FirmhandKY
Posts: 8948
Joined: 9/21/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: rulemylife quote:
ORIGINAL: FirmhandKY FR: The topic of conversation isn't about (necessarily) the BP "payment" of $20 billion. It is about a NYT reporter not understanding that the "rule of law" is not some ancient, drug up, old fashioned concept, but the very basis of the US system of governance. The US government's apparent coercion of the BP payment is an example of its failure to follow the rule of law. Firm There is no all-encompassing "rule of law" despite what philosophical fantasies teabaggers may want to invent. The law is whatever the society determines it to be. And there was absolutely no violation of any law here. Assuming that political pressure was used to "encourage" BP to make such a fund, then the basic concept of "the rule of law", not "the rule of men" was indeed violated, even if no written law was violated. Pressure can mean many things, but in this instance, if the judgment of one man caused BP to commit funds outside of a legal requirement, against their desire, then that was the imposition of a man's will over the "will" of law, and a clear violation of one of the most common concepts of "the rule of law". Now, if BP themselves decided, for public relations or moral reasons to do the same thing, then that would have been a free expression and act of contrition/public relations/morality. Do we know how the decision actually occurred? No. Therefore, unless or until evidence comes out that it was a "forced" decision, no one can truly say that they know it was a violation of the concept of "rule of law". The circumstances, however, are suspicious, and it is not in the interests of BP to admit the facts of the case, so I doubt we will every know. However, the main topic was the lack of understanding of the NYT in understanding what "the rule of law" is, and now (in my mind) has become about the fact that it seems that not many on the left side of the political equation understand what it is, either. Firm
_____________________________
Some people are just idiots.
|