Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


SwPuno -> Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/26/2004 10:36:49 AM)


I was tempted to put this separately on the Ask a Master / Submissive board as I suspect they get more activity but hopefully this board also gets a good mix of people.

Questions from a newbie to D/s relationships:

As a sub I sometimes get urges such as "I wish someone would tie me in this particular position and ...<whatever>". Now I'm not sure if this is something that pure subs experience or if this is the top side of my switch personality turning against me [:D].

So my question for dommes in regards to non-pay relationships is, if a sub comes to you and respectfully or playfully asks to be tied or treated in a certain way or have something particular done to them is this okay and welcome or do you consider it attempted "topping from below"?

Also, for the subs, do you occasionally get similar specific urges? Do you ask your domme for this or just fantasize and/or masturbate about it (if permitted) and hope that it happens at some point?

Also on a related vein, for everyone, what happens if the sub is the more creative one as far as new activities or scene ideas? Does this cause joy or frustration? I suppose one way to handle this might be for the domme to assign the slave to come up with a scene or idea every X days/weeks/months so that the slaves ideas are still within the structure of the relationship and the sub is not perceived as trying to run things. Even if they don't carry it out the sub still gets to express themselves and the domme at least gets to learn more about the subs desires and hopefully becomes intrigued or excited as well.

Looking forward to your thoughts and experiences on this.

puno




MemphisDsCouple -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/26/2004 10:59:15 AM)

If there is anything more erotic, endearing and bonding than my girl kneeling and kissing my feet and in a voice tense with the realization of what she is saying.... somewhere between a whisper and groan.... saying..... "Master, please whip me"..... if there is anything better...... it escapes my memory at this moment.




MizSuz -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/26/2004 11:17:57 AM)

I'm interested in what pushes my submissive's buttons. I am not interested in requests for scripted scenes.

My preference is that fantasies and ideas come up in the normal course of conversations (and if it's someone I'm not currently "involved" with then I prefer they wait until I bring it up) and then leave the timing and the way it may manifest to me.

The short version is "Yes, I like to know what floats your boat and what you think of" and "No, I'm not interested in being approached as if I were a life support system for a whip." The answer is in the middle.





lilldarlin -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/26/2004 7:39:22 PM)

One thing I have discovered is that the only way the man I am with can find out what it is I need or desire is if I find a way to tell him. I haven't yet found a person that is blessed with the ability to read minds. (even if sometimes it seems as if they can. *S)

Some things I have done other than just comming out and saying it are to write a story, a note and to send an article or story I have found that conveys what I need him to know. Another is to ask for a trip to a toy store and express interest in a certain toy or maybe just go and purchase what I wish to try as a gift. Never met a Dom yet that did not enjoy receiving a new toy from their slave/submissive with a little note attached requesting him to show you how this toy might be used. [:D]




RealityFix -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 12:24:31 PM)

Suggestions are welcomed.

Directions are NOT.




CTclay -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 6:21:28 PM)

I have strategies for getting what I want when owned, and I don't see anything wrong with trying to get what I want at times within a relationship where I've already agreed that I'm not the one in charge. It's not the request or the desire that a submissive has that offends a dominant, I'm certain, it's the WAY the request is made. There shouldn't be any pressure, ever. Requests should be pretty few and far between. As has been said by some of the other people posting, it really has a lot to do with the way you ask.

I was once in a relationship with a domme who was pretty new at being one and who was very sensitive to any hint of my topping from the bottom. But there were certain things I decided I really needed in the relationship (certain freedoms), so I decided to do everything I could to get them while at the same time never violating the principle that I would be submissive and would obey her with pleasure.

Dominants have their mindfucks for us, but we submissives have our -- call them "mind blowjobs" -- for them, and they can involve just as much planning. There's nothing unsubmissive about it.

Here are my strategies (none of which involve being unsubmissive, all of which involve being diplomatic):

1. The rule that all the others flow out of is that the dominant should want to do what I'm asking for (or at least be neutral about it) or it won't happen. Therefore, I must practice the Submissive's Art of Persuasion. (It may not work, and I resign myself to the fact that there are certain limits to any BDSM relationship, just like vanilla relationships.)

2. Work on various emotions that all (sane) dominants have: gratitude is one. If I've worked to please my domme, and if she's pleased, then she's in an excellent mood for a request. Getting my domme pleased involves not only doing everything I've been told to do (and if I fail here and there, to show I tried and to be very regretful), but doing something extra to please her. It's better to do this out of devotion and love rather than as a strategy, but motives can be mixed. A surprise gift or surprise act that pleases is very effective. You need to know your dominant well in order to know what pleases.

