "Analyze This," the Billy Crystal character asks the Robert de Niro character, "What can your mistress do for you that your wife can't?"  The answer: "Are you kidding?  Those are the lips she kisses my kids good night with!!!"

Lots of guys can't wrap their heads around the notion that a woman can be "wife material" and also a kinky, "slutty" bitch.  You see this all the time with kinky men taking shots at prodommes and fetish models, as though their willingness to be out there somehow makes them subhuman skeezes.  Madonna/whore complex to the nth degree.

I think it's kind of sad, really.  The guy is destined never to be long-term happy in bed, and the lady is only part of something until she is truly, deeply desired for herself, not just what she brings to the play party.  Self-sabotage.

Even in the Gor books, masters sometimes fell in love with and (secretly) married their slaves.  Of course it happens in reality all the time -- and, personally, it's what I'm looking to build.




NickR -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:35:17 PM)

I don't even have interest in subs/slaves UNLESS there are many of the elements of a "normal" relationship, including love.  Without a deeper emotional attachment, submissive acts don't have any value to me.  I want someone I can discuss things that interest me with, and who has interests of their own they pursue.  Someone being under control 24/7 with no purpose but to serve is a nice fantasy but that's really where it stays for me.




HornyToadsMI -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 6:44:53 PM)

I think alot of it depends on your dynamic.  If the dynamic can evolve, then yes, it is possible.  If one of the parties cannot allow the dynamic to evolve, then no, it is not possible.  Clear as mud?

You wanted more, she didnt, she asked to be released.....the question is will she stay committed this next time, or will she want out again?  For some of us, the wedding ring is the "collar" of love and ownership.  The security.  For others, the wedding ring is a threat. 

I hope that time gives You clarity.....




Paulnz -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/22/2008 8:45:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Master19520061



Unfortunately  this resulted in her asking to be released and us separating and her finding another man but not in the Life Style. 



If I'm reading this right, she seems to be the type who compartmentalises things in terms of BDSM this side, other aspects over there. Thus, she went and found someone not in the lifestyle. She probably intends sneaking back for playtime. Also, she may have not had the same feelings about you.




sirsholly -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 4:02:28 AM)

of course it can work....but ONLY if you keep the lines of communication open.




windchymes -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 6:09:56 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Master19520061

I recently fell in Love with my slave and wanted to marry her. But as my LOVE for her grew I found it more difficult to treat her as just a slave in other areas.

Unfortunately  this resulted in her asking to be released and us separating and her finding another man but not in the Life Style.  I have heard from her two oldest children she is not as happy as she wants me to believe and has told her oldest daughter she misses the Life Style  and is sorry she pushed me away. we stay in touch, Our communications range from strained ( when I would text message her every day) to better and happier now that I let her contact me first. When we do talk She seems to not want to end the conversation and I can tell she still wants and needs me in her life. She just does not want to hurt the other guys feelings.



She doesn't seem to have a problem hurting yours.   Just sayin'.

Also sounds a little weird.....breaks up with you for not being "domly" enough and then shacks up with a vanilla guy.  That just don't make no sense.

She didn't tell her daughter she misses "You", she misses "The Life-Style". 

My impression is that she had the vanilla guy all along, for security, and The Life-Style is what blows her dress up.   




windchymes -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 6:11:08 AM)

But I digress.......of course he can.




Jeffff -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 8:13:29 AM)

Assuming the love is real, how could you not treat her as a slave? Isn't that what she wants?

Would this be an issue if she wanted to be treated as a princess? Would you have a problem treating her well?

If you love a woman who wants/needs to be beaten....... Then beat her cheerfully.. and she will feel treated well

Jeff




ElectraGlide -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 8:21:30 AM)

There does seem to be relationships in the M's lifestyle without love. I just dont understand it. There is nothing wrong with loving your partner. I would not be in a relationship without mutual love. I hope you make out fine.




christine1 -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 8:48:19 AM)

i've never understood this line of thought.  if a person is your slave and you and that person wish to be a married couple, what the hell is the problem?  marriage in my eyes is just another form of commitment....it doesnt' mean vanilla commitment.  a relationship is what the parties involved want it to be.  there is nothing written in stone...do what you want and what makes you comfy and gooey and wet and lovey and all that good stuff.




KatyLied -> RE: Can a Master fall in love with his slave and want her as a wife and still keep her as a slave ? (8/23/2008 8:52:37 AM)

There are some who feel that having a romantic relationship impedes the Master/chattel relationship.  Of course people can and do love their posessions, but not in a romantic way.  I'm not saying that I disagree that M/s can include a love relationship, just saying that I also understand why many think it's not the thing to do.




Page: [1] 2 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125