tweakabelle -> RE: "Save A Life - Surrender Your Knife" (12/8/2015 5:06:21 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: PeonForHer quote:
I don't think it's a "fondness for killing" at all. Sure, there are some really twisted fucks out there, but I highly doubt the vast majority of killings are done because one enjoys killing. I'd be more persuaded, DS, were it not for the fact that the USA not only loves its guns, but also seems to love its capital punishments. From the outside, to me - and I suspect to a lot of non-Americans - there are frequent and quite visceral shocks at the numbers of people who get killed ("righteously" or otherwise) in the USA and the way Americans seem to take all such killings in their stride. I'm not just talking about lefties in the UK who get shocked in this way. I'm talking about everybody here, right across the political spectrum. The USA looks very, *very* unusual in the way it puts up with killing, to us in Europe and probably Aus and NZ, too. That "unusual" attitude towards killing is something worth examining. One can see from some of the pro-gun people's posts here that there is not only an oft stated willingness to use weapons but also there is an impression that some people just can't wait to have the chance to use their weapons on those ubiquitous 'bad guys' lurking, it seems, around every corner. It also seems to me that the way some Americans think and talk about crime and their own safety is quite different to that of people in most other countries which have more or less similar crime levels (homicides excepted). Their discourse is utterly alien to me - by which I mean I've never heard Australians, or any other non-Americans talk about these issues in the same way, to have the same preoccupation with crime or level of paranoia about their own safety. There is also the cultural inheritance of guns occupying a prominent place in US history and culture. All of which combines to create a situation that is very difficult for non-Americans to regard sympathetically. Guns are not only instruments of self defence, they are also a means of asserting one's will, of exercising domination and control over a situation. My suspicion is that there is a lot more acceptance and approval of using weapons as a means of asserting will and domination in US society and culture than other Western countries. In other Western countries, the acceptance would be far more ambivalent, and the approval, for all intents and purposes, non-existent.
|
|
|
|