What native American animal are you? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Polls and Other Random Stupidity



Message

Aneirin -> What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 4:26:19 AM)

What native American animal symbol are you?

http://www.whats-your-sign.com/native-american-animal-symbols.html

How accurate do you think it is concerning yourself?

(Mine is very accurate even more so than the traditional zodiac)



twistedwillow -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 4:36:49 AM)

I would agree, thats very much me.

Wolf: Feb 19 – Mar 20
Deeply emotional, and wholly passionate, the Wolf is the lover of the zodiac in both the physical and philosophical sense of the word. The Wolf understands that all we need is love, and is fully capable of providing it. Juxtaposed with his/her fierce independence – this Native American animal symbol is a bit of a contradiction in terms. Needing his/her freedom, yet still being quite gentle and compassionate – we get the picture of the "lone wolf" with this sign. In a nurturing environment the Wolf is intensely passionate, generous, deeply affectionate, and gentle. Left to his/her own devices the Wolf can become impractical, recalcitrant, obsessive, and vindictive.

twisted..wolf



GrrlieGrrl -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 4:42:13 AM)

This is racist.



twistedwillow -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 4:47:31 AM)

umm.. why?
Most cultures have some sort of zodiac or totem belief.


twisted



MRandme -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 4:50:15 AM)

i don't think it is any more racist than the Chinese zodiac, nor more or less relevant than the European one. i'm not sure where racism comes in.

Mine was kind of off. i'm a falcon apparently and it really didn't fit me, except the part about being a team player. i'm more of a wolf, should have been born earlier in the month, apparently.

g



Aneirin -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 4:52:28 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: GrrlieGrrl

This is racist.


Is consideration of the zodiac of any culture racist?

WHY?



GrrlieGrrl -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 5:01:08 AM)

I don't know much about Chinese culture and the Chinese zodiac, but I do know quite a bit about Native American culture and this is the first time I've ever seen anything about an "animal zodiac."  The site makes no reference at all to exactly which of the over 500 distinct and separate Indian Nations that existed this supposed zodiac came from.

This is the first time I've posted anything here.  I did so because racism against American Indians is so accepted that it goes under most people's radar.  This link is just one example of many.



twistedwillow -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 5:08:08 AM)

I still don't see how its racism.
Ok lets say, for the sake of argument, that its fake or incorrect, I don't see anywhere in it that it denigrates American Indians, or reverse racism, I don't see anywhere where it says American Indians are better.
At  worst its a fun bit of hocus pocus, at best its a true part of American Indian mythology.
Neither way is it racist.

edited to add: The site makes no reference at all to exactly which of the over 500 distinct and separate Indian Nations that existed this supposed zodiac came from.  
Ignorance isn't racism its simply lack of knowledge

twisted 



batshalom -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 5:08:38 AM)

I was a little taken aback by it as well. I wouldn't say it's racist ... but I also don't see anything about the people who came up with it or who profits from it. (Are they NA? If so, then I have less of a problem with it.) It's just a bit of fun, no real harm, but on the border of poor taste.



Aneirin -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 5:12:39 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: GrrlieGrrl

I don't know much about Chinese culture and the Chinese zodiac, but I do know quite a bit about Native American culture and this is the first time I've ever seen anything about an "animal zodiac."  The site makes no reference at all to exactly which of the over 500 distinct and separate Indian Nations that existed this supposed zodiac came from.

This is the first time I've posted anything here.  I did so because racism against American Indians is so accepted that it goes under most people's radar.  This link is just one example of many.



Are you Native American or of that descent, if so explain. If not perhaps those on this site who are Native American or descent might like to offer their thoughts on the matter.(I know of two here)

Oh, by the way, this is posted in 'Polls and other random stupidity' for the simple reason it is a bit of fun for any that choose to engage.

Does it actually mean anything?

Hardly!





mya75 -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 5:27:17 AM)

I think the zodiac portions of the site are just to attract Web Browsers....but if you read each category a bit more the site does offer information on spirituality and different cultures.....I guess everyone has their own definition of racism this site definately doesnt meet any of the criteria for mine...[8|] **yes I am part NA**



slaverosebeauty -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 9:20:51 AM)

This is kinda scarry, especially since I am DEATHLY allergic to any form of seafood.... not very accuarate for me.. interesting though....


Salmon: Jul 22 – Aug 21
Electric, focused, intuitive, and wholly creative, the Salmon is a real live-wire. His/her energy is palpable. A natural motivator, the Salmon's confidence and enthusiasm is easily infectious. Soon, everybody is onboard with the Salmon – even if the idea seems too hair-brained to work. Generous, intelligent, and intuitive, it's no wonder why the Salmon has no shortage of friends. This Native American animal symbol expresses a need for purpose and goals, and has no trouble finding volunteers for his/her personal crusades. In a supportive environment, the Salmon is stable, calm, sensual, and giving. Left to his/her own devices, those that bear this Native American animal symbol can be egotistical, vulgar, and intolerant of others



beargonewild -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 10:41:41 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GrrlieGrrl

I don't know much about Chinese culture and the Chinese zodiac, but I do know quite a bit about Native American culture and this is the first time I've ever seen anything about an "animal zodiac."  The site makes no reference at all to exactly which of the over 500 distinct and separate Indian Nations that existed this supposed zodiac came from.

This is the first time I've posted anything here.  I did so because racism against American Indians is so accepted that it goes under most people's radar.  This link is just one example of many.



