RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Master



Message


slavejali -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/1/2006 3:56:21 PM)

The situation and dynamics you described are the main differences of commitment levels between online and RT. None of those things could happen in RT....many of the frustration's and dilemma's around the dynamics you are experiencing would be non-existant in RT...I found that being online with Master was one of the most incredibly frustrating times in my life..it felt so surreal in so very many ways.

I'm not meaning to be disrespectful of your relationship, heck Master and I met online, I know the intensity of feelings that can develop and they are very very real, but one thing is missing .."contact"....Contact makes one face the reality of commitment, it grounds and puts into action thoughts and feelings, it makes it "real".....in every way.

Due to the fact, you have been living in this surreal online world for three years with your submissive, which is a very large chunk out of both your lives, having to deal with these situations that just would not occur in real life, its almost being removed from reality for 3 years...and with these situatons occurring....this begs the question...is this really how you want to continue to live your life...and is this how she wants to continue to live her life?

Maybe something else is going on with her....maybe she is coming to those conclusions herself.....

Anyways, just a thought and I wish you both the very best in life

Kind Regards
slavejali




Mavis -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 4:58:25 AM)

i have R/T distance M/s relationship that is supplemented with phone and IM when W/we're not together.  Here is some stuff that works for U/us...

The issue of correcting behavior is solved immediately, so there is never that "when I get my hands on you"  delayed corporal punishment thing.   Never is there any element of sexual or physical punishment used..  i think (for U/us) if used in the online element, it can cause a crossover between fun-n-games-n-sexuality that He can't overide with His physical presence, so it's best avoided, IMHO.   W/we don't cam, i don't spank myself, but i get immediate response to my behavior that is unmistakable.

If W/we're on phone, and my tone gets out of wack, He'll say "Ok,  I'm done here, we've hit unproductive time, Goodbye, sleep well.  ::: click :::   Same with IM,  if things degenerate He will save me from myself by not allowing it to go further, and i know when i have messed up! 

Must point out, these tactics are not for days, they are for that conversation.  It is over for that day or night, but i will get my morning greeting and a chance to note where i spotted my errors creeping in and could have stopped myself, etc.   The idea is to stop a behavior or attitude before it's a run-away train, and to cause me to reflect. Correction, not punishment.

Punishments have been rare, but so effective.   He just withdraws the warm-fuzzy parts of our interaction for a time, until i see clearly how much i'd rather behave in such a way as to give Master the desire to be warm n fuzzy with me.     i'll get my daily greeting, it'll be terse, but i never feel abandoned.. something like "Good morning.  I will be busy today.  Emergency contacts allowed as always, but I will not have time for casual chat.  Text messages only, I will reply if needed. Have a good day."   Something similar for the evening.   This has never gone for more than 3 days even in the most extreme cases.   At some point, withdrawl of the warm fuzzies can cause a broken spirit, and the repair job on that... welp, You don't want it.

The point is to never leave her without a way to contact You in case something dire comes up.  Trust me, she will soon learn what is qualified as important and what is whining from the corner.  The other point is..  how would You react if she fell asleep while You were right there?   If You would leave her on the couch and go up to bed, leaving her to feel guilty when she woke up, do the same online.  Just dump the conversation, and leave her to come looking for You.

Always make the punishment fit the crime.  If she's not using Your time effectively, give her less of it to dink with.  If she's not focusing on You when You talk,  allow her to focus on other things instead, and see how she likes not having You to focus on.  i hate to admit this, but sometimes, we get so confortable in our position, we forget what a treasure we serve, and need to be reminded what life was like before... 

Disrespecting Master/ Dom/ Dommes time and attn could become a huge issue between pairs, BUT..   see if she should get checked for sleep apnea, which untreated, can cause daytime sleepiness that hits every time one sits still.   she could be fighting something physical, and need medical help to overcome it.

Good luck to You both, i hope the suggestions in the replies here give You a good springboard to finding something that works for Your relationship.  