3. Get the dominant not just pleased, but in the right mood. If the dominant is angry or upset, indicate you're supportive, then wait a bit, then divert her mind to more pleasant thoughts. The more negative the mood, the more reserved and mild you want to be. If you see the dominant's mood brightening a bit, ask a few questions. As the dominant's mood lightens, gradually bring that mood to something playful with a little humor. If you can go so far as to actually become playful together, then the dominant is in the right mood for a request. Geishas practiced this art, although the point wasn't to request something. Actually, I would do this kind of thing with an owner just as a way of trying to be a good submissive. I noticed that it brought her to a mood in which she was open to my asking for things.

4. Avoid wording your request as a request. When the dominant is in the right mood to chat, chat about that wonderful thing you're longing to do without explicitly asking for it. Indicate that you're interested in it, perhaps by asking a question about it, and then another question about it, and possibly a third. And then you might playfully say, "I'd love to know what that feels like."

5. If you've done a real great job of getting the dominant in a playful mood, you may be able to state your request as a request. Beg, but beg with a smile, lightly. In other words, seduce. And if you're playful enough, you won't offend when you say that you really, really, really, really reeeeeeeeelly want that particular thing. If you're at the point that you can whine like a dog and not offend your owner -- hey, you're three-quarters of the way to getting it. You've been humiliated, you've acknowledged your owner's control over you, and you've pleasantly reminded your owner of that fact. In making the request, then, you've actually pleased your owner and strengthened the relationship by reaffirming the power exchange rather than undermining it.

6. Prepare. Keep your desires for this or that in a filing cabinet in your mind. Open the filing cabinet only at the right time. Don't stuff the filing cabinet with too many things -- concentrate on a few things you want most of all. Think about how you might bring up the subject of that thing you want without explicitly requesting it.

7. If what you want becomes more important than the relationship you're in, then you're in the wrong relationship.

This may be hard to believe, but I can be a bit verbose sometimes by going on and on and on about a subject with perhaps too many words and too many observations and to many examples that maybe I could at times edit out but really just can't bring myself to omitting because -- well that's why my dominant once bought a ball gag and said she planned to make me wear it when we went to a BDSM club for the evening. At the time, I really didn't want to wear it. I was an extremely good submissive boy in the hours leading up to our arrival at the club, surprised her with a sensuous foot and leg massage at a prior BDSM event that evening, and was necking with her in the back of a taxi as we drove to the club. I can't say that I was necking with her because I wanted something -- that latex miniskirt she was wearing had a lot more to do with it, but I have to admit that my not wanting that ball gag was also a small part of the reason.

When I asked her if I'd been a good sub and had pleased her, she agreed. And that was just the right moment to beg that the ball gag not go into my mouth that evening, and to say I was really uncomfortable with it, even afraid of it. And she relented. And I never saw that ball gag again. (And now that the relationship is over, I kind of wish I'd gotten the chance to have it on, at least at some point...) Therefore ...

8. ... Be careful what you beg for. You might get it.




RealityFix -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 6:48:39 PM)

Very good clay!

And then there are just those entirely ORNERY Dominants who after all of that, will do EXACTLY the opposite of what all that hard work was aiming for.

Even if spending the night diapered, and in a cage, WASN'T what you asked for!


[;)]




CTclay -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 7:06:18 PM)

Oh RealityFix, ornery doms ain't so hard. That's when you just ask for the opposite of what you want. Simple reverse psychology! I do it with my boss at work all the time. Works like a charm!

Of course, the dominant shouldn't KNOW I'm doing all this work for this end. It should just look natural. I should never let the dominant know what my aim is until just the right moment, and it should seem unconnected with all the buttering up that went on up until that moment. In fact, the dominant should never even guess that I've got these strategies. A sub should seem innocent of all this Machiavellian maneuvering --

In other words, by posting this, I just screwed myself royally ...

I hope you guys realize how much I'm sacrificing to impart these pearls of wisdom to you all. Now if I was just wise enough to clam up...




RealityFix -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 7:10:43 PM)

LMAO..........

I'm beyond ornery that way clay.

I don't do the opposite,I do something totally off the wall.

And yes, you masochistic types are very charming in giving away all of the defenses.

(ps....I have a mind that goes 100 miles an hour continually-I'm always processing and reprocessing-I have one primary motto when dealing with subs and that is this, "keep em guessing")




INSIDEYOURMIND -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 7:14:10 PM)

quote:

I have strategies for getting what I want when owned, and I don't see anything wrong with trying to get what I want at times within a relationship


STRATEGY - a careful plan or method : a clever stratagem b : the art of devising or employing plans or stratagems toward a goal


If you need a strategy to get what you want, it lends someone to assume you are in a adversary relationship.

