RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Master



Message


FrankAr -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 7:54:19 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TopinPa

This is meant in the context of a Master/slave relationship

Since a safe word can’t be used during punishment, which it would obviously defeat the purpose; do you choose to let your slave safe word while you’re disciplining them? If so, what’s the difference? I know there is a fine line between punishment and discipline and this varies for different Masters.



Greetings Top,

I believe that punishment and discipline are the same, both are to correct the behaviour of the female.  Now when I have been with a submissive, the safe word has been in place.  When I am with a slave, there is no safe word, for the slave does know that I am a FM of Gor and she would understand this before we even meet, and thus no safe words.

If you are with a slave and have the safe word, then the slave is mentally going to use it.  She will use it to top you from the bottom, and I do not require this from a female.  Before we meet there is COMMUNICATION of what is going to happen and why.  If she understands all this and then more and then we meet,. she knows that there is no safe word and she accepts the punishment given by me.

Be well.

Frank Ar.




SimplyMichael -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 12:19:19 PM)

You can't beat someone into being a good submissive.  You have to make them CRAVE being good FOR you NOT by making them fear failing.  It is a long slow process, one that isn't a good mask for a lack of patience and or anger issues which is why many love punishing.

Love, caring, patience, and vigilant attention, as well as an understanding of when they are trying are all crucial skills in forming and guiding someone to a better deeper sense of submission.  My lady often thinks she has slipped something by me but I mention it sometimes days later with a touch of disappointment and it does several things.  She knows that she is the center of my attention, that I am watching over her, that sense of security allows her to relax into me and let go of her need to control.  She feels my love and caring for her in how I deal with the mistakes and errors she makes.  I praise her when she does well and again, I try and praise her for things either she didn't notice she did better or things she might think I didn't notice.  Again, all playing back into ensuring she has a sense of my omnipotence in her life which provides security, safety, love, attention, all things submissives tend to feed on.

I have been harsh with her once, I didn't touch her or scold her, I simply cut off every means of contacting me.  Turned out it was a mistake in communication on both our parts and so we apologized to each other but she KNOWS that my attention and love IS contingent on her being my good little girl which is why she is SUCH a very wonderful girl for me.

To ME, being dominant is about leading someone and being the sort of man and creating the sort of nurturing relationship that makes her want to follow and obey me, not because of fear but because of joy.




Alumbrado -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 12:33:24 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TopinPa

That's why I said a safe word would defeat the purpose.
For example: a slave that wasn't used to or didn't like extreme pain might be ready to safe word out....


So would someone who is choking or having a heart attack.

[8|]




slavemaia -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 12:50:00 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SimplyMichael

You can't beat someone into being a good submissive.  You have to make them CRAVE being good FOR you NOT by making them fear failing.  It is a long slow process, one that isn't a good mask for a lack of patience and or anger issues which is why many love punishing.

Love, caring, patience, and vigilant attention, as well as an understanding of when they are trying are all crucial skills in forming and guiding someone to a better deeper sense of submission.  My lady often thinks she has slipped something by me but I mention it sometimes days later with a touch of disappointment and it does several things.  She knows that she is the center of my attention, that I am watching over her, that sense of security allows her to relax into me and let go of her need to control.  She feels my love and caring for her in how I deal with the mistakes and errors she makes.  I praise her when she does well and again, I try and praise her for things either she didn't notice she did better or things she might think I didn't notice.  Again, all playing back into ensuring she has a sense of my omnipotence in her life which provides security, safety, love, attention, all things submissives tend to feed on.

I have been harsh with her once, I didn't touch her or scold her, I simply cut off every means of contacting me.  Turned out it was a mistake in communication on both our parts and so we apologized to each other but she KNOWS that my attention and love IS contingent on her being my good little girl which is why she is SUCH a very wonderful girl for me.

To ME, being dominant is about leading someone and being the sort of man and creating the sort of nurturing relationship that makes her want to follow and obey me, not because of fear but because of joy.


~smiles~ my Master is much like this as well. i obey Him because i truly wish to please Him. When i am punished in any form, i'm sad and don't enjoy it whether it's in the form of pain or anything else. But then i'm not a pain slut and enjoy only a medium degree of pain. But it's all attitude for me. If i'm whipped or strapped and Master is not pleased with me, it's an entirely different experience than when He does so for His enjoyment and pleasure. i've grown past seeking pain for my enjoyment. my focus is on Him, His enjoyment, His pleasure, His will, when i fail and it's an honest mistake, Chairman is very patient and understanding. If it continues then punishment ensues to help me pay more attention. If i'm acting out and being defiant, which does happen sometimes, then there is no discussion and punishment comes. i usually welcome punishment, not because i enjoy it at all, but because it frees my mind of the wrongdoing. Once He has tended to it, i can let it go.
 
