experience? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Master



Message


salemartist -> experience? (12/18/2010 8:22:41 AM)

who has more experience as a dominant?

the married Dom whom has been married monogomously to the same sub for 10 years....

the Dom who has knowledge of bondage techniques, but no commited partner for 10 years....

the Dom who has had 3-5 D/s partners over the course of 10 years....?






osf -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:26:29 AM)

define the kind of experience

is a man married many times an experienced husband?

does more marriages mean more experience?




salemartist -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:28:16 AM)

all 3 men are in the lifestyle for 10 years, hypothetically




littlewonder -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:32:06 AM)

does it matter how much or how little experience any one of them has as long as whoever they are with and he is happy?

Personally bdsm experience for me has never been important to me at all.




myotherself -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:34:05 AM)

I'm with Littlewonder on this one. None of them has any experience with me, therefore they are all equally inexperienced.




DarkSteven -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:43:42 AM)

A quote from one of my favorite profiles: "Anyway, so I'm into this whole domination thing. While I'm 42 years old, I have over 50 years of experience in being a dominant man. I scored extra points on the test they gave."




salemartist -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:55:01 AM)

[:)] I have 628 years experience as I was a Dom in my previous life and a highlander immortal




LadyPact -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 9:09:39 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: salemartist

who has more experience as a dominant?

the married Dom whom has been married monogomously to the same sub for 10 years....

the Dom who has knowledge of bondage techniques, but no commited partner for 10 years....

the Dom who has had 3-5 D/s partners over the course of 10 years....?

Anybody who isn't interested in a long answer here might want to skip this reply.

I say whichever one has actually been doing whatever it is that he is actually interested in.  It doesn't particularly matter to Me where that interest lies.  For example, the Dom who has been married to his sub for ten years may have no interest in play, but has been the one running his house the whole time.  As far as I'm concerned, that qualifies, even if he's not the one who is up to date on all of the latest bondage techniques.  However, if they got together as D/s, but over the years the dynamic has slipped away, leaving them with more of an equality based relationship, then I'd only count the time the power structure or any play they were engaging in were happening.  (It happens between couples sometimes.)

The Dom who has the knowledge of the bondage techniques, has experience as a top, but not necessarily D/s.  Those really are two different things to Me.  For example, My husband has been topping for about three years now and has what a lot of folks would call a Dominant personality, but due to his lack of experience in an actual dynamic, from that angle, he's a top.

The Dom who has had 3-5 partners over the course of a decade really needs to look at how much hands on experience he's acquired over that period of time.  I don't count the time between the dynamics that he may have been searching for a partner, but wasn't active in anyway with anyone.  If all of those partners only lasted six months each, that's not really ten years of experience, is it?  It's really more the two and a half years total that he was actually doing anything, being in a dynamic where he was actually in charge.

A special mention is worth putting in here.  If during the time that a person is searching they are still active in the community, still doing casual play, etc, I do still count that as experience, at least from the topping side.  That person may only get to play once a week on the weekend, but they are still being active, hopefully learning and acquiring more skill as they go.  I do count that as topping experience.  The person who had their first dynamic twenty years ago, which lasted for six months, but after it ended only had some kinky sex when he could be lucky enough to find it, shouldn't be claiming those whole twenty years.  That's just stagnant.  Almost like a middle aged man trying to claim that he's still a football player, but hasn't been on a team since high school.

Edited to improve some sentence structure and some typos.




NuevaVida -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 9:35:03 AM)

Years of experience isn't important to me. What is his character and life experience? Anyone can learn bdsm techniques.




crazyml -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 2:59:00 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: NuevaVida

Years of experience isn't important to me. What is his character and life experience? Anyone can learn bdsm techniques.


Bingo!

Yes, "years of experience" may provide some indication about how much thinking, and learning someone has done about BDSM - but we've all met jackassed Doms who've been "doing" BDSM for a gazillion years - and they're still Jackasses.

So my answer to the question is - "If they've each been 'doing' bdsm for 10 years then they have superficially the same level of experience" - but you'd have to have a natter with them to figure out whether any of them had 10 years of experience that was actually any good.




DesFIP -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 3:16:22 PM)

It depends what you are looking for. Now the kind of guy Lady P described, who spent ten years taking workshops and learning all kinds of different play activities doesn't interest me at all. I'd rather be with the guy who had spent ten years monogamous and just did basic bondage because that's what appeals to me.

Different subs will have different needs. It all comes down to compatibility.




MasterFireMaam -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 4:24:09 PM)

quote:

the married Dom whom has been married monogomously to the same sub for 10 years....

the Dom who has knowledge of bondage techniques, but no commited partner for 10 years....

the Dom who has had 3-5 D/s partners over the course of 10 years....?


In Our opinion, all of these have different experience. More isn't the right comparison.

Master Fire




DMFParadox -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 6:59:41 PM)

D: The pro Dom who has done hundreds of shows and demonstrations, has an MD in psychology, can knock a dime off the ground with a whip and catch it on the handle, and has women begging him to accept thousands of dollars in order to torture them.




salemartist -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:15:54 PM)

great replies everyone, this was indeed a trick question. most of you saw right through it. if not experience that matters




DMFParadox -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:24:41 PM)

No; experience matters. But the gradiations are way bigger, 3 is kind of equal to 7 is kind of equal to 15, 2 years is kind of equal to 5 years is kind of equal to 10 years... but 1 year is not equal to 10 years active experience, and 1 or 3 or 5 partners is not equal to so many that you get a touch memory ability to sense differences between submissives.

Also, smug fuckhead alert. Do be careful not to show your hand like this; just quietly sit back, smile, and fail to explain how many people got tricked by you. Protip: you can be quietly smug and no one will notice, dig?




salemartist -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 8:56:10 PM)

smug fuckhead? ok, I got an new title?




AquaticSub -> RE: experience? (12/18/2010 9:56:39 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: salemartist

who has more experience as a dominant?

the married Dom whom has been married monogomously to the same sub for 10 years....

the Dom who has knowledge of bondage techniques, but no commited partner for 10 years....

the Dom who has had 3-5 D/s partners over the course of 10 years....?





They have experience in different things. Neither are better or worse but they are going to appeal to different people, both as someone to submit to and as someone to go to for advice/learning.





Darkfeather -> RE: experience? (12/19/2010 12:37:33 AM)

Experience is definitely subjective. Take baking a cake, you can have one recipe for a chocolate cake, but several different interpretations on how to make one. Whether its the chef who went to a 4 star cooking school and learned from the best teachers, or a novice who just picked up a cookbook for the first time, everyone brings their own subtleties to the mix. Is one better than the other, it depends on who is tasting the final product




sunshinemiss -> RE: experience? (12/19/2010 1:09:22 AM)

More importantly, why did they cross the street?  Did they walk into a bar together?  Is one of them a rabbi?  Is there a lightbulb to be changed? 

Inquiring minds and such...




Whiplashsmile4 -> RE: experience? (12/19/2010 3:26:24 AM)

Who has more experience as a submissive?

The married mono sub girl that has been with the same Dominant guy for 10 years.

The submissive that has been tied up, used and fucked by 100 guys, but no committed partner for 10 years...

The submissive that has had 3-4 short term relationships in the last 10 years?

What about a girl that has had very little experience but a burning desire for BDSM for the last 10 years and has done a lot of reading about it?

Seriously? how much of this would effect your own choice if you had to pick between these?






Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875