RE: Slave VS. Submissive (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


Level -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/27/2009 4:03:26 AM)

quote:

People do take a lot of liberties with terms.


I agree.




Andalusite -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/27/2009 7:24:07 AM)

Giraffe vs. human isn't a very good analogy, since there isn't a definite complete difference that everyone can agree on. It's more like pony vs. horse. In most contexts, a pony is under 58" at the top of the shoulder, but individuals of some breeds are still considered ponies even if they are over that size, and horses can be smaller than that if they are other breeds. Some people call really big horses "ponies" as an affectionate nickname, even though they clearly don't qualify based on height. Obviously, the line between submissive and slave is far more fuzzy - there isn't a national organisation which sets standards!

If someone is unattached and seeking, I think it's best for them to use the submissive orientation label, then explain that they have been a slave/want to be one, since I do think of that more as a relationship title with respect to a specific person. I don't get bent out of shape if any singles want to use it, though.

supportourtroops, it sounds like for those specific Dominants, you meet their criteria for being a slave. Before I became owned, I asked my Master what the distinction was in *his* opinion, how his expectations differed for a submissive compared to a slave, etc. Getting more general views isn't going to help you in a specific relationship, you need to be able to get on the same page and be as certain as possible that you're compatible with that specific person!





beltainefaerie -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/27/2009 11:45:28 AM)

I consider myself a slave to Master, though he and I have a tendency to use the terms somewhat interchangeably.  To me there is a permanence associate with the word slave, which I enjoy.  I also think it is fairly appropriate, since my limits are basically his and I can't think of anything he actually would ask me to do that I would not do for him.




sub2pleaseyou88 -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 4:30:33 AM)





I found this on the web and it is the easiest way that I found to explain the differences, However you can always use the title of slave to enhance your excitement.
 
If any of the following apply to you, you are just not yet ready for a life of real slavery:


  • I have set my own "limits", like any "normal" person should and they must be respected!
  • I don't want my hard earned career experience/education to just go to waste; I need an Owner who will allow me to keep my career/get a career in my chosen profession/let me stay in school.
  • I have dependants (children, relatives, et cetera) that I cannot abandon.
  • I don't want to give up any of my friends or risk losing contact with my family.
  • I have a "vanilla" interest (or two, or more) that I simply will not give up.
  • I would never allow my Owner to share me with someone else.
  • I would never be willing to share my Owner with anyone else, after all - they know I am the jealous type; I would insist on being my Owner's only slave!
  • It's not like it's 'real' slavery anyway, you know: it's more like 'role-playing'; isn't it?
  • I am [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here] and I am only interested in an Owner who is [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here].
  • I am an "age-play slave"/"gang-bang slave" and I am only interested in Owners who are couples/groups.
  • I am an "[insert: animal] slave" and I am only interested in Owners who have farms/barns.
  • I am a "non-BDSM slave" and I do not want any Owners who practice/enjoy any type or variety of BDSM.
  • I have rights, you know, just like everyone else; and I would never give any of my rights up!




RCdc -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 4:39:16 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sub2pleaseyou88





I found this on the web and it is the easiest way that I found to explain the differences, However you can always use the title of slave to enhance your excitement.
 
If any of the following apply to you, you are just not yet ready for a life of real slavery:
  • I have set my own "limits", like any "normal" person should and they must be respected!
  • I don't want my hard earned career experience/education to just go to waste; I need an Owner who will allow me to keep my career/get a career in my chosen profession/let me stay in school.
  • I have dependants (children, relatives, et cetera) that I cannot abandon.
  • I don't want to give up any of my friends or risk losing contact with my family.
  • I have a "vanilla" interest (or two, or more) that I simply will not give up.
  • I would never allow my Owner to share me with someone else.
  • I would never be willing to share my Owner with anyone else, after all - they know I am the jealous type; I would insist on being my Owner's only slave!
  • It's not like it's 'real' slavery anyway, you know: it's more like 'role-playing'; isn't it?
  • I am [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here] and I am only interested in an Owner who is [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here].
  • I am an "age-play slave"/"gang-bang slave" and I am only interested in Owners who are couples/groups.
  • I am an "[insert: animal] slave" and I am only interested in Owners who have farms/barns.
  • I am a "non-BDSM slave" and I do not want any Owners who practice/enjoy any type or variety of BDSM.
  • I have rights, you know, just like everyone else; and I would never give any of my rights up!




