The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


kalikshama -> The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 12:25:16 PM)

As long as abortion restrictions and bans continue to be rammed through state legislatures and introduced on Capitol Hill, it seems that anti-choice zealots will continue making headlines with their bizarre, scientifically incorrect and downright cruel remarks. Whether they're confusing the basics of female anatomy, making offensive comparisons to historical tragedies, trivializing rape or labeling pro-choice politicians "terrorists," these anti-abortion crusaders – led by a hee-hawing band of actual elected officials – could populate a thousand lists of epically dumb comments. Here's a sampling of the most ill-informed, borderline delusional and flat-out misogynist statements from the so-called "pro-life" movement:

1. Texas State Senator Wendy Davis is a "terrorist" because she filibustered an anti-choice bill.

2. "If it's a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down."

3. Who needs abortion when victims of sexual assault can just get "cleaned out" by a rape kit?

4. Women shouldn't terminate pregnancies resulting from rape because it's what God intended.

5. Women shouldn't complain about forced transvaginal ultrasounds, because they've already had sex.

6. "If babies had guns, they wouldn't be aborted."

7. "Abortion is much more serious than the rape of children by priests."

8. Abortion rights caused the Sandy Hook massacre.

9. Ban abortions because of masturbating fetuses.

10. Abortion is just like the Holocaust.

Context for quotes: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/the-ten-dumbest-things-ever-said-about-abortion-and-womens-rights-20130715#ixzz2ynPsNL8e




Kaliko -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 2:11:51 PM)

I'm personally against abortion, so I truly expected to read your post and find something redeeming in them to debate you about. But no. They're all just as dumb as you say.

The only one I could even muster up a half-hearted supportive argument for is number 4. There is a sort of certain element of not throwing in our maker's face (pick the maker of your choice) a life that has been given to us, no matter how that life came to be. But, it's really only the smallest morsel of a thought of mine.




Tkman117 -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 2:33:49 PM)

Not everyone believes in a god, and forcing that kind of stuff on women who don't believe in god goes against their right to freedom from religion, or even women who do believe in god. People have different interpretations of "god's will" and it's not for anyone to decide what that is and isn't, since then they're the ones playing god with other people's lives.




Kaliko -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 2:57:29 PM)

Understood. Which is why it's only the smallest morsel of a thought. For me, there might be some merit to #4. My own beliefs would definitely affect my decision in that situation. For others, not. I know that.




MercTech -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 5:36:36 PM)

I tend to separate a personal dislike for abortion from the concept of politicians that don't know a fallopian tube from a catheter legislating what medical options women should have.

I weigh in on the pro-choice side from a distrust of politicians to get it right.





RemoteUser -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 5:51:26 PM)

I think women should have their own say, and leave it at that. (Not much else to add as a male.)

However, it does remind me of a documentary I watched about animals in the wild, which opened with a family of owls. Mama had three babies, but food was scarce, so the two owlets that were strongest forced their way to the food brought, and the weakest one starved to death. And then, they cannibalized it.

Compared to this (being a natural event of appropriate behaviour for the animals involved), I really can't see why abortion would be such a big deal. Somehow being born, starved and then put on the menu seems so much harsher.




njlauren -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/13/2014 8:41:03 PM)

The anti abortion people have a point about abortion, I can understand why they could view it the way they do. The problem is that many of the anti abortion people lose credibility because their views on other things make the matter worse, not better. Many of the anti abortion crowd are also anti sex, so they are big supporters of abstinence only sex ed, bans on condom distribution, cutting funds to planned parenthood and the like, which increases demand for abortion (the bible belt has the highest rate of teen pregnancy in the nation). They talk about the 'right of the fetus', yet as with anti abortion douchebags like Paul Ryan and the rest of the religious right/tea party types, they then turn around and gut the programs that disproportionally help children (polls of pro life people show a large majority of them favor gutting social service programs like medicaid, welfare,head start and other such social programs). They can sit there and excommunicate a nun who approved a medical abortion to save the life of a mother with 4 young kids who was dying, the nun saw the horror of 4 kids growing up without a mother and recognized that morality isn't always so cut and dried, unlike the mean,nasty jerks running the church in the US since JPII and Der Pope stacked the deck with blind fools. Someone drooler blamed Sandy Hook on abortion, but what if testing could have shown that the fetus that became Adam Lanza would have serious mental health issues, and the parents had made the decision to have an abortion, which was worse, that one fetus aborted or 26 people, most of them innocent little kids, still being alive? (I realize that in all likelyhood, no such test could detect Adam Lanza would turn into a cold blooded killer, but suppose it could?).

