Collarspace Discussion Forums


Home  Login  Search 

why we play


View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
 
All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion >> why we play Page: [1] 2   next >   >>
Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
why we play - 11/28/2005 10:23:40 PM   
Slaveboiz


Posts: 38
Joined: 4/19/2005
Status: offline
Why we play
“A look at play beyond kink.”
11/16/06


In the SM community today there seems to be a steady pull to understand the nature and intent of play. I would surmise this new view of play has become more popular today as we live in a culture of electronics and machines.

Often our connections to the outside world are done in a fragment of the time it used to be. We have all become slaves to technology; the computers, cell phones, and technologies that make things that once were made by hand, not to mention Wal-Mart lol. Seriously, we are vastly becoming a world that moves way to fast. The very nature of technology is causing us to be disconnected from ourselves, let alone each other.

This pull towards a spiritual look at SM is an attempt to make sense of ourselves in a world that barely sees us.

Experiencing play for the first time is a scary first step into the world of SM. The door, at which you stand, generally opens rather slowly for some and for others it swings wide open.

Many folks are exposed to the erotic side of play through porn, fiction and the internet, with little understanding of the deeper more spiritual meaning behind the things we do both in and out side the dungeon.

When we begin our journey into SM one may hear a lot about the release of endorphins and headspace but do we ever delve any deeper then that?

As my experience had shown me there are generally three types of players; the erotic player; those who only seek play for its erotic content and as a sexual stimulant. The endorphin player; better known as the “true masochist or true sadist” and lastly the spiritual player; one who plays to gain insight about his or her spiritual self. Of course we all float in and out of all the above mentioned. However, I would like to present to you is my thoughts on the spiritual player.

If I take an overview of all the cultures of the world, I note a consistent theme, that theme seems to entail rites and rituals of passage in one form or another, mainly those forms are to transition a child into adulthood; more specifically boyhood to manhood. Even here in western culture we have certain rites of passage and connectedness. Look at the father that takes his son out for his first hunting trip, or the indoctrination into a fraternity, just to name a few.

So you ask, what does this have to do with play?

Rites of passage usually follow the idea of a test of sorts, the test has the intent to transform or transition a person into something new. It takes us from our every day life and tests our limits, our endurance and our connection to something or someone viewed as more important then ourselves. Its focus is usually about the body and spirit of that person.

In a culture that teaches us to disconnect from our physical and emotional selves. i.e. women and the way they view their bodies as to fat, to thin, to what every, all in an attempt to chase some illusion of perfection we can never achieve. Men also are somewhat disconnected from their bodies as well, in the way that they refer to their sexuality and the often misuse of their bodies and their disconnection from their emotions.

So again what does this have to do with play?

Play allows us to separate from the dominant cultures we live in, in order to connect with our own bodies and the spirit of who we are. Often time’s pain/ sensation play is the vehicle for that connectiveness.

The feelings we experience in play are what transforms us into more consciously aware beings. Lastly it connects us to others (top or bottom and community) it in effect, is a ritualistic rite of passage, not in the sense of the stages of life, but rather in the sense that we use the vehicle of pain to transcend our minds and bodies to a better more conducive state. We become more connect with our bodies in play than in any other state; other than perhaps sex or perhaps really good drugs.

Often we are presented with play as away to escape from the dominant culture but in fact play is very much the opposite. Play is a form of heightened connectedness with the mind, body, spirit and to each other.

So, if you are playing for the first time or have been playing for years, I invite you to look at what primitivism drives us to SM. What are your motives in SM and what is the personal gain you have in your play activities. I also invite you to look at the ritualism of the play you seek, and how it connects you to your mind, body and spirit.


Living for the spiritual connection
Slave ziggy
SE slave 2006
In grateful service



Profile   Post #: 1
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 2:17:49 AM   
IronBear


Posts: 9008
Joined: 6/19/2005
From: Beenleigh, Qld, Australia
Status: offline
In most cultures, I've noticed that Women have their rites of passage along with other rites too.

_____________________________

Iron Bear

Master of Bruin Cottage

http://www.bruincottage.org

Your attitude, words & actions are yours. Take responsibility for them and the consequences they incur.

D.I.L.L.I.G.A.F.

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 2
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 4:04:46 AM   
ExistentialSteel


Posts: 676
Joined: 1/18/2005
Status: offline
That was a well written piece. Yes, play is a way of connecting to someone on an intense level that surpasses any other emotions we will ever feel. The endorphin high is only one of the tools in the bag, although a necessary one for me, since I find my own high when I am manipulating a whip of some type.

_____________________________

For those who are like Roman Candles leaving bright trails in the night sky while the crowd watches until the dark blue center light bursts into magnificent colors and the crowd goes, ahhhhhhhhhh.

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 3
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 4:17:14 AM   
candystripper


Posts: 3486
Joined: 11/1/2005
Status: offline
quote:

In most cultures, I've noticed that Women have their rites of passage along with other rites too.

