|
willbeurdaddy -> RE: This just in re 0bama0Care (2/1/2011 1:39:54 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: DomYngBlk
quote:
ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
quote:
ORIGINAL: DomYngBlk
quote:
ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
quote:
ORIGINAL: truckinslave
quote:
ORIGINAL: jlf1961
And if the government mandate on Health insurance is unconstitutional, then the requirement to own car insurance falls under the same ruling.
What a disingenuous canard. Owning a car is an activity voluntary to a degree not commonly associated with just living.
Remember, if this stand they can force you to buy asparagus. And Chevies. At times of their chosing.
The whole auto insurance thing is moot anyway..that is state law, not Federal, and states can do anything they want unless preempted.
Missing the point again. The states Require by law that its citizens have Auto Insurance.....No different than a federal mandate to do the same thing with health care.
No, you dont have a fucking clue about the structure of the US. The CONSTITUTION delineates the powers of the Federal Government. If it isnt specified in the CONSTITUTION the Federal Government has no standing to legislate a fucking thing.
The STATES can impose any law that they want as long as there is no valid PRE-EMPTION under Federal Law.
There is nothing in the Constitution that gives the Federal government the power to regulate driving. Therefore the States are free to do whatever they want.
Take a fucking civics course for gods sake.
Ohhh, I guess a better connect the dots for you numbnuts. There is nothing in the Constitution that permits the Federal government to mandate that health insurance be purchased. STATE auto insurance, STATE health insurance mandates are constitutional. FEDERAL mandates for either ARE NOT.
Are you 3? FDIC is a FEDERAL INSURANCE PROGRAM Administered to banks in the STATES! It is not a CHOICE, it is a REQUIREMENT to do business. FEDERAL INSURANCE,,,,,on Individuals and Corporations. The precedence has been set. Get over it.
As for Auto Insurance,,,,,,see if you can follow. I was inferring that the state was taking the role as the Federeal Gov't in applying that to its citizens. No where did I say it was legal or illegal. Compare/Contrast........Did you finish first grade? The law can and most likely would be administerd in fashion to Medicare/Medicaid which are STATE RUN!
You catching on yet? Try reading and comprehension before hitting the reply button bubba
Try twisting yourself into a pretzel over what you claimed re auto insurance and were proven wrong.
FDIC is constitutional under the commerce clause. There are many federally mandated programs are administered by states.
Get thee to that civics class, shitforbrains.
|
|
|
|
