Everyone Has a Closet (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


dcnovice -> Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 1:27:58 PM)

I really enjoyed this and thought others might too.

Ash Beckham is awesome. She also happens to be gay, and she thinks it's hard for straight people coming out of the closet.

At 2:30, she gently confronts a 4-year-old. At 3:30, she explains how hard it is for straight people to come out of the closet. At 7:53, she makes a hard decision. And at 8:56, she shares three rules about pancakes and life that you should follow.


http://www.upworthy.com/a-4-year-old-girl-asked-a-lesbian-if-shes-a-boy-she-responded-the-awesomest-way-possible?g=2&c=ufb2




NiceButMeanGirl -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 4:12:58 PM)

Oh yeah. A friend of mine told me about that today. I thought she was really cool the way she did it.

NBMG




kiwisub12 -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 4:35:56 PM)

Her whole monologue is so awesome. If someone had shown me this while I was married, I may have had the courage to be authentic, even if my husband disapproved. *sigh* Shoulda, coulda, woulda. Hind sight is so easy.[:o]




sunshinemiss -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 4:53:34 PM)

She's hot.




MalcolmNathaniel -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 5:44:40 PM)

Excellent, I have spread it around.




kdsub -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 7:36:09 PM)

We have come a long way in the last few years when it comes to attitudes on Gays...Sometimes I get the idea here on CM that many think the war is won and only right wing conservatives are bigoted...Will... when there is no need to hide in a closet terrified to come out...then I'll think the war is won.

Butch




LanceHughes -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 7:46:42 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub
We have come a long way in the last few years when it comes to attitudes on Gays...Sometimes I get the idea here on CM that many think the war is won and only right wing conservatives are bigoted...Will... when there is no need to hide in a closet terrified to come out...then I'll think the war is won.

Butch

Those that practice WIITWD (aka BDSM) are just now learning what it was like to be gay 30-some years ago.  Just follow in our footsteps!  Imagine a Gay Pride Parade 30 years ago.... if you can.  There were NO politicians marching, looking for votes, corporate sponsors?  maybe the big beer boys that NEEDED us to support them, so that they could continue to sell beer to the gay bars.  All these churches and phone companies and non-profits of every ilk - ones that had ZERO to do with one's orientation.  Well, it was SO disgusting last year, I'll probably never attend again.

I appreciate the kink community joining with the "Leather Contingency," but only a few folks.  I hope one day (soon) to return the favor.

ETA: But, Lance.  How do you really feel? LOL!




njlauren -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 9:14:37 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

We have come a long way in the last few years when it comes to attitudes on Gays...Sometimes I get the idea here on CM that many think the war is won and only right wing conservatives are bigoted...Will... when there is no need to hide in a closet terrified to come out...then I'll think the war is won.

Butch

Very true, butch.It is very easy with conservative catholics turning Catholicism into being anti gay (and anti abortion, thank you, Pope Francis, for the very least at telling them and other that Catholicism has a lot of things more important to worry about), of course the religious right and their GOP handlers with their full court press against gays to please the rednecks and yahoos and the like, it is easy to think that the war is gonna be won because they are in full retreat over same sex marriage, and young Catholics and even evangelicals don't have the hatred of gays their elders often did.

That said, it is very much like racism, where it is very easy to point to the Jim Crow south or to the attitudes of many of the tea party types as proof that racism is a redneckey kind of thing..where as another thread on schools pointed out, in the so called liberal places, most kids are in schools about as segregated as the deep south was in the 1950's, and attitudes towards blacks, while not overt, are still there, fear of things like low income housing cause 'that is going to bring blacks from the projects", or even fear if a black family moves into the neighborhood and so forth.

With gays, it is much the same thing. People who have no problem with gay marriage being legal might very well go nuts if one of their kids is gay (especially sad, worried about 'what other people will think of them'). People who claim they are okay with gays, but if they work with someone who is openly gay or suspect they are, will treat them differently, even if it is to go out of their way to show they are cool around gays (if you are cool around someone, you don't treat them any differently). And we can't say the victory is won until as butch says, being open about being gay is about as interesting as saying you like pork chops for dinner or prefer dating brunettes or admit you root for the NY Jets (well, okay, the last one will always be shameful..). The fact that people all over still feel afraid to simply be themselves means there is still a lot of homophobia out there, if someone grows up where something is truly accepted, it isn't hard to admit it the way coming out still is. Not to mention that in 35 states you can be fired for being gay or for openly saying you married a person of the same sex,and the federal government refuses to pass legislation protecting LGBT people from discrimination (and think about this, what does it tell a gay person coming out that congress refuses to protect them from one of the most important things out there, being able to have a decent job, or that no one, not the democrats, not Obama, is calling those against on it?).




MalcolmNathaniel -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 9:30:09 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: njlauren
"of course the religious right and their GOP handlers "


You got that completely backwards.


quote:

ORIGINAL: LanceHughes

Those that practice WIITWD (aka BDSM) are just now learning what it was like to be gay 30-some years ago. Just follow in our footsteps! Imagine a Gay Pride Parade 30 years ago.... if you can. There were NO politicians marching, looking for votes, corporate sponsors? maybe the big beer boys that NEEDED us to support them, so that they could continue to sell beer to the gay bars. All these churches and phone companies and non-profits of every ilk - ones that had ZERO to do with one's orientation. Well, it was SO disgusting last year, I'll probably never attend again.

