RE: do you truely? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Submissive



Message


leadership527 -> RE: do you truely? (3/29/2011 1:52:31 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins
having thought some more about this and the way alot of you say it's his way, or the highway. what then happens if you are in a loving relationship and you decide that you just don't want to be a full on sub/slave anymore (forgive me as i don't know if it happens or not) but you still love him and want the relationship. is it all over just because you changed your mind?

This is a pressing problem for Carol and I (well, in a distant, theoretical sort of way). The issue is that I cannot think of her as my TOTAL power exchange wife if she disobeys. So if she disobeys, I release her. That's the easy part. But since there's no way in hell I'm divorcing her we're still going to need to figure out "what next". Complicating the issue further is that what we do now is simply a reflection of who we are. It's not a result of agreements, promises, contracts, or any other artificial construct. We cannot "stop" doing it. We've tried. It was tragically amusing. Vanilla, oddly enough, ends up being roleplay. She pretends to be asking questions and I pretend to be providing input. Of course, we both know that whatever input I provide is going to get acted on.

So I'm not really sure what's next. Temporarily I've just settled into the idea that there's nothing next. If she disobeys, then she's my not-TPE wife who obeys a lot as opposed to my TPE wife who obeys always.

Tying into some of your larger concerns, I can tell you that between Carol and I it is the person and the relationship that is first. I want Carol, not "slave Carol". I'll take her any way I need to in order for it to work. Our problem isn't so much that I'm unwilling to release her and then keep her in some other way. Our problem is that neither of us knows what that other way might be. If we ever get into that situation, I'm sure we'll work it out.




needlesandpins -> RE: do you truely? (3/29/2011 2:13:17 PM)

i did debate with myself about starting this thread as i didn't want to offend people by asking personal questions. i've very glad i bit the bullet and greatful to all who have written.

porcelaine, i'm glad i'm not the only one to have got something out of it [:D] makes the posting even better!

needles




needlesandpins -> RE: do you truely? (3/29/2011 2:24:03 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: leadership527

quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins
having thought some more about this and the way alot of you say it's his way, or the highway. what then happens if you are in a loving relationship and you decide that you just don't want to be a full on sub/slave anymore (forgive me as i don't know if it happens or not) but you still love him and want the relationship. is it all over just because you changed your mind?

This is a pressing problem for Carol and I (well, in a distant, theoretical sort of way). The issue is that I cannot think of her as my TOTAL power exchange wife if she disobeys. So if she disobeys, I release her. That's the easy part. But since there's no way in hell I'm divorcing her we're still going to need to figure out "what next". Complicating the issue further is that what we do now is simply a reflection of who we are. It's not a result of agreements, promises, contracts, or any other artificial construct. We cannot "stop" doing it. We've tried. It was tragically amusing. Vanilla, oddly enough, ends up being roleplay. She pretends to be asking questions and I pretend to be providing input. Of course, we both know that whatever input I provide is going to get acted on.

So I'm not really sure what's next. Temporarily I've just settled into the idea that there's nothing next. If she disobeys, then she's my not-TPE wife who obeys a lot as opposed to my TPE wife who obeys always.

Tying into some of your larger concerns, I can tell you that between Carol and I it is the person and the relationship that is first. I want Carol, not "slave Carol". I'll take her any way I need to in order for it to work. Our problem isn't so much that I'm unwilling to release her and then keep her in some other way. Our problem is that neither of us knows what that other way might be. If we ever get into that situation, I'm sure we'll work it out.



this actually made me smile alot Jeff. i'm glad to read that it's like that for you both, that you don't have a clue what will happen. to me that just means that the status quo is working for you so well that it's stops any other thought being able to form. it's good to know though that your basic relationship comes first. in this instance i see no point in sweating what doesn't seem a possible future, for the time being at least if anything.

thank you once again!

needles






littlewonder -> RE: do you truely? (3/29/2011 6:06:38 PM)

quote:

having thought some more about this and the way alot of you say it's his way, or the highway. what then happens if you are in a loving relationship and you decide that you just don't want to be a full on sub/slave anymore (forgive me as i don't know if it happens or not) but you still love him and want the relationship. is it all over just because you changed your mind?


