RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


pahunkboy -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 8:42:09 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyEllen

Then there is the age old problem of forgery. Anything that can be made can be copied - look what happens with credit cards as they evolve.

If someone else has an ID that has my name and my DNA on it, and their picture, who is the real me?

E


LOL- teh real you is the you that is a corporate entity , not the breathing live you.  ;-0

I seen a docu where someone replicated a UK passport.   easily too.....




kdsub -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 8:51:27 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyEllen

Then there is the age old problem of forgery. Anything that can be made can be copied - look what happens with credit cards as they evolve.

If someone else has an ID that has my name and my DNA on it, and their picture, who is the real me?

E


Why something may not work is very important...at least when developing a product or system...but we would never get anywhere in this world with that type of thinking. Better to think of ways something will work otherwise another innovative species will overtake us. As it is bacteria are pretty close to overtaking us now.

Butch




pixidustpet -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 9:03:36 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: KyttynTheMynx

quote:

ORIGINAL: variation30

you cannot use credit cards/cheques if you don't have an ID. and so on and so on.


Incorrect.  I have used my own credit card and havent had to show ID.  And no, not at the local store around the corner that knows my face.  I have been to big chain stores 3 hours away and used my credit card sans ID.  I have even used my moms credit card (with permission of course) at random stores and not had to show ID.  I dont really know about checks since I have never had to cash one in person at a bank...



while it is not a law that you have to show an ID to use a credit card, and in fact is AGAINST the merchant part of the credit card agreements (its in the agreements that a merchant cannot ask for an ID to verify that a holder of the credit card is who s/he says she is)....

it is STORE policy in some stores to verify ID against credit cards on a random basis, or if the total is above a certain store-specified amount.  the reasoning is that the store can say "well, we matched the ID to the person/name on credit card!" if the person disputes the charge.  it "protects" the store from fraudulent purchases, at least in theory.

checks, most of the time you must show an ID of some sort, even if they know you by name, face, and account number at the store/bank.  same thing, it protects the store from fraudulent charges....and the banks, well, the TELLER might know who you are but joe shmoe back in the bookkeeping office probably doesnt.  it protects them *and* your account.

and the state of texas SUCKS ASS if you move here from out of state.  you MUST get a new licence.  they MAIL you the new state licence with your photo on it.  the old licence is confiscated and you are issued a temporary paper licence.  you are then left without photo id till it comes in.  police officers will take this as an official identity document, but NO ONE else will.

kitten




GreedyTop -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 9:14:21 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyEllen

Then there is the age old problem of forgery. Anything that can be made can be copied - look what happens with credit cards as they evolve.

If someone else has an ID that has my name and my DNA on it, and their picture, who is the real me?

E


I'll vouch for ya, E *grin*




LadyEllen -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 9:19:47 AM)

aww thanks GT! Although of course in my case its purely a hypothetical - after all, there is only one Lady Ellen!

(cause no one else would want to be me LOL!)

E




GreedyTop -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 9:21:30 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: pixidustpet

quote:

ORIGINAL: KyttynTheMynx

quote:

ORIGINAL: variation30

you cannot use credit cards/cheques if you don't have an ID. and so on and so on.


Incorrect.  I have used my own credit card and havent had to show ID.  And no, not at the local store around the corner that knows my face.  I have been to big chain stores 3 hours away and used my credit card sans ID.  I have even used my moms credit card (with permission of course) at random stores and not had to show ID.  I dont really know about checks since I have never had to cash one in person at a bank...



while it is not a law that you have to show an ID to use a credit card, and in fact is AGAINST the merchant part of the credit card agreements (its in the agreements that a merchant cannot ask for an ID to verify that a holder of the credit card is who s/he says she is)....

it is STORE policy in some stores to verify ID against credit cards on a random basis, or if the total is above a certain store-specified amount.  the reasoning is that the store can say "well, we matched the ID to the person/name on credit card!" if the person disputes the charge.  it "protects" the store from fraudulent purchases, at least in theory.

checks, most of the time you must show an ID of some sort, even if they know you by name, face, and account number at the store/bank.  same thing, it protects the store from fraudulent charges....and the banks, well, the TELLER might know who you are but joe shmoe back in the bookkeeping office probably doesnt.  it protects them *and* your account.

and the state of texas SUCKS ASS if you move here from out of state.  you MUST get a new licence.  they MAIL you the new state licence with your photo on it.  the old licence is confiscated and you are issued a temporary paper licence.  you are then left without photo id till it comes in.  police officers will take this as an official identity document, but NO ONE else will.

kitten


I am required, per company policy to ask for ID before accepting a credit/debit card.

