RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


UncleNasty -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 11:22:48 AM)

I'm against any para-military group that operates outside the control of government. That is one of the foundational stones for converting an open society into a closed society. Blackwater USA falls under that definition in my mind.

I also consider citizen militias to be of a different ilk. Their allegiance lies with themselves and with other citizens advocating for the citizenry. State Militias fall under the control of state Governors.

Uncle Nasty




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 12:06:12 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: celticlord2112

quote:

The U.S. Marine corps has a different mission than the constitutionally approved military and as such does not suffer from the same constraints placed on the Army,Navy and Air Force.

The US Marine Corps is governed by the same Uniform Code of Military Justice as the other military branches. Section 4 of the act that created the Marines specifically puts the Marines under the same military oaths and regulations as the rest of the military establishment, and the especial regulations of the Navy.  
I did not say that the U.S. Marine corps was not subject to the UCMJ.

How exactly is the Marine Corps not "constitutionally approved"? 
If you were to actually read the constitution it approves of a Navy and an Army(the Air Force comes out of the army so by extension they are constitutionally approved).  The U.S. Marine corps was created by the congress in 1799.  As such the U.S. Marine corps can be disolved by congress.  Congress may not disolve the Army or the Navy or the Air Force without a constitutional ammendment.
If the president wishes to use the Army,Navy or Air Force he needs to get congressional approval.  To use the Marine corps he needs only ask the commandant of the Marine corps,whom he appoints and who serves at the presidents pleasure.
I find it curious that in the same post you cribbed my quote from you failed to notice my example of Mai Lai vs. Cam Ne.
If you were to acquaint yourself with the history of the Marine corps you would find that they do not fight wars so much as they terrorize the shit out of people so that they will do as they are told. 


Given that the Constitution explicitly affords the Congress the power "to provide and maintain a Navy"--and the Marines are to this day a part of the Department of the Navy
True on the whole but not the whole truth. 
The Department of the Navy is not the Navy.  The Navy is the Navy department which is under the Department of the Navy just as the U.S. Marine corps is.  You may think this is picking flyshit out of the pepper but the Navy department(which is the squids and all their boats) and the Marine corps are co-equal subdivisions of the Department of the Navy.  The Department of the Navy is an administrative branch of the Federal government.  This is something that all Marines are taught in boot camp...either you were sleeping durring that lecture or you were in the same marine corps that Thadius was.



--their Constitutional status is, if anything, superior to that of both the Army and the Air Force.
Hardly since the Navy and the Army predate the U.S. Marine corps by ten years.

Edited to add:  The 82nd Congress specifically designated the Marines at the United States' expeditionary force in readiness.  In that regard, yes, the mission of the Marines is different from the rest of the military.
The mission of the U.S. Marine corps was different from day one.





slaveboyforyou -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 6:51:54 PM)

quote:

You have no clue who Blackwater recruits...if you do have this information please post it.  Your post states the units that Blackwater recruits from but fails to recognize that these are reconisance units not combat units.  They are trained to infiltrate,glean intelligence and leave without leaving any trace of thier pressence.


The information is readily avaliable from news accounts and Blackwater's own website.  Look it up yourself, I am not writing a paper.  I have no obligation to provide you with citations.

quote:

Have you a cite to back up this assertion?


Again, look it up.  I don't have to provide you with a citation.  The information is readily avaliable from news sources covering the shooting and the indictment of those involved. 

quote:

That is an arguement I did not make.  I said that Blackwater was a bunch of undisciplined thugs.


Well, you shouldn't have included a comparison to the Marine Corps in your assertion if you didn't intend that argument. 

quote:

Duties like what?  Murdering indiscriminantly?
The last time I checked the Marine corps is nearly 200,000 active plus a division and an air wing in reserve. 


Bodyguards, training foreign police forces, State Department security (not the Marines' job.), etc.  The military is not a jack of all trades, and there aren't enough personnel to do everything that needs to be done.  200,000 and a reserve division is a drop in the bucket.  The armed services are not just in Iraq. 

quote:

When was the last time the U.S. used field mercenaries?


In every armed conflict that it's ever been involved in.  They aren't always called mercenaries, but that's what they are.  Read up on your history. 

quote:

That is why we make rules for it's conduct and have war crimes trials when it is over. 


Sometimes we do, and sometimes we don't.  You'll never hear about a lot of the things that went on in any war. 




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 7:21:36 PM)

quote:

The information is readily avaliable from news accounts and Blackwater's own website.  Look it up yourself, I am not writing a paper.  I have no obligation to provide you with citations


Your post stated something as fact...when pressed for proof of your assertion you are either unable or unwilling to produce it.
It would appear that you feel your only obligation is to post assertions and deny any need to substantiate them.
 