I appreciate the kink community joining with the "Leather Contingency," but only a few folks. I hope one day (soon) to return the favor.

ETA: But, Lance. How do you really feel? LOL!


Actually, I do want to know what you think. Too much innuendo and not enough statement to really understand unless you want me to put what you are thinking into what you are saying. I don't know you well enough to do that without one of us looking like an ass.




FrostedFlake -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 11:06:56 PM)

Thanks, DC. That is a great TED.

And it occurs to me, there are two sides to a closet door. I may be wrong, but it might be worthwhile for me to speak to this topic for a moment. Hopefully without causing offense, or suggesting I am proud of it, I'd like to go over one of my greatest learning experiences. It might be inappropriate to start at the beginning, but I am going to.

Dear old Dad was one of those guys who simply was not comfortable unless everyone around him was afraid of him. The lessons he taught were not... helpful. Living with a sociopath tends to make one one. It is a simple matter of survival. And naturally, you can't act like that with 'normal' people. And so I had to learn those rules too. And be very careful which I applied where. It was... confusing. But I lived. Not everyone in my family can say that. I left home with a lot of very important lessons to unlearn. And quite a few just as important to learn. I worked hard at that. With some minor success here and there, now and then. But it is difficult to see everything at once. I missed some tricks. And things needed to be pointed out to me on occasion.

On one such occasion, about thirty years ago, a friend introduce a friend. This friends' friend was pretty clearly Gay. And I hadn't had occasion to think seriously about that. I reacted by holding the closet door closed. I don't recall exactly what I said, but I do recall it was really quite foul. I recall that much quite clearly, because Jennifer wasn't going to put up with that for a second. She expertly shoved those words right back where they came from. Invited me to chew. And decide whether to spit or swallow. Waited patiently while I made up my mind. Silence dripped off the ceiling. I slowly chewed. It took maybe ten seconds. I apologized.

It was a good decision. Instead of having no friend, I had two. Still do. I know better now than to hold a closet door closed on someone. But I didn't know better. Until I learned. And I didn't learn by myself.

There are a lot of ignorant people out there. And they are not going to learn by themselves. A lot of progress has been made since Stonewall. But the battle will not be over before people learn to stop "protecting" their children from "the Gays". As in "the Enemy".

The assertion that it is inappropriate to mention to children that there are Gay people is the assertion that being Gay is wrong. Let's think a moment about all the folks who REALLY don't want to hear that. Let's ask ourselves if that is not EXACTLY why they need to. It is the only way to actually end this conversation.




FrostedFlake -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (3/31/2014 11:48:59 PM)

[image]https://upworthy-production.s3.amazonaws.com/nugget/528d4edcec7056168a000b32/attachments/homophpboc_reply_yes.jpg[/image]




LanceHughes -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (4/1/2014 12:18:31 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MalcolmNathaniel
<snipped>
quote:

ORIGINAL: LanceHughes

Those that practice WIITWD (aka BDSM) are just now learning what it was like to be gay 30-some years ago. Just follow in our footsteps! Imagine a Gay Pride Parade 30 years ago.... if you can. There were NO politicians marching, looking for votes, corporate sponsors? maybe the big beer boys that NEEDED us to support them, so that they could continue to sell beer to the gay bars. All these churches and phone companies and non-profits of every ilk - ones that had ZERO to do with one's orientation. Well, it was SO disgusting last year, I'll probably never attend again.

I appreciate the kink community joining with the "Leather Contingency," but only a few folks. I hope one day (soon) to return the favor.

ETA: But, Lance. How do you really feel? LOL!

Actually, I do want to know what you think. Too much innuendo and not enough statement to really understand unless you want me to put what you are thinking into what you are saying. I don't know you well enough to do that without one of us looking like an ass.

Thanks, Malcolm.  What is missing is:

"Current Gay Pride Parades are filled with Corporate sponsors, churches, non-profits.  They mostly join the CURRENT  pride parades for the visiblity."

The parades 30 years ago were fraught with worries about police action, taunting and worse from the cowards.... er, the crowds gathered around.  Of course, local TV stations broadcast the most "visible" parts - two parts, really - the drag queens and the leatherfolk.  Nice to see yourself on the 10 o'clock news marching.  Not only were you outed, you were outed twice.  AND!!!! Both those sub-groups were ALWAYS asked by the organizers to "tone it down."  The closet door was being "held shut " for us by members of our own..... WTF?  This internal prejudice continues to this day.  (Love that idea about "door being held shut."  I'm stealing it.)

Here in Denver, the parade passes by the front of Roman Catholic Cathedral. Religious groups would gather there.  They do so to this day, but they are heckled right back. - My favorite response to the Phelps like nonsense is "Hate is Sin."  (Made that up myself.)

I guess my main point is that I found my self thinking "Where were you 30 years ago when we REALLY needed a show of support instead of riding on OUR coat-tails as you do currently."

