RE: Mind Fucks (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


KnightofMists -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 11:04:00 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Mercnbeth

I also don't want her to believe I would ever have the need to "test" her.



This is a common misconception that mindfucks are about Testing ones trust in another. It maybe a factor... but this should not be the purpose.... if it is!?, then I would be very very concerned.

quote:


I watched a terrible "mind fuck" scene. A slave, who was deathly afraid of heights was taken to a remote section of the Jersey Palisades (near the old park) and walked around nude in the night. she was taken to a cliff overlooking the Hudson and a bungee cord was attached to her feet. she was then blindfolded and a discussion followed where she overheard people discussing that this wasn't a good place because she could hit the side of the cliff. So blindfolded and bound, she was carried to another location. Along the way she heard ongoing discussions and debate whether this spot or the other was a "good". Finally her master told her she was at a perfect place, it was time to test her devotion. she had to jump off the cliff. she begged pleaded, promised anything, basically she was hysterical. she screamed to be released not only from her present bondage but from her "master". It seemed to take hours but I'm sure it was less than 15 minutes. Finally, the rest of the group convinced him this scene had gone very wrong and she was released. When the blindfold was removed, she discovered that the "cliff" she was carried to and currently standing upon was about one or two feet in height and a large gym pad was on the ground for her "landing". At that point it didn't matter. The actual situation didn't really calm her down much. her mind was scrambled.

Fantastic "mind fuck" huh?


This isn't a Mind Fuck... this Fucking with the Mind!




nonuts4thshoney -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 11:07:14 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Mercnbeth

quote:

The reason mind fuck scenes can be very beneficial in relationships, is because of the sense of accomplishment and pride that comes from them. The result might not be instantaneous, but it plays in the MIND long after the scene has stopped. The dominant will go back to how brave and trusting the sub was, the reactions he/she discovered during the scene that gives more information on other activities to do later or diferent areas to explore.


Lady Kim,

I would never involve beth in a "mind fuck" for the exact reason noted in your post that I emphasized; "it plays in the MIND long after the scene has stopped." That "it" you refer to, in my opinion, is doubt. An essential aspect of beth's training has been to eliminate doubt. I believe a "mind fuck" scene would be counter productive. From that point on, it would be impossible for her to know if whatever I was doing had a goal to further her training or was another "mind fuck".

I also don't want her to believe I would ever have the need to "test" her.


i haven't experienced any mind fucks with Master or anyone else ever. i do wonder how i would react to a " would i, wouldn't i" situation but then again i do wonder about the after affects. i also wouldn't want Master to feel the need to test my trust in Her. it would make me feel horrible.





Mercnbeth -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 11:19:03 AM)

quote:

This isn't a Mind Fuck... this Fucking with the Mind!


KoM,
Please differentiate? And again, how would anyone know before hand that what was planned as a "Mind Funk" ends up "Fucking with the Mind"?

If you and the sub/slave know absolutely that there is "no risk" it's not a "mind fuck" - right? We have "game playing" scenes frequently. Qualified as both of us knowing confidently there is no real danger, but I wouldn't refer to that as a "mind fuck".

I'll accept the point that we may be debating semantics. If so, we are in agreement. But some of the aforementioned examples seem to run the same risk as the example I used. To me that is not a risk worth taking.




amayos -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 11:21:52 AM)

One might say the entire practice of BDSM is one great big "mind fuck".




KnightofMists -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 11:41:16 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Mercnbeth

Please differentiate? And again, how would anyone know before hand that what was planned as a "Mind Funk" ends up "Fucking with the Mind"?

If you and the sub/slave know absolutely that there is "no risk" it's not a "mind fuck" - right? We have "game playing" scenes frequently. Qualified as both of us knowing confidently there is no real danger, but I wouldn't refer to that as a "mind fuck".

I'll accept the point that we may be debating semantics. If so, we are in agreement. But some of the aforementioned examples seem to run the same risk as the example I used. To me that is not a risk worth taking.



quote:

If you and the sub/slave know absolutely that there is "no risk" it's not a "mind fuck" - right?


No not right in my opinion.... all play has risks .. the degree of risks will vary of course... but just because their is Risk don't make it a MindFuck.

The Mind fucks play on fears in general... A Top that places themself as a bringer of the fear puts the relationship to the test. The bottom must choose the trust of the Top over the Fear that the person feels. Now sometimes, the Top will get away with it and thus the relationship will go forward. But, if the fear is stronger... then you have a huge problem.... This to me is Fucking with the mind.... in general... a person might get away with it alot... but pity the poor relationship that the Fear is greater than the trust that is in the relationship.