Sometimes I don't.

ACtually, USUALLY, I don't.  But that is based on the clientele I usually deal with (Primarily military).

I, as a rule, take my ID in with me when I plan to use my debit card. in this age of identity theft I am often amazed by how many people DO NOT ask for verification that I AM the person to whom the debit card has been issued. 
That may sound hypocritical, but since the USAFB usually makes the reservation (and the guests show up with all the paperwork needed..not to mention theyre usually in uniform w/ nametag),not so much.

IN a retail environment, I would be demanding ID.. why? because *I* do not wish to geet slapped with the charges for fraudulent CC use....

ok, hope that made sense.. I'm sleepy...




GreedyTop -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 9:24:07 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyEllen

aww thanks GT! Although of course in my case its purely a hypothetical - after all, there is only one Lady Ellen!

(cause no one else would want to be me LOL!)

E


Dear Lady...

There is not a soul on this earth that could come within lightyears of being YOU :)

(you realize, of course, with my history, my vouching may be more harmful than good.. so I'd use it ONLY in extremis - thats the right phrase, yes?)




pixidustpet -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 9:32:15 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GreedyTop

quote:

ORIGINAL: pixidustpet
while it is not a law that you have to show an ID to use a credit card, and in fact is AGAINST the merchant part of the credit card agreements (its in the agreements that a merchant cannot ask for an ID to verify that a holder of the credit card is who s/he says she is)....

it is STORE policy in some stores to verify ID against credit cards on a random basis, or if the total is above a certain store-specified amount.  the reasoning is that the store can say "well, we matched the ID to the person/name on credit card!" if the person disputes the charge.  it "protects" the store from fraudulent purchases, at least in theory.

checks, most of the time you must show an ID of some sort, even if they know you by name, face, and account number at the store/bank.  same thing, it protects the store from fraudulent charges....and the banks, well, the TELLER might know who you are but joe shmoe back in the bookkeeping office probably doesnt.  it protects them *and* your account.

and the state of texas SUCKS ASS if you move here from out of state.  you MUST get a new licence.  they MAIL you the new state licence with your photo on it.  the old licence is confiscated and you are issued a temporary paper licence.  you are then left without photo id till it comes in.  police officers will take this as an official identity document, but NO ONE else will.

kitten


I am required, per company policy to ask for ID before accepting a credit/debit card.

Sometimes I don't.

ACtually, USUALLY, I don't.  But that is based on the clientele I usually deal with (Primarily military).

I, as a rule, take my ID in with me when I plan to use my debit card. in this age of identity theft I am often amazed by how many people DO NOT ask for verification that I AM the person to whom the debit card has been issued. 
That may sound hypocritical, but since the USAFB usually makes the reservation (and the guests show up with all the paperwork needed..not to mention theyre usually in uniform w/ nametag),not so much.

IN a retail environment, I would be demanding ID.. why? because *I* do not wish to geet slapped with the charges for fraudulent CC use....

ok, hope that made sense.. I'm sleepy...



made perfect sense to me.  :)

my credit cards are signed with my name and the words "SEE ID".  why?  cause i WANT my ID to be asked for.  make sure you're dealing with ME.  period!  now...its NOT legal tender to have just "see ID" on the back of the card, and not all of the cashiers are bright enough to look at it....

but i'm content when they do.  fewer fraudelent charges are likely to get through to my account that way.

kitten, who about choked laughing at the typo "accunt"




rulemylife -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 4:30:31 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

Gun proponents like to use the...one law will lead to others bugaboo. I believe this way of thinking applies to your arguments.

I’m for the Patriot Act but not it’s abuse…but because there is potential for abuse does not mean all Government actions will be abused as well.

Remember we had enough of the abuses and we kicked them and their kind out of office.

Butch


No, my main opposition to it is that we have a right to privacy and that right is slowly being eroded.

I don't agree with the NRA because I think they take things too far, but I can see the "slippery slope" rationale.

