RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


BitaTruble -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:00:31 AM)

quote:

Could please cite WHERE in the FOUNDING documents you read anything about minority rights?


Article 4, Section 2

"The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States."


and..


14th Amendment

"No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."





tazzygirl -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:01:48 AM)

sorry Bita.. meant to put that in as a fast reply

anyways.  i have held to two points here, both of which the OP has seemingly chosen to ignore... points many others have brought up.

the first... law is legislated.. and heavily influenced by religious groups.. like  it or not, just how it is.  those in power now are not about to give up their "religious beliefs" when they have most of the power and the money.  the gay marriage group offers them nothing in compensation... yeah.. politics suck.  and, until DOMA is repealled, no state has to recognize the same sex marriage of any other state.  somewhere along the line, i also pointed out that the Native American Tribes would love to grant same sex marriages... but.. in doing so.. they risk losing federal monies... and again... no state has to recognize the tribes legalizing the marriage...even the one the tribe is located in.

my second point was echoed by LP.  are they fighting over the right to call it a marriage, or, over the rights afforded to them BY the marriage?  what is more important?  because, as much as i hate to say it, the latter wont happen anytime soon.  better to fight for what you can get... ie:  insurance, joint ownership of property, ect... the more it LOOKS like a marriage, the less they can so no its not.




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:07:08 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

quote:

Unfortunately, it's still a fact that a MAJORITY of Christians (and Catholics, Jews, and Muslims) are against gay marriage and therefore bigots. 


Please site your source.

It sounds to me like these outrageous statements are your opinion as opposed to fact. It also sounds like you are full of it.

Prove me wrong. Site your source.


I cited two polls a couple of pages back. That religious folks, in consistent majorities, are railing against gay marriage is nowhere near "outrageous". But, just for fun, a few more I dug up:

Poll in NY mentions notable Protestant disfavor here.

Christians, Catholics and Protestants all registering at 40% or under as far as favoring gay marriage according to a survey here.

A poll specifically on the religious effect of voters on Prop 8 shows clear favor towards enacting Prop 8 (85%) by Evangelicals and born-agains here.




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:09:56 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BitaTruble

Opposing gay marriage, however, does not, factually, make one a bigot since one can oppose gay marriage and het marriage at the same time, so no bigotry. It's like the guy who say's "I'm not a racist! I hate everyone equally!" Technically, he's not a racist!

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

But to say ALL who oppose are bigots is wrong.


Okay. How about "opposing gay marriage makes you one type of bigot though it may not make you one unilaterally across the board"?




sirsholly -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:11:52 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

quote:

Unfortunately, it's still a fact that a MAJORITY of Christians (and Catholics, Jews, and Muslims) are against gay marriage and therefore bigots. 


Please site your source.

It sounds to me like these outrageous statements are your opinion as opposed to fact. It also sounds like you are full of it.

Prove me wrong. Site your source.


I cited two polls a couple of pages back. That religious folks, in consistent majorities, are railing against gay marriage is nowhere near "outrageous". But, just for fun, a few more I dug up:

Pollin NY mentions notable Protestant disfavor here.

Christians, Catholics and Protestants all registering at 40% or under as far as favoring gay marriage according to a survey here.

apoll specifically on the religious effect of voters on Prop 8 shows clear favor towards enacting Prop 8 (85%) by Evangelicals and born-agains here.

I was not disputing that. I was asking Dreamgoddess to provide the source that ALL those who oppose gay marriage are bigots. (post 326)




BitaTruble -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:12:24 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: thishereboi

That's funny, I thought her position was that they were all bigots and should change their views, but maybe I read it wrong.


I never read a post in which she said that Christians (or anyone else) should change their view. I may have missed it though but it wasn't in the quote of her which you provided and there are just too many pages to have to scroll through looking for that particular statement. I'm pretty sure she just doesn't want a religious belief system to dictate the law of the land. I'll leave that up to her to defend or disput though. She may very well want everyone to change their view but that's not realistic. Of course, she does have the word 'dream' in her sn, so who knows?

Look at it this way .. if it's okay to use some Christian bible to make 'one' law, is it okay to use another religious text to make another law? What if Sharia's law had been approved by a Prop 8 like bill. Is that okay because if Prop 8 holds, a door has been opened to allow just such a thing to happen.