IronBear


Yes..first bra..first pair of heels...first pair of stockings...first period...first french kiss...first real boyfriend...etc, etc, etc.

i think one difference is, women continue to mark off stages in life while Men generally do not pause and consider. First sex...first marriage...first baby...first full time job and role of breadwinner...first time dealing with a teenager...empty nest...last period...sexual peak. And so forth.

candystripper

(in reply to IronBear)
Profile   Post #: 4
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 6:10:46 AM   
LuckyAlbatross


Posts: 19224
Joined: 10/25/2005
Status: offline
So you're going to be at Dark Odyssey right? :)

I love all this influx of positivity and introspection.

For me play is both completely shallow for fun AND intensely spiritual and connecting, depending on my mood at the time.

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 5
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 6:38:52 AM   
Rover


Posts: 2634
Joined: 6/28/2004
Status: offline
I agree that the lifestyle (including play) is whatever each of us, individually, makes of it for ourselves. I also agree that there is a growing trend (primarily on the west coast... go figure) to "spiritualize" the lifestyle.

But then, it seems exceptionally common for people to want to make their lifestyle (and by extension, themselves) into something "more". I'm not sure if that means that people need ever greater stimulation, or feel the need to be "special" in greater ways, or whether this is a form of "edge play" whose boundaries continue to be "pushed back", or if there is something else going on.

No matter the cause, it's obvious that the level of elaborate fantasy becomes ever greater (collectively). New sources such as "spiritualization" and "cathartic scening" (another west coast phenomenon making its way east) are taking the place of "Old Guard" and "Gor", which took the place of power exchange relationships, which took the place of S/M (and so on).

Personally, I have no issue with whatever anyone finds personally pleasing, though many of these become the basis for much disinformation, fantasies portrayed as realities (lies), manipulation, exploitation, etc. I have an issue with that.

Interesting and thought provoking article. The kind I like best. Thanks for sharing it.

John


< Message edited by Rover -- 11/29/2005 6:40:36 AM >

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 6
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 6:49:07 AM   
candystripper


Posts: 3486
Joined: 11/1/2005
Status: offline
quote:

I agree that the lifestyle (including play) is whatever each of us, individually, makes of it for ourselves. I also agree that there is a growing trend (primarily on the west coast... go figure) to "spiritualize" the lifestyle.

But then, it seems exceptionally common for people to want to make their lifestyle (and by extension, themselves) into something "more". I'm not sure if that means that people need ever greater stimulation, or feel the need to be "special" in greater ways, or whether this is a form of "edge play" whose boundaries continue to be "pushed back", or if there is something else going on.

No matter the cause, it's obvious that the level of elaborate fantasy becomes ever greater (collectively). New sources such as "spiritualization" and "cathartic scening" (another west coast phenomenon making its way east) are taking the place of "Old Guard" and "Gor", which took the place of power exchange relationships, which took the place of S/M (and so on).

Personally, I have no issue with whatever anyone finds personally pleasing, though many of these become the basis for much disinformation, fantasies portrayed as realities (lies), manipulation, exploitation, etc. I have an issue with that.

Rover/John


Spiritualization? Cathartic scening? First i've ever heard of anything like this. i tend to agree with Your about California; it does seem to produce more fruits and nuts; which must make it a fun (but strange) place to live. I remember the murderer who was acquitted on the "twinkie defense"; the Menlendos Brothers trial; the O J Simpson acquittal; etc, etc, etc. One worries than such people will soon decide whether to grant parole to Charles Manson.

Frankly, i am proud i grew up in NY, where the boys become Men (straight or gay) and the girls become women (same) and the produce is only on sale at the grocer's. Course, NY did elect Hilary as a US Senator, so i guess we have our share of shame.

Seriously; the only thing like this i know of is tantric sex, which i vaguely understand is a spiritual development that encourages people to seek communion with God through sex. i'd like to know more about the matters You described.

Thank You.

candystripper


< Message edited by candystripper -- 11/29/2005 6:54:52 AM >

(in reply to Rover)
Profile   Post #: 7
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 7:12:43 AM   
Rover


Posts: 2634
Joined: 6/28/2004
Status: offline
Please understand that these are not areas of personal interest, so I won't even pretend to offer a complete and accurate description.

"Cathartic scening" is purposely reconstructing (via scening) a state of mind that is evocative of some deeply seated mental anguish (a rape, for instance) as a means of therapeutic healing and to achieve some sense of "invigoration". Now, we all accept that a cathartic episode may (unintentionally) occur during any scene (the mind is a funny place to play), and we need to be prepared for that. But to purposely set about to achieve that state, and for untrained amateurs to engage in such "therapy" is (to me) beyond the pale. I've attended some interesting workshops on the subject (femcar presented the most recent one I attended) and was not a wall flower.