For us yes it would be the end of us.

If one of us one day woke up and said "I don't want to be your Master/slave" anymore", it would be like we were with someone else and not the person we love so much.

I would think he bumped his head or was drugged that his personality so radically changed.

This isn't just a role for us but who we are. I am a submissive personality. He is a dominant personality. The thought that it would suddenly change would just dumbfound me or I'd think he was just faking it the entire time we've been together. If he did he did a grand job!





Ishtarr -> RE: do you truely? (3/30/2011 6:51:05 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins

having thought some more about this and the way alot of you say it's his way, or the highway. what then happens if you are in a loving relationship and you decide that you just don't want to be a full on sub/slave anymore (forgive me as i don't know if it happens or not) but you still love him and want the relationship. is it all over just because you changed your mind?



I used to be and absolutely TPE 24/7 owned slave.

My Master is married to a vanilla woman who was okay with him having a slave.
The decision was made that I would have to obey her in full as totally and perfectly as I did him.

I struggled with that from the beginning, because I never for a second felt submissive to her. Very early on in the relationship I told him this and told him I wanted to leave because I didn't think I could live like that, but he disagreed and told me it would work out in the end.
He forced me to stay, by the power of his will and dominance alone, despite my own fears.
Because I wanted to be with him so badly, and because I literally couldn't walk away from him at that point, I was determined to make it work and obeyed her from a sense of duty to the fact that it's what he commanded of me.
For a while, it worked out pretty well, and submitting to her was just like any other command he gave me that I didn't want to obey: I did it anyways because his dominance was just strong enough to compel me to do so.

However, in the end, mostly because his job kept him away from home so often that I ended up spending about 80% of my time alone with her, and only 20% of my time with him home, in which she -being his wife of 25 years- obviously still came first.

So in the end, the day came that I decide that what I was getting out of the relationship just wasn't worth doing something that made me feel miserable and out of balance all the time anymore.
I still loved him, still wanted to be with him, still needed him, but I knew that he would never be willing to renegotiate the relationship in a way that could make it work for me, so ended up choosing to leave.

By that time his dominance over me wasn't strong enough anymore to compel me to do what he wanted, mostly because I just ended up spending so little time with him, so he found out -as Jeff has mentioned in his first post on this tread- that he couldn't just do whatever the hell he wanted, so despite him trying to pressure me for a long time to stay, I persisted and left.

So yes, in my case, because I changed my mind and didn't want to be a slave to his wife anymore, our relationship was over.

Ishtar




DesFIP -> RE: do you truely? (3/30/2011 7:50:58 AM)

There's no way that I could wake up and say I don't want to live like this anymore unless he changed first. Unless he had a stroke and a personality change as a result. Because only in such a situation would he make decisions that were unhealthy for me and for the relationship.

So yes, if he has a stroke, or gets hit by a car and is  brain damaged, then things would change. Until then, I can't imagine it needing to.




agirl -> RE: do you truely? (3/30/2011 3:04:01 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins

having thought some more about this and the way alot of you say it's his way, or the highway. what then happens if you are in a loving relationship and you decide that you just don't want to be a full on sub/slave anymore (forgive me as i don't know if it happens or not) but you still love him and want the relationship. is it all over just because you changed your mind?

thank you sexyfun25, a good read.

needles


If I no longer wanted to be owned by him then the relationship, as we know it, would be over......and as this is the only way we have ever related to each other neither of us can imagine how we would*be*.

Jeff touched on what we THINK would happen....

quote...
We cannot "stop" doing it. We've tried. It was tragically amusing. Vanilla, oddly enough, ends up being roleplay. She pretends to be asking questions and I pretend to be providing input. Of course, we both know that whatever input I provide is going to get acted on.
unquote

We don't know any other way of being together and we cannot possibly know if either one of us could continue.

agirl










ranja -> RE: do you truely? (3/31/2011 3:16:05 AM)

i consider myself to be owned... sort of... i am His wife
there was a time i considered walking... as He is unfortunately not at all perfect... but then neither am i... and i simply can not imagine where to start without Him
anyway... since He is the boss i always end up doing as He wants, unless i can cleverly manipulate Him into my way of thinking... and on occasion i succeed




MaxsBoy -> RE: do you truely? (3/31/2011 3:33:56 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins
having thought some more about this and the way alot of you say it's his way, or the highway. what then happens if you are in a loving relationship and you decide that you just don't want to be a full on sub/slave anymore (forgive me as i don't know if it happens or not) but you still love him and want the relationship. is it all over just because you changed your mind?


