RE: Question for Sadomasochists (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


Ligeia72 -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:30:41 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: laurell3

Yes, you are in fact a card carrying sadist Jeff. Thank god.

I am a masochist. I do not desire fluffy erotic pain (although it's good as a warm up). I desire real pain that is painful. The misnomer that all masochists can convert all pain to erotic pain and are writhing with desire is just that, a misnomer and myth. It hurts. It will eventually stimulate me to the point of orgasm, but that state is not continual by any means. Nonetheless it is what I desire. It is what he desires as well. We are not talking about heightened sensation, we are talking about pain. Mentally, I do enjoy it, physically, not as much. However, the idea that to be a masochist or sadist there is a requirement of fear or enduring, is silly. I don't feel fear. To an extent I may physically endure the pain, mentally I am embracing it. That's not to say it doesn't hurt, it does. I don't have the mental responses to it of fight or flight others would have though.

My perfect companion is a sadist. Not because the myth of conversion is true, but because nonsadists would have a difficult time with the actual pain being inflicted. I am also service oriented and submissive. To the extent the pain becomes really challenging, my focus is HIM and his pleasure. I do NOT want someone to do this ONLY for me, quite the contrary, I am their instrument to express their sadistic desires, I would not play with someone that was merely being a service top (no I am not judging them, merely stating my preference..I am very much a service top with a twist when I switch), nothing is more unattractive or undesirable to me. I enjoy being challenged, I enjoy being pushed, even if in the moment I am not liking it. Sexual arousal is a good companion for him to allow me to take more pain. That doesn't come close to meaning I'm orgasmic all the time from the pain.

KoM once explained this really well maybe he will come along and do that again, he can actually do it better than I can. Rest assured the presumption that S&M is only fluffy play and there aren't real sadists and masochists out there is false. People sometimes hold firm to that belief because it is safe. I think that's why the myth of conversion is repeated so often. I don't feel anything close to terror or abuse though, so rest assured, the myth isn't necessary for me.




Thanks for responding. This is exactly the kind of thing I was looking for, wanting to see how different people viewed/responded to the discussion. Just in case it wasn't clear, I certainly wasn't meaning to imply any sort of 'myth' status to the idea of S&M, or trying to say that it has to be either/or, this way or no way, the label says this, ergo you must do/be/say/think/feel a certain way, and so on. [:)]




laurell3 -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:38:14 PM)

You're fine and I know, I'm not offended, merely clarifying and my comments weren't in response to anything in paticular, I have a much thicker skin than that. I just tend to write very directly.





kyraofMists -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:41:23 PM)

Yep, he actually does enjoy inflicting pain and the less pleasure I receive from it, the more his sadistic desires are fulfilled. I do not consider myself to be a masochist, though many who have seen us play would disagree. There are some sensations that I enjoy and others that just plain hurt. Flicking my nipples is on a list of things I would prefer not happen again, but put clothespins all over my breasts and yank them off and I laugh (once I can breathe again).

I am not sure what you consider to be actual sadism. For me, there are very few that I have seen that are sadistic. The majority just seem to enjoy playing with sensation. Those who revel in actually causing pain are in the minority.

As for him, sadism is not the only way the he receives pleasure. There are times that he has no desire to cause pain and times that the only pain he wants to inflict is the type that Alandra or I enjoy. Then when he tells you "pick a toy" you know you are in for some pain and the sadists is in charge. *eg*

Knight's Kyra




Jeffff -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:43:28 PM)

Wait.... that sounds like a relationship.


Are you folks sure you are doing this correctly?




WHat about my scarf?




BitaTruble -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:45:57 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Ligeia72

I still don't see it as an enjoyment of inflicting pain, but rather an enjoyment of inflicting heightened sensation, which sometimes is done through pain stimulus. Or to put it another way, there is a difference, to me, between a bottom who's whimpering, and moaning, and writhing in a state of heightened arousal through the perception of pain and fear, and someone who actually IS in pain, and terrified. Then again I suppose if I did actually enjoy the former, as opposed to the latter, I'd probably be considered more of a 'textbook' example of a Sadist.




