CallaFirestormBW -> RE: disappointed.... (11/14/2008 12:20:02 PM)
|
Yellowtail, I completely missed the whole issue that he'd made this a 'promise'... I think that's because I hear so many people use the word 'promise' in a different way than I do that I've stopped asking the "Did he really mean 'I promise'?" thing, because unequivocally, the individual on the receiving end tells me that it -was- a promise, and the one who reneged tells me that he never "promised" anything... I don't ask people for promises, because I don't like "leading a person into evil". A promise is a guarantee that something is going to go a certain way, and for me, I don't think that it is honest or feasible to make a -promise- about some future time when one has no control over the future. For me, it feels like -asking- for a promise is asking someone to lie, since xhe doesn't really know what will happen and can't promise on something that doesn't exist. Personally, I don't make promises either -- I let people know that I'll do my best, but that I won't promise. Yellowtail, would it make a difference if he changed his wording so that he made it clear that he would try, but that it wasn't a promise? Would you feel more secure knowing that he loves you, and he'll try to do whatever it is he said that he'd do... but if it doesn't happen or plans get fouled up, at least you'll be secure in knowing that he didn't lie. It was so hard to teach my ex not to make promises to the kids, since there was no way he could guaranteed that, say, 3 hours or 3 months later he'd be in a position to do what he promised he would. I know that, for some people, they want to be able to treat things people say as 'guaranteed'... so taking away the opportunity for the guarantee doesn't work for them, even though it would eliminate the whole issue of unkept promises. For me, though, I think that not falling into that trap of making promises (or extracting impossible promises from someone else) and then failing to keep them helps to alleviate some of that sense of betrayal and underlying dishonesty that can build up in a relationship where one person has a fundamentally more concrete idea of what a 'promise' means than the other's more ethereal or transient perspective. I think your idea of 'promise' is substantially more concrete than your husbands... so eliminating that as a pool of potential issues by not giving or expecting 'promises' seems like it would be a logical first step.
|
|
|
|