King of Pop or King of Rock? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Polls and Other Random Stupidity

[Poll]

King of Pop or King of Rock?


Pop
  40% (9)
Rock
  59% (13)


Total Votes : 22
(last vote on : 6/29/2010 11:17:50 AM)
(Poll will run till: -- )


Message


gedienstig -> King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 5:17:12 AM)

Well, with the anniversary of Michael Jackson's passing, a magazine here held a poll whether you prefered the King of Pop Michael Jackson or King of Rock, Elvis Presley.

It turned out to be 50/50, so I was just interested to repeat the poll here, and see how it would turn out here. It's forced choice, so even if you like both , you'd have to choose who fits you best. Chances are of course that you like another band/singer a lot better, but choosing from these two, who gets your preference? If you don't like either, well, then don't vote obviously.

For me it's crystal clear, ever since I was a child, my mother embedded into my mind that Michael Jackson was the best singer and dancer there ever was, and I kinda followed her. Plus I'm sure she had a crush on him, before the operations turned out to be too bad around 2000 or so. With English as my third language I could already sing the words to Heal the World at age 7 or 8 or so without even knowing what they meant.




igor2003 -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 5:27:48 AM)

I'm an old fart that grew up on Elvis. By the time MJ came along music was already taking a turn for the worse. Admittedly, Jacksons music was better than most of what was being played at the time, but in my opinion it doesn't even come close to being in competition with Elvis.




laurell3 -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 5:30:48 AM)

I liked Michael Jackson. I think he was a phenomenal performer. I think his other issues really made him a bit of a creep.

I grew up listening to Elvis. At a time when rock and roll or anything suggestive or progressive was really frowned upon, Elvis paved the way for everyone after him, including MJ.




VirginPotty -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 5:47:53 AM)

Elvis was the King of Rock, MJ was the King of Pop.





windchymes -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 6:40:11 AM)

They both were phenomenally talented, multi-faceted musicians, performers, & entertainers.  I can't "prefer" one over the other, it's like choosing a hot fudge sundae or a butter pecan sundae, whatever I'm in the mood for at that time, lol.

I mean, if I HAD to......it would be Elvis, but only by a tiny margin, and not in any way because I think he was "better" than MJ.  It's just the genre of music I would drift toward.




sappatoti -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 6:41:15 AM)

Elvis's music made much more sense to me whereas Michael's music just seemed like noise. Don't misunderstand me... both were very good at what they did; probably the best in their genres. I'm basing my vote strictly on the music they each wrote, not the artist.

Elvis - 1, Michael - 0




AQuietSimpleMan -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 6:45:52 AM)

Michael had Bubbles

Elvis - 1 / Michael - 1




sappatoti -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 6:58:35 AM)

Elvis had peanut butter and bananas...

Elvis... um... - 1 / Michael - 1




AQuietSimpleMan -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 7:17:20 AM)

Michael had The Sparkley Glove.

Elvis - 1 / Michael - 2




sappatoti -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 7:23:42 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: AQuietSimpleMan

Michael had The Sparkley Glove.

Elvis - 1 / Michael - 2



Elvis had the gyrating pelvis during the time when such public displays were thought to be rude, crude, and obnoxious.

Elvis - 2 / Michael -2




VirginPotty -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 8:16:24 AM)

MJ had the face mask

Elvis -2/ MJ - 3




windchymes -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 8:24:23 AM)

Elvis had Lisa Marie.  Oh wait, so did Michael.  Still a tie. [8|]




VirginPotty -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 8:30:09 AM)

**SNORT**




gedienstig -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 9:26:23 AM)

In Moonwalker MJ transformed into a car, a space ship, a robot and a black man. No Elvis movie could top that, imho.

So

Elvis 2 - MJ 4

quote:


I mean, if I HAD to......it would be Elvis, but only by a tiny margin, and not in any way because I think he was "better" than MJ.  It's just the genre of music I would drift toward.


Well, I think is what it boils down to. Both were revolutionary artists in their own. Elvis revolutionized performance the first time, Michael rode on the upcoming popularity of MTV and revolutionized video clips, and world tour shows. So I don't think you can say one was better than the other (also hard to compare different time periods), just which type of music suits you more.

To me, Michael was the Jesus of our time though. Already famous and destined as a child for greatness, then he gained amazing popularity, used that popularity for a "message of peace", then we turned against the messenger of peace and did a lot of nasty stuff which we might as well not have done to such a nice person, then they die, and after their death, their message all of a sudden springs back to life, and the adversaries once again become the followers.

I discovered this parallel during a shroom trip though, just to explain you the state in which I believed this to be true ;-)




VirginPotty -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 10:03:35 AM)

quote:

In Moonwalker MJ transformed into a car, a space ship, a robot and a black man. No Elvis movie could top that, imho.


Let's not forget the Zombie he turned into in "Thriller"!
PLUS he was "Bad" & a "Smooth Criminal" that had that incredible leeeeeeean! [:D]

Elvis 2 - MJ 8




sappatoti -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 10:48:16 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: VirginPotty

quote:

In Moonwalker MJ transformed into a car, a space ship, a robot and a black man. No Elvis movie could top that, imho.


Let's not forget the Zombie he turned into in "Thriller"!
PLUS he was "Bad" & a "Smooth Criminal" that had that incredible leeeeeeean! [:D]

Elvis 2 - MJ 8


As long as we're going with Michael's filmed attributes, let's not forget about this one... "Captain Eo"...

Elvis -2 / Michael - -2

(Yes, I'm giving -10 points for that waste of celluloid, just mho)

:-D




AQuietSimpleMan -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 10:51:50 AM)

Michael Jackson, Was friends with and inspired by Marcel Marceau, Now depending on how you feel that could be a point either direction.

I think Michael Jackson and Elvis Presley are close but in the end Michael was a better dancer and a better showman.

QSM




Estring -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 10:57:06 AM)

No "King Of Strange" choice? Michael wins that hands down.
Elvis was amazing until he went into movies.




sappatoti -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 11:25:06 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Estring

No "King Of Strange" choice? Michael wins that hands down.
Elvis was amazing until he went into movies.


Good point. I generally don't like Elvis's movies because I thought they were a bit... well... like "Captain Eo," only lower tech. :-D




gedienstig -> RE: King of Pop or King of Rock? (6/28/2010 12:54:28 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: AQuietSimpleMan

Michael Jackson, Was friends with and inspired by Marcel Marceau, Now depending on how you feel that could be a point either direction.

I think Michael Jackson and Elvis Presley are close but in the end Michael was a better dancer and a better showman.

QSM


Weird how you immediately linked him to Marcel. Michael made Marcel one of the most immortal unknown celebrities. For those who don't knnow Marcel Marceau, he was the mime player that "invented" the moonwalk.




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875