As far as the difference between punishment and discipline, well discipline for me is more of a self act. Obedience is a discipline, speaking respectfully is a discipline, exercising regularly, eating correctly, moving gracefully are all disciplines. They remain disciplines - something i need to consciously focus on, until they become habitual - things i do automatically. Then new disciplines are put in place to practice. i see this as being trained to be who He likes me to be and how He enjoys seeing me as well as developing into a more beautiful woman and slave.

In regard to safe wording - ha ha ha - there's no such thing really in O/our relationship. i trust Him to know when i've had enough - whether it's from punishment or pleasure.




Celeste43 -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 6:06:24 PM)

Why would you assume no safe words for punishment? Do you really think that most subs automatically would refuse punishment? Because if so, you're wrong. Most subs are unwilling to use their safeword and risk being accidentally harmed under any circumstance, especially during something as emotionally upsetting as being punished.

Just because you've been put nose on penny in the corner doesn't mean that if you lock your knees (as we automatically do) we won't pass out. It's a common response to locked knees. You do a lot better to call red and drop to the floor under your own control then passing out and hitting your head on a bookcase with resultant trip to the hospital.

Safewords or communication should be used any time they are needed to prevent a bad outcome whether that be diarrhea, fainting, heart attack or crying uncontrollably if the sub has emotional issues.




MadRabbit -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 6:21:05 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TopinPa

This is meant in the context of a Master/slave relationship

Since a safe word can’t be used during punishment, which it would obviously defeat the purpose; do you choose to let your slave safe word while you’re disciplining them? If so, what’s the difference? I know there is a fine line between punishment and discipline and this varies for different Masters.



I view punishment as a tool to achieve discipline and nothing more.

I've found many punishments to use to discourage bad behavior I dont like and most of them wont be defined as punishment when it comes to the realm of fantasy kink. Such as...not talking to someone for a period of time, showing my disapointment, or responding in a harsh tone.

As far as corporeal, I know how to use effectively, but have not been at a point where I felt I needed to use it. I, personally, dont have any issues with using it, but its an "end of the line, you have competely fucked up kind of thing". I hope I never come to a point with someone where I feal I have to actually pick up a paddle and beat their ass to get a point across.

Theortically, if I were to use it, then I would expect them to inform me if something was seriously wrong. But outside of that...nope.




MadRabbit -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 6:24:17 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: proudsub

quote:

Since a safe word can’t be used during punishment,


Why not? If it's not consensual it's abuse in my book.


In my world, if one agrees to be my slave and agrees to my rules, then the punishments come attached with that. There is no way out of the second if one accepts the first...short of ending the relationship.




MasterLDesade -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/19/2007 10:36:46 PM)

Addressed to FrankAr , Discipline and Punishment are two completly different components.....The definition i will not explain to you......The aspect of your " Gorean " proported Mastery , that Chill's me to the Bone is the non-use of a " Safe " word , in your writen hand is a Recipe for disaster , this is a sad inditement of this " Gorean " culture which has no basis in reality and seeks legitimization of  such Fantasy writing's by incorpating said veiw's into a thousand year old plus Traditional B.D.S.M society which is based in Historical Fact and practised right up till the present day . My standards are there in Black and White not formulated by thousand's of " Book Worm's " . 
                                        Regards
                                                      MasterLDeSade




Celeste43 -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 6:46:50 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: PAcpllooking



LOL Ok I think you mean that she would safe out just to get out of punishment?
Well the way I look at safe words is that if she is in distress, or something is going on in her head that really making her freak or something physical or medical is going wrong then she safes out.
Now if she safes out for any other reason, then she is really going to get it.

William


Actually if she safes out because she doesn't believe in corporal punishment and it's your primary way of teaching, then what you have here is a severe lack of compatibility.

If she's agreed theoretically to corporal punishment but safes out, you need to find out why. Are you one of those types who think that punishment is an excuse to break hard limits? Because unfortunately there are a lot of them around.

Or is there so much anger and resentment built up that she cannot respect nor obey you? Because punishing negative emotions just gets you more anger and less respect, what's needed here is honest communication and your ability to apologize for ignoring her feelings for so long and to such a degree that you've lost her trust. And then comes the hard work, changing what you've done wrong so you can slowly work to regain lost trust, love and respect.

But of course beating someone senseless is a lot easier.