What total trash.
I have never read so much codswhollop in my life that determines who is ready or not.!

the.dark.




sirsholly -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 4:43:50 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sub2pleaseyou88





I found this on the web and it is the easiest way that I found to explain the differences, However you can always use the title of slave to enhance your excitement.
 
If any of the following apply to you, you are just not yet ready for a life of real slavery:
  • I have set my own "limits", like any "normal" person should and they must be respected!
  • I don't want my hard earned career experience/education to just go to waste; I need an Owner who will allow me to keep my career/get a career in my chosen profession/let me stay in school.
  • I have dependants (children, relatives, et cetera) that I cannot abandon.
  • I don't want to give up any of my friends or risk losing contact with my family.
  • I have a "vanilla" interest (or two, or more) that I simply will not give up.
  • I would never allow my Owner to share me with someone else.
  • I would never be willing to share my Owner with anyone else, after all - they know I am the jealous type; I would insist on being my Owner's only slave!
  • It's not like it's 'real' slavery anyway, you know: it's more like 'role-playing'; isn't it?
  • I am [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here] and I am only interested in an Owner who is [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here].
  • I am an "age-play slave"/"gang-bang slave" and I am only interested in Owners who are couples/groups.
  • I am an "[insert: animal] slave" and I am only interested in Owners who have farms/barns.
  • I am a "non-BDSM slave" and I do not want any Owners who practice/enjoy any type or variety of BDSM.
  • I have rights, you know, just like everyone else; and I would never give any of my rights up!

you make it sound like slavery is something everyone aspires to, and it is not.

Most of these statements are laughable and total BS[8|]




ncbabe -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 5:55:29 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sub2pleaseyou88





I found this on the web and it is the easiest way that I found to explain the differences, However you can always use the title of slave to enhance your excitement.

If any of the following apply to you, you are just not yet ready for a life of real slavery:



Define 'real slavery'.




agirl -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 7:05:33 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sub2pleaseyou88





I found this on the web and it is the easiest way that I found to explain the differences, However you can always use the title of slave to enhance your excitement.
 
If any of the following apply to you, you are just not yet ready for a life of real slavery:
  • I have set my own "limits", like any "normal" person should and they must be respected!
  • I don't want my hard earned career experience/education to just go to waste; I need an Owner who will allow me to keep my career/get a career in my chosen profession/let me stay in school.
  • I have dependants (children, relatives, et cetera) that I cannot abandon.
  • I don't want to give up any of my friends or risk losing contact with my family.
  • I have a "vanilla" interest (or two, or more) that I simply will not give up.
  • I would never allow my Owner to share me with someone else.
  • I would never be willing to share my Owner with anyone else, after all - they know I am the jealous type; I would insist on being my Owner's only slave!
  • It's not like it's 'real' slavery anyway, you know: it's more like 'role-playing'; isn't it?
  • I am [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here] and I am only interested in an Owner who is [insert: race/creed/gender/sexual preference here].
  • I am an "age-play slave"/"gang-bang slave" and I am only interested in Owners who are couples/groups.
  • I am an "[insert: animal] slave" and I am only interested in Owners who have farms/barns.
  • I am a "non-BDSM slave" and I do not want any Owners who practice/enjoy any type or variety of BDSM.
  • I have rights, you know, just like everyone else; and I would never give any of my rights up!



 That's really a lot of silliness.  But you've certainly determined what *real slavery* is for yourself.