Mavis -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 5:01:34 AM)

OMG,  when i posted the reply above, and went back to the main thread, i realised i was in "Ask a Master"...

i'm sorry people, i hope i haven't committed a huge breach of ettiquette posting a reply in a Masters section.    <blushes>




Varicolored -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 5:18:20 AM)

Sir,

You raise a number of issues, and having gone through a long distance ralationship as a slave for a number of years, I can offer some perspective on this:

1.  At a distance, most punishments aren't going to work.  It's that simple.   You can say do this, or that, and she might do it, but, YOU aren't there.  It can be effective depending on what you do, in the instance, but, over time, all it does is remind that person that you aren't there.  It becomes a cancer that eats away at the soul and heart.

2.  Time apart can be good, if you are clear about why it is happening and why you are doing it, but, here, you have to be deeply thorough in advance.  You can't just skip out, or, as you say, it comes across the wrong way.   Personally, I hated when this happened, as I lived to see her everyday, even if it was only in an email.

3.  "Roleplaying" punishment.   Not sure how you do this...oh, wait...our prison system in the US does this....I get it!  *Laughing*  No.   No.  No.   Punishment has to be immediate and it has to be unpleasant.   Period.   I work as a retail manager (yeah, and I'm a slave, go figure that one) and I know first hand that you have to correct behaviors then and there, not later.  Silence is consent.  Also, if they know you aren't going to follow through, and I think that role playing would fit here, the punishment that you would prescribe is meaningless.

Personally, my solution to your situation would be to find a way to either move to her, or bring her to you.   Period.  Eventually, the distance between you will overwhelm whatever love is there.   It is very hard to exist in a long distance relationship, unless you can see each other relatively frequently.

Just my two cents.

Scott.
 




michaelGA -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 5:21:51 AM)

i've always thought of the "online punishment" thing as such a joke...how could someone be so certain that the punishment is being carried out?




RavenMuse -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 7:06:07 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: michaelGA
i've always thought of the "online punishment" thing as such a joke...how could someone be so certain that the punishment is being carried out?


I don't do online myself Michael but I can answer that one... it is a little thing called trust. It is either there or not and it is either justified or not, but if it is both there AND justified then things will be carried out as directed.




amaidiamond -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 1:23:44 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: RavenMuse

quote:

ORIGINAL: michaelGA
i've always thought of the "online punishment" thing as such a joke...how could someone be so certain that the punishment is being carried out?


I don't do online myself Michael but I can answer that one... it is a little thing called trust. It is either there or not and it is either justified or not, but if it is both there AND justified then things will be carried out as directed.



Would agree with that, and if there is no trust then imo the relationship is pointless anyway, i could not have a D/s relationship, or indeed any sort without it




Larry862 -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 2:38:09 PM)

I read most if not all the replies on this.  The one thing I never heard mentioned is does she have a web cam so you could verify punishment other than emailing letters or whatever?  I had a sub several hundred miles from me.  When she mis-behaved I would make her turn her cam on and do things like putting pins on her nipples for an assigned time.  With the cam you can easily see if she does the task or not and does  it correctly.  This also shows the level of servitude the sub is at.  If she is feeling no connection or attachment she could easily say screw you and be gone.  But if a sub is connected to you and knows she has done wrong she will do as she is told.  Within reason of course.  I mean it has to be physically possible for the sub to do.  But with any punishment I strongly believe the Dom has to make damm sure the sub understands what they did wrong and why its wrong.  It will do no good to punish a sub if she does not understand what they did wrong.  Depending on what they have done wrong I may at my discrection give a warning the first time.  If the behavior in question continues then institute punishment. 




slavejali -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 3:04:33 PM)

quote:


Original Quote: Larry862
The one thing I never heard mentioned is does she have a web cam so you could verify punishment other than emailing letters or whatever? 


I would have to agree with that, if online is your only option, webcam would be a must, at least it takes a little bit of the pure fantasy away.

quote:

 
Original Quote: Larry862
I would make her turn her cam on and do things like putting pins on her nipples for an assigned time. 


but...after I read that, it went back to fantasy for me, why would you use normal sensation play as punishment, how effective can that be...like really?

