Karmastic
Posts: 1650
Joined: 4/5/2012 From: Los Angeles Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Aswad quote:
ORIGINAL: Karmastic I do have to say, I'm amazed that so much has been made of the porn. I watch porn. I like it. But I've also observed the mechanism during a sexually frustrated period of my life, and curbed it immediately because I know enough about how such things work to recognize the feedback loop in action. So, for me, it stayed a healthy adjunct to my sex life. In short, I'm not inclined to point fingers at porn. Shake a stick at it, yes. Point a finger, no. The OP is describing that feedback loop, however, and describing what happens if you let it become a problem. Increasing desires or urges that are sufficient to post about it as being a problem, let alone considering breaking up an otherwise working relationship, should not occur in someone with postpubertal hormone levels. Except when that feedback loop is at work. If you're not familiar with the problem, the pointers are easy to miss. If you are, they stick out like a sore thumb. Perhaps we're seeing something that isn't there. An easy way to find out is to simply cut back a while. If he isn't stuck in something negative, he will experience no change after laying off a few weeks. If he is, he will see a significant change in his desires in the same time. And if the porn is important enough that cutting back to check if we might have a point here seems drastic, then he's too invested in it and has a problem. I don't know about you, but for me it's always been important to test the realism of my own assessments whenever a question is raised as to whether or not they are accurate. quote:
I didn't see it as anything other than him fulfilling a sexual need that he's already tried to initiate and fulfill (and failed) with his girlfriend. That's how I see it as starting out, and how it can remain when one keeps an eye on it. quote:
The focus remained on that, even as the OP protested that he was misunderstood, and that it hasn't taken over his life, or driven any wedge into his relationship that didn't already exist. Which is why I simply described a problematic mechanism. I didn't feel that there was justification for going as far as to suggest an addiction or problems on the scale of one. That's a pretty serious thing to suggest on scant evidence. Obviously, that isn't to say that such a thing can't happen, just that I don't think it has done so yet. And I don't have any solid indication that it necessarily will progress that far. What I do have, is his admission that a problem has occured, and an indication of one of the driving mechanisms behind the problem. Based on personal experience, observation of this mechanism in others, and a quick review of how it works, I found it to be the one thing that will give the best cost/benefit tradeoff for him to do something about at this time. Except, of course, communicating clearly with his partner, where I made the apparently erroneous assumption that he already has tried doing so. The basis for that assumption was that he mentioned having posted about his situation already, and that the first piece of advice given is usually precisely to communicate. It is also usually the most ignored advice, and it's something most people aren't very good at, but I try to give people the benefit of the doubt. Turning a submissive girlfriend into a dominant doesn't seem like a very viable course of action. Getting her to top him once in a while is a different matter, of course. quote:
But what truly astonishes me, is that more than one person automatically went to telling this guy he should see a therapist, because he likes kink/bdsm, his girlfriend isn't into that, and he keeps his (failing?) relationship intact by satisfying that urge with porn. The problem he voiced is growing urges, in a thread titled "resisting the urges". Talking to a couples therapist or a regular therapist is a much faster way to get good input from someone who knows what they're talking about than going via the boards. I know we have several people here that are actually qualified therapists, and the feedback I've had so far indicates a lot of people think I make sense more often than not. Without a lot of digging and exchanges back and forth, none of us will have enough context to give tailored advice. And in the end, he will be left with diverse advice to sort through with little to tell him which advice is worth listening to, and if he doesn't like it, it's going to be easy to write it off as "advice off the Internet" even if it should happen to be the right advice. In short, a lot of investment for those offering the advice, with dubious prospects of actually doing any good. A therapist can be interactive in real time and arrive at good advice in a short amount of time with more weight behind that advice, while getting paid to provide it. That increases the odds of getting sound advice, recognizing it as sound, and then acting on it. Whatever it happens to be. I'm not going to pretend mine is necessarily the right advice. It's just as close as I'll get with the available information and the time I care to spend on it without compensation, i.e. a best effort reply. quote:
Okay, so I'm the newb here, am I getting this all wrong? What did I miss? Being a newb doesn't preclude being right. You may well be. And you're asking good, honest questions in a manner that is quite promising (please don't take that as condescending; I often come across as such, but it is rarely my intention). If there's one thing you're ascribing less weight to than I am, it's the aspect of "resisting the [growing] urges" that he has presented as being problematic. Without that, I would have completely ignored the porn thing, foregone any mention of therapists, and simply said "talk to her" (albeit likely taking a couple of paragraphs to say it; you may have noticed already that brevity is not my strong suit). I hope that clears up the whys and wherefores on my end, at least. Else, feel free to ask, and I'll try to clarify better. Health, al-Aswad. quote:
condescending "Perhaps we're seeing something that isn't there." Forgive me for throwing your own words back at you, but that's my response to just about everything you're saying. And remember, it was me that said he should communicate, and others who said he needs therapy. I do agree a couples therapy might be a last ditch hail mary and good karma, but not therapy for him, unless he's really breaking down (which I think clearly he's not, but that's just me). You're right to perceive an "admission" - I think it was him crying out because he's using porn to satisfy his kink/bdsm urge as life-support for a brain-dead relationship. Turned out he knew damn well he couldn't "resist his urge", and porn was a band-aide. I read "urge" in the title as being related to this forum, kink/bdsm, not porn. I'm sure you'll agree that one cannot resist such urges (their true sexual nature) for long without something giving! I humbly suggest you read into his words, and ran with it. Its okay if we disagree, I enjoyed your posts and replies very much. I love intelligent back and forth. Especially with people who disagree or challenge me, because whether I'm right or wrong, I will have learned something from the exchange, and filed it away. I tend to be condescending or even intimidating (IRL) myself, so I can relate. I do not want to be that, so please tell me if I am and I will to you. Also, yes, sorry, you probably sensed that my insecurity crept into my reply regarding you, so no worries, no offense taken. And thank you for the compliment - I try to be humble, and respect the social order I'm stepping head-first into. I appreciate any help you or anyone gives me on that, and take constructive criticism really well (and nonconstructive criticism really shitty). Ps - smooches
< Message edited by Karmastic -- 4/9/2012 10:01:42 PM >
|