My approach is as a champion to the bottom in facing their fears. I do not bring the fear... we work together in facing the fear. A submissive I had was deathly afraid of canes... so afraid that she would and did freak at the sight of them. There is some concrete reasons why she had these phobic fears. In the beginning, her and I discussed this fear... the question was to her... Do you wish to manage and conquer this fear or not? She choose to conquer it... gave Consent for me to support her in facing this fear... and there was others as well... but this was a big one. I went to visit her... I left a cane in her bedroom in the corner until I return... told her she could break it if she choose to... but I also told her it was my favorite cane.... I returned about 2 weeks later and my cane was still there... this is a mind fuck.... in a mild form. About 6 months later... after some more work on the fears.. she asked and recieved strikes with the cane. She never really liked the cane... but she did conquer her fear of it.... and it all started with a mind fuck.




Mercnbeth -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 12:42:30 PM)

quote:

My approach is as a champion to the bottom in facing their fears. I do not bring the fear... we work together in facing the fear. A submissive I had was deathly afraid of canes... so afraid that she would and did freak at the sight of them. I left a cane in her bedroom in the corner until I return... told her she could break it if she choose to... but I also told her it was my favorite cane.... I returned about 2 weeks later and my cane was still there... this is a mind fuck.... in a mild form. About 6 months later... after some more work on the fears.. she asked and recieved strikes with the cane. She never really liked the cane... but she did conquer her fear of it.... and it all started with a mind fuck.


KoM,
I would consider your example as training, and advancing the subs experience level, and see it as a good illustration of consensually advancing limits. If you define that as a "mind fuck", then I routinely used and use similar mind fuck training techniques. I too believe the most effective training comes with the submissive acquiescing to activity which previously would be avoided. Having a sub beg for an experience that was previously a "hard limit" is fulfilling to me as a Master.

As you state, fear is a valuable tool. Not just for training, but for understanding. I don't know exactly when or even if, beth's obedience to me was inspired by fear. I can't pinpoint when it transitioned from the fear of punishment to the fear of disappointment. But I assure you now she fears more to disappoint me versus any punishment I could render.

I see your point that any scene where you come out of it with a deepening of trust serves a purpose. Removing fear and replacing it with trust is an obvious and very desirable goal. Sessions and scenes that accomplish that may accelerate the deepening of trust. It comes back to risk/reward. If I could accomplish the same goal taking a longer time, but avoiding the crossroad type mind fuck scenario, I'd choose the longer time. Maybe I'm jaded by that camping experience but I can't help it. If it's a weakness or if I'm missing out, I accept that too. Truth be told, that until it was obvious that the slave from my example was not going through the process as planned, I enjoined the rest of the group taunting and tormenting her. I didn't feel very good about myself afterward, but I was just as wrapped up into the scene as her Master and everyone else there. Again, it wasn't planned to come out the way it did. Being the control freak I am, I avoid situations where any unexpected result could be terminal to a relationship as special as I share with beth. Because of that, I've never been involved with a "mind fuck" that would compare.

I don't think your situation falls into the same category. You have indicated communication and a willingness on the submissive's part to address this fear. In the case of the camping trip, the entire scenario was a surprise. Even those subs with a "kidnap/rape fantasy" whose Master's facilitate the experience fundamentally have given consent. Your sub did the same. You technique worked well as indicated by her asking to feel the sensation of a cane.

In my example if the slave had expressed a desire to conquer her fear of heights, or even casually wanted to know what it felt to bungee jump, then that would be the same category, albeit maybe more intense, than your cane example. If, in my example, the master took her to that same cliff, had a real bungee cord attached and without the blindfold told her to jump all the time telling her it was safe, he tested it, he maybe even made a jump of his own, it may be in the same category. But as in your case, I would think the slave should also have had the desire to conquer the fear.

Thank you for replying to my inquiry and providing your perspective.




MistressDREAD -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 12:44:42 PM)

quote:

I believe a "mind fuck" scene would be counter productive. From that point on, it would be impossible for her to know if whatever I was doing had a goal to further her training or was another "mind fuck".

I also don't want her to believe I would ever have the need to "test" her.



Spoken from a true D/s position Merc.
However mindfucks are a S/m scene and action with the
act being very productive, stimulating, exciting and rewarding
to a sadist and masocist whom actually desire feelings and
reactions that to You as a D/s'er find revolting to what Your
desire for a D/s relationship is based off of. It doesent make
it wrong nor usless simply not a part of YOUR D/s. ~smiles~

Happy Kwanzza and New Year You two!! ~Kiss kiss~ ~Hug hug~




Mercnbeth -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 1:24:02 PM)

Mistress Dread,
All the best Holiday references to you too! Most important of all Happy Festivus!
quote:

exciting and rewarding to a sadist and masochist actually desire feelings and
reactions that to You as a D/s'er find revolting to what Your desire for a D/s relationship is based off of


Putting a label on me huh? Never been called a "D/s'er" before. Is it a good or bad?[8D]

I don't find any activity short of permanent disfigurement or death "revolting". My aversion is solely based upon the potential consequence of the activity. If challenged about beth having "no limits" within our relationship by someone who wants me to prove the statement by ordering her to poke out her eye I would say the consequence doesn't justify the request. A slave is a valuable possession, it takes great effort and a good amount of luck to find one. How stupid would it be, once you find such a rare and valuable commodity to destroy or damage it in such a way just to prove something to someone? If slaves were easy to come by and disposable, trust me, I could come up with some very sadistic and interesting "mind fucks". As it is, maybe I miss out by just doing it with/to beth but without the mind fuck part. But I don't avoid the physical activity.