Addition:
Guess it just comes down to different strokes for different folks..but sitting in front of a webcam while my Master was telling me to put pins on my nipples as a punishment, knowing I'm probably making his c*** hard, knowing how amazing I must look..knowing how much attention he is affording me, just wouldnt be an effective punishment for me..in fact it might inspire me to repeat the error cuz its all just so much fun *grin*




crouchingtigress -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 4:31:04 PM)

I apologize for not getting back to you sooner Canadian Guy, I often check for replies to my posts, this one it seems fell through he cracks because I played a lot of that three word game...lol.
 
I applaud that you are with her for 3 years, you must have found something so deep and nourishing for you, and my heart goes out to you too...how hard it must be to be so far.
 
After reading her thoughts on the necklace you gave her I would not recommend  taking it off, it would be too destabilizing and could send her into a depression from feeling abandoned, (this I think points to a high maintenance sub, and you may want to introduce things to help her gain some independence when you can be more available to depend on in the future) But I think you can threaten to take it off and mean it, because I think she would do anything to avoid it, and if she disobeys she has made that choice.
 
If she forgets you had planned to talk or falls asleep are two different things, falling asleep sometimes cant be helped, but forgetting, is a choice. I would say she has forfeited her privilege to talk to you that whole day. That may feel like you are being punished too and in a way you are, so tell her that, tell her that her actions have created not only the separation but have made your dominance over her something she is in control of.....EEEEK I swear she will hate that.
 
I personally think withdrawal is the most powerful and effective tool in a Dominants arsenal, but only when it is used properly ie:
 
*Tell the sub/slave what the infraction is.
 
*Tell the sub slave that not only are they not getting what they want but their actions are making it so that You are not getting what You want, typically they can live with denying themselves but it is much harder to know they have denied you.
 
*Tell them that their actions were hurtful to you and to the dynamic you are both investing so much of your life energy into, and basically by not holding up her end of the bargain she is cheating herself out of the deeper fulfillment she is craving that led her to find a Master as opposed to a boyfriend.
 
*And lastly set an exact time for the infraction to be over. This differentiates the value of punishment from the something like ignoring her, because that is passive aggressive and childish and the dominant ends up loosing power and trust every time in that sort of scenario.
 
You briefly mention and age difference, might I suggest planning ahead of time for the issues that come up around that, very thoughtfully?  Develop the dyanmic so that she still has her daddy Dom but also begins to come into her responsibility's to you as a woman.
 
This might look like her finding strong women slave mentors, and being held accountable for childish impulses and indiscretions.
 
Reigning in a sub like this is very hard even when you are not far away, and even when you have had years of experience, so I dont envy your task. 
 
You are doing the right thing by asking for help, yet I dont think the boards are enough, you may have to find a live mentor in the leather community, some one with a lot of experience with younger submissives.
 
email me anytime...~Tigress
 
PS in my opinion corporal punishment would be non-effective in these circumstances.



quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress

I think she is looking for more attention, and it is understandable as that she must ache so deeply for you, however you want to get through to her.
 
The thing I would do, is withdrawn my dominance. If she is collared she can either be told to take off the collar or if this would be too destabilizing for her you might not allow her any caps or honorifics, in fact you might make her call you pumpkin or sweetheart. Tell her you no longer control her orgasms if you both practice this, tell her cum as much as she wants, trust me this is a punishment, and it has an effect.
 
Even an hour of with drawn dominance has lasting effects on a sub, and when the time you have designated is up, I would have her beg to be in my service again, listing reasons why she should be considered, and what she plans to differently this time.