Seat belt laws started out as secondary offenses that you could only be cited for if their was a primary offense, speeding, running a light, etc..  Now many states have made them primary offenses where you can be pulled over and cited just for that.

Drunk driving laws are another good example of overstepping what was an originally good intention.   No one wants to confront a blindly drunk driver driving left of center and heading straight for them.  But what started out as a campaign to eliminate drunk driving has turned into a campaign resembling the pious crusade against alcohol during Prohibition.  We're now told that even one drink is one too many while MADD is trying to yet again lower the legal level of intoxication to .06%.  Which basically means you can forget about having a glass of wine or two with dinner. 

Not to mention the sobriety checkpoints, where absent any probable cause, or even hint of driving drunk, we can be randomly pulled over to prove we have done nothing wrong.  Is this in keeping with your idea of a free society? 

We've had a long history of government agencies overstepping their bounds.  When Social Security was being debated one major concern of opponents was Social Security numbers would be used as a way of government monitoring.  Opponents were assured that the numbers would only be used for their intended purpose.
Do I need to point out how that worked out?




rachel529 -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 4:47:29 PM)

in ohio now you can be pulled over for suspicious behaviour.   my Master has been pulled over 20+ times... for DELIVERING PIZZA.  in a stupid uniform, with a sign on the car.  once, they checked to see if the pizza was hot, as they thought he was breaking into houses.  what right to privacy?  what civil rights?  he hasnt recieved any tickets either.  he called the ACLU.




BlackPhx -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 6:46:55 PM)

There is actually no right to Privacy in our Constitution or the Amendments that make up our Bill of Rights, rulemylife. That unfortunately is the crux, even our bodies are not private, just ask anyone who has had a cavity search.

The closest we come is Amendment 4 to wit:
Amendment 4 - Search and Seizure.  Ratified12/15/1791.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

So basically as long as they have probable cause or a warrant, your right to privacy isn't worth flash paper. The Declaration of Independence unfortunately is not the Preamble to the Constitution so even the Pursuit of Happiness statement ( nebulous as it is) does not give us the right to privacy.

That said..passports issued these days contain RFID chips. RFID chips are used to track packages around the world and even in some bars http://www.infowars.com/articles/bb/rfid_wear_your_chip_or_eat_it.htm and http://www.knowledgedrivenrevolution.com/Articles/200603/20060313_Living_Microchip_Society.htm . Soon they may be used to track us, just as we use them to track our pets, and, IF that happens we will be able to access our bank accounts, computers, cars, etc, though them. A hand held scanner allows the chip to be read and call up information on a database.

Everyone is "up in arms" about Big Brother and National ID cards, but frankly Big Brother has ALWAYS been with us..He looked over our shoulders when we gathered roots and hunted mammoths, She gossiped over the rocks at the river as she did the wash, we toiled in his fields as he took first nights with our brides and we paid him rent, he recorded our births marriages and deaths in a big book held behind the altar, and so on and so forth down through the annals of history.  Heck those of us old enough remember every mother on the block who watched over us as we played. This is but the latest incarnation. We have had to have ID for a lot longer than any of us remember. As civilization became more complex and mobile, it became a necessity. The simplest form was the birth certificate, or baptismal certificate, or failing that the family bible and letters of introduction. Welcome to life in America and many other countries. But it goes all the way back to the first tribal marking and clothing to identify what village and tribe you came from.

It takes a Village.


Yes it is a requirement in most states that you can prove who you are and what your intent is in certain areas. We have always had that with the military, and with most businesses as well. That our proof now comes on little plastic cards, instead of papers is progress. I suspect there is not a one of us here that doesn't log onto his computer, log into his accounts online, by providing a login and password and we think nothing of it. We think nothing of filing our papers with our teachers with our names on them, presenting ID to get food, lodging, etc. We rent apartments and our landlords check our credit history, buy a car and fill out paperwork that carries our information where it needs to go, gert Drivers Licenses and present the information on them to rent cars, get insurance, etc. It is a world where ID is a necessity.

Here's the kicker. There is also not a single one of us who would not pitch a fit, and move heaven and earth to fight against Identity theft. Well that theft becomes even easier if there is No Way for you to identify yourself. You don't have ID, A Social  Security card, etc. it becomes extremely easy for someone to say they are you. If E.R.s did not tag you ( and more and more are using RFID tagged wristbands) anyone could walk in say they were you and use your health insurance information if they have it. You..unlucky person get the bill. How many people have heard of people who have had credit cards, even houses bought in their names by people who have stolen the junk mail in their mail boxes.. or heard of charges to peoples credit cards made by people who clone the card. Please ask me for my ID or something that will verify who I am.. Of course the sales in paper shredders have gone up.