As for "spiritualization", that's fairly self-explanatory. Though some take that to the extreme (gee, how shocking) in which BDSM and religion become indistinguishable from one another and some are rather cultish in their behaviors.

John

(in reply to candystripper)
Profile   Post #: 8
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 7:49:02 AM   
MsIncognito


Posts: 742
Joined: 5/24/2005
Status: offline
First, thank you for a well written and thought out piece. This is such a refreshing change for these boards. I did disagree with several things and I hope you won't mind me tossing in my POV.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Slaveboiz
In the SM community today there seems to be a steady pull to understand the nature and intent of play. I would surmise this new view of play has become more popular today as we live in a culture of electronics and machines.


How so? I'm curious as to how you think the culture of electronics and machines, as you put it, is somehow linked to a desire to understand the nature and intent of play. IMO, humans have always sought to understand themselves and their motivations. Well, many do. Some clearly do not and that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Introspection for the purposes of understanding and clarity is something I fully support. However, incessant navel gazing is a counter productive avoidance technique in my books. It can be a fine line between those two at times.

quote:


Often our connections to the outside world are done in a fragment of the time it used to be. We have all become slaves to technology; the computers, cell phones, and technologies that make things that once were made by hand, not to mention Wal-Mart lol. Seriously, we are vastly becoming a world that moves way to fast.


Although you may not have meant it in this way, I found you tend to use quite a few generalizations such as "we have all become slaves to technology" and I find those are not really accurate. I'll concede that many people have become slaves to technology but not all of us. I'm the first to admit that I'm an electronic gadget/toy whore. I love my integrated phone/PDA/web browser that fits neatly in my pocket. It's the coolest little thing. However, I'm not a slave to it. I have the ability to turn off my cell phone, computer, phone and TV and so does everyone else. These things are conveniences which should make our lives easier. If we allow them to become things which take over our lives then we need to re-evaluate how we use these technologies.

quote:


The very nature of technology is causing us to be disconnected from ourselves, let alone each other.


If anything I find that the problem is that these things leave us "too connected" but in a superficial way. I do not want everyone and their dog to be able to contact me on my cell phone whenever they feel like it. As a result only a handful of people have my cell number. I will never give it to my boss or anyone I feel will abuse it. The phone is for my convenience, not the convenience of others.

quote:


This pull towards a spiritual look at SM is an attempt to make sense of ourselves in a world that barely sees us.


Although I will agree that a spiritual approach to SM is in part about making sense of ourselves I think it can go far beyond that. For me it also contains an element of transcendance on a physical, emotional and psychological plane.

quote:


Many folks are exposed to the erotic side of play through porn, fiction and the internet, with little understanding of the deeper more spiritual meaning behind the things we do both in and out side the dungeon.


Perhaps for some people there is no spiritual element to SM. In fact, I don't see anything wrong with engaging in play without ever feeling a need to make it spiritual. In part, I think some people want to add a spiritual element to SM because in their minds it elevates SM beyond just some freaky shit we enjoy. It helps to legitimize and elevate it so that when vanillas cock an eyebrow we can so "No, really, it's not just a kinky thing, it's a spiritual thing!" While some of us want, need or enjoy a spiritual element to our SM play I don't think it's necessary and I don't think it's any "better" because we choose to add that element to it.

quote:


When we begin our journey into SM one may hear a lot about the release of endorphins and headspace but do we ever delve any deeper then that?


Some do and some don't. Delving deeper is not required nor is one better than the other.

quote:


As my experience had shown me there are generally three types of players; the erotic player; those who only seek play for its erotic content and as a sexual stimulant. The endorphin player; better known as the “true masochist or true sadist” and lastly the spiritual player; one who plays to gain insight about his or her spiritual self. Of course we all float in and out of all the above mentioned. However, I would like to present to you is my thoughts on the spiritual player.


I don't think everyone floats around between these categories. Again, some do and others do not. I know some who are strictly endorphin players. They don't have a submissive bone in their body but they are masochists to the core. I know others for whom it's all foreplay and a prelude to intercourse.

quote:


If I take an overview of all the cultures of the world, I note a consistent theme, that theme seems to entail rites and rituals of passage in one form or another, mainly those forms are to transition a child into adulthood; more specifically boyhood to manhood. Even here in western culture we have certain rites of passage and connectedness. Look at the father that takes his son out for his first hunting trip, or the indoctrination into a fraternity, just to name a few.


Women have their rituals as well. Jewish girls have bat mitzvahs to mark the beginning of their journey into womanhood. Many native tribes also have rituals for females at puberty. Even in North American culture there are female rites of passage - first menses, first bra, first kiss, first date, etc. They may not be as elaborate as he rites of passage in some other cultures but they are nonetheless significant.

quote:


So you ask, what does this have to do with play?