Wow, that is excellent.  It sounds like you actually really thought about what I asked, and your answer shows that.  Thank you.
Indeed, she does ache, and I agree that she's looking for more attention and possibly more control.  Providing that online can be tricky, of course.  Withdrawing dominance is an excellent idea.  In fact, in the past, I have mentioned something of the sort and she seemed quite upset by the idea.  I'm glad you've reminded me of this.  I'm going to try it.  She does wear a necklace I bought her with my symbol on it, and she considers that a reminder that she is owned, so in a way it's much like a collar.  I've told her to remove it before and she begged to be allowed to keep it on.  She said that if it comes off, she'll feel like our connection is gone.  I think that was mostly her fear of being without my control and ownership, though.  She knows in her heart that it's only a symbol.  Perhaps I'll consider having her remove it for a short period as a punishment.  Excellent suggestion.  Calling me pumpkin?  Wow, that's a good one!  I'm not sure how that'd make ME feel, probably a bit silly, but I think it would be worth it to watch her squirm.  Orgasm control - definitely.  She sometimes slips up and gets off without being told she can, and feels guilty about that, but I know it's because she loves the control behind the idea of only cumming when she's allowed.  Telling her to cum whenever she wants for a few days would probably be a good punishment.  I may try that. 

How long do you think is suitable for a moderate punishment?  For example, if she forgets we planned to talk (falls asleep, or is lazy)?  If we're both online, and talking, an hour would be enough for withdrawn dominance?  If we'll be apart for  the better part of a day, would a full day be alright?  I ask this because I think when we're together she'll definitely "feel" the withdrawn dominance effects much more strongly.




fastlane -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 4:35:53 PM)

Yawn..after reading two pages I'm going to sleep. Why are you sooooooo long winded?
Short is nice, except below the pants......Say what you mean and mean what you say...in less then 15,000 words, unless you have a publicist.

Please!   Kevin




proudsub -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/5/2006 4:53:08 PM)

quote:

OMG,  when i posted the reply above, and went back to the main thread, i realised i was in "Ask a Master"...

i'm sorry people, i hope i haven't committed a huge breach of ettiquette posting a reply in a Masters section.    <blushes>


Mavis--anyone can post in any forum. Welcome to the boards.




CanadianGuy -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/6/2006 2:16:18 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slavejali
I know the intensity of feelings that can develop and they are very very real, but one thing is missing .."contact"....

is this really how you want to continue to live your life...and is this how she wants to continue to live her life?

Thank you for your post.  You're right, contact is missing.  I haven't been with her since that one single time 9 months ago, which was amazing.  Everything felt justified and true, I was completely enveloped in my own control of her, and in her submission to me, and our love.  Every single thing I'd felt with her was real.  Later, she said that it had been amazing, especially as her first time in real life, but that she had a feeling of being unsure at times.  Not sure if it was totally right.  She said it is because she has little to compare it to.  I can assure her that it IS right, being more experienced, I know it was right.  I've told her that I'll guide her and support her until she's sure it's what she wants.  When I say "it", I mean to dedicate her life to me and come and be with me.  I told her that I'll give her some more time.  She's going to be going to college within a year... but she doesn't know where.  Lots of decisions to start thinking about.  Being apart forever isn't going to work for me.  You're right when you say she's probably contemplating that too.  She doesn't think it'll work long distance for much longer... but she's also not sure where she'll go to college, and if she wants to devote herself to me irl.  I refuse to force her to decide right now.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mavis
If W/we're on phone, and my tone gets out of wack, He'll say "Ok,  I'm done here, we've hit unproductive time, Goodbye, sleep well.  ::: click :::   Same with IM,  if things degenerate He will save me from myself by not allowing it to go further, and i know when i have messed up! 

He just withdraws the warm-fuzzy parts of our interaction for a time, until i see clearly how much i'd rather behave in such a way as to give Master the desire to be warm n fuzzy with me.     i'll get my daily greeting, it'll be terse, but i never feel abandoned.. something like "Good morning.  I will be busy today.  Emergency contacts allowed as always, but I will not have time for casual chat.  Text messages only, I will reply if needed. Have a good day."   Something similar for the evening.   This has never gone for more than 3 days even in the most extreme cases.

If she's not using Your time effectively, give her less of it to dink with.  If she's not focusing on You when You talk,  allow her to focus on other things instead, and see how she likes not having You to focus on.  i hate to admit this, but sometimes, we get so confortable in our position, we forget what a treasure we serve, and need to be reminded what life was like before...

