RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Mistress



Message


FrostedFlake -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (6/22/2013 3:00:14 AM)

quote:

Can a sub ever say no to something and run?


Run if you like, but in my opinion, if you have to more than walk it is best to turn and fight. The difference is, is the situation social? Or criminal? I think this point worth keeping track of. If it takes an effort for you to tune into this wavelength, then you need to tune in to this wavelength.

Now, let's focus on what is actually up, here. There was a face to face, things got talked over, it didn't go so well. BUT, what was wrong got let out of the bag before anyone was more invested than the price of a cup of coffee. That is exactly the way things should go, if they go bad. The thing to notice about all of this is, nothing went wrong, though someone decided to walk.




njlauren -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (6/22/2013 12:20:23 PM)

What you are facing IMO is the boundary between the fantasy of being a sub/slave and the reality. The fantasy slave/sub does anything their dom/me expects of them, willingly, they never say no, and so forth...there are people who live D/s where the sub/slave has no right to say no to anything (which to be honest, makes me uncomfortable, but that is another discussion), but based on my experiences, relative few do this.

There is no such thing as a 'true sub', in the sense that everyone is different. Most people in D/s's I have known have a negotiated relationship, where the sub has hard limits, and they usually have safewords as well. Someone could of course just be kinky, who does the play and such because it simply is erotic, where they are a top/bottom, but that is not being sub at all, not being 'real' or 'not real' IMO.

And yeah, you can feel like you have disappointed you dominant, but to me a dominant should want their subs to tell them where they are, and if something isn't right, say no. If a femme domme wants to do strap on play and the M sub has hemorroids and says no, for example, that is being a true sub, rather than 'taking it' and getting harmed.

In any event, most people have limits, I can't do sense deprivation or certain types of bondage because I am claustrophobic, but it isn't about not being a good sub or not, it is about having something where doing that would be dangerous to me. Likewise, a sub with diabetes may not be able to do certain kinds of sensation play or bondage, due to physical limitations.

In your case a couple of things stand out. One, you didn't really know the people well, and doing scat play is something that I suspect would take a lot of trust, and without knowing someone, you can't have that. sub/dom relationships usually take time to build, even if both people are experienced, there is a time to for them to know and trust each other (which isn't all that different than any relationship, kinky or vanilla. Yeah, it is easy to say don't run away, but when faced with strangers with an extreme request, it is kind of natural for alarm bells to go off and/or to panic when faced with this, and you 'ran away' because it set off warnings, and there is nothing wrong with that.

As far as a dom deciding what a hard limit is, that is complete, utter bullshit. Unless it is a total consent to non consent, if you have hard limits and have said them, he/she has no right to say no, go beyond a hard limit like that, and they are playing in abuse land (I am not talking accidentally doing so, I am talking deliberately). There is a difference between stretching a limit, which goes on all the time IME (which would be covered by a safeword, or should be, so if it goes too har, the sub can say "too much") and going through a hard limit. There is a big difference; for example, in a play session if a domme wanted me to experience sex with a man as her slave, and it had been a limit but step by step she brought me to doing that, and I didn't safeword out, it would be okay; but if she tied me to a bondage bench and had a guy had sex with me, ignored my safeword or distress, that would be abuse, because she didn;'t have the right. Dom/sub relationships are negotiated ones, even 24/7 TPE, and if limit is hard and has been negotiated, that is it.




Iknowyoursecrets -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (6/22/2013 12:41:35 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: njlauren

What you are facing IMO is the boundary between the fantasy of being a sub/slave and the reality. The fantasy slave/sub does anything their dom/me expects of them, willingly, they never say no, and so forth...there are people who live D/s where the sub/slave has no right to say no to anything (which to be honest, makes me uncomfortable, but that is another discussion), but based on my experiences, relative few do this.

There is no such thing as a 'true sub', in the sense that everyone is different. Most people in D/s's I have known have a negotiated relationship, where the sub has hard limits, and they usually have safewords as well. Someone could of course just be kinky, who does the play and such because it simply is erotic, where they are a top/bottom, but that is not being sub at all, not being 'real' or 'not real' IMO.

And yeah, you can feel like you have disappointed you dominant, but to me a dominant should want their subs to tell them where they are, and if something isn't right, say no. If a femme domme wants to do strap on play and the M sub has hemorroids and says no, for example, that is being a true sub, rather than 'taking it' and getting harmed.