If it'd ever been presented to me in that way, I'd have wandered away bored stupider than I aready am.

agirl




porcelaine -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 7:13:34 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sub2pleaseyou88

I found this on the web and it is the easiest way that I found to explain the differences, However you can always use the title of slave to enhance your excitement.
 
If any of the following apply to you, you are just not yet ready for a life of real slavery:


this was truly entertaining. [:D]

porcelaine




leadership527 -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 10:09:42 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: porcelaine
this was truly entertaining. [:D]
Heh, actually, if you strip out all the one-true-wayism I mostly like what's left.




eroticinnocence -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 4:38:23 PM)

I was always under the impression that slave does anything that the Dom wants, no ifs ands or buts and that the submissive does follow what the Dom says but can also stop the session if she is really uncomfortable with it.




MarcEsadrian -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 6:45:10 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: supportourtroops

What do you consider to be a slave VS. a submissive?


Submissive: Surrendered

Slave: Completely surrendered


quote:

ORIGINAL: supportourtroops
I have always called and considered myself a submissive as I have limits. The DOMs I meet always tell me I'm a slave to the bone. I've asked and their comments are, "I know a slave when I see one, and, you have slave written all over you"


I suppose it's neat to say such things for their effect, but I chalk that up mostly to one part rhetorical analysis and one part simply wishful thinking.




CaringandReal -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 7:06:40 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: sravaka

wonderful, enlighting post, Caring  (as always).....

quote:

There are great many rewards to being a slave, in my opinion. But they are often not the ones people without experience in this role imagine that they are.


I wonder if you'd be willing to elaborate on this?  What do you see as the rewards?  Did your own sense of them come to differ with experience, vs. what you may have expected initially?




Hi, thanks for the compliment. It's undeserved, but hey, a starving man isn't picky. :D You're quite observant to notice what's not there, what I purposefully left out, in fact. I've noticed you doing that before. You see the center(s) of things.

I'll talk about a few of what I see as the rewards but let me tackle the second question first. I didn't have a sense of "rewards" or a concept of rewards initially. I just thought that being a slave would be the most thrilling and rewarding way I could possibly live. That hasn't changed. What I've learned from experience has just filled in the details of this expectation, sometimes in unexpected ways! But the thing is, I don't know what or whether any of these details will specifically happen to me or when they will happen, if they do at all. It all... depends! :)

So about those rewards...

The ones I was thinking of are not the standard rewards, or what I think of as the standard rewards, but I might as well start out with a few of those. But even these often-spoke-about rewards don't happen to every one. Relationships differ.

1. The feeling of security and safety and of being accepted, appreciated, even loved unconditionally. Sometimes this is described as feeling contained, or as being a part of your owner. There's safety in imprisonment, and people who willingly become slaves tend to like that feeling a lot. But this is something given to you by your master, and not all masters give this.
2. The feeling that you're in the right place, that you're home, that you are exactly where you belong. This has nothing to do with how your partner makes you feel, it's more of an internal recognition that you're finally doing what you've really needed to do your entire life. A vocation fulfilled. Or you feel like you fit, finally.
3. The relief from the burden of decision-making. The amount of this relief you're given depends on your owner, obviously. And also obviously not all see decision-making as a burden, but those craving slavery tend to, more often than not. With some masters, this is combined with infantalism at some level or age-play, if you prefer. Some of us do get that second childhood...long before we become senile.
4. The great joys involved in pleasing someone, making their lives lighter and easier, giving to them, being in service.
5. Almost nobody mentions this one, but it's the one I'm always thinking about. The. Steaming. Hot. Sick. Perverted. Sex. :p


Ok, now for some of the ones I was referring to in my other post. Some of these are kind of freaky. That's why I hesitated to directly speak of them earlier. And like I said, they don't happen to every person who becomes a slave, as they depend a lot on the tastes of whoever ends up owning you.