This feels like conditioning - and I strongly believe in that kind of model for modifying undesireable behaviour.  I'm definitely going to consider this.  I believe it's one thing that will work.  You're right - she'll respond if I tell her that the conversation is over, and we'll talk again tomorrow.  Thank you.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Varicolored
Time apart can be good, if you are clear about why it is happening and why you are doing it, but, here, you have to be deeply thorough in advance.  You can't just skip out, or, as you say, it comes across the wrong way.   Personally, I hated when this happened, as I lived to see her everyday, even if it was only in an email.

Personally, my solution to your situation would be to find a way to either move to her, or bring her to you.   Period.  Eventually, the distance between you will overwhelm whatever love is there.

Thank you for your honesty.  The first part of the post which I quoted makes sense to me.  I will make sure I'm thorough when I give her time apart, letting her know why it's happening, and how long it's for.

The second part strikes a chord with me.  Being with her would be so right, I know that.  She hates not having my control around her, gets scared and sad and unsure of herself when she has any control of her own.  She needs and craves to submit so badly it hurts her.  And when I hear her talking like that, I want to protect her and be with her physically.  It is the biggest strain in our relationship.  To imagine not ever having to worry about that particular thing again... that would me so amazing.  We could actually focus on dealing with the other issues, which would be minor compared to that, and in growing our relationship in a forward direction again.

quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress
I applaud that you are with her for 3 years, you must have found something so deep and nourishing for you, and my heart goes out to you too...how hard it must be to be so far.

Your ability to empathize with exactly how I feel is powerful.  I have to say that I respect you for that, and for your well thought out reply... and I don't say that to a lot of people.  Thank you, tigress!  You're very right - it is incredibly hard.  This last week has been nasty, as she pulled away when I gave her the 3 day punishment, and is still distant.  We're used to long daily chats, and some phone and webcam too.  We're doing no more than a few lines of text a day right now.  It feels like even less than it is, even.  Basically I'm just reaching out, making sure she's alright, and giving her a chance to say she's ready to talk.  But each day, she seems (or acts) quite content when I said "okay, I guess I'll talk to you later", because she immediately replies with "bye".  It hurts, having her act like she's not missing me and the control.  At times I do feel like pushing her to open up, but she made it clear a few days ago that she's doing a lot of thinking right now.  I don't know if that's true - I see her online a lot, which means she's chatting and surfing in her spare time.  I can't help but think I'm being manipulated, a bit.  She knows I adore her.  I know it's not all manipulation, because there's certainly something going on.  I really hope it doesn't go much further.  Thursday nights are usually nights where we spend several hours in the evening together, and almost always have a phone call.  Maybe tonight will be the night she's ready to talk.  And of course, in a way, I'm not looking forward to it.


quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress
After reading her thoughts on the necklace you gave her I would not recommend  taking it off, it would be too destabilizing and could send her into a depression from feeling abandoned

Okay, good point.  You're right, she definitely sees it as a symbol of my ownership.  I've told her that it doesn't mean that to me.  For example, if it breaks by accident, that doesn't mean she's not mine.  Or, if it needs to be cleaned, taking it off doesn't ruin our bond.  It's just a necklace.  She made it clear that to HER, it does have meaning, a lot of meaning.  So I told her I respect that it has meaning for her, and told her to keep it on then, unless it needs fixing or cleaning etc.  When she threatened to completely end our relationship during a depressed and very stressful period a few months ago, I told her to take it off.  She said she'd been trying to, and wasn't able to do it.  She undid the clasp but couldn't separate the parts.  Maybe she was just being dramatic, I don't know.  In any case, it has been on for 17 months.  It's just a simple gold chain with my first initial "D" as a pendant.
 
quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress
If she forgets you had planned to talk or falls asleep are two different things, falling asleep sometimes cant be helped, but forgetting, is a choice. I would say she has forfeited her privilege to talk to you that whole day. That may feel like you are being punished too and in a way you are, so tell her that, tell her that her actions have created not only the separation but have made your dominance over her something she is in control of.....EEEEK I swear she will hate that.

