RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


CRYPTICLXVI -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/5/2012 7:59:34 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice

quote:

People who are intensely invested in a belief will defend it with vigor because you are challenging their core. It is an emotional function, not rational.

Good point. I suspect it applies to much more than religion.


Paradigm theory, something I remember from another life when I was in college... that whenever you present someone evidence which lies outside of their paradigm, they either have to change their world view to accept that evidence or deny it to justify how they perceive things. Usually quite vehemently. This has nothing to do with religion but rather with any view point which is held strongly.




GotSteel -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/5/2012 8:03:16 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: gungadin09
Others reject evolution, basing this belief in faith in God. If there is a God, then he must be powerful/intelligent enough to have created an illusion of a false fossil record if he wanted to. Can you prove that that's NOT what happened? If you can't, then your own beliefs are also founded on faith.

Human perception is falliable. We can't even be sure of what we know. I would not be so quick to laugh at other people's faith.


When you dismiss the vast amount of evidence for what actually happened with a conspiracy theory, then no we don't have any more evidence for what actually happened then the vast amount of evidence we have.

However that does not mean that pushing a conspiracy theory and not pushing a conspiracy theory are equivalent.




Silentrunner26 -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/5/2012 8:11:18 PM)

OK I am a Southern Baptist and I have always thought that God wanted me to find my own way to Him . This means to me that He put up things to make me wonder about how we got here and I had to chose on my own if it was Him or something else . I have always know there was a God but it was not till I held my daughter for the first time just minutes after birth . I was 34 and never thought I would have a child til her mom came into my life . Yea there is a God and he is very good to me .




GotSteel -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/5/2012 8:37:26 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice
Don't all parents indoctrinate their kids in some form or fashion? They teach kids about familial, cultural, and national lore, attempt to instill values, and strive mightily to guide behavior. One friend of mine, raised by folks she describes as "devout atheists," heard as much from her parents about what she should believe (or not) as I did.


quote:

ORIGINAL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indoctrination
Indoctrination is the process of inculcating ideas, attitudes, cognitive strategies or a professional methodology (see doctrine).[1] It is often distinguished from education by the fact that the indoctrinated person is expected not to question or critically examine the doctrine they have learned.[2] As such the term may be used pejoratively, often in the context of education, political opinions, theology or religious dogma. The term is closely linked to socialization; in common discourse, indoctrination is often associated with negative connotations, while socialization refers to cultural or educational learning.


I don't think so, explaining social conventions to a child may be somewhat similar but it's not the same as teaching them presuppositions from which to think. While religion isn't the only area where indoctrination can occur (politics and nationalism come to mind) I don't think indoctrination is universal.




ARIES83 -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 12:15:47 AM)

Ok, thank you all those who contributed, even the
haters have added something, for those with an
intrest in this kind of stuff I'm putting a link to
the wikipedia page for [The Creation - Evolution Debate]
Best of luck to you all.

-ARIES




GotSteel -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 5:43:09 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub
quote:

I wouldn't call 50% little effect.


I said half of anything is neutral… meaning there was no significant influence during your so called indoctrination. These kids made up their own minds regardless of the religious up bringing making your links statistics conflicting.


I think you're not understanding the numbers. Without the indoctrination English children didn't become religious. With the indoctrination 50% of English children became religious. That's a 50% increase, that's not "no significant influence", that's huge.




GotSteel -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 6:27:16 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel
You've got 2 claims there that look to be in direct contradiction, either the percentages are remaining the same or religion is on the decline.


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub
To me and most reasonable thinkers would agree spirituality which means…of religion: relating to religious or sacred things rather than worldly things…and an organized religion have a lot more in common then spirituality and atheism.

But as usual we disagree...no thats not quite true... lets say I do agree with you in some extreme cases but not in general.


