torchure -> RE: Why do so many in this lifestyle lie about their experience level? (9/17/2007 5:09:59 AM)
|
Hello all, My first post. :) I have a lot of experience with forums and such, but never on here or a BDSM related forum. It does though allow me to know how I approach them. Meaning, I do not and will not post often, though I'll read a lot. Every once in a while though, something will catch and spark, and I'll weigh in with whatever chain of thought is born. So, with that, greetings to all and on with the meat. Short answer: People lie, because it is one of the many things that most people do. It is not limited to this sub-group or that one. In the "West", we live in a culture that not only tends to overlook lying, but actually rewards it. Bush, Trump, Oral Roberts, Ollie North, etc, etc, etc Longer discussion: The whole experience question is an interesting excercise in truth and thought. I will use myself as an example. I desicribe myself to all with whom this is a topic of discussion as extremely new, inexperienced, a n00b, and several other similar expressions. Why? Because that's the truth as I see it. What I would consider my "real" experience is limited to about 5 months with my most recent ex at the beginning of our relationship. For a variety of reasons that aspect of our relationship went away at that point. But, .... What is experience in a larger context? I have none using a flogger on someone. Haven't picked up a single tail except at a renfaire once, and everyone was careful to stay out of my way. (With damn good reason!) I could spend the next three pages listing all the things I haven't done. Yet. ;) On the other hand though, 18 years ago as a young punk, when I took my handcuffs off my belt loops, placed them on my girlfriend in the mall, laid my trench coat over them so as to be somewhat descrete, whispered in her ear, "We're leaving. Now." and lead her out for an afternoon of fun that had her restrained to the bed and spanked. Is that part of the experience? I had certainly taken a dominant position and used some (admittedly very light) forms of play. Well, yes, and no. Yes, it was a single experience. No, I wouldn't then say, "I've been in the lifestyle for 18 years." In my eyes, that would be ludicrous. I could cite other similar incidents throughout my life. I still wouldn't use that to extend my actual experience. At best they're examples of my kink being pretty much life-long. Perception is everything though. Usually the truth is secondary, at best. Simply because truth is subjective. We may find a million people who agree and thus argue that it is truth, but it doesn't make it so. Using religious examples, Christians say that Jesus walked the Earth a little over 2000 years ago, was the son of god incarnate, etc. This doesn't necessarily make it the truth, despite their many numbers. Muslims say that Mohammed heard the voice of Allah. This doesn't necessarily make it the truth, despite their many numbers. The Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster says that the world was built the world using his noodly appendage. This doesn't neccessarily make it the truth, despite its great humor. allyC wrote: It is really disheartening but unfortunately, like any close-knit or even like-minded community of people, there is an overwhelming desire on the parts of some folks to not only fit in, but to be better than the others. Very true. I've seen this in the pagan community for years. Then it occurred to me that this, too, is nothing new. For thousands of years written works were attributed to older, more respected writers because their actual authors did not believe that the work would be respected on its own. I suspect that this is related to why people lie about their experience. Without the added weight of this supposed experience, they don't believe they'll get the respect they are due. Someone else (Apologies, but I didn't note who it was before I started this), mentioned work and resumes. And that person was right. There's another double edged sword there though. Everyone wants experience, but very few are willing to give it. I remember being very frustrated over that fact when looking for a job. Still, I wasn't willing to lie about it to get the position. Same holds true for me in this context. TheIronOrchid wrote: Subs have described me as a "breath of fresh air" and tell me that because I'm so new, I'm not stuck in a rut like many experienced Dom/mes are. Ah, the novice has the edge because they'll try anything, whereas the master's disadvantage is that he knows what won't work so he won't try it. Certainly holds true in some contexts. :)
|
|
|
|