If you are arrested and are convicted and imprisioned, be prepared to have your DNA taken and stored. Check any states registry and you can find out the information on any sex offender and where he lives..does not matter if he has done his time and paid his dues..his life is an open book for any one to read. He's hauled in anytime there is a crime that might match his.

So a National ID card or RFID chip may well be the next step, but often the same people railing against illegal aliens also rail against this loss of privacy. A Privacy we have never really had, just an illusion in smoke and mirrors. We have always been tracked..buy a car..get a license plate, gps in your cars computer brain who needs the transponder look up on the traffic light posts cameras are watching.., we track what is watched on TV, what we buy, where we surf..you want to be off the grid, you literally HAVE to be off the grid..a Hermit and even then Google earth can probably spot you. Talk about annoying.

Someone mentioned innocent until proven guilty, and while that is a presumption by most that it is granted by the Bill of Rights, it isn't. Check back on Amendment 4 about and then glance at these:

Amendment 5 - Trial and Punishment, Compensation for Takings. Ratified 12/15/1791.
No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

Amendment 6 - Right to Speedy Trial, Confrontation of Witnesses. Ratified 12/15/1791.
In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defense.

No where in there is there a presumption of innocence. Ask anyone who has ever been arrested, unless you are released on RoR, you either post bail or sit in jail until you come to trial. There is only a statement that Due Process has to be followed. Now this is a sticky one under Homeland Security as the Patriot Act supersedes and negates Due Process, and Amendments 4-6 in cases where Terrorism or Terroristic acts are suspected. 

That my friends is where the real battle begins.

poenkitten




BlackPhx -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 6:49:09 PM)

That has been a fact of life for 1/2 this country for the past 40 years... if you don't look like you belong...you can get stopped in any ritzy neighborhood for having the wrong car, the wrong accent or many other criteria.

poenkitten




rachel529 -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 6:55:16 PM)

true.  sad, but true. 




Termyn8or -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 8:02:04 PM)

Sorry for the jumpthrough, but here's the deal. I will not carry such an ID and if they put me in jail because of it, when they let me out I will turn right around and turn myself in saying "Hey muthafukers, I still ain't got an ID".

If that is what this country is coming to I would just as soon be in jail.

T




rachel529 -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 8:03:55 PM)

it might come to that... or, what if they put a rfid chip in your body? aint technology great?




Owner59 -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/24/2008 10:16:14 PM)

I think the plan Dearest One has to implant ID chips into each of us makes this thread moot.

As a slavish follower of his Majesty,I`ve already signed up for my ID implant chip.

Both my dogs have them,why not us all?[8|]

<plays scary music>




thishereboi -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/25/2008 5:19:46 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: pixidustpet

quote:

ORIGINAL: GreedyTop

quote:

ORIGINAL: pixidustpet
while it is not a law that you have to show an ID to use a credit card, and in fact is AGAINST the merchant part of the credit card agreements (its in the agreements that a merchant cannot ask for an ID to verify that a holder of the credit card is who s/he says she is)....

it is STORE policy in some stores to verify ID against credit cards on a random basis, or if the total is above a certain store-specified amount.  the reasoning is that the store can say "well, we matched the ID to the person/name on credit card!" if the person disputes the charge.  it "protects" the store from fraudulent purchases, at least in theory.

checks, most of the time you must show an ID of some sort, even if they know you by name, face, and account number at the store/bank.  same thing, it protects the store from fraudulent charges....and the banks, well, the TELLER might know who you are but joe shmoe back in the bookkeeping office probably doesnt.  it protects them *and* your account.

and the state of texas SUCKS ASS if you move here from out of state.  you MUST get a new licence.  they MAIL you the new state licence with your photo on it.  the old licence is confiscated and you are issued a temporary paper licence.  you are then left without photo id till it comes in.  police officers will take this as an official identity document, but NO ONE else will.

kitten


I am required, per company policy to ask for ID before accepting a credit/debit card.

Sometimes I don't.