WTF does a cell-phone company have to do with a Gay Pride Parade?

Clear 'nuff?




LanceHughes -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (4/1/2014 12:20:50 AM)

Interesting note on PFLAG:  Founded here in Denver.




LanceHughes -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (4/1/2014 12:30:02 AM)

Part of  my answer to Malcolm (that I started in Cmail) is:
Not sure how to make it more clear:

"Those that practice WIITWD (aka BDSM) are just now learning what it was like to be gay 30-some years ago." means that:
BDSMers must be closeted, especially with regards to court and psych views.  Custody of a child is most often given to the non-BDSMer.  The difference between abuse and BDSM is not understood - police, DAs and the like can make BDSMers' life miserable.

"Just follow in our footsteps!"  means that:
Gay folk followed in the footsteps of the Civil Rights marchers and the parallels are incredibly .... well, parallel.




LanceHughes -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (4/1/2014 12:42:25 AM)

LOVE that newspaper clipping.  I usually "go with" - - - - "what day in your life were YOU given the choice to be gay or straight?  I'd like to know since I guess I missed the chance to decide."

But! From my POV, that's (mostly) all old hat.  There remain people closeted - and rightly so - about WIITWD.

At least y'all (kinky straights) have a leg up.  You're ahead of us by where we were when the DSM - Diagnostic and Statistical Manual - remove homosexuality as a prima facie mental illness. (On the face of it.  That is, "You homo?  You sick, boy.")  Fortunately, the 5th edition was recently released (May, 2013) and Sadism and Masochism are now listed as mental illnesses ONLY if the patient is bothered by it. (Used to be that you were mentally ill if anyone was bothered by it!)  Homosexuality is now in that same type of status.  That is, to be homosexually mental ill, the patient must be bothered by it.

Anywho - late here and I've got a project to finish, due in AM.




thishereboi -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (4/1/2014 7:02:00 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: njlauren


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

We have come a long way in the last few years when it comes to attitudes on Gays...Sometimes I get the idea here on CM that many think the war is won and only right wing conservatives are bigoted...Will... when there is no need to hide in a closet terrified to come out...then I'll think the war is won.

Butch

Very true, butch.It is very easy with conservative catholics turning Catholicism into being anti gay (and anti abortion, thank you, Pope Francis, for the very least at telling them and other that Catholicism has a lot of things more important to worry about), of course the religious right and their GOP handlers with their full court press against gays to please the rednecks and yahoos and the like, it is easy to think that the war is gonna be won because they are in full retreat over same sex marriage, and young Catholics and even evangelicals don't have the hatred of gays their elders often did.

That said, it is very much like racism, where it is very easy to point to the Jim Crow south or to the attitudes of many of the tea party types as proof that racism is a redneckey kind of thing..where as another thread on schools pointed out, in the so called liberal places, most kids are in schools about as segregated as the deep south was in the 1950's, and attitudes towards blacks, while not overt, are still there, fear of things like low income housing cause 'that is going to bring blacks from the projects", or even fear if a black family moves into the neighborhood and so forth.

With gays, it is much the same thing. People who have no problem with gay marriage being legal might very well go nuts if one of their kids is gay (especially sad, worried about 'what other people will think of them'). People who claim they are okay with gays, but if they work with someone who is openly gay or suspect they are, will treat them differently, even if it is to go out of their way to show they are cool around gays (if you are cool around someone, you don't treat them any differently). And we can't say the victory is won until as butch says, being open about being gay is about as interesting as saying you like pork chops for dinner or prefer dating brunettes or admit you root for the NY Jets (well, okay, the last one will always be shameful..). The fact that people all over still feel afraid to simply be themselves means there is still a lot of homophobia out there, if someone grows up where something is truly accepted, it isn't hard to admit it the way coming out still is. Not to mention that in 35 states you can be fired for being gay or for openly saying you married a person of the same sex,and the federal government refuses to pass legislation protecting LGBT people from discrimination (and think about this, what does it tell a gay person coming out that congress refuses to protect them from one of the most important things out there, being able to have a decent job, or that no one, not the democrats, not Obama, is calling those against on it?).



So now it's the conservatives fault that the catholic church is against gays? For a minute this looked like it was going to be an interesting article. I should have know someone would drag the left vs right bullshit into it.


and back on topic...that was a great link dc. I loved her answer to the 4 year old. I am going to have to remember her answer next time I get asked that.




Wolf2Bear -> RE: Everyone Has a Closet (4/1/2014 8:51:37 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: LanceHughes

I guess my main point is that I found my self thinking "Where were you 30 years ago when we REALLY needed a show of support instead of riding on OUR coat-tails as you do currently."

WTF does a cell-phone company have to do with a Gay Pride Parade?

Clear 'nuff?



The other side to this issue of riding on coat tails is these corporate sponsors, the churches etc is a double edged sword. Even if they are doing so with the main motivation to increase their visibility, it also means that they too are also showing support for the cause. It is by this action which speaks volumes in support of Gay Rights and Equality even though they are not able to directly state to the public and especially to their share holders




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875