I would like to clarify something if I may. This site is a watered down version of the Native American Totem Animals. It is no more racist then the book written by Ted Williams titled " Animal Speak" which is a more in depth look into amimal totems and how to find yours and to connect with the Great Spirit.
It doesn't matter which clan or tribe a Native American or Native Canadian is from, animal totems or spirit guides apply to all whether Iroquois, Sioux, Apache, Chippewa, White, Asain  etc. Each clan has their own variations of the animal symbolism yet the basic premises is still the same. On this I know what I am speaking, as I have been following the Native path for many years and count many Shamans and Pipe bearers as friends and as teachers.



ryssa -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 12:41:11 PM)

fairly accurate, though I don't believe I'm two faced or lazy [:)]
 
Deer: May 21 – Jun 20
This Native American animal symbol is the muse of the zodiac. The Deer is inspiring lively and quick-witted. With a tailor-made humor, the Deer has a tendency to get a laugh out of anyone. Excellent ability for vocalizing, the Deer is a consummate conversationalist. This combined with his/her natural intelligence make the Deer a must-have guest at dinner parties. Always aware of his/her surroundings, and even more aware of his/her appearance, the Deer can be a bit self-involved. However, the Deer's narcissism is overlooked because of his/her congeniality and affability. In a supportive environment the Deer's natural liveliness and sparkly personality radiate even more. He/she is an inspiring force in any nurturing relationship. Left to his/her own devices the Deer can be selfish, moody, impatient, lazy, and two-faced.



sambamanslilgirl -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 12:53:54 PM)

Beaver: Apr 20 – May 20
Take charge, adapt, overcome – this is the Beaver motto. Mostly business, the Beaver is gets the job at hand done with maximum efficiency and aplomb. Strategic, and cunning the Beaver is a force to be reckoned with in matters of business and combat. One might also think twice about engaging the Beaver in a match of wits – as his/her mental acuity is razor sharp. The Beaver has everything going for him/her – however tendencies toward "my way or the highway" get them in trouble. Yes, they are usually right, but the bearer of this Native American animal symbol may need to work on tact. In a nurturing environment the Beaver can be compassionate, generous, helpful, and loyal. Left to his/her own devices the Beaver can be nervous, cowardly, possessive, arrogant, and over-demanding.

*weg*

totally 100% true about me and my fiance ...this should make an very interesting relationship and marriage



trappedinamuseum -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 1:31:45 PM)

Wolf: Feb 19 – Mar 20
Deeply emotional, and wholly passionate, the Wolf is the lover of the zodiac in both the physical and philosophical sense of the word. The Wolf understands that all we need is love, and is fully capable of providing it. Juxtaposed with his/her fierce independence – this Native American animal symbol is a bit of a contradiction in terms. Needing his/her freedom, yet still being quite gentle and compassionate – we get the picture of the "lone wolf" with this sign. In a nurturing environment the Wolf is intensely passionate, generous, deeply affectionate, and gentle. Left to his/her own devices the Wolf can become impractical, recalcitrant, obsessive, and vindictive. Click here for more wolf totem meanings.


Racist or not, it described me perfectly.


Lighten up...its a website for goodness' sake.....unless, you fall into the wikitality group, and take everything you read at face value.



sappatoti -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 1:42:20 PM)

My animal, per this site, came up as Beaver. Interesting, since a totem I had done a few years back didn't even have that animal as part of the collection. I guess it's, as so often stated, "for entertainment purposes only."

:)



trappedinamuseum -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 1:48:38 PM)

sappa, I think it describes you pretty well though...I don't think I'd ever want to be on the serious other end of a sparring match with you...



subtee -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 2:00:10 PM)

I have a "yuck" factor also. Yes, distasteful also. I don't believe the OP meant it to be so, in fact, on the contrary, he seems to be showing respect as he characterizes it as "consideration." I respect that consideration and your opinion!

However, this is a for-profit site and gives no citations nor authority to be making the claims it is making. Native American spirituality is not a game or a personality quiz. Those who have taken on animal totems typically do so after years of introspection and in consultation with a shaman or medicine man/woman or tribal leader(s). (Bear would you agree?) I am 1/4 Cherokee, but I mention it only because you asked. Truly, like Bear, I comment because it has interested me and I have learned what I can.




beargonewild -> RE: What native American animal are you? (11/8/2007 2:40:25 PM)

You are right subtee, a shaman could reveal to a person who their animal totem is, though one does have to make a gift of sema to the shaman. A person could seek it out themselves which involves deep meditation and some will do a vision quest or will even fast. Or simply put tobacco down and ask the Creator.
    According to the site mine is Owl: Nov 23 – Dec 21
Changeable and mutable as the wind, the Owl is a tough one to pin down. Warm, natural, with an easy-going nature, the Owl is friend to the world. The bearer of this Native American animal symbol is notorious for engaging in life at full speed, and whole-hearted loves adventure. This can be to his/her detriment as the Owl can be reckless, careless, and thoughtless. Owls make great artists, teachers, and conservationists. However, due to his/her adaptability and versatility – the Owl would likely excel in any occupation. In a supportive, nurturing environment the Owl is sensitive, enthusiastic, and an attentive listener. Left to his/her own devices, the Owl can be excessive, overindulgent, bitter, and belligerent.

Much of this does ring fairly accurate though my actual animal guide is the Wolf and sometimes the Bear



Page: [1] 2 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.078125