ACtually, USUALLY, I don't.  But that is based on the clientele I usually deal with (Primarily military).

I, as a rule, take my ID in with me when I plan to use my debit card. in this age of identity theft I am often amazed by how many people DO NOT ask for verification that I AM the person to whom the debit card has been issued. 
That may sound hypocritical, but since the USAFB usually makes the reservation (and the guests show up with all the paperwork needed..not to mention theyre usually in uniform w/ nametag),not so much.

IN a retail environment, I would be demanding ID.. why? because *I* do not wish to geet slapped with the charges for fraudulent CC use....

ok, hope that made sense.. I'm sleepy...



made perfect sense to me.  :)

my credit cards are signed with my name and the words "SEE ID".  why?  cause i WANT my ID to be asked for.  make sure you're dealing with ME.  period!  now...its NOT legal tender to have just "see ID" on the back of the card, and not all of the cashiers are bright enough to look at it....

but i'm content when they do.  fewer fraudelent charges are likely to get through to my account that way.

kitten, who about choked laughing at the typo "accunt"


I used to write "see ID" in the signature spot. It always amazed me how many clerks would look at my sig on the slip and compare it to the card that said "see ID" and hand it back saying "thanks, have a nice day"




pixidustpet -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/25/2008 5:29:11 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BlackPhx
(massive snippage to get to the point i wanted)

If you are arrested and are convicted and imprisioned, be prepared to have your DNA taken and stored. Check any states registry and you can find out the information on any sex offender and where he lives..does not matter if he has done his time and paid his dues..his life is an open book for any one to read. He's hauled in anytime there is a crime that might match his.

poenkitten



i'll amend this to say that (in the state of florida at least, this one i'm positive about) it doesnt matter if you've died.  they still keep your file "open" till you've been dead a year.

it also doesnt matter WHAT you were charged with....or if the charges are false.  knew a gentleman whose niece got pissed off because he wouldnt take her to the mall when she wanted, so she called the police and reported that he molested her.  she was 14 at the time.  her mother didnt want her going to the mall that day.  she recanted once it was obvious that he was going to be in a LOT of trouble....he was sent to prison for over 2 years, is on the list for the rest of his life, and could no longer see his own UM's till they were of age.

there were 5 young men registered in my former neighorhood (jacksonville, florida) who are now branded as sex offenders for life.  their crime?  turning 18 before their g/f turned 17.

i dont know.  while its good to know if chester the molester is moving in across the street, how much is reasonable, and how much is we've perverted the laws?

i lost my purse and driver's licence about 20 years ago and was handed a new driver's licence on my word of who i was, and a bill showing my name and address.  now it would have taken nearly 2 months to get here, taken 2 forms of ID (birth certificate and social security card)....i dont even want to THINK about what its going to take to change it once my name changes again.

i was already told "you have to go to the SS office, change it there, bring back your marriage certificate and the form from the SS office, then we'll take your driver's licence and issue you a new one."  which means, again, that i'll be nearly 2 months with no photo id at all.  i will not be able to write a check, use a credit card, or change the information on my checking account to reflect my name change.  isnt it all wonderful?

kitten, grumpy




pahunkboy -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/25/2008 6:23:38 AM)

hmm, they say to never let the passport out of hand when on foreigne soil.   if real ID becomes a must, then might places "hold for you" your real ID while you are in the store/mall????

that any entering one must...prove real ID, then it is held for you.  but if you then loose it, you may not drive, buy food, or do business.  never agree to be chipped EVER.  the electric impulses in it are too volerable to putting current into the body nerves....they can only chip a few places on the body.   the body then acts as the battery that powers such chip.




pahunkboy -> RE: Real ID, will you carry ID??? (11/25/2008 6:25:16 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: pahunkboy

hmm, they say to never let the passport out of hand when on foreigne soil.   if real ID becomes a must, then might places "hold for you" your real ID while you are in the store/mall????

that any entering one must...prove real ID, then it is held for you.  but if you then loose it, you may not drive, buy food, or do business.   

so this renders you a alien in your own land.   see?  the real ID is a de facto passport to walk down your street.  key word, "your"




never agree to be chipped EVER.  the electric impulses in it are too volerable to putting current into the body nerves....they can only chip a few places on the body.   the body then acts as the battery that powers such chip.





Page: <<   < prev  3 4 [5] 6 7   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.078125