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:15:58 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly
I was not disputing that. I was asking Dreamgoddess to provide the source that ALL those who oppose gay marriage are bigots. (post 326)


That's self evident.

It's like crime. Performing even just one criminal act means you are a criminal.

Irmy: I slept with someone for it. Does that makes me a whore?
Kleinmann: [Referring to the money he's holding] This?
Irmy: Just one person. Does that make me a whore?
Kleinmann: Well, no, only by the dictionary definition.

(excerpt from Shadows and Fog)





NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:24:23 AM)

Wait! I've got it!

Let's just call them: "enhanced bias viewpoints".




sirsholly -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:41:28 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly
I was not disputing that. I was asking Dreamgoddess to provide the source that ALL those who oppose gay marriage are bigots. (post 326)


That's self evident.

It's like crime. Performing even just one criminal act means you are a criminal.

Irmy: I slept with someone for it. Does that makes me a whore?
Kleinmann: [Referring to the money he's holding] This?
Irmy: Just one person. Does that make me a whore?
Kleinmann: Well, no, only by the dictionary definition.

(excerpt from Shadows and Fog)


nope...it is an opinion. Not a fact.

As i stated earlier, there are opponents to marriage in general...who feel the institution in and of itself should be abolished. A bigot? Hardly.






BitaTruble -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:43:41 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl
.

the first... law is legislated.. and heavily influenced by religious groups.. like  it or not, just how it is. 


That kind of puts a damper on the whole debate thing, doesn't it? Follow along like sheep because that's how it is? To that I say.. baaaaa.

quote:

those in power now are not about to give up their "religious beliefs" when they have most of the power and the money.  the gay marriage group offers them nothing in compensation... yeah.. politics suck.  and, until DOMA is repealled, no state has to recognize the same sex marriage of any other state.  somewhere along the line, i also pointed out that the Native American Tribes would love to grant same sex marriages... but.. in doing so.. they risk losing federal monies... and again... no state has to recognize the tribes legalizing the marriage...even the one the tribe is located in.


DOMA is in violation of Constitutional law and efforts against DOMA have been tireless. There is a current case pending and I'm optimistic. That said, I was optimistic that Prop 8 would go down in defeat as well, so I'm also a realist and know the fight is far from over.. not to fight at all though, that would be truly sad. That said, two steps forward, one step back is still a net gain on the side of progress.

quote:

my second point was echoed by LP.  are they fighting over the right to call it a marriage, or, over the rights afforded to them BY the marriage? 


I'm bi. I want both! [:)]

quote:

what is more important?  because, as much as i hate to say it, the latter wont happen anytime soon.  better to fight for what you can get... ie:  insurance, joint ownership of property, ect... the more it LOOKS like a marriage, the less they can so no its not.


The latter is already happening. I understand what you're saying though and even those who approve of gay marriage don't all agree on the subject. I'm willing to lose a few battles to win the war though, so I will keep doing what I've done my entire adult life, stump, stuff envelopes, make phone calls, write letters and vote for the opportunity for equal treatment under the law. Short of running for an office to which I would never get elected (cuz of that whole freak, being an out perv thing plus living in Europe) that's about the best I can do other than try to educate with reason, logic and factual citations.

Sometimes the effort is thwarted, but I do try to fight the good fight.




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:52:42 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

nope...it is an opinion. Not a fact.

As i stated earlier, there are opponents to marriage in general...who feel the institution in and of itself should be abolished. A bigot? Hardly.

Oh! I get it! The folks that want to erase the liberty for all people equally....they don't get to be bigots because they're 'equal opportunity bigots'?

[8|]




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 6:54:22 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly
nope...it is an opinion. Not a fact.

And basic linguistics is not an opinion.

Really. That's on par with "god works in mysterious ways" in the special pleading department.




beargonewild -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:01:40 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl

my second point was echoed by LP.  are they fighting over the right to call it a marriage, or, over the rights afforded to them BY the marriage?  what is more important?  because, as much as i hate to say it, the latter wont happen anytime soon.  better to fight for what you can get... ie:  insurance, joint ownership of property, ect... the more it LOOKS like a marriage, the less they can so no its not.


