RE: Dont be surprised! (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


Whiplashsmile4 -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 9:47:23 AM)

This topic is an area filled with land mines of opinions, thoughts and experiences.

I do and don't have problems with having my boundaries pushed or tested.  It's a bit of a case by case basis.  Depends too if it's an established relationship and to what level it's been tried, tested and true and blue.

First and foremost, in cases where somebody is attempting to control me as a means to cover their own ass from stupid mistakes.  Basically, to get me to back down from digging up "The Truth", forget it.  My nature, is to notice changes in bahaviors, attitudes and even emotions.  I'm driven by both logic and emotion personally.   Anyways, I don't deal well with somebody holding our relationship hostage as a means of control.  For instance, somebody telling me not to talk or interacte with another human being with a threat of ending things.  Even more so when this other person is a complete stranger to me.  If anything, it just provokes my mind into wondering why not?   Generally speaking, anybody trying to push me into doing or not doing something when they are using our relationship as leverage, forget it.   I will go ahead anyways, and with more reason to discover what the HELL is really going on.  

So, when somebody uses Threats of Ending relationship unless I do or do not do something, it really rubs me wrong way.  I'm a bit of a Rebel anyways.  Meaning, good luck at anybody trying to truely control me.  This is just my personality.  I don't look at it as being a Dom or submissive trait.  It's just who I am as a human being.

I hate being set up in CATCH 22 situations, I dispise it in fact.  Where if I say YES or NO to something, either case it's fucked.  I hate having a submissive toss me into a CATCH 22 situation.   I just might take the path, the submissive will least enjoy or like.  Hell, I might just call them on it being a CATCH 22.   Generally, it makes me some what resentful, and I will express that resentment.  (look no punishment involved).

I do not deal with anybody threatening the relationship itself.  Trust me, if you attempt to threaten me by using your friendship/relationship with another Dominant or guy as a means of leverage to get to do or not do something,  Big fucking mistake.  In short, when a submissive trys to play the Jealously Game with me.  The result generally turns out with me being resentful and untrusting of that subs friendship with another person.  I will literally lay down the ultimatium card of having that friendship come to an END.  (guess you can call this a form of punishment, as well as means of relationship protection and even personal protection).  I dispise somebody trying to play Jealously Games inorder to get me to do or not do something.  Even more so, if I'm not in a position to even do what somebody is trying to get me to do.   In short, don't provoke my own limitations as to what I can not do.

Nothing more stupid then to attempt to push a DOM into doing something they are not capable or able to do at the time.  Really sort of sucks.   Let's say for instance, it's something I myself really want to do.  I'm working on it, the submissive runs out of patience and pushes the issue.   OK, this does not rub me well.   I hate being pushed a long faster then I can humanly move in what it is that I'm doing.   Bad idea for a sub to do this.  It actually sort of makes a DOM feel sort of powerless to humanly move things along faster.   Tends to make us DOM types a little resentful.   (punisment may or may not be an option).

Personally, I pefer to talk about things to deal with problems.  However, make no mistake, I can verbally eat somebody up and spite them up as a means of punishment.  Verbal humilation, or simply expressing my pissed offness.  It all depends.  I tend to resent it when somebody not want to talk about things, clams up and goes into avoidence mode.

I'm not expressing by any means, that how I handle or deal with things, is right or wrong.  I'm just expressing things from my own Dominant perspective here.   I can become verbally sadistic without resorting to the use of mindless name calling even.  However, there is some form or basis of logic and truth in what I'm expressing. 

OK, here's another mistake that submissives have made.  That is to toss a past relationship in my face.  Such as having somebody accuse me of wanting an EX (love,sub,slave or girl) in my life still.   i.e. for instance, being told why don't I go off and fuck so and so because so and so still wants me.  I don't like games like this.  Because If I wanted so and so, I would be with so and so.  There is a reason why an EX is an EX.

I literally had somebody who repeatedly said things to me regarding an EX, that I had no interest in being with.  I coddled their insecurity for awhile, but trying to give them assurances that I did not want my EX nor thought about my EX like that.  Then one night during a tense situation, she made a comment that I should go off and fuck my EX.   I said, that's it.  Since you want to play like this, I'm taking my gloves off.   I proceeded to give her a dose of her own medication, however it was 10 times more intense.  I simply got done with being Mr. Nice guy trying to give her positive assurance and dealing with things in a positive human manner.  So I verbally punished the HELL out of her with a taste of her own medicine. 

OK, so I may or may not be polically correct in my style or nature.  None the less, I am Dominant, I try to have understanding and compassion.  I myself have limits.  If you push my limits you might be in for a rude fucking awakening.

Some DOMs will simply drop some submissives at a drop of dime over such behaviors.  I tend to be a little more tolerent at times, but.. make no mistake.  Keep it up, bad things will and do happen.