Remember the context we are talking about. We're getting the data that religion is on the decline because more people are identifying as non-religious. You're taking the word "spiritual" that many of the non-religious are still willing to use and defining it in terms of religion in order to count people as religious who self identify as non-religious. This is not something that most reasonable thinkers would agree to.




dcnovice -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 6:35:44 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel

quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice
Don't all parents indoctrinate their kids in some form or fashion? They teach kids about familial, cultural, and national lore, attempt to instill values, and strive mightily to guide behavior. One friend of mine, raised by folks she describes as "devout atheists," heard as much from her parents about what she should believe (or not) as I did.


quote:

ORIGINAL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indoctrination
Indoctrination is the process of inculcating ideas, attitudes, cognitive strategies or a professional methodology (see doctrine).[1] It is often distinguished from education by the fact that the indoctrinated person is expected not to question or critically examine the doctrine they have learned.[2] As such the term may be used pejoratively, often in the context of education, political opinions, theology or religious dogma. The term is closely linked to socialization; in common discourse, indoctrination is often associated with negative connotations, while socialization refers to cultural or educational learning.


I don't think so, explaining social conventions to a child may be somewhat similar but it's not the same as teaching them presuppositions from which to think. While religion isn't the only area where indoctrination can occur (politics and nationalism come to mind) I don't think indoctrination is universal.


The qualifier that you bolded from Wikipedia is interesting and does narrow the definition a bit. Intriguingly, the Merriam-Webster entry I consulted before writing my post didn't include it.

I do suspect that we all imbibe and transmit many more presuppositions than we care to admit. I'm not sure, for instance, how critically we're taught to think about the importance of fair play and cooperation--or about the horror of talking with our mouths full. [:)]




petslave2b -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 2:38:00 PM)

ARIES,
That wiki link says it all as far as any "debate" goes on the subject of Evolution.
"The creation–evolution controversy (also termed the creation vs. evolution debate or the origins debate) is a recurring cultural, political, and theological dispute". Cultural, political and theological dispute, but no scientific dispute. And that is the full extent of any "debate", believers trying to force their beliefs on others, and trying to circumvent scientific standards to prop up their belief system, and calling it a debate as though their position had any merit.




VideoAdminTheta -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 3:57:03 PM)

Due to the topic and the wording of the origninal post, the thread has been allowed to make more personal comments. Some post were overly personal and have been removed. Many of the post were in response to a removed post.

The personal comments that remain are within reason and I hope you all will consider keeping it that way. [;)]

I really hated to dissect the thread and don't want to ruin anyone's debate. Sometimes it can't be prevented though.

Enjoy!




PeonForHer -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 4:15:18 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: VideoAdminTheta

Enjoy!


No. Stop giving me orders. Fascist.




dcnovice -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/6/2012 6:17:56 PM)

quote:

What's one day to God??

This brought to mind two very different quotes:

-- In 1776, Adams berates Jefferson for being so slow to draft the declaration: "A week! Good God, man, the whole world was created in a week!" Jefferson stares for a few seconds, then says slowly and softly, "Some day, you must tell us how you did it."

-- Psalm 90.4: "For a thousand years in your sight are like a day that has just gone by, or like a watch in the night."




GotSteel -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/7/2012 1:12:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice
I do suspect that we all imbibe and transmit many more presuppositions than we care to admit.

There are quite a few floating around and quite a few of them are religious. Even after I managed to get rid of the presupposition that a god exists and self identified as an atheist I still ran into vestigial Christian presuppositions in my world view for years.

quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice
I'm not sure, for instance, how critically we're taught to think about the importance of fair play and cooperation

That of course is the difference between religious morality and secular humanism.

quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice
--or about the horror of talking with our mouths full. [:)]

I'm not horrified by talking with my mouth full, never have been. That's an area where I was informed of social ethics not conditioned to have an emotional response of shame or horror. I think there's an important difference there.





GotSteel -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/7/2012 2:30:19 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: dcnovice
The qualifier that you bolded from Wikipedia is interesting and does narrow the definition a bit. Intriguingly, the Merriam-Webster entry I consulted before writing my post didn't include it.