We've sort of had this "problem".  More than once, in fact.  I have to preface this though by saying that a dog pack dynamic is not really like a D/s dynamic, so our response is a little different.

Alpha owns me.  He has for as long as we've been together, and he always will.  On one occasion he briefly decided that maybe he didn't want a slave anymore.  On another occasion, very recently, I decided that I didn't want him to be in charge.  Both times there was a power shift in the relationship, but his ownership of me did not cease because of either shift.  I have acted as his equal once, and his leader another time, but he has never stopped being my owner.

I know that's might be a little hard for some to wrap their heads around.  A pack, as I said, is a bit different.  The authority and power dynamic are a bit more fluid - when he's having an off day I might tale more control and be a bit mkore proactive about making decisions.  On the occasions I just described, Alpha needed a real break from being in charge due to extenuating circumstances (that took some time to build up in both cases) that were driving him into the ground.  So basically my leadership at those times were a service to Alpha, and to the stability of our pack.  In the long term, if the power switch had become long term, it would have been the same.  Sometimes we behave as equal packmates, but that doesn't stop him from being my owner, and me his property.




needlesandpins -> RE: do you truely? (3/31/2011 10:42:07 AM)

thanks very much all!

Maxsboy, it's cool to have had insight from another angle too, thanks.

needles




mysouldesire -> RE: do you truely? (3/31/2011 8:04:42 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins

now i maybe generalising here, but it is how it comes across, but some of the male Dom's just come over as complete arseholes. they seem to have a complete lack of seeing a woman as anything but an object. i get the whole you are my toy to do with as i please, but in some cases there really does seem to be a total disreguard for the woman as an actual person. that she is just a thing to be discarded when the next thing comes along.


I really do think the last dom had regard for me as a person, but not as a woman and I was definately a "plaything." It took me about a year to realize, I was even "ok" with it for the most part.

N's and P's...... you ask an age old question.
I think it might come down to a man's upbringing of what a woman is.




MasterSlaveLA -> RE: do you truely? (4/1/2011 10:16:56 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins

i have seen some people refer to themselves as a slave or as owned and that they lead a 24/7 D/s relationship, therefore what the D says goes no matter what. i'm struggling to understand this concept. as i see it no-one is truely a slave or owned by anyone, you are free to walk away at any time.



Honestly, it's not that tricky a concept to undersand, and LittleWonder has probably indirectly defined it best.

In short, what your'e referring to is a M/s Total Power Exchange (TPE) relationship/dynamic, where one has complete control over the other. Period!  How is this accomplished? Simple...

1.  You have to desire this type of dynamic -- i.e., it ain't nothin' you can fake.

2.  You have to mentally accept this type of dynamic -- sometimes even to a point of leaving yourself no emotional/financial escape.

3.  You have to have chosen the one to own you very, very carefully.  There are no "limits"... the word "no" is no longer an option... you absolutely can (and will) be used in ways you may dislike... your absolute goal should is to be pleasing/useful to your Owner, no matter if you're being used in ways you may dislike -- but ultimately, you must know in your heart that no matter what, you belong to each other -- forever!!!  The two of you are cut from the same cloth... just from different ends.

For some, this is the proverbial "doormat", where for others it is absolute bliss!!!  An important point to remember in this type of relationship/dynamic is:  Just because one can be an abusive tyrant, it does not mean one will be an abusive tyrant -- with "abuse", of course, being defined in whatever manner suits you.

In a way, the mental aspect is akin to being a parent... can you leave and abandon your kids?  Sure.  Would you?!!  It's kinda the same mental commitment.

Hope this helps?!! [:)] 






DesFIP -> RE: do you truely? (4/1/2011 10:21:49 PM)

I will disagree that you have to desire such a dynamic. I had no plans for anything like this, yet over time he just took more and more control and I found myself happier as he did.