Her sleep problem is laziness.  She sleeps 10+ hours a night, doesn't do anything strenuous, and just goes to class during the day.  Sometimes she'll sleep 12 hours, wake up and talk to me for an hour, and then just disappear.  The next day, she'll say she passed out, and that she's sorry.  I don't believe there are any medical issues - she is young, fit, and in good condition other than a touch of depression which comes and goes.  The falling asleep problem has been happening on and off for a long time.  She never fell asleep when we were together... but maybe that's because she was too busy learning how to give head.  :p
 
quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress
*Tell the sub/slave what the infraction is.
*Tell the sub slave that not only are they not getting what they want but their actions are making it so that You are not getting what You want, typically they can live with denying themselves but it is much harder to know they have denied you.
*Tell them that their actions were hurtful to you and to the dynamic you are both investing so much of your life energy into, and basically by not holding up her end of the bargain she is cheating herself out of the deeper fulfillment she is craving that led her to find a Master as opposed to a boyfriend.
*And lastly set an exact time for the infraction to be over. This differentiates the value of punishment from the something like ignoring her, because that is passive aggressive and childish and the dominant ends up loosing power and trust every time in that sort of scenario.

This is more great information, similar to the above posts.  I think I already "know" that stuff, but it's very good to hear it from your perspective.  I'm going to take it into consideration for sure.
 
quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress
You briefly mention and age difference, might I suggest planning ahead of time for the issues that come up around that, very thoughtfully?  Develop the dyanmic so that she still has her daddy Dom but also begins to come into her responsibility's to you as a woman.

Yes, a fair age difference.  I'm going on 31, she's.... not in college yet.  I'll look into the "issues" you speak of.  Perhaps that's for another thread?
 
quote:

ORIGINAL: crouchingtigress
You are doing the right thing by asking for help, yet I dont think the boards are enough, you may have to find a live mentor in the leather community, some one with a lot of experience with younger submissives.

Unfortunately I won't be able to get involved in the community IRL at the moment.  It's going to be online help for now.  But that's okay - you are giving excellent ideas and support.  Thank you so much.




CanadianGuy -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/7/2006 7:37:58 PM)

Update: confronted her today about taking control of the relationship, hurting me, and keeping me away.  She just said she needs more time.  I told her to give me a picture of the chain on her desk, and she refused, saying I'm making too big a deal of it.  So I cut the conversation off.

I feel rather peaceful about it right now, which is strange, because that was a very bad outcome.  I should miss her, be angry, feel insulted - topped by my submissive?  And yet I'm just going to let it go, and see what happens tomorrow or the next day.

If my updates are getting annoying, just tell me, and I'll stop talking about this.




ella4444 -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/7/2006 9:22:21 PM)

This is something that has worked very well as punishment for me that has corrected my behavior.

It is possible to withdraw contact without her being unsupervised. Tell her that she is to write a detailed email to you every day telling you what she has done that day and what she has learned and experienced, but tell her you will not respond to her until you feel she has been properly disciplined.  This allows you to continue to monitor what she is doing, and you can step back in and guide her if it is truly necessary before the punishmet is over. Let her know that you love and care for her, and that is why you want her to write to you every day, but let her know that because she is being disciplined that you will not write back to her until she is properly contrite for what she has done and you are certain she has learned her lesson. 

I'll tell you, it was torture writing to Sir every day, sharing my thoughts, my feelings, what I did for the day, asking my usual questions, etc. and not getting any feed back at all.  And I didn't know how long it would last! By the time my punishment was over, I was extremely contrite and sorry for what I had done.





Greatcornbow -> RE: ideas for punishment of an online submissive (4/9/2006 2:31:14 AM)

Have you tried the FondOfWriting program?

Otherwise IMO if long-distance is to work set up a few strategic webcams so you can be watching her obeying your orders you send her on-line, or enen phone/snail mail.




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875