First and foremost I'm a sadist. As a reference I had to take beth to the doctor a few months ago when a spider bite got infected. The Doctor required her to get an injection of antibiotics and a tetanus shot for good measure. I never knew that beth had such a fear of needles. When she had to bend over and pull down her pants for her shot she was in tears. I was laughing hysterically! I really thought she was faking it and crying just for my amusement, but even afterward when she admitted to her fear and told me she was afraid of needles I still couldn't stop being sadistically amused by the whole process.

Fast forward to this month when we both got physicals. beth was dreading the unavoidable blood drawing needle process. But now knowing of her fear, I turned it into "play". Going into the lab with her, I held her hand as a little child and said to her in the presence of the lab nurse; "If you are a good girl and don't cry, I'll have the nurse give you a nice lollipop and we ill go to Ihop for a Carmel Pancake breakfast." The nurse looked at us like we were a bit crazy (very insightful I'd say) and went along with it - giving her the lollipop and telling beth what a "brave big girl" she was! btw - she didn't cry.

Was that a "mind fuck"?

We both hope your tenure this time coming back from "double secret probation" on CM is long!




LadyJC -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 1:43:18 PM)

I'd love to be able to go, but finances cut me short. Most of my learning I've been doing was really from my mother (who is in the lifestyle) and information I read on here and bondage.com. Not to mention a few of my own personal lessons that I learned the hard way.
I have been in search of a mentor that isn't my mother, we're really close but it can still be a little wierd at times to ask her some stuff.
My network area is unfortunately small and not to many other doms who I actually respect around here.
If you're ever coming to Canada though give me a head's up I'd love to go.
LadyJC




Sensualips -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 3:17:40 PM)

quote:

the relationship lasted six months. Not bad, particularly in the 60s.


I feel the sixties are like Vegas. It doesn't really count. ;)

quote:

By the definition of the examples given on this thread, doesn't every "mind fuck" have the potential of ending similarly?


I understand and identify with the idea of valuing a relationship over a scene. I don't believe "mind fuck" should be an excuse for otherwise inexcusable behavior.

However, I also agree with the poster that said mind fucks don't have to be extreme, just tailored. I know in the example I gave regarding the blindfolded oral sex, he was never terrified or mentally tormented.

I'd love to hear from some fuckees about their experience and how it effected them. Successful or dreadful.




MistressDREAD -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 4:16:22 PM)


Well Merc it was the nicest label I could find for Your sexie self and beth.
Cant I get cudos for My tempts at being civil and nice today afterall
it is a holiday!! And by the way You would of had Me with the Carmel Pancake breakfast!
LOL!
And as usuall I can agree to disagree [:D]

damn what that what My double indemnidy Mod boot blast was called? (double secret probation)
You will notice I have no less then 10 posts so far with nay a ill word even tho
I have allready been pravoked several good times. [8D]
May all Your visions for the new year come tru with a bitch,bang, and baller!!!
hehehehehehe Happy 2006 My life stylzeeee peeps...




LadyKim -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 4:58:05 PM)

John,

I apologize if my last entry indicated that I was quoting a rule from the DSM (the only version of which I have access to is IIIV). I was trying to say that psychology had to find out the norm or 'rule' before figuring out what was outside of the norm. The only portion of what I said that was from DSM IIIV is the portion about the lack of concern for consentuality being a part of the criteria for diagnosis. The fact that it is a diagnosis for a mental condition eliminates the activites being safe or sane. I was simply stating that the bdsm creed of "Safe, sane, and consentual --- it must always be all three" separates what those in the lifestyle call sadism and masochism from the psychological diagnosis. There are obviously a list of criteria for each diagnosis; however, the list of criteria do not include activities that are safe, sane, or consentual.

I have a tendancy to try to break things down to an easily understandable application that is not always clinically complete but what helped me to understand it when I was first introduced to the psychological definitions. I do not yet hold a PhD in psychology, and I do not profess to know about everything in the DSM. Thus far, I'm only familiar with what I have already studied in school and discussed with my dear friend who is lifestyle and holds his PhD in Psychology. I'm still learning! LOL!!!