This without a doubt is a blatant example of topping from the bottom.

I have no issue with my sub expressing things that she may want to experience, good communication is key to any relationship, lifestyle, vanilla, whatever.

I certainly do not want to feel as though my sub has to scheme to get what she wants...........

If you are going to sub to me, please leave your strategies at the door.




lilldarlin -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 7:23:51 PM)

I honestly think that it would be very difficult for me to give myself fully to someone that did not want to know what my need's, want's, fantasies, hopes and fears were. It seems to me that it would not be possible for him to know any other way what was going on in my head.

Just as there is no way for me to know HIS need's, want's, fantasies, hopes, goals, likes and dislikes are. How can I be the submissive I want to be if he does not share these things with me. Unless he talks and shares these parts of himself with me I cannot be what I want and need to be for him. That is unfair to both of us.

This is why I see my ability to find ways to let him know these things about me as a very important part of my role in a relationship with a Dom. It is unfair of either one of us to not share this part of ourselves. Otherwise it wont work like it should between us.

Plus, see I have these very hot fantasies that I would just love to see if real life is as much a turn on as they are in my mind!!!

*grinzzzzzzzzzz*




MistressFire70 -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/27/2004 7:52:37 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CTclay
I have strategies for getting what I want when owned


Oh lord CTclay, the slaves are SO going to take away your membership card for telling all their secrets! LMAO!

In answer to the original question from SWPuno:

Catherine Gross and Vi Johnson are both the slaves of Masters who are "newer" than them. They have perfected the art of "Master, may I suggest a way to do X that you might not have considered, Master, Ma'am?" (This whole topic made for a GREAT workshop!) This kind of thing can work for making requests, too. There are two keys to doing this:

1) Never make the suggestion out of the blue. Always ASK if you can make the suggestion or a special request. Perhaps the question should be: "Master, may I suggest a special reward if I have been particularly good and you are pleased with me at some point in the future, Master, Ma'am (or Sir)?"
2) WAIT FOR THE ANSWER before you continue; WAIT for a yes or no.
a. If yes, say thank you and continue, and try to not make your request too self-serving. You might say: “I think Master might like how I would react to X. I find it very erotic and it turns me on immensely and I know Master likes seeing me this way.”
b. If no, say thank you and then BE QUIET. There’ll be other times to approach them.

Fire




realophelia -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/28/2004 9:31:44 AM)

My Master is interested in my dreams and fantasies. There are times when he will ask me for this information (in detail) and just sort of file it away. Sometimes it will resurface, sometimes it won't.

I rarely make direct requests. Except very occasionally in the heat of passion.

Yours truly,
Ophelia




MizSuz -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/28/2004 9:58:01 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: CTclay


In other words, by posting this, I just screwed myself royally ...

I hope you guys realize how much I'm sacrificing to impart these pearls of wisdom to you all. Now if I was just wise enough to clam up...



HA! I've just spent the last few minutes reading your posts. You are indeed interesting and more than a little entertaining.

Ya know, I don't think I even own a ball gag....

of course this is where it might be best for me not to mention the bit gags, ring gags, inflatable gags, penis gags and dental gags.

But then, I've never been good with knowing when to shut up, either.





MsCameron -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/28/2004 10:05:25 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: CTclay
Dominants have their mindfucks for us, but we submissives have our -- call them "mind blowjobs" -- for them, and they can involve just as much planning. There's nothing unsubmissive about it.

Here are my strategies (none of which involve being unsubmissive, all of which involve being diplomatic):


Hmmmm. I would disagree with you. Being manipulative is unsubmissive.

I truly hate feeling like I have been manipulated into something. If I feel like that, you will not get what you want. In fact, the tables will turn quite quickly.

I expect my boy to know if I am in a mood to deal with a request and to ask in a straight forward manner. In turn, I will take it under consideration.
I also expect him to be "good" because he wants to please me, not as a means to an end.

MsC




subchris04 -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/28/2004 6:05:18 PM)

I am fairly new here so if I am not doing this right let me know. I am submissive and I am owned. For me it isn't getting what I want, its doing what I am suspose to. If there is something that intrests me that I want my Mistress to know I will write about it in my journal. When I write my Mistress reads it. If I have be good and make her proud she may use something I wrote. It is at her discresion what she does, I don't ask for her to do anything that may please me. For me just pleasing her is pleasure enough. She likes to see me happy though, and wants to know my intrests so if something comes up I just write about it and let her decide if and when the time is appropriate.
slave chris




SwPuno -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/28/2004 8:18:17 PM)


Thanks to EVERYONE for the great responses, it has given me some things to think about regarding what kind of relationship and partner I need as well as some great ideas.