Generally, though experienced submissives don't pull this crap.  Actually, anybody who is experienced at relationships in general does not pull the kind of crap that I'm writting about.

This kind of pushing and testing, is relationship thing and not just something a submissive does.  There are DOMs that push things to crazy levels with submissives that causes a relationship to fall apart quickly as well.

Limits are two sided.  Both submissives and Doms have them.  Push too hard, push things in the wrong manner, Game Over...

I actually wish people could step back, abd look at things from a General Human behavior perspective at times compared to just a D/s point of view. 




Jeptha -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 9:58:38 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: eyesopened

quote:

ORIGINAL: VampiresLair
he has decided to look for a third to train in hopes she will improve her efforts in order to stay his number one and not be demoted to number two.


Wow. I cannot imagine being asked to join an existing household to help the first submissive retain her status so I can remain number two OR to work hard to overthrow my sister's status and demote her. ...
You know, I picked up on that in the original post, but just went with the form of the question about testing. But that particular example does sound like a conflict between a slave who wants to have some boundaries and a frustrated dominant who would like more - not so much a question of testing, but of negotiation, in my book (note; I don't really have a book.)




lronitulstahp -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 10:05:40 AM)

quote:

If you are with me as a submissive, I expect you to be in your place. I do not test to see how submissive you will be under any circumstances and I do not expect you will push to se how I react to any either. I found you becasue you were sub, I expect you to be sub. You should expect me to be domme, and learn the boundaries as we naturally get to them, not by forcing


Sounds simple enough...but i have felt myself subconsciously testing in the past. i am very guarded, and have a hard time accepting people at face value.  When i am made aware of my behaviors, i try to refrain from continuing down that road. But old habits die hard...and i can't profess perfection....quite yet.[;)]  
('k, maybe never...whatever...)

What i find really amusing is when my "fellow submissive types" give relationship advice that is usually based on one form of testing or another, and when they express distaste at a willingness to be the submissive in a D/s relationship that is fairly new.  i'm not sure how many months are supposed to go along until it's okay for the "s" type to decide to be viewed as submissive....but i figure if you meet someone that supposedly, already KNOWS you're a sub...don't be stunned when they expect you to be...[image]http://www.collarchat.com/micons/m24.gif[/image]SURPRISE: submissive!!!!!!







LadyPact -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 10:45:20 AM)

It's a good topic, DV.  I won't speak to the specifics of what brought the thread about.  Just the generalities.

First of all, I want to address this whole testing concept, from either side of the kneel.  Let's face it.  Not only subs do this.  It can come from the other way around, too.

Any dynamic, new or old, shouldn't be asked to weather this type of nonsense.  Someone else said it earlier.  There are enough things that come up in day to day life to let anyone know if the person they are with Dom enough or sub enough for their expectations.  Nobody should have to set up little situations to 'test' how a person is going to react.  I don't know about anyone else out there, but life brings it's own opportunities to find out where anyone stands on this or that.  There's no need to go creating situations to do so.

With that said, if you're the type of person who feels you have to do that, I can promise that, in dealing with Me, you're probably not going to like the result.  Especially if it comes to pass that I find out that I was being tested in the first place.  If you want to question My Dominance or any other thing, you should know enough about Me that I'm willing to discuss it.  Approach Me with respect in hopes of honest communication, and you'll get it.  Approach Me with some other BS, and you'll find that shit slings both ways.

So, no, you don't get to cry, bitch, or moan when you find that I pass your little 'test' and end up punishing you.  It's not that I like punishing in the first place, because if I'm in that position, something is obviously very wrong.  Any time that I am in the situation where a punishment is warranted, yes, like you, I am going to question the compatibility of the relationship.  That is not the same thing as holding the dynamic hostage.  That is Me being honest with you about My feelings on the matter. 




RedMagic1 -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 10:57:44 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DavanKael

I think it's a bit strange to set up an intentional test when the subtleties of everyday interaction are so very telling. 
Davan

Quotes for emphasis.  Life throws enough tests at you already.  Why manufacture drama, when you already get handed so much for free?




LadyIce -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 10:59:27 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: RedMagic1

quote:

ORIGINAL: DavanKael

I think it's a bit strange to set up an intentional test when the subtleties of everyday interaction are so very telling. 
Davan

Quotes for emphasis.  Life throws enough tests at you already.  Why manufacture drama, when you already get handed so much for free?



I agree, I don't find the need to "test", when your normal actions, tell me far more.
Most people tend to hang themselves, given enough rope.




antipode -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 11:28:44 AM)

quote:

I found you becasue you were sub, I expect you to be sub.


I've found that a good proportion of women that think they are subs have in fact a controlling personality, and "top from the bottom". You need to test for that.




Whiplashsmile4 -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 12:13:03 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: antipode

quote:

I found you becasue you were sub, I expect you to be sub.