In any event, most people have limits, I can't do sense deprivation or certain types of bondage because I am claustrophobic, but it isn't about not being a good sub or not, it is about having something where doing that would be dangerous to me. Likewise, a sub with diabetes may not be able to do certain kinds of sensation play or bondage, due to physical limitations.

In your case a couple of things stand out. One, you didn't really know the people well, and doing scat play is something that I suspect would take a lot of trust, and without knowing someone, you can't have that. sub/dom relationships usually take time to build, even if both people are experienced, there is a time to for them to know and trust each other (which isn't all that different than any relationship, kinky or vanilla. Yeah, it is easy to say don't run away, but when faced with strangers with an extreme request, it is kind of natural for alarm bells to go off and/or to panic when faced with this, and you 'ran away' because it set off warnings, and there is nothing wrong with that.

As far as a dom deciding what a hard limit is, that is complete, utter bullshit. Unless it is a total consent to non consent, if you have hard limits and have said them, he/she has no right to say no, go beyond a hard limit like that, and they are playing in abuse land (I am not talking accidentally doing so, I am talking deliberately). There is a difference between stretching a limit, which goes on all the time IME (which would be covered by a safeword, or should be, so if it goes too har, the sub can say "too much") and going through a hard limit. There is a big difference; for example, in a play session if a domme wanted me to experience sex with a man as her slave, and it had been a limit but step by step she brought me to doing that, and I didn't safeword out, it would be okay; but if she tied me to a bondage bench and had a guy had sex with me, ignored my safeword or distress, that would be abuse, because she didn;'t have the right. Dom/sub relationships are negotiated ones, even 24/7 TPE, and if limit is hard and has been negotiated, that is it.



Dear original poster "op" read this again and then perhaps a third time. It is VERY good advice, wishing you the best.







Darkersided -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/3/2013 8:59:10 AM)

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.




LookieNoNookie -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/3/2013 4:15:07 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: shygtasub

Or does it make you a "less real" sub.
I must say I'm a total noob with practically 0 experience, however I still think I'm allowed to form my opinion about what I'm into or not. What I thought was a first encounter had me escape and run. Thankfully I was told what was expected of me so I could bail. Without getting into details, it was really disgusting and I'm not even sure it could be considered "normal" if there is such thing.

So in your opinion, can a sub say NO to something or does that make him/her less of a sub?


Bud, this is America....you can do anything you want.




PeonForHer -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/3/2013 4:44:45 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.


However, that rule doesn't apply if the mistress isn't very attractive, Darkersided.




OsideGirl -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/3/2013 4:53:20 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.


No, it's not. A slave/submissive can withdraw consent at any time. Contracts have no merits beyond an agreement between two people as to how they will run a relationship. They cannot be enforced. And to prevent someone from leaving is illegal.




tazzygirl -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/3/2013 5:02:59 PM)

wow.... simply... wow




njlauren -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/3/2013 10:49:42 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.


A contract is a two way document, it is not one way. If the owner violates the terms of that contract, it is null and void IMO. Even 24/7 TPE's can have limits on them, and in my opinion there is one right a slave reserves for themselves, and that is the right to self preservation (that is my opinion, which obviously isn't binding on anyone else).




DesFIP -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/7/2013 9:20:45 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.


Have you asked your solicitor about the legality of this contract? I think you will be surprised by the response.




DarkSteven -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/8/2013 5:09:39 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.


WTF?

A standard legal contract can be broken by either party if and only if the other party(ies) agree to that.

A slave contract has no legally recognized validity and is simply an informal agreement. As such, why should the owner get to ignore the contract while the slave does not? Does the owner have no accountability?




searching4mysir -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/8/2013 5:14:04 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.



You are a speshul snowflake, aren't you? A "slave contract" isn't worth the paper it's written on.




thishereboi -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/8/2013 5:51:34 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: nagabandha

Sounds like you have learned some more of your Hard Limits. Discuss these with your Dom. it will be up to the Dom to decide to proceed or not. I'm not sure saying no and running will be an option if you enter slave status.



Real slavery is illegal here so even if you call yourself a slave you still have the option of saying goodbye and leaving if you are not happy with the relationship.




Charles6682 -> RE: Can a sub ever say no to something and run? (7/8/2013 3:16:04 PM)

I do think a "contract" is actually a good idea. It does give the parties involved some idea on how things should work. However, a signed contract has no legal standing here in the U.S.A since clearly,slavery is illegal here and for very good reason.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Darkersided

If a slave has signed a contract its up to the owner to allow him to go.I wouldent want someone who is fake.




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875