1. The joys of humility, of humbleness, of being small, of being brought low, of being shown, forcibly if necessary, that you are NOT the center of the universe (everybody needs to have this demonstrated to them before they'll do more than pay lipservice to it), that you shalt not have other gods before Him or Her, and that includes that nasty and intrusive little pair of false deities named Ego and Pride (oh yeah, and their little niece with the hot boot-tay, Vanity). The ways that this is shown to you can be extermely rewarding, if you're open to the experience and willing to change. Being brought low isn't what most people would describe as "pleasant" or "easy" but this can be, in my experience anyway, incredibly rewarding.
2. The intensity involved with of doing things that are very hard or very challenging to you. If you are careful to seek out a master who is closely compatible to your world view, who wants for you what you want for you, who agrees with you about what you won't do, you will not have much of an opportunity to experience this. While I do not personally seek out a challenging master, my attitude is that if I see clearly that a dominant is capable of controlling me (something that in my experience is both rare and valuable), then to hell with the compatibilities of our world views. I'll lose my world view and assume his. Sometimes a large sacrifice is required in life to gain a great or rare prize, but losing one's world view is not exactly that, to me. It's actually an unburdening, like cleaning out your house and getting rid of years of accumulated junk. It's refreshing! Back to the hard things for a minute. They hurt. If they didn't they wouldn't be hard. But there is a satisfaction in doing them anyway, and an even greater satisfaction in knowing that you're doing them for someone else. Sacrificing yourself for another is the best. One of the most sublime human experiences you can experience and in fact, I am hard pressed to think of anything better except for The. Steaming. Hot. Sick. Perverted. Sex. Of course. :-p
3. Learning patience. People think they know how to be patient...until that concept is tried. And tried. And tried again, by circumstance, by the intentions of your Lord or Lady, or by both. You learn so much about yourself when you must be patient beyond anything you'd ever considered possible in this area before.
4. Hurt, emotional. The typical pattern: you get hurt. You feel misunderstood, unappreciated, ignored, treated badly. Self-pity. Anger at the other. Lashing out or trying to get them to change. Rinse and repeat. A potential new pattern, one that only happens if you're very tightly controlled, otherwise the correct context doesn't exist for this to emerge: You get hurt. You accept it as a "gift" from your owner because you percieve everything in your world, in your life, as coming from him. The hurt starts to transform. It still hurts, but because it comes from Him or Her, it is special, good, sacred almost, a lesson, something they want you to feel or something you undergo in your desire to understand them, to serve them better.
5. This next is a piquant spice, and it's also quite a rare one. But it does get sprinkled upon you prior to being devoured, upon occasion. I like this one because I am an adventurous sort, I've always loved mental exploration, even when it was quite terrifying and painful. I always like to know what's around that next bend (yes, I meant to put it that way). And sometimes curiousity does kill the cat. ;) Some want you to lose your mind for them. Not go insane, although some might argue that a master-slave relationship is a mutually imposed conspiracy of insanity. I mean lose some of your mental abilities, some of your acuity, maybe temporarily, maybe permanently. Not as an act. For real. How is it done? There are lots of ways, and I don't want to go into them here, as some are considered quite creepy. But it can be an interesting experience. And it doesn't have to be permanent. Unless your owner wants it that way. :)

Ok, I'm tried of writing lists. I'll try freehand for a while.

Different masters have different ideas about what they want to do with their slaves and I think you need to be prepared for anything, because if the person is right for you, you will do as he says. So the "rewards" will differ, depending upon the owner, but it's so hard, in my experience, to find someone who will control you in as extreme a manner as you need, that the nature of the experience becomes a small matter. It looks like present day bdsm submissives who want to be slaves have a great deal of choice in the matter, particularly on a personals site like this one. If you have a halfway attractive profile, hundreds of guys will write you wanting to be your dominant. But you know how it is: out of those hundreds, maybe one or two or if you're very lucky three will strike someone who sincerely wants slavery of being able to be her master. The rest just won't "feel" dominant or dominant enough. So despite all our apparent freedom and ability to pick and choose, it's still very much like being on an auction block. The appearance of choice is an illusion. When someone finally comes along who you know can master you and master you in ways that you need desperately, there's no choice involved at all, unless you're pretty badly torn or conflicted inside. You want him to take you, you try to qualify yourself to him, and you do this naturally, in response to his personality, not because of any HNG tricks or games he's playing with you. You're already bought, signed, sealed, wrapped, and delivered at this point. You might or might not realize it. But when you do, you realize that you've also no choice but to accept everything he wants to do to you. Why? Because he's what you NEED and no other man who has contacted you has even come close to being that. For some female slaves this realization comes instantly; for others it takes time, it needs to "cook."