I've found that a good proportion of women that think they are subs have in fact a controlling personality, and "top from the bottom". You need to test for that.



I've encountered this too along with a variety of different tactics.




InTonguesslut -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 12:55:01 PM)

quote:

It never ceases to amaze me when submissives I know and talk to wind up on the losing end of a test they had tried with their dominants and then they caterwaul about how unfair it was that they were punished or even worse dismissed for it


Actually i'm more on the other side of this, it never fails to amaze me how many subs / slaves get away with pulling shit with their dominants. I spot it a mile off but the dom just can't see it.




Prinsexx -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 4:48:21 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: antipode

quote:

I found you becasue you were sub, I expect you to be sub.


I've found that a good proportion of women that think they are subs have in fact a controlling personality, and "top from the bottom". You need to test for that.


As with scart plugs... if they don't fit, they don't work. No amount of testing is going to make electricity now is it?




AquaticSub -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 5:19:04 PM)

~Fast Reply~

I just don't like tests. I don't put up with them, I don't expect Val to either. I don't understand why anyone puts up with being tested in their relationships. When you start getting into the testing, it just seems like they don't really want to be in the relationship. Or they just want the drama that comes along with the testing, the punishment and the whining.

Though I have to agree with everyone else that I doubt adding anyone else is going to help the situation. I certainly would stay a long way away from anyone to wanting to add me to a relationship to fix one with problems.




VampiresLair -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 11:00:18 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Prinsexx

I'm amazed by your entire approach. If it never ceases to amaze you then why are you still a 'testy' dominant?

So stop being a hypocrite and dishing ot out to others.? wtf?


I am only addressing this part. The whole post, and all the rest of it... is not about me.
*I* do not test people, and I do not appreciate being tested. I take people at what tey tel me the are and then get to know them as a person and see where it leads. I do not try and fast forward the learning curve by placing unnatrual tests in the way and seeing how they react.





VampiresLair -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/22/2009 11:06:30 PM)

And as far as the relationship that I was addressing... I do not believe they should be together nor do I think either of them can handle a poly one. I never said I did. Just that the situation they are in is coming from a wounded pride on account of a test rather than a sincere interest in the pursuit. I feel awful for any girl getting into the relationship at this point because I am frankly shocked it has not blown itself to smithereens yet. I in no way, shape or form agree with what is going on there. Actually, I have told the Dom that he is asking for more trouble than he wil be fixing by putting them both in this place. He is stubborn and hurt now and continuing on his path.

My thoughts, though, were prompted by the situaton but have been a long standing issue with me. I do nt abide with testing, nor do I take part in it. I dont see how it can be helpful when it is not a natural occurnace in the relationship, but an artificial scenario constructed in order to get a reaction in one way or another. In a more natural situation, said reaction might be far different.

DV





Prinsexx -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 1:03:23 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: VampiresLair

quote:

ORIGINAL: Prinsexx

I'm amazed by your entire approach. If it never ceases to amaze you then why are you still a 'testy' dominant?

So stop being a hypocrite and dishing ot out to others.? wtf?


I am only addressing this part. The whole post, and all the rest of it... is not about me.
*I* do not test people, and I do not appreciate being tested. I take people at what tey tel me the are and then get to know them as a person and see where it leads. I do not try and fast forward the learning curve by placing unnatrual tests in the way and seeing how they react.



Then I am even more amazed. Why would you take so much time to post about something not about you? Where are your theoroies about testing from then? La La Land?
You do seem to be wanting to make a point about submissives though.

And since you say you are making that point entirely outside of your experience your whole claims to understand being a dominant and indeed being a master seem spurious.

OR having seen the tone of the responses are you now trying to wriggle off the hook, reticent about the fact that you test your submissives anyway.

Someone who needs to test the water is someone who is insecure about their abilities to cross it. In my experience.




MaamJay -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 1:41:46 AM)

Prinsexx you are way off beam here, your earlier post made it clear you thought the OP was about Dominants testing submissives, when in fact it wasn't, it was about a submissive testing her Dominant. DV made it abundantly clear then and has clarified it further since, that SHE is not involved in this scenario one bit and SHE is against being a Dominant who tests a submissive AND Her submissive, Fox, isn't one who would test Her either. They have arrived at their D/s through the natural trials of everyday life, and through that he has come to know Her as Dominant and She knows him to be submissive to Her. Her post was however saying that any sub who chooses to set up an artificial test for their Dominant shouldn't be surprised (nor should whinge or bitch) at the outcome. It was really a general post about that issue, which happened to have been triggered off by someone else's drama. That was the basis on which She posted, and that is perfectly reasonable. Lots of posts here are general and not personal.  