Rites of passage usually follow the idea of a test of sorts, the test has the intent to transform or transition a person into something new. It takes us from our every day life and tests our limits, our endurance and our connection to something or someone viewed as more important then ourselves. Its focus is usually about the body and spirit of that person.


Here I have to disagree. Some rites of passage may take the form of tests and have a spiritual focus but that is not necessary. IMO, a rite of passage is merely something that marks a significant turning point in a person's life. It does not have to be a test. It can be a noisey, raucus celebration (stag parties, anyone?) or it can be a quiet, solemn marker.

quote:


So again what does this have to do with play?

Play allows us to separate from the dominant cultures we live in, in order to connect with our own bodies and the spirit of who we are. Often time’s pain/ sensation play is the vehicle for that connectiveness.

The feelings we experience in play are what transforms us into more consciously aware beings. Lastly it connects us to others (top or bottom and community) it in effect, is a ritualistic rite of passage, not in the sense of the stages of life, but rather in the sense that we use the vehicle of pain to transcend our minds and bodies to a better more conducive state. We become more connect with our bodies in play than in any other state; other than perhaps sex or perhaps really good drugs.


For some of us play can do those things but I would not equate it with a rite of passage. I think it can be a transforming experience for some or even many but that shouldn't be considered a forgone conclusion. While pain/play can assist in connectivity to ones self and to others (or more accurately the other(s) you are playing with) it is ultimately your willingness to be open to that connectivity that facilitates that transformation. Not every wants to or is capable of going there. They may have other vehicles for experiencing that connectivity that have nothing to do with SM play.

quote:


Often we are presented with play as away to escape from the dominant culture but in fact play is very much the opposite. Play is a form of heightened connectedness with the mind, body, spirit and to each other.


Earlier on you said that play was a way to seperate from the dominant culture in order reconnect with our own bodies and who we are. Now you seem to be saying that play is NOT a way to seperate from the dominant culture but the opposite - so that would mean that play is a way in which to connect to the dominant culture? Sorry, I've lost your train of thought here.

quote:


So, if you are playing for the first time or have been playing for years, I invite you to look at what primitivism drives us to SM. What are your motives in SM and what is the personal gain you have in your play activities. I also invite you to look at the ritualism of the play you seek, and how it connects you to your mind, body and spirit.


A while back there was one of the usually insipid threads about how BDSMers are so much more highly evolved than vanillas and someone (can't remember who) made what I thought was a very interesting point. If BDSM is about tapping into our primal urges can we really consider ourselves more highly evolved or is it actually a process of devolution? I'd say that for me it is a process of personal evolution which hinges on integrating those primal urges in a healthy, responsible and appropriate way. Others mileage may vary.

Again, thanks for the great post.

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 9
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 8:15:27 AM   
pollux


Posts: 657
Joined: 7/26/2005
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: MsIncognito

A while back there was one of the usually insipid threads about how BDSMers are so much more highly evolved than vanillas


Hey! That was my insipid thread!

LOL

(in reply to MsIncognito)
Profile   Post #: 10
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 8:45:59 AM   
candystripper


Posts: 3486
Joined: 11/1/2005
Status: offline
quote:

As for "spiritualization", that's fairly self-explanatory. Though some take that to the extreme (gee, how shocking) in which BDSM and religion become indistinguishable from one another and some are rather cultish in their behaviors.

Rover/John


Not to be a pest, but what do these spiritualist BDSM'ers worship? i am lacking in imagination, i guess. BTW i agree with Your assessment of Cathatic Scening; does sounds contrary to good mental health practice, particularly in the hands of an amateur.

candystripper


< Message edited by candystripper -- 11/29/2005 8:46:24 AM >

(in reply to Rover)
Profile   Post #: 11
RE: why we play - 11/29/2005 9:16:07 AM   
MsIncognito


Posts: 742
Joined: 5/24/2005
Status: offline
Oopsie

quote:

ORIGINAL: pollux
Hey! That was my insipid thread!
LOL

(in reply to pollux)
Profile   Post #: 12
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 9:05:32 AM   
Slaveboiz


Posts: 38
Joined: 4/19/2005
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: MsIncognito

First, thank you for a well written and thought out piece. This is such a refreshing change for these boards. I did disagree with several things and I hope you won't mind me tossing in my POV.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Slaveboiz
In the SM community today there seems to be a steady pull to understand the nature and intent of play. I would surmise this new view of play has become more popular today as we live in a culture of electronics and machines.


How so? I'm curious as to how you think the culture of electronics and machines, as you put it, is somehow linked to a desire to understand the nature and intent of play. IMO, humans have always sought to understand themselves and their motivations. Well, many do. Some clearly do not and that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Introspection for the purposes of understanding and clarity is something I fully support. However, incessant navel gazing is a counter productive avoidance technique in my books. It can be a fine line between those two at times.

quote:


Often our connections to the outside world are done in a fragment of the time it used to be. We have all become slaves to technology; the computers, cell phones, and technologies that make things that once were made by hand, not to mention Wal-Mart lol. Seriously, we are vastly becoming a world that moves way to fast.