I often wonder if men got pregnant, if we would see such an outcry. One of the unsaid things underlying a lot of the posts mentioned by the idiots is the idea that in some ways, an unintended pregancy is 'the just rewards for sin". When they say abortion shouldn't cover rape, because if a women is really raped a baby won't form, that implies directly that if a woman got pregnant from a so called rape, what she really is doing is covering up consensual sex (since of course, according to their bible, all women are Eve's daughters, temptresses of pure men, etc...). They also believe if you put exemptions in rape laws for abortion, women in droves will claim to be raped to be able to get an abortion (leaving out, of course, that it is likely that if such a thing came to pass and abortion was made illegal, women would need to show proof they had been raped, not to mention that to avoid the embarassment of having to come forward,most women would probably seek out an illegal abortion so women crying rape to get an abortion is not likely to happen, but they believe that.

A lot of pro choice people, like myself, believe there are far too many abortions, using abortion as birth control makes no sense. Hillary Clinton, whom I rarely agree with, said that abortion should be rare but legal, and if the pro life crowd really want to eliminate abortion they should get on the page with preventing pregnancy, not banning abortion, and they should also be pushing, not to gut social programs, but to strengthen them so they can offer pregnant women hope for themselves and their kids. If they truly feel abortion is murder, then maybe they should work towards where women don't feel that abortion is their only option. All the talk about adoption is crock, if there really were all these people willing to adopt kids, how come the adoption and foster services of every state are blown out by huge caseloads? And how about instead of living in the dark ages, push for realistic sex education and access to birth control to prevent pregnancy rather than promoting bronze age morality as sex ed?




tweakabelle -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 12:46:28 AM)

My! What a collection of doozies!

The most obscene aspect to all of this is that many of the loonies responsible for these ridiculous claims hold public office. For example, my personal favourite, #9, the claim that abortions ought to be banned because the are somehow connected to the phenomenon of c20 week old male infants masturbating (!) was made by a US Congressman Micheal Burgess ( R Texas ). Incredibly this person is a medical specialist in obstetrics. Far more credibly he's a member of the Tea Party caucus.

Who needs Al Quada to destroy the USA when, given their way, people like this will do the job for you at a fraction of the cost?




Moonhead -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 5:29:14 AM)

I particularly like 6: how the fuck is a gun going to stop a second trimester foetus getting aborted? You need eyes and fingers to use a gun, and even if you didn't, I doubt they'd work when full of fluid.
That's without even getting into how a gun is going to defend a foetus short of it taking its mother hostage: "One step closer, Satanist, and I'm putting a slug through the whore's cunt!"
Dearie me...




DaddySatyr -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 5:35:38 AM)

I like to think we're a little bit more advanced (Pronounced: "smarter", "kinder", "humane") than animals but, I do have to admit that there are some subjects (and people) that make me doubt my own reasoning.

The preceding bit ("and people") was not aimed at you, RU.








quote:

ORIGINAL: RemoteUser

Compared to this (being a natural event of appropriate behaviour for the animals involved), I really can't see why abortion would be such a big deal. Somehow being born, starved and then put on the menu seems so much harsher.





Screen captures still RULE! Ya feel me?







Yachtie -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 6:38:39 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Moonhead

I particularly like 6: how the fuck is a gun going to stop a second trimester foetus getting aborted? You need eyes and fingers to use a gun, and even if you didn't, I doubt they'd work when full of fluid.
That's without even getting into how a gun is going to defend a foetus short of it taking its mother hostage: "One step closer, Satanist, and I'm putting a slug through the whore's cunt!"
Dearie me...


Don't get the illustrative metaphorical of it, do you. Comprehension is definately in short supply around here.

The others, yeah, pretty ignorant.




cloudboy -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 7:30:00 AM)


How many of those quotes are from "conservative" white men?




cloudboy -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 7:34:13 AM)

You are 100% right --- the clusterfuck reasoning --- is a huge problem.

Whatever happened to the libertarian, conservative position: "If you don't like abortion, don't get one."

Many nutjobs believe that contraception is abortion --- so now we have the HOBBY LOBBY case before the Supreme Court.




thishereboi -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 8:23:41 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: cloudboy


How many of those quotes are from "conservative" white men?



they were all idiots, not sure what difference it makes how many were white conservative men unless you plan on using this later to try and claim all white conservative men feel the same way. Kinda reminds me of the assholes who try and claim all blacks are criminals because the majority of prisoners are black. Or maybe you honestly believe that there is no one on the left who has really stupid ideas regarding abortion in which case I can't help you. Maybe a profession could do more.




