longwayhome -> RE: May to seek snap election June 8th (4/20/2017 1:57:58 PM)
|
The situation with Scotland and the EU would appear in fact to be far more straightforward than the scaremongers suggest. A number of heads of state, EU politicians and Commission employees have pointed out the obvious truth, which is that if an independent Scotland applied to become part of the EU, there would be a very short process because an independent, democratic Scotland would already meet all the requirements for joining, including the financial requirements. Scotland's laws (already separate to the rest of the UK) have already integrated all EU and European Human Rights legislation. Scottish industry complies with all EU regulations. Scotland, although smaller and more economically vulnerable than the UK, has the same level of debt as the rest of the UK. Furthermore Scottish politicians have for many years worked as part of a larger polity, i.e. the UK, and so have no problem working with Europe. The hypocrisy with which people have promoted UK independence from Europe whilst complaining about Scots wanting self-determination is staggering. Usually this is combined with a quite vicious attitude towards the Scots where the same people say they want a vote on Scottish independence in which they would vote to kick the Scots out of the UK, despite the fact that they do not live in Scotland and therefore have no say. Imagine the same people putting up with EU interference in UK politics or referendums. I don't want to see the break up of the UK, but I also don't want to see the break up of the EU. English politicians and the English public are perfectly entitled to have a view on the unity of the UK and a view on Scottish independence, but they have no conceivable justification for seeking to assert their own sovereignty whilst complaining about or actively interfering with self-determination for Scotland. Bear in mind that Scottish self-determination has for living memory been to remain in the UK. If Scotland does become independent, the deciding factor will be the UK decision to leave the EU. The majority in Scotland for staying part of the UK was far larger and more convincing than the vote for Brexit. It is a sad reflection on our new found desire for conflict, inward-looking and distrust of others that the Scots may vote for independence not to be apart from the UK so much as to remain part of a wider community of nations. The Scots always saw independence as self determination and would have chosen to be part of a community of nations including the rest of the UK. The Brexit vote represents a far more significant form of isolationism than those supporting Scottish independence ever conceived for Scotland. I don't even support Scottish independence but the continued patronisation and hypocrisy in the attitude that many have towards Scotland is just one feature of the troubling attitude we are developing towards our fellow human beings and our neighbours in the world. One election to confirm the future direction of the UK. When will we really know the consequences of Brexit? No-one is telling us what type of agreement with the EU we are going to have. This election will give us no more openness. We voted for a pig in a poke with no knowledge of what Brexit would deliver. That is not to say that people didn't vote for Brexit because they did. It was the precise nature of that Brexit that we were never told. Even now May is telling us nothing, except to trust her to negotiate effectively with our European neighbours and trust her to get a good deal. Given the fact that May has made a second referendum in Scotland inevitable by not even make a decent pretence of communicating with the Scottish government since the Brexit vote, how can we trust her negotiation skills? She could have made sure that the SNP had no grounds for a referendum just by turning up and publicly discussing their concerns. Sturgeon doesn't have a majority in the Scottish Parliament. She wouldn't have carried a vote there without May's high-handed refusal to engage at any serious level. May handed it to Sturgeon on a plate. Someone so poor at negotiating with other countries and taking account of their domestic politics shouldn't be given a free reign to negotiate and decide the UK's future.
|
|
|
|