I don't think I worded myself very well. I do enjoy inflicting pain just for the sake of inflicting pain and if the bottom is *not* enjoying it, I'm cool with that and if they are, I'm cool with that as well. I'm bi like that. [:D]

I *also* enjoy inflicting pain for the other things I mentioned.. the creativity etc. My mood/mental state, energy levels, time of the month, stock market dips [;)] all contribute to *how* I will engage in a scene at any given time. I rarely feel fluffy bunny from either side so raw, hard, painful, and bloody is what does it for me in a big way. That's one of the reasons I'm so fond of take downs. Himself and I come out of it looking like we've been at war, bloody and bruised, black and blue. (I'm on a B word kick!)




Ligeia72 -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:49:59 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: laurell3

You're fine and I know, I'm not offended, merely clarifying and my comments weren't in response to anything in paticular, I have a much thicker skin than that. I just tend to write very directly.




Fair enough. Being both a newbie here, and also with the limitations of reading tone/intent online I do like to err more on the side of caution and clarify stuff if it might be needed. [:)] I did enjoy reading your response. I guess in a way it comes down to how we might define what pain and pleasure is for us individually. Different people are obviously going to have different ideas of what constitutes pain, and the enjoyment of such - eg as in the context of this discussion, is it necessarily pain or heightened sensation that is being enjoyed? People are obviously going to have different responses/ideas.

Just speaking from my own personal view point, I differentiate between the 'oh crap I've just slipped over and broken my arm, get me to a hospital' type pain, and the sort of pain stimulus that is received/given during play. Both may very well hurt, and it might be the sensation of pain that the bottom is seeking, but then I sometimes wonder if that really is the same as desiring actual pain. Or to put it a simpler way, I tend to see it as 'there's pain, and then there's 'pain', even if they both feel the same, one is not necessarily the same as the other' YMMV of course. [:)]




DomImus -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:51:52 PM)

(quoting:  Ligeia72)
So would you therefore see yourself fitting more the textbook definition of a Sadist, and not necessarily the definition of a Sadist within wiitwd?


I would say that is an accurate appraisal, yes... based on what we regularly see in wiitwd.


Although in regards to the idea of the ingrained fetish psyche being that everyone has to enjoy everything every step of the way, if someone consents to endure something they don't enjoy, then doesn't that mean that at least in some topsy turvy way they are actually enjoying it at some level? Would they necessarily consent if it was something they absolutely did not what to do, or that wasn't pleasing to them on some level? Just a thought/random musings. [:)]

That why I phrased it "Doing those things to someone who doesn't really enjoy the activities but derives their own sense of satisfaction or fulfillment from having endured them for my pleasure is by far my preference." It is analogous to disliking the journey while still enjoying the destination. The payoff at the end, if you will. To many in wiitwd it is solely about the journey or the journey and destination are inescapably intertwined. One can derive enjoyment in the afterglow while there was little enjoyment getting there. Come to think of it this is not entirely unlike many people's daily exercise regimens.

And yes if you wanted to slap a label on me personally, then I would happily consider myself a 'Service Top'. [:)]

No shame whatsoever in that. As long as it suits you (whatever situaiton we are in) it's all good.





KnightofMists -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:55:00 PM)

quote:




But, does that really apply to what we do? Do you actually enjoy inflicting/receiving pain?



not sure about we... but it applies to me.... and yes.... I actually enjoy just inflicting pain. But... it's not just without certain parameters.... I enjoy fucking women... but I don't fuck just any woman. they have to meet certain parameters.


quote:


In regards to the above, do you think there is a difference between the concept of Sadomasochism within BDSM, and 'actual' Sadomasochism? (for want of a better term).


have absolutely no clue of what your trying to ask here. Sadomasochism is Sadomasochism... But... there are difference in the people that engage in sadomasochism... and that makes all the difference in the world. The sociopath is going to be alot different than that ethical sadist one sees at a play party.


ps... laurell... I think you said things pretty good... not much I could add.




Icarys -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 6:59:33 PM)

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]




Jeffff -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:00:12 PM)

I would consider my self an ethical sadist....... but then so would any GOOD sociopath...:)




Jeffff -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:01:39 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]




I didn't day "feel".... I said "want"




Ligeia72 -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:03:53 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: KnightofMists


quote:




But, does that really apply to what we do? Do you actually enjoy inflicting/receiving pain?



not sure about we... but it applies to me....