Zonie63 -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 8:25:29 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Moonhead

I particularly like 6: how the fuck is a gun going to stop a second trimester foetus getting aborted? You need eyes and fingers to use a gun, and even if you didn't, I doubt they'd work when full of fluid.
That's without even getting into how a gun is going to defend a foetus short of it taking its mother hostage: "One step closer, Satanist, and I'm putting a slug through the whore's cunt!"
Dearie me...


Yeah, that one made me shake my head and wonder. And that was supposedly somebody's idea of a campaign slogan. I guess they wanted to convey the candidate's support of the Second Amendment and their opposition to abortion in one slogan, so they came up with this: "If babies had guns, they wouldn't be aborted." Either it was meant as a joke (which would seem to be in poor taste for a political campaign) or they really are that ignorant about quite a lot of things as revealed in such a statement.

Apart from needing eyes and fingers to be able to use the gun, how is the fetus going to get the gun in the first place? Is it going to be surgically implanted? Would it be a baby-sized gun at first which develop and grow with the fetus (so that when the baby is born, it's an AK-47 and the baby is ready to become Rambo)? This could be an interesting ploy the CIA could use to carry out assassinations.





thishereboi -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 8:30:18 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Zonie63


quote:

ORIGINAL: Moonhead

I particularly like 6: how the fuck is a gun going to stop a second trimester foetus getting aborted? You need eyes and fingers to use a gun, and even if you didn't, I doubt they'd work when full of fluid.
That's without even getting into how a gun is going to defend a foetus short of it taking its mother hostage: "One step closer, Satanist, and I'm putting a slug through the whore's cunt!"
Dearie me...


Yeah, that one made me shake my head and wonder. And that was supposedly somebody's idea of a campaign slogan. I guess they wanted to convey the candidate's support of the Second Amendment and their opposition to abortion in one slogan, so they came up with this: "If babies had guns, they wouldn't be aborted." Either it was meant as a joke (which would seem to be in poor taste for a political campaign) or they really are that ignorant about quite a lot of things as revealed in such a statement.

Apart from needing eyes and fingers to be able to use the gun, how is the fetus going to get the gun in the first place? Is it going to be surgically implanted? Would it be a baby-sized gun at first which develop and grow with the fetus (so that when the baby is born, it's an AK-47 and the baby is ready to become Rambo)? This could be an interesting ploy the CIA could use to carry out assassinations.




#6, yea not sure how I missed that one. But all reality aside, I would love to see the doctors face when he peered inside and saw that he was looking down a gun barrel. All that would be needed is a deep voice saying "put down the knife and step away from the uterus'




Moonhead -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 10:48:04 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Yachtie


quote:

ORIGINAL: Moonhead

I particularly like 6: how the fuck is a gun going to stop a second trimester foetus getting aborted? You need eyes and fingers to use a gun, and even if you didn't, I doubt they'd work when full of fluid.
That's without even getting into how a gun is going to defend a foetus short of it taking its mother hostage: "One step closer, Satanist, and I'm putting a slug through the whore's cunt!"
Dearie me...


Don't get the illustrative metaphorical of it, do you. Comprehension is definately in short supply around here.

You mean there's anything more to that soundbite than some fuckwit thinking they can endear themself to the antichoicers and the gun lobby at the same time through the use of a metaphor so cretinous that it beggars belief?
Blimey. Some members of the American right are even stupider than I feared.




Kirata -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 11:11:50 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Moonhead

You mean there's anything more to that soundbite than some fuckwit thinking they can endear themself to the antichoicers and the gun lobby at the same time through the use of a metaphor so cretinous that it beggars belief? Some members of the American right are even stupider than I feared.

First you took it literally and made great sport of how stupid it was. Now you're trying to blather your way out of it. Sorry, but there's no rabbit in that hat.

K.





Yachtie -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 12:01:47 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata

First you took it literally and made great sport of how stupid it was. Now you're trying to blather your way out of it. Sorry, but there's no rabbit in that hat.

K.

[/font][/size]


Yup Yup !! And it's all there in glorious black and white. [:D] And that ain't no metaphor. [8D]




PeonForHer -> RE: The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Abortion and Women's Rights (4/14/2014 1:54:09 PM)

FR

Er, What does 'If babies had guns, they wouldn't be aborted' actually mean, then? No doubt I'm having a stupid moment, but I'm developing a migraine here trying to get my head around it. Could somebody help me out?




Page: [1] 2 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875