While I agree that the Dominant person in the original scenario is nutso for thinking of bringing in another sub, I got the impression from the OP that the sub in question has a history of being bratty and deliberately provoking and testing her Master. And I stand by My earlier post, and alongside others such as LadyPact in saying that I wouldn't approve of a sub deliberately setting up secret little tests for Me. I don't expect someone to submit all blindly, I see submission as something that is gradually yielded over time, though obviously, there has to be a certain preparedness to submit some things to start with. There's no need to be sneaky ... a sub will be experiencing My daily Dominance ... the sub and I will have talked extensively before they choose to become My sub about My style of Dominance and any time they are unsure ... speak up! Ask questions. Challenge My decision openly if you feel you must. No need for all the drama! If a sub can't be sure of My Dominance as We go through the time of consideration ... then they are not a good fit and shouldn't be with Me. Just as I should be able to become sure of their submission to Me during that time also. And I won't be setting up any sneaky little tests for them either. It's not My style.

Maam Jay aka violet[A]




Phoenixpower -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 12:21:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BKSir

Ugh, I hate when they test.  Why do they do that? 


IMO because it gives security...because for me, what I need is that someone means what he says and does what he says...and though I am not someone who is a big tester, I do have my moments where I check them out when I have my stubborn moments or my moments where I can't be bothered...how a current involvement tends to name me now being a "slacker" (thankfully he also supplied me the meaning of that word during a chat...and *phew* I have to admit it does fit a fair bit). However, if I don't find out where the boundaries are how am I supposed to know that they are real? Everyone can pretend to be dominant if I just follow blindly...but to see how he responds shows me how he reacts with his response and gives me more confidence in him being trustworthy...because what is if something serious is going to happen and I never found out how he reacts in situations he does not like??? He might just run away like a scary cat or over-react...therefore, no thanks, I prefer to test the best, even if that means that he aims to put my test to a rest...then at least I know he is what he is claiming to be and can feel safe...(at least that's how I figured it out for myself.) - though I am not someone who whinges afterwards...because even when I dislike a consequence then I am still fine to accept that I might have pushed a bit too hard and are likely to avoid pushing again [8|]

therefore i join the queue of Ironitulstahp:

quote:

 ...but i have felt myself subconsciously testing in the past


and have to disagree Prinsexx, who says:

quote:

  Someone who needs to test the water is someone who is insecure about their abilities to cross it.


because I am fully aware about my skills and happy to supply them, if I would be insecure about "the water"...well, then I would not cross it in the first place...for me it's really about ensuring that my prospective Dom is man enough to handle me and if he is a person where I get the impression to be safe if we would have to face troubles in whatever form. If he runs off or overreacts heavily in whatever way (though I am unlikely to push as hard as in that example)...well, then we simply aren't a match, and therefore both safed our time [:)]




AquaticSub -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 2:06:05 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Prinsexx

Then I am even more amazed. Why would you take so much time to post about something not about you? Where are your theoroies about testing from then? La La Land?
You do seem to be wanting to make a point about submissives though.


Are we supposed to be so self-focused that we can only post about ourselves? You are way off your mark here. It seems to me like you've got an issue with the poster, not the post.




LaTigresse -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 2:14:51 PM)

Agreed.




Jeptha -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 2:42:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: antipode

I've found that a good proportion of women that think they are subs have in fact a controlling personality, and "top from the bottom". You need to test for that.

I may have my own version of this, but I don't think of it as "testing"; just observing what her attitudes about various things are - and then trying to check reality v. words (and trying to consider whatever slant our respective expectations or hopes may add to things.)
I think it's more observation and general information gathering than testing.




LovingMistress45 -> RE: Dont be surprised! (3/23/2009 8:22:08 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Prinsexx

quote:

ORIGINAL: VampiresLair

quote:

ORIGINAL: Prinsexx

I'm amazed by your entire approach. If it never ceases to amaze you then why are you still a 'testy' dominant?

So stop being a hypocrite and dishing ot out to others.? wtf?


I am only addressing this part. The whole post, and all the rest of it... is not about me.
*I* do not test people, and I do not appreciate being tested. I take people at what tey tel me the are and then get to know them as a person and see where it leads. I do not try and fast forward the learning curve by placing unnatrual tests in the way and seeing how they react.



Then I am even more amazed. Why would you take so much time to post about something not about you? Where are your theoroies about testing from then? La La Land?
You do seem to be wanting to make a point about submissives though.

And since you say you are making that point entirely outside of your experience your whole claims to understand being a dominant and indeed being a master seem spurious.

OR having seen the tone of the responses are you now trying to wriggle off the hook, reticent about the fact that you test your submissives anyway.

Someone who needs to test the water is someone who is insecure about their abilities to cross it. In my experience.



I am amazed that you can not understand the starting post of this thread.  Everyone else has been able to. Your put downs and rudeness are unwarranted. I don't know DV but have read enough of her post to believe she is exactly what she claims to be and has a good understanding of the lifestyle.  I can't say the same about you.




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125