Although you may not have meant it in this way, I found you tend to use quite a few generalizations such as "we have all become slaves to technology" and I find those are not really accurate. I'll concede that many people have become slaves to technology but not all of us. I'm the first to admit that I'm an electronic gadget/toy whore. I love my integrated phone/PDA/web browser that fits neatly in my pocket. It's the coolest little thing. However, I'm not a slave to it. I have the ability to turn off my cell phone, computer, phone and TV and so does everyone else. These things are conveniences which should make our lives easier. If we allow them to become things which take over our lives then we need to re-evaluate how we use these technologies.

quote:


The very nature of technology is causing us to be disconnected from ourselves, let alone each other.


If anything I find that the problem is that these things leave us "too connected" but in a superficial way. I do not want everyone and their dog to be able to contact me on my cell phone whenever they feel like it. As a result only a handful of people have my cell number. I will never give it to my boss or anyone I feel will abuse it. The phone is for my convenience, not the convenience of others.

quote:


This pull towards a spiritual look at SM is an attempt to make sense of ourselves in a world that barely sees us.


Although I will agree that a spiritual approach to SM is in part about making sense of ourselves I think it can go far beyond that. For me it also contains an element of transcendance on a physical, emotional and psychological plane.

quote:


Many folks are exposed to the erotic side of play through porn, fiction and the internet, with little understanding of the deeper more spiritual meaning behind the things we do both in and out side the dungeon.


Perhaps for some people there is no spiritual element to SM. In fact, I don't see anything wrong with engaging in play without ever feeling a need to make it spiritual. In part, I think some people want to add a spiritual element to SM because in their minds it elevates SM beyond just some freaky shit we enjoy. It helps to legitimize and elevate it so that when vanillas cock an eyebrow we can so "No, really, it's not just a kinky thing, it's a spiritual thing!" While some of us want, need or enjoy a spiritual element to our SM play I don't think it's necessary and I don't think it's any "better" because we choose to add that element to it.

quote:


When we begin our journey into SM one may hear a lot about the release of endorphins and headspace but do we ever delve any deeper then that?


Some do and some don't. Delving deeper is not required nor is one better than the other.

quote:


As my experience had shown me there are generally three types of players; the erotic player; those who only seek play for its erotic content and as a sexual stimulant. The endorphin player; better known as the “true masochist or true sadist” and lastly the spiritual player; one who plays to gain insight about his or her spiritual self. Of course we all float in and out of all the above mentioned. However, I would like to present to you is my thoughts on the spiritual player.


I don't think everyone floats around between these categories. Again, some do and others do not. I know some who are strictly endorphin players. They don't have a submissive bone in their body but they are masochists to the core. I know others for whom it's all foreplay and a prelude to intercourse.

quote:


If I take an overview of all the cultures of the world, I note a consistent theme, that theme seems to entail rites and rituals of passage in one form or another, mainly those forms are to transition a child into adulthood; more specifically boyhood to manhood. Even here in western culture we have certain rites of passage and connectedness. Look at the father that takes his son out for his first hunting trip, or the indoctrination into a fraternity, just to name a few.


Women have their rituals as well. Jewish girls have bat mitzvahs to mark the beginning of their journey into womanhood. Many native tribes also have rituals for females at puberty. Even in North American culture there are female rites of passage - first menses, first bra, first kiss, first date, etc. They may not be as elaborate as he rites of passage in some other cultures but they are nonetheless significant.

quote:


So you ask, what does this have to do with play?

Rites of passage usually follow the idea of a test of sorts, the test has the intent to transform or transition a person into something new. It takes us from our every day life and tests our limits, our endurance and our connection to something or someone viewed as more important then ourselves. Its focus is usually about the body and spirit of that person.


Here I have to disagree. Some rites of passage may take the form of tests and have a spiritual focus but that is not necessary. IMO, a rite of passage is merely something that marks a significant turning point in a person's life. It does not have to be a test. It can be a noisey, raucus celebration (stag parties, anyone?) or it can be a quiet, solemn marker.

quote:


So again what does this have to do with play?

Play allows us to separate from the dominant cultures we live in, in order to connect with our own bodies and the spirit of who we are. Often time’s pain/ sensation play is the vehicle for that connectiveness.

The feelings we experience in play are what transforms us into more consciously aware beings. Lastly it connects us to others (top or bottom and community) it in effect, is a ritualistic rite of passage, not in the sense of the stages of life, but rather in the sense that we use the vehicle of pain to transcend our minds and bodies to a better more conducive state. We become more connect with our bodies in play than in any other state; other than perhaps sex or perhaps really good drugs.