Ok, thanks for saying this - I might actually reword the original post to remove the term 'we', I didn't realise it might be giving the impression that I'm talking about some sort of universally applicable principal for everyone, as opposed to individual points of view. [:)]

quote:


In regards to the above, do you think there is a difference between the concept of Sadomasochism within BDSM, and 'actual' Sadomasochism? (for want of a better term).

have absolutely no clue of what your trying to ask here. Sadomasochism is Sadomasochism... But... there are difference in the people that engage in sadomasochism... and that makes all the difference in the world. The sociopath is going to be alot different than that ethical sadist one sees at a play party.


Neither do I now that I think about it *lol*, I think my brain just ran away with itself. I sometimes tend to think random thoughts, and go off on tangents, they make sense to me at the time, but I must admit I am sometimes left looking back on something and just shaking my head thinking, 'Ok, what. I've just confused myself?' [:)]








Icarys -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:04:45 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeffff


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]




I didn't day "feel".... I said "want"

You didn't day?

For the record..I was just messing with you...I did read that incorrectly..I have a really bad astigmatism. I have to squint to read this crap.




laurell3 -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:05:50 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]



Agreed, but I don't think alot of people get that though Icarys. The statement is made on this thread and many others that I'm not a masochist because I don't enjoy all pain or I don't want a masochist because they enjoy all pain.

I don't enjoy all pain, I most definitely FEEL pain. I just want it.




Jeffff -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:08:13 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeffff


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]




I didn't day "feel".... I said "want"

You didn't day?




LOL... cripple picker....... I didn't SAY




Icarys -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:09:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeffff


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeffff


quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]




I didn't day "feel".... I said "want"

You didn't day?




LOL... cripple picker....... I didn't SAY

lol




BitaTruble -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:11:54 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: laurell3



Agreed, but I don't think alot of people get that though Icarys. The statement is made on this thread and many others that I'm not a masochist because I don't enjoy all pain or I don't want a masochist because they enjoy all pain.

I don't enjoy all pain, I most definitely FEEL pain. I just want it.


Yes, this. I feel pain, sometimes quite acutely. I knew I was a masochist when I had an orgasm from an ear ache but stubbed toes just suck. [8D]




Icarys -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:15:03 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Icarys

quote:

Perhaps a real sadist would say you can only really be sadistic with someone who absolutely wants no pain at all.

You've heard "sadists" say this?

Even the toughest masochists feel the pain.[:D]



Agreed, but I don't think alot of people get that though Icarys. The statement is made on this thread and many others that I'm not a masochist because I don't enjoy all pain or I don't want a masochist because they enjoy all pain.

I don't enjoy all pain, I most definitely FEEL pain. I just want it.


Of course we all have different tolerances..That's wired in I think.

I don't enjoy pain but I do have high tolerances for certain types. I've tested out electric devices before I've put them to use..on myself..It doesn't hurt like burning my finger does(I hate that crap!) or like smashing ones finger(I also hate that)..I can get "slightly" irritated when the last two things happen.

I laughed when I shocked myself.

Edited: Crap! Obviously I messed up the quote boxes and lost a reply to jeffff somewhere lol..




Ligeia72 -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:15:21 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: laurell3

Agreed, but I don't think alot of people get that though Icarys. The statement is made on this thread and many others that I'm not a masochist because I don't enjoy all pain or I don't want a masochist because they enjoy all pain.

I don't enjoy all pain, I most definitely FEEL pain. I just want it.


Yes I have to admit the concept of 'You can't be *insert label X* if you don't do/enjoy/want/etc *insert activity Y* is kinda sorta annoying to me. I don't mind if other people view themselves along those constructs, so long as they don't try and tell me that's how I should view myself. Each to their own, YMMV and all that lovely stuff. [:)]




BitaTruble -> RE: Question for Sadomasochists (6/30/2010 7:15:45 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeffff


LOL... cripple picker....... I didn't SAY


You're not a cripple yet. I'm still researching which bones I'll have to break to fit you into my carry-on. Some body parts are precious but others.. eh, they're expendable. How tall are you? [;)]




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875