Sanity -> RE: Should Government Subsidize The News? (5/10/2009 11:58:00 AM)
|
That internal report is just as damning, Politesub53. A few excerpts: quote:
Suddenly the liberal consensus has discovered there’s a bit of a problem about this cultural diversity business. So these people who think that they are the truthful middle ground, actually a lot of the time they’re all rushing one way on the ship, then they’re all rushing the other way on the ship. They think that other people are the people with different views, and they’re the ones that have always got it right. Dorothy Byrne, Head of News and Current Affairs, Channel 4 quote:
‘It’s a bit like walking into a Sunday meeting of the Flat Earth Society’, said The Daily Telegraph’s Jeff Randall about his time as Business Editor of the BBC. ‘As they discuss great issues of the day, they discuss them from the point of view that the earth is flat. If someone says, “No, no, no, the earth is round!”, they think this person is an extremist. That’s what it’s like for someone with my right-of-centre views working inside the BBC.’ quote:
Janet Daley, also of The Daily Telegraph, said it was not a systematic political conspiracy to impose party political bias, but ‘something more insidious: a kind of corporate conformity – the uncritical acceptance of smug, consensual, received opinion accompanied by a journalistic credulousness’. quote:
Georgina Born (Cambridge University), whose in-depth study of the BBC was published under the title Uncertain Vision, said it was ‘a highly self-critical organisation’ with ongoing editorial debates that she had witnessed. ‘On the other hand, it has an extraordinary defensiveness, extraordinary arrogance and a great deal of complacency.’ What worried her was that ‘banging on about enlightenment values can become a cloak for an intellectual mono- culture within the BBC’. quote:
Justin Webb, the BBC’s Washington correspondent, said the BBC and other broadcasters failed to ask serious questions about why the USA is ‘as successful as it is, why the system it invented works. And, in the tone of what we say about America, we have a tendency to scorn and deride. We don’t give America any kind of moral weight in our broadcasts.’ When Webb was asked about ‘a casual anti-Americanism’, he said he consciously tried to redress it. quote:
Andrew Marr, former Political Editor, said that the BBC is ‘a publicly-funded urban organisation with an abnormally large proportion of younger people, of people in ethnic minorities and almost certainly of gay people’ compared with the population at large.’ All this, he said, ‘creates an innate liberal bias inside the BBC’. quote:
Michael Buerk said he believed the problem lay with an insufficiently diverse employment policy. ‘Most of the people working for the BBC are middle-class, well-educated, young metropolitan people.’ He said that, although the BBC had made great efforts to widen ethnic and gender diversity, ‘the actual intake of those people has narrowed quite appreciably in terms of age, social category, and education’. Roger Mosey, Director of Sport, thought that ‘the BBC has in the past been too closed to a wide range of views and we’ve had too narrow an agenda. And I have some sympathies with what Janet Daley says generally about a liberal/pinko agenda at times.’ And isn't asking the admittedly Liberal BBC to police itself a lot like asking, say, Rush Limbaugh to police his own radio show for bias? Having government pay all of Rush Limbaugh's expenses on top of that, while granting him almost a monopoly over the airwaves... quote:
ORIGINAL: Politesub53 Sanity, the link Phil used refers to an article by the Times. All this is is the Times guessing what the report may say. The BBC refutes the claim it is biased, its own report doesnt say the BBC is biased either. You cant claim something is true, ie "The BBC admits bias" When there is no evidence they have said this themselves. If you have such a link, or can find one, I would welcome it and admit I am wrong. Here is the actual report referred to. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/bsp/hi/pdfs/18_06_07impartialitybbc.pdf
|
|
|
|