RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


rulemylife -> RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (2/2/2010 3:00:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Thadius

See that is where it becomes confusing to me. If I remember correctly, the Dems took control of the House in the 2006 mid-term elections, with Pelosi becoming Speaker in Jan '07. I think they got control of the Senate right around that time as well. So we are looking at 4 years of a Dem controlled congress (both houses), they had a super-majority for the last year, with a Dem president, and they couldn't accomplish their goals? If their promises were even close to what most folks wanted, it would have been done in the first 6 months of President Obama's term. Something is going on other than the Repubs trying to roadblock every bill.

Know what I mean?


What's going on is you have different factions within the Democratic party.

The so-called super-majority was by one vote, which is now lost.

The Democrats have liberal, moderate, and conservative factions which often don't reach agreement, while the Republicans put extraordinary political pressure on their members to tow the party line. 

The health care vote is a pure example of that, one lone member of the House was the only Republican in Congress to vote for either bill.

And you are very well aware of this, so why are you putting forth this disingenuous
argument?   




Thadius -> RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (2/2/2010 3:19:19 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: rulemylife

quote:

ORIGINAL: Thadius

See that is where it becomes confusing to me. If I remember correctly, the Dems took control of the House in the 2006 mid-term elections, with Pelosi becoming Speaker in Jan '07. I think they got control of the Senate right around that time as well. So we are looking at 4 years of a Dem controlled congress (both houses), they had a super-majority for the last year, with a Dem president, and they couldn't accomplish their goals? If their promises were even close to what most folks wanted, it would have been done in the first 6 months of President Obama's term. Something is going on other than the Repubs trying to roadblock every bill.

Know what I mean?


What's going on is you have different factions within the Democratic party.

The so-called super-majority was by one vote, which is now lost.

The Democrats have liberal, moderate, and conservative factions which often don't reach agreement, while the Republicans put extraordinary political pressure on their members to tow the party line. 

The health care vote is a pure example of that, one lone member of the House was the only Republican in Congress to vote for either bill.

And you are very well aware of this, so why are you putting forth this disingenuous
argument?   


Disengenuous? The failure to pass these promised bills lays squarely at the feet of the Dem leadership. They could have easily gotten something passed that would have even got some Repub support. Perhaps, if the promises made about transparency and compromise were fulfilled, or at the very least attempted to, alot more could and would have been accomplished (including a much higher approval rating).

Let's also not act like the assumption of power just occured in this last election. The Dems have had control of both houses of congress since the '06 mid-terms. Unfortunately, or fortunately depending on how you look at it, the oppurtunity to fundamentally change the nation has been squandered.




rulemylife -> RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (2/2/2010 3:53:16 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Thadius


Disengenuous? The failure to pass these promised bills lays squarely at the feet of the Dem leadership. They could have easily gotten something passed that would have even got some Repub support. Perhaps, if the promises made about transparency and compromise were fulfilled, or at the very least attempted to, alot more could and would have been accomplished (including a much higher approval rating).

Let's also not act like the assumption of power just occured in this last election. The Dems have had control of both houses of congress since the '06 mid-terms. Unfortunately, or fortunately depending on how you look at it, the oppurtunity to fundamentally change the nation has been squandered.


Then let me ask again about my original point.

Can you honestly make a case that there has been any spirit of cooperation or sense of bi-partisanship from the Republican party?


President Obama Addresses The Republican Retreat (Transcript)




Thadius -> RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (2/2/2010 4:01:13 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: rulemylife

quote:

ORIGINAL: Thadius


Disengenuous? The failure to pass these promised bills lays squarely at the feet of the Dem leadership. They could have easily gotten something passed that would have even got some Repub support. Perhaps, if the promises made about transparency and compromise were fulfilled, or at the very least attempted to, alot more could and would have been accomplished (including a much higher approval rating).

Let's also not act like the assumption of power just occured in this last election. The Dems have had control of both houses of congress since the '06 mid-terms. Unfortunately, or fortunately depending on how you look at it, the oppurtunity to fundamentally change the nation has been squandered.


Then let me ask again about my original point.

Can you honestly make a case that there has been any spirit of cooperation or sense of bi-partisanship from the Republican party?


President Obama Addresses The Republican Retreat (Transcript0



If you are asking me to defend the Repubs... I guess that will go undone. I would suggest that there hasn't been much cooperation from either side of the aisle. I do know that the Repubs did try to introduce a few alternative bills to various Dem bills that could have been a good place to start for some sort of compromise.

I bet if Pelosi or Reid would have thrown in some sort of tort reform in their health care bills they could have brought over quite a few Repubs.

Unless by bipartisan you mean, the minority needs to bend over and take whatever is shoved in, with a smile.

I would suggest that the question (argument) you are making is a bit on the disingenuous side, no?




DomImus -> RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (2/2/2010 4:10:51 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Archer
The Democrats had the votes but couldn't even convince their own members without giving away huge PORK BRIBES to vote for their own party's bill.


That was their downfall. Instead of sticking together and getting something in motion that they could build upon they got a little greedy, or at least some of them did. I don't think it was so much that they had to convince some memebrs as it was just those same members seeing an opportunity and taking it. Putting themselves ahead of the party. Then when certain members were promised 'ponies' that didn't sit well with others and it just went downhill from there. It's something that can and does happen on both sides of the aisle but this was an important issue for the Dems and they dropped the ball. Kennedy is probably rolling in his grave in frustration.






DomImus -> RE: A very productive Congress, despite what the approval ratings say (2/2/2010 7:03:08 PM)

I'll add to my previous post that I wonder how it might have changed the discussions, votes and bribe handouts had the Dems even been able to fathom that Scott Brown would win in January. They figured they could bat this thing back and forth between the House and Senate until they came up with something that all the Dems could live with and the hell with the GOP.




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.171875