dcnovice
Posts: 37282
Joined: 8/2/2006 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Musicmystery quote:
ORIGINAL: dcnovice In a letter to the New Yorker (5-31-10), David B. Kanin, adjunct professor of international relations at Johns Hopkins, offers an interesting (to me, at least) perspective on Tea Partiers vis-a-vis the American founders. quote:
The so-called Tea Partiers may portray themselves as heirs to the American Revolutionaries, but they are actually the descendants of those who lost the debate of 1788--in particular, the strain of constititutional opponents who violently resisted federal authority until Washington took to the battlefield against them. American Revolutionaries opposed taxation without representation. These people oppose any taxation at all. Despite their "We the People" T-shirts, the visceral drivers of this fragmented formation are not conservatives striving to defend the Bill of Rights and strictly define constitutional language. They are anti-federalists, opposed to any meaningful central government, hostile to the principles of America's founders, and determined to re-create the loose association of local authorities that fell apart within a few years of its establishment. Thoughts? Is Kanin on to something? Overstating his case? Who are the true heirs to America's founders? dc, I think this is more correlation than intentional similarity. The Teas, after all, complain "liberals don't love America" -- they aren't out to undermine it. They are, as Kanin notes, not the conservative voice they imagine themselves to be, but they are also not purpose-driven to create governance by loose association of local authority either. Rather, these are largely people previously unengaged in the political process sending a reactive message out of frustration, with no real understanding of its consequences and with no real plan to replace what they hope to erase. And, of course, the people who hope to take advantage of their momentum. Well said (as usual), Tim! I think you may have nailed it. In my less charitable moments, the "reactive message" sometimes strikes me as a temper tantrum.
_____________________________
No matter how cynical you become, it's never enough to keep up. JANE WAGNER, THE SEARCH FOR SIGNS OF INTELLIGENT LIFE IN THE UNIVERSE
|