For some of us play can do those things but I would not equate it with a rite of passage. I think it can be a transforming experience for some or even many but that shouldn't be considered a forgone conclusion. While pain/play can assist in connectivity to ones self and to others (or more accurately the other(s) you are playing with) it is ultimately your willingness to be open to that connectivity that facilitates that transformation. Not every wants to or is capable of going there. They may have other vehicles for experiencing that connectivity that have nothing to do with SM play.

quote:


Often we are presented with play as away to escape from the dominant culture but in fact play is very much the opposite. Play is a form of heightened connectedness with the mind, body, spirit and to each other.


Earlier on you said that play was a way to seperate from the dominant culture in order reconnect with our own bodies and who we are. Now you seem to be saying that play is NOT a way to seperate from the dominant culture but the opposite - so that would mean that play is a way in which to connect to the dominant culture? Sorry, I've lost your train of thought here.

quote:


So, if you are playing for the first time or have been playing for years, I invite you to look at what primitivism drives us to SM. What are your motives in SM and what is the personal gain you have in your play activities. I also invite you to look at the ritualism of the play you seek, and how it connects you to your mind, body and spirit.


A while back there was one of the usually insipid threads about how BDSMers are so much more highly evolved than vanillas and someone (can't remember who) made what I thought was a very interesting point. If BDSM is about tapping into our primal urges can we really consider ourselves more highly evolved or is it actually a process of devolution? I'd say that for me it is a process of personal evolution which hinges on integrating those primal urges in a healthy, responsible and appropriate way. Others mileage may vary.

Again, thanks for the great post.


(in reply to MsIncognito)
Profile   Post #: 13
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 10:34:22 AM   
Slaveboiz


Posts: 38
Joined: 4/19/2005
Status: offline
Dear Ms Incognito

As i read your well thought out responses to my posting i wish first to thank you for taking the time. Perhaps i can offer some more of my thoughts. It is not my intent to make generalizations but rather express an idea. i find that this lifestyle is in no way and exact science and wouldnt wish that to be so..

Anyway here goes:


quote:

ORIGINAL: MsIncognito

quote:

How so? I'm curious as to how you think the culture of electronics and machines, as you put it, is somehow linked to a desire to understand the nature and intent of play. IMO, humans have always sought to understand themselves and their motivations. Well, many do. Some clearly do not and that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Introspection for the purposes of understanding and clarity is something I fully support. However, incessant navel gazing is a counter productive avoidance technique in my books. It can be a fine line between those two at times.
quote:



i think we live in a culture (world wide) that is technology driven and can either bring us together ( as in this message board)or it can also serve to seperate us as well. ( facelss individuals on the internest) Where i agree that most people do eventually search for meaning in what we do, in our daily lives we are bomarded with cell phones computorized messages and automated systems. i think because of that, and perhaps in the course of my own journey, we are even more drawn to finding meaning in what we do especially in D/s and SM. And yes i agree it can be a fine line between avoidance and introspect... boy do i know that lol


quote:

Although you may not have meant it in this way, I found you tend to use quite a few generalizations such as "we have all become slaves to technology" and I find those are not really accurate. I'll concede that many people have become slaves to technology but not all of us. I'm the first to admit that I'm an electronic gadget/toy whore. I love my integrated phone/PDA/web browser that fits neatly in my pocket. It's the coolest little thing. However, I'm not a slave to it. I have the ability to turn off my cell phone, computer, phone and TV and so does everyone else. These things are conveniences which should make our lives easier. If we allow them to become things which take over our lives then we need to re-evaluate how we use these technologies.
quote:



You are right there are some generalizations here and perhaps i need to look at that in my writings. However "we are all slaves to technology" simply means that be damned if my comuptor doesnt connect when i want it to and my cell phone often gives people the ability to contact me regardless time or convience.. i am reminded that it has been years since i have hand written a letter. And the last car i was able to work on was a 1967 ford mustang. i note that when i call a business i get an automated menu directing to another automated menu. Its just a matter of being so reliant on technology that often makes us faceless in the world around us. It is for this reason i feel we find ourselve looking for the connection and the reason for that connection might very well be out of a desire to be seen, heard and felt as real people and not some nameless number.. Yes they do offer a convience but with that convience comes with a price.

quote:

If anything I find that the problem is that these things leave us "too connected" but in a superficial way. I do not want everyone and their dog to be able to contact me on my cell phone whenever they feel like it. As a result only a handful of people have my cell number. I will never give it to my boss or anyone I feel will abuse it. The phone is for my convenience, not the convenience of others.
quote:



Good point Ma'am

quote:

Although I will agree that a spiritual approach to SM is in part about making sense of ourselves I think it can go far beyond that. For me it also contains an element of transcendance on a physical, emotional and psychological plane.
quote:



Yes OMG yes

quote:

Perhaps for some people there is no spiritual element to SM. In fact, I don't see anything wrong with engaging in play without ever feeling a need to make it spiritual. In part, I think some people want to add a spiritual element to SM because in their minds it elevates SM beyond just some freaky shit we enjoy. It helps to legitimize and elevate it so that when vanillas cock an eyebrow we can so "No, really, it's not just a kinky thing, it's a spiritual thing!" While some of us want, need or enjoy a spiritual element to our SM play I don't think it's necessary and I don't think it's any "better" because we choose to add that element to it.
quote:



Exactly. my point was to say that i have been noting over the years that those people i knew back in the day doing casual play are now taking a more spiritual stance in what they do in D/s and SM. Please note there is no judgement here just and observation. Its kin to "why am i here what is the purpose in what i do and who i am?" Often deving int to consious and uncousious motives.

quote:

Some do and some don't. Delving deeper is not required nor is one better than the other.
quote:



Absolutly, i would offer that we often find ourselves at some point on our journey asking the above questions.. i personally am at that point.


quote:

I don't think everyone floats around between these categories. Again, some do and others do not. I know some who are strictly endorphin players. They don't have a submissive bone in their body but they are masochists to the core. I know others for whom it's all foreplay and a prelude to intercourse.
quote:



Perhaps. i am not sure if even the masochist isn't submitting to the Top during play. Even the masochist needs to submit for their time on the cross. Even the mosochist recongnizes that transision of self to another plane of existance even if it is only in the dungeon. His or her need to do so has its origians in tribel traditions dating as far back as history can show us. Perhaps at some point in the life of a masochist he or she will dicover the Why's to what they do and feel.

quote:

Women have their rituals as well. Jewish girls have bat mitzvahs to mark the beginning of their journey into womanhood. Many native tribes also have rituals for females at puberty. Even in North American culture there are female rites of passage - first menses, first bra, first kiss, first date, etc. They may not be as elaborate as he rites of passage in some other cultures but they are nonetheless significant.
quote:



Yes and i see us as humans as very ritualist anyway.. in SM and D/s i see those rights and rituals magnified... ie the collaring before play or how we structure things like protocol.


quote:

Here I have to disagree. Some rites of passage may take the form of tests and have a spiritual focus but that is not necessary. IMO, a rite of passage is merely something that marks a significant turning point in a person's life. It does not have to be a test. It can be a noisey, raucus celebration (stag parties, anyone?) or it can be a quiet, solemn marker.

i think of this in terms of the transition from everyday life to the experiences we have either at home or in the dugeon and then back out into the world. And the scene that is difficult but is still completed is infact a test... just ask someone deathly afraid of needles and then does a needle scene. He or she can't help but feel the test of thier abilities to work through pain and fear.


quote:

For some of us play can do those things but I would not equate it with a rite of passage. I think it can be a transforming experience for some or even many but that shouldn't be considered a forgone conclusion. While pain/play can assist in connectivity to ones self and to others (or more accurately the other(s) you are playing with) it is ultimately your willingness to be open to that connectivity that facilitates that transformation. Not every wants to or is capable of going there. They may have other vehicles for experiencing that connectivity that have nothing to do with SM play.
quote:



Smiles i think perhaps we are thinking along the same lines

quote:

Earlier on you said that play was a way to seperate from the dominant culture in order reconnect with our own bodies and who we are. Now you seem to be saying that play is NOT a way to seperate from the dominant culture but the opposite - so that would mean that play is a way in which to connect to the dominant culture? Sorry, I've lost your train of thought here.

oops>Perhaps there is no real way to fully disconnect from the dominant culture except in play. Even D/s is sometime infulanced by the demands of that culture. Those quiet spaces we share do disconnect us from the dominant culture and do very much reconnect us with our bodies in away that is often not accepted by the dominant culture. No! play does seem to allow us to seperate from the dominant culture. When we are opportating in the dominant culture, and this goes back to the technolgy theory, we are much less connected to our bodies and our spirit, when you compare it to the connectivness we feel when we are in a play session.


quote:

A while back there was one of the usually insipid threads about how BDSMers are so much more highly evolved than vanillas and someone (can't remember who) made what I thought was a very interesting point. If BDSM is about tapping into our primal urges can we really consider ourselves more highly evolved or is it actually a process of devolution? I'd say that for me it is a process of personal evolution which hinges on integrating those primal urges in a healthy, responsible and appropriate way. Others mileage may vary.

i dont know if i can say that we as SMers are more evolved i woul dhave to think about that but i would be open to that idea based on what i have see of other more priamal cultures that use pain to transition, look at native american, and african culture which are still in practice today. In the essence of being more evolved i think the very nature of what we do and who we are neccitates a more concouses existance.

i realize in writing that sometimes i might be coming from a place that is different then others. i think we have to take a look at , is this play we are talking about or the over all relationship between two people. They can very well be percieved as two different view points..

Again thank you for your thought provoking questions. i hope that i have offered some clearity or at least cause for more questions... i enjoy looking inward for more questions and outward for more possible answers..

warmest regards
slave ziggy

Again, thanks for the great post.