RavenMuse -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 7:10:55 AM)

It comes down not to wether it is pleasure or punishment, but rather to the nature of what IS a safeword in the context of an M/s relationship.

With just a sub, the safeword is all to often in the context of "OK I've had enough now and I'm stopping the 'game'"

With a slave... it isn't a game, she has given up ALL her control, placed herself full in the hands of the Master she trusts with her wellbeing. she trusts in My duty of care and the fact I take effort not to HARM what is Mine.

So is there any need for a safeword? IMO it can be useful.... because good I maybe, but I am human and that means there is always that small chance that I miss something, make a mistake.... her having a safeword is just one little safety net.... it isn't "I want to stop" it is an "Oh shit I think I am about to take harm" panic button.

That holds true wether it is for pleasure or punishment... because I am not and would not aiming to harm My girl in either!




TopinPa -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 10:49:49 AM)

This is the first opportunity I've had to respond to all the well thought out answers you've all provided me with. (I was out of town all day yesterday, I just had the chance to look at the thread early this afternoon)
Thank you all for your very well thought out and insightful posts!
LuckyAlbatross thanks very much for all the links, they're very helpful!

Two things I want to make clear that I didn't in the OP; first, the slave to be I'm talking about is young and very inexperienced so just the thought of not having a safe word to her might make up 90% of her punishment. I realize to most subs/slaves pain is enjoyable, to her, not so much.

Also, the people here that posted the difference between discipline and punishment hit the nail on the head. I was very much looking for that clarification.

Everyones reply was very much appreciated as well as any further contributions.




SmokingGun82 -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 10:58:16 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterLDesade

Addressed to FrankAr , Discipline and Punishment are two completly different components.....The definition i will not explain to you......The aspect of your " Gorean " proported Mastery , that Chill's me to the Bone is the non-use of a " Safe " word , in your writen hand is a Recipe for disaster , this is a sad inditement of this " Gorean " culture which has no basis in reality and seeks legitimization of  such Fantasy writing's by incorpating said veiw's into a thousand year old plus Traditional B.D.S.M society which is based in Historical Fact and practised right up till the present day . My standards are there in Black and White not formulated by thousand's of " Book Worm's " . 
                                        Regards
                                                      MasterLDeSade


You know, I'm not sure why Gor/non-Gor came up... but if you'd kindly explain why your observation of a "thousand year old traditional society" is more legitimate than someone's following of Gorean philosophy, and why people who read apparently aren't able to form their own standards, that'd be fantastic.

Of course, since your answer would probably be as ridiculous and wanker fantasy filled as your profile, it probably wouldn't be very useful.

And no, I'm not Gorean... but if your philosophy is ok, then so is theirs. Either it's all ok, or none of it is.






daddysprop247 -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 11:10:23 AM)

actually, i'm not quite understanding the concept of a safeword being in place in a M/s dynamic. that was one of the things i gave up when i agreed to become a slave...there are no safewords, no break glass in case of emergency button.




grlneedstolearn -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 11:16:36 AM)

Even though i'm not in a master/slave relationship i still get punished/discipline (which to us is the same thing), and no i get no safe word with either.




Alumbrado -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 3:00:28 PM)

Either the morgues are full of these 'no safe word' hardcore type subs, or somebody can't tell fantasy from reality.

Again, safewords are for real medical emergencies as well as limits.

And anyone who is thinking of trotting out the old, 'Well, I would just know if they were in real trouble' can also explain what they did with the Amazing Randi's million dollar prize for proven psychic abilities. [8|]





Redoubt -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 6:20:12 PM)

A safeword is there to say No stop, rather than "No.. please No.. oh my god NO!! Oh yesssssss"

If the subject in question is telling you No by using a safeword, is that you have selected a punishment that they do not feel they have the right to be submitted to, by continuing, you really have crossed the line. And as the dominant or master, that is your error in judgement... either by choosing the punishment, or in determining their level of commitment in the relationship.

I would expect a slave in a M/s relationship to understand this, and I would sincerely hope that my understanding of her commitment to the relationship would have been extremely defined prior. And before taking her as a slave, I would also need to be as clear as I could be on my expectations, and her limits. (Please let's not discuss slave limits)

So I would say that my slave would always be entitled to use her safeword, but if she did at any time, not just during punishment that I would consider it a grave overestimation on my part, and my responsibility alone. Either the overestimation of my actions or her level of submission, both of which I am obliged to gauge.