When I've been using the word indoctrinate I'm not just using a synonym for the word teach. One might be able to approximate the concept I'm trying to convey by defining imbue just so but mostly I think merriam webster has a different take on the word than I'm used to. It's fine if you want to go with that definition, but at that point it's no longer the best word to convey the concept I'm trying to express and I'll need to use an alternative, perhaps condition.




stellauk -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/7/2012 2:41:13 PM)

FR

I think you can divide religious people into two camps - there are people who practise their religion and faith being open-minded and generally at one with the world and people, and there are others who preach their religion generally because they are living in their own reality (which differs vastly from that around them) and they have unresolved issues with other people or with who they are in the world.

I don't get the God vs. evolution issue at all. We live as microscopic components in a Universe which is constantly expanding to infinity. Knowing everything there is to know about the Universe lies beyond the realms of possibility, and I believe this is an established fact for which there is a reason.

I see a natural, physical world. I can touch material objects, I can reach out and using a physical sense I can touch and feel myself, and other people.

I know there is a spiritual plane of existence which exists and which sometimes creates or influences situations which defy logical explanation. I am sceptical, because in four and a half decades of living I have yet to witness or come across an event where a concrete or physical object has managed to defy the laws of physics.

I also feel sure that as I am living and capable of creativity and spontaneous thinking and activity I am both spiritual and physical.

I therefore feel I understand the fundamental principle of religion, which is essentially that the spiritual within us is just as important (if not more so) as that what is physical. 'God' is spiritual, 'God' is creative, and therefore to be at one with God I feel we need to also be spiritual and creative.

Creativity requires interaction with others and a degree of integration into a community. Isn't this why people go to church in the first place? Why else also would religious organizations be so heavily involved in charitable causes?

I feel that the bottom line is that we are all living relative to time and space. As we get older time passes therefore progressively there is a constant rate of acceleration, which also means that death is progressively accelerating towards me and everyone else. Therefore relatively life is getting shorter and shorter.

And life is the only thing I can say I know something about. Of death I know nothing. What is more it is not possible to know anything about death or what will happen after it. All I have is faith that something will, and a belief that there is something more.

There is a common assumption that religion is about belief and faith. But is it really? I actually feel that religion is about much more than belief and faith, I feel that it's also about living with an open mind and working to develop that what is spiritual about us just as much as that what is physical. Working on the spiritual part of you to me is just as basic and fundamental to living as taking care of your personal hygiene, getting enough sleep and generally looking after yourself.

This I feel is the core message of any religion. But here is where I feel there is a general misconception.

This is what I feel the OP is driving at. It's not necessarily just about the bigots who exploit religion (just as they exploit politics) to justify their actions and provide external validation for their issues with other people (or indeed themselves).

It's also not necessarily about those 'followers' with a deep seated hatred of left wingers, communists and socialists (here 'followers' is the correct term for they live according to Stalinist ideals and embrace the exact same hierarchy and structure different only in that it is labelled 'the Church'). But to be fair there is a hardcore of 'Marxists' who despise religious types and yet who adhere to the same structures and teachings of 'the Church' but label it 'the Party'.

Both are part of a number of people who devote their lives to trying to live in defiance of the basic principles of the Universe and existence. They appear to be living under the assumption that they are going to be here forever, they seek to exist in a permanent, unchanging state of existence, their beliefs and hierarchy of moral values is rigid and fixed, and they go through life believing they are right and thus do not need to make any effort to work on that spiritual part of them.

I know of this because I have met enough religious people who do work on that what is spiritual about them, therefore I feel that religion isn't just about faith and belief but it's also about working (creativity and actions) to develop oneself spiritually.

The issue some people have with the religious is simply because of this, and because society is generally far more accepting of those who don't bother to work on their spiritual development than we are of those who are perceived not to be bothered about that what is physical. Many openly condemn people who are overweight, few would interact with people who don't take care of their personal hygiene or laundry, but those who don't work spiritually are generally given a free pass.

Therefore I partly agree with the OP, while I wouldn't tar all religious people with the same brush, I accept that the issue exists and because it does, so too do many other issues in society and the world today.









kalikshama -> RE: All the religious people I know are closed minded... (8/7/2012 5:43:22 PM)

Great post Stella!




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 3 4 [5]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875