From my reading of it I would agree Clay is being rather manipulative and non-submissive and is trying to top from below but I do have to give him credit for putting a lot of thought and work into it [:D].

And the response from B from MemphisDsCouple made both my top and bottom sides go tingly - thanks for the imagery!

Also, to MizSuz, I certainly understand that the top should not be considered or treated as a "life support system for a whip" as you very cleverly put it. And I did not mean to imply that the bottom would constantly request or suggest things, I was wondering about what happens when the occasional idea or concept pops up, though if the sub gets a lot of ideas I can see them becoming frustrated if the top only occasionally incorporates one. I guess they would need to find or be with someone who plays a lot or, as Clay said, focus on the things you really want. I would imagine writing or a journal is another good way to live out, or at least imagine out, such fantasies in the interim. This also brought up a question about scripted scenes but I'll save that for another thread.

Also, it seems that my message came across largely as "how do I get what I want?" type of question. That was I'm sure part of it, but being new to real D/s relationships - something other 2 equal partners dabbling in kinkiness every once in a while - I really was/am just trying to get an idea of how these relationships work in the real world and that was my main purpose. And I do understand a relationship is about both parties having a good time and being satisfied, not just the top "doing" the bottom in some form or another. The suggestions and guidelines you all gave may also come in very handy, however !!

Thanks again.

Puno





topcat -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/29/2004 5:33:27 AM)

quote:

I truly hate feeling like I have been manipulated into something. If I feel like that, you will not get what you want. In fact, the tables will turn quite quickly.

I expect my boy to know if I am in a mood to deal with a request and to ask in a straight forward manner. In turn, I will take it under consideration.
I also expect him to be "good" because he wants to please me, not as a means to an end.


M. Cameron-

I'd agree with all the above, though I'd say I was a bit more tolerant of manipulation than you seem to be, and if fact, when I am aware of being skillfully manipulated, actually can have a certain appreciation of the artisry involved. This assumes that I believe there is an underlying urge to please me, and that the ends of the manipulation are benign.

It is rare (IMX) to find someone who be really clear and honest about what they want, and I am willing to settle for one that if I ask 'why are you doing this?', could answer 'well, sir, to please you of course, but I was also hoping that if you were pleased with me you'd do XYZ later'.

There is a certain level of this in any power exchange (and I see all human interactions as power exchange at some level), and I would rather deal with it on a good faith , good will, good humor level, than deal with it's denial...

Stay warm,
Lawrence




topcat -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/29/2004 5:42:32 AM)

quote:

I am fairly new here so if I am not doing this right let me know.


Midear Chris-

Welcome to the boards!

You are doing just fine, but may I sugest breaking your posts into paragrahs? It make it easier to read.


quote:

For me just pleasing her is pleasure enough. She likes to see me happy though, and wants to know my intrests so if something comes up I just write about it and let her decide if and when the time is appropriate.


I'd say that if she likes to see you happy, to really serve her, you have to be happy, and you have to let her know what would make you happy ( and you seem to have good way to do that built in to your relationship).

Doing things to put her in a mood to reward you is a isn't a underhanded way to deal with things, it's smart, and it's a good form of service all to it's self.

Stay warm,
Lawrence




MsCameron -> RE: Question re ideas, requests from bottoms (12/29/2004 6:00:02 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: topcat

quote:

I truly hate feeling like I have been manipulated into something. If I feel like that, you will not get what you want. In fact, the tables will turn quite quickly.

I expect my boy to know if I am in a mood to deal with a request and to ask in a straight forward manner. In turn, I will take it under consideration.
I also expect him to be "good" because he wants to please me, not as a means to an end.


M. Cameron-

I'd agree with all the above, though I'd say I was a bit more tolerant of manipulation than you seem to be, and if fact, when I am aware of being skillfully manipulated, actually can have a certain appreciation of the artisry involved. This assumes that I believe there is an underlying urge to please me, and that the ends of the manipulation are benign.

It is rare (IMX) to find someone who be really clear and honest about what they want, and I am willing to settle for one that if I ask 'why are you doing this?', could answer 'well, sir, to please you of course, but I was also hoping that if you were pleased with me you'd do XYZ later'.

There is a certain level of this in any power exchange (and I see all human interactions as power exchange at some level), and I would rather deal with it on a good faith , good will, good humor level, than deal with it's denial...

Stay warm,
Lawrence



Topcat,

After I tripped and fell off my soap box, it occurred to me that if it was done skillfully (and you're right) with good will and humour, it wouldn't feel like a means to an end.

I don't usually draw such a hard line. In fact, I was grumpy and cranky and the post came out like that.

Still trying to stay warm :)

Regards,
MsC




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875