H.




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 7:26:18 PM)

quote:

Again, look it up.  I don't have to provide you with a citation.  The information is readily avaliable from news sources covering the shooting and the indictment of those involved


If it is readily available from news sources covering the shooting and the indictment of those involved then it would not be too difficult for you to post it to substantiate your post.  Since it is not one can only surmise that your post is more opinion than fact...which was my point.
 
H.




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 7:29:45 PM)

quote:

Well, you shouldn't have included a comparison to the Marine Corps in your assertion if you didn't intend that argument.


I did not include it in my comparison...you did and I was correcting you.
 
H.




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 7:37:35 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

quote:

Duties like what?  Murdering indiscriminantly?
The last time I checked the Marine corps is nearly 200,000 active plus a division and an air wing in reserve. 


Bodyguards, training foreign police forces, State Department security (not the Marines' job.), etc.  The military is not a jack of all trades, and there aren't enough personnel to do everything that needs to be done.  200,000 and a reserve division is a drop in the bucket.  The armed services are not just in Iraq. 


This may come as a surprise to you but protecting diplomats is one of the primary missions of the Marine corps.  They are the embassy guard around the world.
The Marine corps has a long history of training police forces...Hatie,Dominican Republic,Cuba,Nicaragua...the list is quite extensive.
There are more than enough Marines to replace Blackwater's thugs.
 
H.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 7:40:36 PM)

quote:

If it is readily available from news sources covering the shooting and the indictment of those involved then it would not be too difficult for you to post it to substantiate your post.  Since it is not one can only surmise that your post is more opinion than fact...which was my point.
 
H.


Well, I surmise you don't read or watch the news.  You are the one who seems to pass opinions off as facts.  Where's your citations for all of your assertions (like your numbers for the Marine Corps.)  Hmm, it seems to me you believe that your opinion and large, bold fonts are enough. 

Since you're too lazy to find your own information.  Here you go: 

http://www.federalnewsradio.com/?nid=78&pid=&sid=1542381&page=1

quote:

December 8, 2008 - 7:29pm


By The Associated Press


(AP) - Five Blackwater Worldwide security guards in their mid- to late 20s, all with distinguished military records, are each charged with 14 counts of manslaughter and 20 counts of attempted manslaughter in the September 2007 deaths of 17 Iraqis in Baghdad's Nisoor Square.
Prosecutors says the men opened machine-gun fire on innocent, surrendering Iraqis and launched a grenade into a girls' school during the gruesome shooting.
Below, a biographical sketch of each man based on court documents filed Monday in support of their pretrial release and biographies on a Web site set up by their lawyers.
___
Donald Ball is a 26-year-old from West Valley City, Utah. His residency is a reason defense lawyers say the case should be tried in Salt Lake City, not Washington. Presumably, the men would find a more conservative jury pool and one more likely to support the Iraq war.
Ball attended school in Utah. He was a track and cross-country standout and achieved the rank of Eagle Scout. His father died when he was 16. After graduating from high school, Ball enlisted in the U.S. Marine Corps. He was an honor graduate in the School of Infantry following boot camp at Camp Pendleton, Calif.
Ball served three tours in Iraq _ March-May 2003, February-July 2004 and February-July 2005 _ and was squad team leader during each stint. He reached the rank of corporal.
In support of an award nomination, a commanding officer described Ball as focused on his mission and calm under pressure. "His attitude and devotion to duty were excellent examples for his Marines to follow," the officer wrote.
The list of awards he received is long: a Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal for his leadership while coming under sniper fire, a Certificate of Commendation for his combat service in the city of Fallujah, a Marine Corps Good Conduct Medal, a Combat Action Ribbon, a Sea Service Deployment Ribbon with two stars, an Iraq Campaign Medal, a Global War on Terrorism Expeditionary Medal, a National Defense Service Medal, a Presidential Unit Citation and a Rifle Expert Badge (second award).
Ball was honorably discharged from the Marines before Blackwater hired him in August 2006. He returned to Iraq in December of that year. He left Blackwater in November 2007, two months after the Nisoor Square shooting, and joined another company where he trained Marines who were preparing to deploy to Iraq.
In March, Ball entered the police academy at Salt Lake Community College _ he's scheduled to graduate on Dec. 18. He also works as a bailiff at Salt Lake City justice court.
___
A Texas native, Dustin Heard, 28, lives in Maryville, Tenn., with his wife and young daughter.
He joined the U.S. Marine Corps in 2000. After basic training at Camp Pendleton, Heard enrolled in the security force battalion school in North Carolina.
Heard was stationed in Bahrain as part of a security force supporting U.S. missions in the Middle East. Before the 2003 invasion of Iraq, he was assigned to Kuwait. During the invasion, Heard was part of an anti-terrorist team deployed to protect oil fields off the coast of Iraq.
He was later moved to southern Iraq, near Karbala, as part of a team of Marines assigned to recover downed pilots and aircraft. Later in 2003, he was deployed to Afghanistan.
He was honorably discharged in 2004 and joined Blackwater in December of that year.
His honors include: Certificate of Commendation, Navy and Marine Corps Expeditionary Medal, Sea Service Deployment Ribbon, Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal, National Defense Service Medal, Global War on Terrorism Expeditionary Medal and three certificates of appreciation from U.S. Embassy, Baghdad, for securing the embassy and Ministry of Parliament and providing security for Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice.
___
Evan Liberty, 26, lives in Rochester, N.H.
After graduating high school, Liberty enlisted in the U.S. Marine Corps, where he served for four years. From 2002-04, Liberty was posted to security details at U.S. embassies in Cairo, Egypt, and Guatemala City.
He eventually was promoted to sergeant of the guard, supervising a detachment of 24 Marines.
Liberty received an honorable discharge, and he joined Blackwater in December 2004.
His honors include: Meritorious Mast, Marine Corps Good Conduct Medal, White House Communications Agency Certificate, National Defense Service Medal, and Navy and Marine Corps Overseas Service Ribbon.
____
Nick Slatten, 25, has lived in Sparta, Tenn., except for his time in the military and with Blackwater.
Slatten enlisted in the U.S. Army after graduating from high school in 2002. In September 2003, he was deployed to Iraq for an eight-month tour, where he spent time in Fallujah on missions to capture top Iraqi government officials.
He completed the Army's sniper training program and was redeployed to Iraq for a second tour in September 2005 along Iraq's northern border with Iran.
After four years, Slatten was honorably discharged as a sergeant. He was hired by Blackwater in October 2006.
Slatten received the Army Good Conduct Medal, Iraq Campaign Medal, Combat Infantryman Badge, Army Commendation Award, Army Achievement Medal National Defense Service Medal, Global War on Terrorism Expeditionary Medal, Global War on Terrorism Service Medal and Army Service Ribbon.
___
Paul Slough, 29, grew up in Texas and, aside from his time in the military and with Blackwater, has lived there all his life.
He enlisted in the U.S. Army after graduating high school in 1999.
As a member of the 3rd Infantry Division, he was deployed to Bosnia for six months in 2000, where he conducted security patrols.
After an honorable discharge in 2002, Slough joined the Texas National Guard and deployed to Iraq in January 2005 for one year. He left the National Guard in 2006, and joined Blackwater in the spring of that year.
His honors include: Army Commendation Medal, Army Good Conduct Medal, National Defense Service Medal, Combat Infantry Badge, Driver and Mechanic Badge, Armed Forced Expeditionary Medal, Armed Forces Reserve Medal, NATO Medal, Army Service Ribbon, Overseas Service Ribbon and Global War on Terrorism Service Medal.
He lives with his wife in Keller, Texas, and works as a welder. Since May Slough has attended community college part time.
___
On the Net:
http://www.raven23.com/
(Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.) By The Associated Press

(AP) - Five Blackwater Worldwide security guards in their mid- to late 20s, all with distinguished military records, are each charged with 14 counts of manslaughter and 20 counts of attempted manslaughter in the September 2007 deaths of 17 Iraqis in Baghdad's Nisoor Square.  


If you'll read further, the article gives brief biographies of all 5 defendents.  Three of the five were honorably discharged Marines.  Two of the five were honorable discharged Army veterans.  All of them had distinguished records.

So were is your citations that Blackwater is filled with undisciplined recruits?  My guess is you don't have any. 




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 7:42:04 PM)

quote:

In every armed conflict that it's ever been involved in.  They aren't always called mercenaries, but that's what they are.  Read up on your history. 


Your post, once again, is unsubstantiated opinion.
 
H.




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 8:12:08 PM)

quote:


If you'll read further, the article gives brief biographies of all 5 defendents.  Three of the five were honorably discharged Marines.  Two of the five were honorable discharged Army veterans.  All of them had distinguished records.

Anyone who has actually been in the military would dispute the term "distinguised records"  the campagn ribbons are what are refered to as "fire watch" ribbons...you get them for being someplace not for doing something.
Something I noted is that one of the Marines did not receive a good conduct medal which would inidcate that he had some sort of discipline problem...a good conduct medal is awarded for not being a fuck up.
Another of the Marines is said to have served 4 years from 2002 till 2004. Maybe that is the "new math" but my old math says that is two years.  Perhaps these "bios" are not "complete"
 
 

So were is your citations that Blackwater is filled with undisciplined recruits?  My guess is you don't have any. 