So you accept him, and with that accept whatever he wants to do with you, whatever he is, no matter how hard or different or difficult all this may be. That acceptance is one of the rewards, and it's one that keeps on giving. It never gets old. No matter how close your master is to your ideal of dominance, he's going to do things that are hard for you to accept. Sometimes they are, objectively, very good things. But if you don't like being pampered or don't feel you deserve to be loved so intensely or don't want to be coddled or even infantalized in some ways, even these can be very hard to accept. Other times, if he is a different type of master, they are different things, colder, harsher things that fill you with despair. Either way, what you accept is that things are no longer your way anymore, they are his, and you accept what he gives you, no matter how much you do not want it. And you try to accept it with good grace and a big dose of humility. And you grow to like these things that are initially so hard to accept. It helps to remember how alien and isolated from your core you felt before you met him. Each time you accept something that, for whatever reason, is hard for you to accept, hard to swallow, hard to incorporate, you feel rewarded inside. You reward yourself.





CaringandReal -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 7:19:44 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: leadership527

I stand corrected on all counts.


Another brilliant and deeply thought out response. I'm so impressed. Sigh.

Why are you so angry so much lately and so miltantly anti-master-slave? If it's too personal don't answer, but it's pretty offensive and grating to hear you constantly attacking a sort of relationship I've loved and thrived in for many years. (shrug) I don't grasp what's going on with you.




CaringandReal -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 7:30:30 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Padriag

quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

(slave-hopeful? fledgling slave? near-slave?soon-to-be-slave?)

I was going to go with proto-slave myself.  [;)]


:D

They need to award those as rare pets in mmorpgs.




NihilusZero -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 8:24:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CaringandReal


quote:

ORIGINAL: Padriag

quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

(slave-hopeful? fledgling slave? near-slave?soon-to-be-slave?)

I was going to go with proto-slave myself.  [;)]


:D

They need to award those as rare pets in mmorpgs.

15 Points for the suggestion and just the mention of mmorpgs. [:D]




HouseDom -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 8:57:52 PM)

OK...I'm sure this has been said before in the last 5 pages of posts that I have no intention of reading all the way through.  A submissive is one who submits.  Maybe not all the time, maybe not every day, and maybe not all the way (or in all ways).  They submit only as much as they are comfortable submitting in certain ways (not always sexual).  A slave, on the other hand, implies (to my mind) a more permanent and deeper state of submission.  Slaves give up significantly more power when they submit and for substantially longer periods. 

Then again, I think we all know that these are just signposts at certain points on a VERY broad spectrum of preferences and behaviors as well as people who enjoy both ends of the spectrum at different times (switches).

Relatedly, and to hijack the thread just a little bit at the risk of adding another 5 page of posts:  Why is there only 1 word for dominant (yes, I realize there are doms and dommes)?  There is certainly an equally wide variety of dominant styles and philosophies running around out there as well.  Yet, I have only 1 option to select on my profile here.  Am I sadistic, a daddy dom, a humiliator, a micromanager type, a pet owner, whore master?  Probably a little of all of them at different times, but I don't get to click the box I gravitate to most-just Dominant.  Instead, I have to proclaim that I am a dom and then spend a few paragraphs explaining what that means to me..  There are lots of unofficial dom types out there but I think there is an unfortunate dearth of broadly understood/accepted terms to classify Doms. 