With this issue here in Canada, the answer is both. Let me clarify by saying that even though we wanted to call our unions a marriage; it is more accurate to state that it's the legal definition of the word "marriage" needs to include the union between same sex couples.




sirsholly -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:07:09 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: NihilusZero

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly
nope...it is an opinion. Not a fact.

And basic linguistics is not an opinion.

Really. That's on par with "god works in mysterious ways" in the special pleading department.

Put your money where your mouth is, hon

Show me the stats. Cite the source. Just one where all those opposed to gay marriage are bigots.

If you cannot...then it is an OPINION.

Any by the way...it is an OPINION that i happen to hold for most...so if you are going to yap that i oppose gay marriage, you are wrong.
What i oppose are generalities and blanket statements.




tazzygirl -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:12:22 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BitaTruble


quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl
.

the first... law is legislated.. and heavily influenced by religious groups.. like  it or not, just how it is. 


That kind of puts a damper on the whole debate thing, doesn't it? Follow along like sheep because that's how it is? To that I say.. baaaaa.

quote:

those in power now are not about to give up their "religious beliefs" when they have most of the power and the money.  the gay marriage group offers them nothing in compensation... yeah.. politics suck.  and, until DOMA is repealled, no state has to recognize the same sex marriage of any other state.  somewhere along the line, i also pointed out that the Native American Tribes would love to grant same sex marriages... but.. in doing so.. they risk losing federal monies... and again... no state has to recognize the tribes legalizing the marriage...even the one the tribe is located in.


DOMA is in violation of Constitutional law and efforts against DOMA have been tireless. There is a current case pending and I'm optimistic. That said, I was optimistic that Prop 8 would go down in defeat as well, so I'm also a realist and know the fight is far from over.. not to fight at all though, that would be truly sad. That said, two steps forward, one step back is still a net gain on the side of progress.

quote:

my second point was echoed by LP.  are they fighting over the right to call it a marriage, or, over the rights afforded to them BY the marriage? 


I'm bi. I want both! [:)]

quote:

what is more important?  because, as much as i hate to say it, the latter wont happen anytime soon.  better to fight for what you can get... ie:  insurance, joint ownership of property, ect... the more it LOOKS like a marriage, the less they can so no its not.


The latter is already happening. I understand what you're saying though and even those who approve of gay marriage don't all agree on the subject. I'm willing to lose a few battles to win the war though, so I will keep doing what I've done my entire adult life, stump, stuff envelopes, make phone calls, write letters and vote for the opportunity for equal treatment under the law. Short of running for an office to which I would never get elected (cuz of that whole freak, being an out perv thing plus living in Europe) that's about the best I can do other than try to educate with reason, logic and factual citations.

Sometimes the effort is thwarted, but I do try to fight the good fight.


i so never said not to continue the fight... but pick and choose your battles at this point.  its a long, hard battle.  many groups have battled such before gays.  it doesnt matter to me if gays call it marriage... to me.. a marriage is a union between two people.  two men.. or two women.. fit that bill.  but to rant and rave, speak of picking up arms to get your way, to attack the very people who ultimately hold the ability to stop what you want from becoming a reality... all self defeating actions.  just because something is what it is doesnt always make it right.  just makes it harder to overcome.




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:21:10 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

Put your money where your mouth is, hon

Show me the stats. Cite the source. Just one where all those opposed to gay marriage are bigots.

If you cannot...then it is an OPINION.

Any by the way...it is an OPINION that i happen to hold for most...so if you are going to yap that i oppose gay marriage, you are wrong.

You're being intentionally dense. This isn't about polls. You're asking me to pull out sources that gauge the equivalent of 'proof' that "all pro football players are men" (that's a blanket statement, btw).

Wanting to remove a right from a group of people for ethically reprehensible and insensible reasons is bigotry. You can't just play the "it's just your opinion that a word means what a word means" whenever it suits you to do so.

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

What i oppose are generalities and blanket statements.

Ah. you're one of those weird semantic idealists. To "oppose generalities and blanket statements" across the board you have to oppose reality.

What people with a coherent understanding of that viewpoint would suggest is to oppose blanket statements that do not adequately reflect reality.

Any person who commits and/or embraces a bigoted act is (by definition!) at very least, a 'selective' bigot.

That you would advance a notion that would absolve people of the responsibility to own up to their bigotry because you mischaracterize it as a semantic loophole is disheartening.




sirsholly -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:39:15 AM)

quote:

You're being intentionally dense.