My statement was and still is that they were "undisciplined thugs".  That they would fire into a crowd of non combatants is prima facia evidence of undiciplined thuggery.
 
I would like to thank you for posting the cite that I asked for.




celticlord2112 -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 8:18:14 PM)

quote:

If you were to actually read the constitution it approves of a Navy and an Army(the Air Force comes out of the army so by extension they are constitutionally approved). The U.S. Marine corps was created by the congress in 1799. As such the U.S. Marine corps can be disolved by congress. Congress may not disolve the Army or the Navy or the Air Force without a constitutional ammendment.
If the president wishes to use the Army,Navy or Air Force he needs to get congressional approval. To use the Marine corps he needs only ask the commandant of the Marine corps,whom he appoints and who serves at the presidents pleasure.


Article I Section 8 of the Constitution ennumerates the powers of the Congress.  Included in that list is the power to "Provide and Maintain a Navy".  Congress need not maintain a Navy, and, prior to 1794, did not maintain a Navy (the "Act to Provide A Naval Armament" was passed on 27 March 1794.  The act establishing the Marine Corps was enacted on 11 November 1798 (not 1799).  What Congress can create, it can also dissolve--and it can dissolve either the Navy or the Marine Corps with a single legislative act.

There is exactly ONE reference to the Army in the Constitution, and that is Article II Section 2, which establishes the President as the Commander-in-Chief of the Army and Navy.

Nowhere does the Constitution mandate the maintenance of any standing military force, and, in the first years after its ratification, Congress did not maintain such a force.

Congress can, at its pleasure, disband any or all of the armed forces, without need of Constitutional amendment.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 8:22:55 PM)

quote:

Anyone who has actually been in the military would dispute the term "distinguised records"  the campagn ribbons are what are refered to as "fire watch" ribbons...you get them for being someplace not for doing something.
Something I noted is that one of the Marines did not receive a good conduct medal which would inidcate that he had some sort of discipline problem...a good conduct medal is awarded for not being a fuck up.
Another of the Marines is said to have served 4 years from 2002 till 2004. Maybe that is the "new math" but my old math says that is two years.  Perhaps these "bios" are not "complete"


Um, where's your citation to back up these assertions?  Anyone who was in the military would make that claim, huh?  Where is your proof that ANYONE who was in the military would make that claim?  I knew you'd do that.  You like ask for citations, but then you state opinions as facts in response.  Using large, blod fonts doesn't make you look important.  It sure doesn't make your opinions more valid.  DONE.




HunterS -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 8:36:31 PM)

quote:

Um, where's your citation to back up these assertions?  Anyone who was in the military would make that claim, huh?  Where is your proof that ANYONE who was in the military would make that claim?  I knew you'd do that.  You like ask for citations, but then you state opinions as facts in response.  Using large, blod fonts doesn't make you look important.  It sure doesn't make your opinions more valid.  DONE.


No the large bold fonts just make it easier for me to read without my glasses.  Not all of are as young as you.
As for my proof...I was in the military and I am telling you that a campagn ribbon is for where you have been not what you have done.
 
H.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 8:41:36 PM)

quote:

As for my proof...I was in the military and I am telling you that a campagn ribbon is for where you have been not what you have done.


That's not proof.  It's an opinion based on personal experience.  You made that claim that ALL veterans of military service would make that claim, which may or may not be true.  It's not a fact backed up by any real data.  The point I'm making is that maybe you shouldn't demand citations when you don't provide any of your own to back up your claims. 




Lorr47 -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/18/2008 10:22:15 PM)

quote:

Your post would seem to indicate that you would disavow the Neurmburg trials in Germany and the war crimes trials that took place in Japan.

H.


Oh, to the contrary, Germany and Japan were the losers.  Therefore, we had a right to punish the wrongdoers and should have conducted mass executions. However, I never would condone an American combat solder being changed with a War Crime.




kittinSol -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/19/2008 4:37:35 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lorr47
Oh, to the contrary, Germany and Japan were the losers.  Therefore, we had a right to punish the wrongdoers and should have conducted mass executions. However, I never would condone an American combat solder being changed with a War Crime.


Double-standards are such a wonderful thing.




Lynnxz -> RE: Blackwater may loose license in Iraq (12/19/2008 4:39:34 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lorr47

quote:

Your post would seem to indicate that you would disavow the Neurmburg trials in Germany and the war crimes trials that took place in Japan.

H.


Oh, to the contrary, Germany and Japan were the losers.  Therefore, we had a right to punish the wrongdoers and should have conducted mass executions. However, I never would condone an American combat solder being changed with a War Crime.



O.o




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875