(edited to include I enjoyed SimplyMichael's response greatly)




MasterLDesade -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 7:37:44 PM)

Smokinun82 , Frank states he is "Gorean " i suggest you read it helps clarity in your perspective and would save you angst and confusion in your mind .
My  Traditional Mistress's , Mistress and the Master whom taught her is still teaching and well into his 80's , if one was ask him to name the generation's before himself that taught Traditional B.D.S.M then my direct line go's back how far Smokingun82 , trade secrets handed down the line unbroken . All of the talk on this site you seek knowledge , before your internet whom Stored the Knowledge and how was it taught and to whom was it passed on to in trust , do you know ? No you do not Sir .
 Traditional B.D.S.M has been here time imorial and is the basis of all your talk and interest and without re-above Mr Norman would have had Jack Shit to write about and Fantasize to put his view's in a " Fiction Book " designed for Fiction Reader's . Sadly people whom live a fantasy bring fantasy veiw's to a real world , like NO SAFE WORD'S to be used , oh you have them but are unable to use them , so this is good for B.D.S.M to bring non realist based views into a real world  and then apply them and not  expect ridicule and scorn when  " Ocupational Health And Saftey " rules are discarded and Human Life mean's less  " THAN EGO "  .
Smokingun82 by the way you have addressed me show's your lack of self controll and self disapline and intestinal fortitude , " Note " Respect begets Respect you have been taught none and in your way of verse show a poor understanding of Protocol in the B.D.S.M world and understanding of same .
I am a Pro-Domm Registered in two States as such in the country where i reside , check out my cage , wooden stock's which are made for a female slave and assorted good's , do you want my phone number also my  " Yellow Pages " add's newspaper add's or do you want to see my " A.B.N " number for taxation purposes or Businiess Registration Certificate from the state government .
" Wanker " no sir i do not have to masterbate , thank you for asking but i don't want your attention's in my sex life .
I am not a fence sitter sir like yourself where all is ok , it is not .
                                     Regards
                                                   MasterLDeSade




MadRabbit -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 9:30:56 PM)

Personally, I wont say his post was devoid of self control and self restraint.

In fact, I would say your's was, given the fact that its littered completely with ad homineum attacks and insults.

I would be interested in hearing some kind of sources and legit information about this "thousand year old community" that go past your own self aprondizing posts.

Especially since the recorded history of BDSM and Leather barely goes past the early 20th century.

I would also be interested in hearing about this "established protocol" of the BDSM world that we are so clueless about.

Unforatenely, some of us on the forums are somewhat educated and dont fall for bullshit and misinformation spread by a "Master" claiming the name of a mythical character.

I hate it when the World of Warcraft and Everquest 2 servers are full.




adoracat -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/20/2007 10:42:50 PM)

~~fast reply~~

i'm allowed to use my safeword any time i wish.  punishments for me usually involve thinking about what i've done in error, and writing assignmenats to show that yes, i do understand, and why i am going to endeavor NOT to err in that way again.  Sir prefers to teach me rather than punish me.

i've safeworded a couple of times.  i've been in non-BDSM related pain at the time.  Sir made me comfortable again, and play continued.  i'm also allowed to say "ow" as much as i wish...and Sir decides what he wishes to do about the ow.

kitten, who has only *not* felt safe a couple of times, and those times were not related to Sir, but to old memories.




MasterLDesade -> RE: No safe word for punishment; what about discipline? (8/21/2007 12:39:13 AM)

Madrabbit , if you think slurring my profile whilst  not addressing myself to his person is normal behaviour , then as your responce is to me i:e when addressing another you use the Title they use as in your case Madrabbit is acepted common courtousy and though you show none i will not lower my standards to yours , and continue my letters to you showing you respect as i have from the beginning .
History and or your lack of it . I have given you 1 Link which is a University one so as to correctly present to you the information as to educate you that apart from the well recorded Leather B.D.S.M asociation which rose to record after world war two , late 40's to  early 50's there is recorded history and one such lady was Madame Pompedour 1721 to 1764 , so whom should open there mouth before checking the facts and not all online go to a Libary and use books in the Non-Fiction section Madrabbit just for this simple research .
http://departments.kings.edu/womens_history/pompadou.html
Mythical about Desade well well well , 1740 to 1814 , i dismay at the state of your idiotic statements , once again here is a Link for your further education as well as read these books written by Desade .
Philosophy In The Bedroom
120 Days of Sodom
Justine
Juliette
These larst two published in 1797 Madrabbit .
http://www.litencyc.com/php/speople.php?rec=true&UID=3901
A uni link once again . Now what the Hell have you to say about your ignorance voiced in public and meeting your match , i have no need to speak untruth's  unlike other's .
                                   Regards
                                               MasterLDeSade
 




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625