EmeraldSlave2
Posts: 3645
Joined: 1/1/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: ProtagonistLily Headaches aside, just what exactly would you propose as critera here? Out of curiousity, would you support castrating the developementally disabled, or perhaps we'll just sterilize all the stupid people while we're at it. I've heard you make some pretty thoughtless remarks, but Em, this one left a crater in it's wake. Lily Like I said, raising a child is different than giving birth to a child. And as I also said, the ETHICAL headaches boggle me. Your question is asking what my ethical boundaries on this would be. The answer is that I'm not completely sure. I've had this exact discussion with many friends many times before because it's something I find fascinating,the drive to procreate, the awful job most parents do, the awful reasons parents usually have for making new babies, from the micro problem of good nutrition to the macro problem of over population. On the one hand we'd like to say that only people who could richly raise children to be fostered individually, who were mature in body mind and spirit, whose wisdom was only matched by their love...and yet you have everyone else, including me, who was certainly not raised by such pristine models. Where would the world be if such reproduction and parenting methods were controlled? Better? Worse? Far too large a problem for me to really even peck at. But I will say that I do not believe someone is a good choice to raise someone just because they have the biological means to do it, and someone is not a bad choice just because they do not have the biological means as well.
|