Cite your source. Otherwise it is your opinion that i am dense. Seee...labels!! You do not know that i am dense, in the same way you do not know all who oppose one thing are bigots.

quote:

you're one of those weird semantic idealists

oh for petes sake...i thought i was dense?

Kindly make up yer mind. [8|]




BitaTruble -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:44:23 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl
  but to rant and rave, speak of picking up arms to get your way, to attack the very people who ultimately hold the ability to stop what you want from becoming a reality... all self defeating actions.  just because something is what it is doesnt always make it right.  just makes it harder to overcome.


Is that how I've come across to you? As someone who is ranting and raving? Do I appear or have I said something that leads you to believe that I have attacked or want to attack anyone or that I think doing so will get the job done? I just wrote that the way to win is to use logic, reason, factual citation and education. In fact, you quoted me writing it, so I have no idea how you have drawn that conclusion. I'd chalk it up to a fast reply if you hadn't, in fact, quoted my entire post. I'm stumped, truly, that you hold that opinion of me unless you have confused me with someone else or I'm in some sort of alternate universe!

I would suggest that if you do have me confused with someone else and you're just speaking in general terms, that you not allow the voice of a single person or even a few people to color your judgement on everyone who is fighting this battle for equality under the law. That makes you no better than the ranters and ravers who lump everyone into a single catagory because of the vocal few.

That just smacks of pot, kettle, black to me even when it's wrapped with roses. The only thing different is the delivery system.

The majority of posters in this thread, on both sides of the issue, have put forth reasoned and well-thought out posts and there are only a few who choose a different standard, so the remarks about ranting and raving, in my opinion. are unjustified, uncalled for and do nothing but bring even more divisive words into the fray. What is the reasoning for doing that unless it's to push buttons or stir shit? If you have a problem with a poster send them a private email, or call them out for their words on the forum. People should be held accountable for their words. I stand by mine and when I screw up, I admit it, apologize for it and move on. Most people who read what I have to day probably know that about me. There has been evidence of just those actions by me twice in this thread already when I worded things poorly.

If you actually think I am ranting and raving though, I can't imagine that we will be able to have an effective dialogue.




NihilusZero -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 7:45:53 AM)

All people who choose to not eat meat are vegetarians.
All adults who have engaged in sexual acts with children under 10 are pedophiles.
All married people who have had sex with someone other than their spouse without their spouse's consent are cheaters.
All lottery players are gamblers.
All people who commit bigoted acts or espouse bigoted views are bigots.


All blanket statements. All perfectly jive with reality.
Sure, there are blanket statements that don't:


All masochists have psychological issues that require professional psychiatric help.
All Christians think the world is 6000 years old.
All avid porn watchers are sex addicts.
All Muslims are terrorists.


The barometer by which to gauge whether a premise is factual or not, however, is not simply whether it's presented as a blanket statement or not.




LafayetteLady -> RE: Prop 8 ruling makes me wanna kill people... (5/29/2009 8:04:12 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BitaTruble

quote:

Could please cite WHERE in the FOUNDING documents you read anything about minority rights?


Article 4, Section 2

"The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States."


and..


14th Amendment

"No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."




The 14th Amendment had nothing to do with the FOUNDING FATHERS.  That was the point I was making.  Thank you for proving my point.

There are untold types of "minorities."  And no, not all of them are entitled to protection of their "rights" under the law.  NAMBLA members would be considered a minority, but I doubt anyone is going to come on here and suggest they have the right to do what they do.

The "majority" of christians oppose gay marriage.  Did EVERY christian respond to the poll or are they using a sampling?  Of course they are using a sampling.  Many homosexuals are also christian.  Statistics exist for the purpose of manipulation.

Regardless, I am christian and I am all for gays having the right to marry.  Again, change takes time (and based on 18 pages for the thread, so does understanding).  Nothing happens overnight.  Each small step is a milestone; applaud it and move on to the next step.  There ARE states that allow gay marriage, there WILL be more.

This thread is at a point where the posts are no longer even about gay marriage, but rather about whether the right to legislate should exist (although there is no alternative mentioned other than a "revoloution").

People who are on the same side are having disagreements about the minutae of the issue.  Where does that get you?  No where.




Page: <<   < prev  16 17 [18] 19 20   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625