porcelaine -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/28/2009 9:17:52 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CaringandReal

2. The feeling that you're in the right place, that you're home, that you are exactly where you belong. This has nothing to do with how your partner makes you feel, it's more of an internal recognition that you're finally doing what you've really needed to do your entire life. A vocation fulfilled. Or you feel like you fit, finally.


other things apply but this one speaks loudest. i even use the same terminology - Home.

quote:

1. The joys of humility, of humbleness, of being small, of being brought low, of being shown, forcibly if necessary, that you are NOT the center of the universe (everybody needs to have this demonstrated to them before they'll do more than pay lipservice to it), that you shalt not have other gods before Him or Her, and that includes that nasty and intrusive little pair of false deities named Ego and Pride (oh yeah, and their little niece with the hot boot-tay, Vanity). The ways that this is shown to you can be extermely rewarding, if you're open to the experience and willing to change. Being brought low isn't what most people would describe as "pleasant" or "easy" but this can be, in my experience anyway, incredibly rewarding.


i'll grin and admit i've been guilty of having a smidge of ego on occasion. [;)]

quote:

2. The intensity involved with of doing things that are very hard or very challenging to you. If you are careful to seek out a master who is closely compatible to your world view, who wants for you what you want for you, who agrees with you about what you won't do, you will not have much of an opportunity to experience this. While I do not personally seek out a challenging master, my attitude is that if I see clearly that a dominant is capable of controlling me (something that in my experience is both rare and valuable), then to hell with the compatibilities of our world views.


i love the challenge. this is one of the big musts for me. i need someone that is hard, otherwise i feel a disconnection of sorts. it is hard to explain but the best word i can attribute to the feeling is bleh. i think is has a lot to do with my internal drive and the desire to have someone that pushes me. because i'm going to do the same as well.

porcelaine






CaringandReal -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/29/2009 5:07:12 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

quote:

ORIGINAL: CaringandReal


quote:

ORIGINAL: Padriag

quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

(slave-hopeful? fledgling slave? near-slave?soon-to-be-slave?)

I was going to go with proto-slave myself.  [;)]


:D

They need to award those as rare pets in mmorpgs.

15 Points for the suggestion and just the mention of mmorpgs. [:D]




Thanks! (preens) I won't ruin it then by saying "Everquest" in the next breath.

...

oops.




CaringandReal -> RE: Slave VS. Submissive (10/29/2009 5:20:48 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: porcelaine

other things apply but this one speaks loudest. i even use the same terminology - Home.



Yeah, home is ... very nice.

quote:



i'll grin and admit i've been guilty of having a smidge of ego on occasion. [;)]



Eh. Talented people do. It goes with the territory, I think. ;)

I really have a fetish for having my ego shattered in non-destructive ways these days. It's like an addictive drug. The humility one is my favorite thing to experience in a bdsm relationship.

quote:

2. The intensity involved with of doing things that are very hard or very challenging to you. If you are careful to seek out a master who is closely compatible to your world view, who wants for you what you want for you, who agrees with you about what you won't do, you will not have much of an opportunity to experience this. While I do not personally seek out a challenging master, my attitude is that if I see clearly that a dominant is capable of controlling me (something that in my experience is both rare and valuable), then to hell with the compatibilities of our world views.


i love the challenge. this is one of the big musts for me. i need someone that is hard, otherwise i feel a disconnection of sorts. it is hard to explain but the best word i can attribute to the feeling is bleh. i think is has a lot to do with my internal drive and the desire to have someone that pushes me. because i'm going to do the same as well.



Nods. That makes sense for someone who likes or loves achivement...and who is also good at it! I am not very driven, in fact I have big fears of failure about everything, so the challenging item, above, is often very challenging to me. What I like about that sort of dominant is that I am very curious and challenges or a challenging personality certainly do keep things "interesting."




Page: <<   < prev  2 3 4 [5] 6   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875