Again, I apologize if my thought process got mumbled and I gave the impression I was giving direct quotes from the DSM. It was not my intent.

MzKim




LadyKim -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/28/2005 5:12:52 PM)

Merc,

I can see your point and your reasoning for not wanting to do a mind fuck scene with beth. And I would never say that everyone HAS to do mind fuck scenes to really be in the lifestyle. That is ludicrious. We all have things we enjoy and things we just flat aren't interested in or remotely interested in exploring.

With that being said, as long as you do not break the trust during the scene it is not doubt that plays in the mind after the scene is over. The submissive already knows you DID NOT break the trust, so what plays around in their mind is how you pushed them further than they thought they could go ...... and you did it safely. They learn that they can trust you to guide them further to explore areas they were not sure about before. It also can give the submissive a major rush of pride in knowing what they were able to accept and conquer.

I am not saying this applies to every instance......... so please don't think I am. I am merely stating what has been my experience. Having stated this lifestyle as a submissive, I know what I experienced during mind fuck scenes....... good ones and bad ones. The bad scenes are what led me to talk to people I knew excelled in mind fuck scenes and learn from them how to build on them slowly to keep the trust prior to venturing into it as a Domme.

For those interesting in finding out more about mind fuck scenes, LadyD (former owner of PEP Atlanta) gave an excellent seminar on this subject at DomCon Atlanta this year with her submissive of 5 years, gypsy. You may be able to get a copy of the video tape or find a link to the seminar on DomCon's website.

MzKim




Wolfie648 -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/29/2005 12:33:29 AM)

quote:

Well, PERSONALLY, I can, however it only works if done judiciously and infrequently. There is a lapse in logic that repetitive mindfucks represent. If we are to say that a mindfuck is something that is not believed then the sub has nothing to fear. If we are saying that the sub will believe it, but the action is not enough to cause real fear, then I say, why bother?

Simply put, I would create a situation where the sub believed something bad was going to happen and actually happening. That doesn’t mean sneaking up on her daily and saying boo.

I will give you that there are things that can be done on a minor scale that are believed, but are not life threatening fears…things like threatening to burn and then putting ice on her, threatening to put ants on her, etc. However, again we run into the fact she either has learned from experience that it is not real or does not greatly fear the event.

For instance, in another OP about electrical play, the presentation made to the sub was that a severe, possibly fatal shock, was coming if she flipped the switch. She could:
1. believe it
2. think you wouldn’t do it
3. think you will only deliver a small shock.

Which is a mindfuck?


Exactly.

D (owner of j)




Ares1 -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/29/2005 12:34:21 PM)

quote:

if you were a regular play partner of mine I would know this about you.


This would not mean she still would fuck with your mind, and use all your weaknesses against you in the cruelest way imaginable.

quote:

I understand and identify with the idea of valuing a relationship over a scene.


History and actions would demonstrate differently.




ExistentialSteel -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/29/2005 12:57:12 PM)

There seems to be a couple of definitions of mindfuck going on here. Maybe we should differentiate between minor and major or something? I would love to hear more from John Warren and his view of minor mindfucks.




JohnWarren -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/29/2005 1:10:35 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: ExistentialSteel

There seems to be a couple of definitions of mindfuck going on here. Maybe we should differentiate between minor and major or something? I would love to hear more from John Warren and his view of minor mindfucks.


I don't think of them in terms of major and minor. Best done, the mindfuck is tailored to the submissive, her needs, fears and limits. What would be a perfect mindfuck for one person would send another running from the relationship and simply bore a third.




ExistentialSteel -> RE: Mind Fucks (12/29/2005 1:27:36 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: JohnWarren


quote:

ORIGINAL: ExistentialSteel

There seems to be a couple of definitions of mindfuck going on here. Maybe we should differentiate between minor and major or something? I would love to hear more from John Warren and his view of minor mindfucks.


I don't think of them in terms of major and minor. Best done, the mindfuck is tailored to the submissive, her needs, fears and limits. What would be a perfect mindfuck for one person would send another running from the relationship and simply bore a third.


Thanks John. I can agree with what you said and I think it was kind of what I was trying to say. I would love to be able to see your upcoming demo.




KnightofMists -> RE: Mind Fucks (1/20/2006 8:57:49 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Ares1

quote:

if you were a regular play partner of mine I would know this about you.


This would not mean she still would fuck with your mind, and use all your weaknesses against you in the cruelest way imaginable.

quote:

I understand and identify with the idea of valuing a relationship over a scene.


History and actions would demonstrate differently.


It really is a matter of perspective isn't it..... If one was hurt and angry there opinion and feelings on a particular person that is percieved to be the cause of that hurt and angry wouldn't be exactly unbaised. Especially if they are demonstrated vengeful behaviors and hold resentment!




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625