(in reply to MsIncognito)
Profile   Post #: 14
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 10:37:57 AM   
Slaveboiz


Posts: 38
Joined: 4/19/2005
Status: offline
OOPS Sorry about the double post..... have mercy on me ......... i am learning how to use it for the first time lol......

warmest regards
slave ziggy

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 15
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 10:49:06 AM   
candystripper


Posts: 3486
Joined: 11/1/2005
Status: offline
For Pete's sake, Slaveboiz, take this private with MzIncognito or increase the font size so we can at least read it.

candystripper

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 16
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 10:49:26 AM   
afmvdp


Posts: 494
Joined: 7/10/2004
Status: offline
A well written article, but it tends to be from sort of a fanciful mindset.

To some play appears as an escape and a chance to be something they are not within their daily lives while to others it is an undeniable part of who they are and how they live. Some are merely acting upon instinctual and genetic traits within them from birth. To some life just wouldn't feel right living it any other way, and to them it sort of supercedes the generalities of societal structures or a desire to deviate from or alleviate yourself of them.

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 17
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 11:09:22 AM   
candystripper


Posts: 3486
Joined: 11/1/2005
Status: offline
quote:

A well written article, but it tends to be from sort of a fanciful mindset.

To some play appears as an escape and a chance to be something they are not within their daily lives while to others it is an undeniable part of who they are and how they live. Some are merely acting upon instinctual and genetic traits within them from birth. To some life just wouldn't feel right living it any other way, and to them it sort of supercedes the generalities of societal structures or a desire to deviate from or alleviate yourself of them.

afmvdp


i think i understand you. i know, for myself, there is no going back to 'nilla. Either i will find my One, or i will live a happy, peaceful life alone. The idea of a 'nilla boyfriend just makes me remember -- i cannot "make" him a Dom -- Men don't change.

candystripper


< Message edited by candystripper -- 11/30/2005 11:10:03 AM >

(in reply to afmvdp)
Profile   Post #: 18
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 11:21:07 AM   
ErosPsyche


Posts: 46
Joined: 11/5/2005
Status: offline
-The sense of alienation Ziggy articulates doesn't resonate with me. Like Ms. Icognito, I don't feel enlsaved or trapped by technology - the technology I choose to use I find very liberating. I'm not alienated from the nation or culture - I can look back to Victorian London and hear the exact same question we about class, gender, sexuality, culture, materialism, technology, etc. This age is better by degree, but not different in type, than any other - I'm cool with the 21st century.

-If I understand your thesis, it is: some of us use Sadomasochistic relationships to transcend a dehumanizing culture - a culture that makes us a bra size, dress size, a set of genitals. By passing through the pain (or inflicting?) we heal ourselves, or at least rebalance ourselves, in a harmonious body/mind/spirit tripartided health.

That doesn't resonate with me. The gulf I want to transcend with my BDSM action isn't internal, but an external gulf between my love and I. An intensely brutal M/s relationship is the only gateway we have to intimacy. Both of us are to a degree cut off from others, in the sense of not being able to experience eros love in the general context most experience it. I need to hurt her to the very limits of her flesh, just as she needs that hurt, for us to be able to connect in intimacy.

So for us this is not spiritual, but rather intimate.

-I applaud your attempt to model your appraoch to BDSM, to understand yourself and your sexuality more clearly. I don't have the same framework, but I very much hope you fully flesh out yours.

-Eros

(in reply to afmvdp)
Profile   Post #: 19
RE: why we play - 11/30/2005 11:51:23 AM   
slavejali


Posts: 2918
Status: offline
quote:

So, if you are playing for the first time or have been playing for years, I invite you to look at what primitivism drives us to SM. What are your motives in SM and what is the personal gain you have in your play activities. I also invite you to look at the ritualism of the play you seek, and how it connects you to your mind, body and spirit.


i have a pretty good inner life. i dont attribute my involvement in bdsm play as a key factor in that. What i do gain from bdsm M/s interaction with my partner is a level of intimacy with another person. Its a way to interact with another that reflects my inner drive and way of being in the world.

My feminism seems to be one of surrender i see my male partner as the complimentary force to that. It is quite an eastern thought and their primal ideas of how man and woman interact and the symbolism of such really resonate with me.

i enjoy the intensity of play as it allows me to feel that surrender more as an actual experience in the world. i enjoy being pushed as it allows me to exhibit and express my inner drive to surrender. It's from that, my sexuality is turned on, not the other way round for me. i find out what its like to express in the world, how it all plays out, rather than uncovering any great truths about myself. It brings me out to play, if that makes sense.

< Message edited by slavejali -- 11/30/2005 12:20:52 PM >

(in reply to Slaveboiz)
Profile   Post #: 20
Page:   [1] 2   next >   >>
All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion >> why we play Page: [1] 2   next >   >>
Jump to:





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy

0.109