Disagee about no financial escape. I have assets. They are mine and he scorns men who steal a woman's home and inheritance or her children's college funds.

Disagree about being a doormat with no thoughts or opinions. I'm supposed to give them, because he knows he is fallible and knows that I'm a smart cookie so it makes sense to use my brains for his best advantage in the exact sense that he has me do the cooking because I'm better at it than he is.

There is no one true way.




MasterSlaveLA -> RE: do you truely? (4/1/2011 10:30:20 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

I will disagree that you have to desire such a dynamic. I had no plans for anything like this, yet over time he just took more and more control and I found myself happier as he did.


You're welcome to "disagree"... I believe one has to desire to belong to another.

quote:


Disagee about no financial escape. I have assets. They are mine and he scorns men who steal a woman's home and inheritance or her children's college funds.


You're welcome to "disagree"... not all have, or for that matter desire the acquisition of, "assets", and when entering a TPE relationship/dynamic, accept they may very well be completely dependent on their Owner.  No mention of "stealing" anything was made.

quote:

 
Disagree about being a doormat with no thoughts or opinions. I'm supposed to give them, because he knows he is fallible and knows that I'm a smart cookie so it makes sense to use my brains for his best advantage in the exact sense that he has me do the cooking because I'm better at it than he is.


You're welcome to "disagree"... but you apparently define "doormat" differently than I do -- I don't define it as an unthinking mute, but rather, one who obeys 100%.

quote:


There is no one true way.


Never stated there was.  My post clearly comes from me and reflects my views... others will offer their own in addressing the OP's question.


*Note:  Your definitions of certain words and/or understanding of certain scenarios within my post are clearly very different.





polyslave4life -> RE: do you truely? (4/3/2011 2:51:35 AM)

Being able to walk away and not doing so is the submission, the more the situation wants to make you walk the more surrender it takes to stay. In my opinion the only choice is to obey, regardless of how insane it seems, it is not for me to know why or decide if it is reasonable or makes sense, actually it may be either of those things and him just wanting to flex his muscles and bask in my submission. Sure life gets in the way at times, if one is suppose to be somewhere at a given time and there is a huge accident and the roads closed..........outside things can get in the way, inside things shouldn't, that is where you have to trust that if it is asked of you then you are capable of delivering, obviously this means he better be sane and know you and also know what he's doing, but making sure that happens is your responsibility not his, once you feel you have made the right choice, no isn't an option. As for you just don't feel like it right now.....sucks to be you




lally2 -> RE: do you truely? (4/3/2011 3:01:31 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins
as the 'slave' can you really tell the difference behind a man that is just a twat, and one who is basically a good guy but can satisfy what you want.


for me its taken a bit of time to recognise twats dressed up as Doms, now i can see them a mile off.  its all about checking their profile, reading into their messages and emails to you and not ignoring the little voice inside youre head thats telling you something doesnt hang right.

i think too often people are so caught up in what they want from BDSM and a Master-figure that they forget to factor in compatibility and personality.

when you eventually find a guy who triggers the slave in you then youll probably find youll be in a relationship where the term slave starts to mean something to you. 

what you read on the net about other peoples feelings and experiences mean nothing to you right now because youve never been there - it seems like so much high pitched noise.  it isnt.





phoenixmoonn13 -> RE: do you truely? (4/3/2011 7:14:56 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: needlesandpins

thank you for answering.

what happens though if you just plain don't want to do something, not because of life getting in the way, but just because you don't feel like it?

needles



if he tells me to i will do it i wouldnt even consider not. however, he knows me extrelmy well and he would not ask me if he knew i was exausted etc as he also wants me healthy etc. but if i jsut didnt feel like it that wouldnt even occur to me.




leadership527 -> RE: do you truely? (4/3/2011 8:31:42 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterSlaveLA
You're welcome to "disagree"... I believe one has to desire to belong to another.
why? Why do you believe desire is so important to this concept of "belonging"?? Carol absolutely desires to be "the woman in Jeff's life" in some form or another. The whole "slave" gig is a big yawn to her... just not relevant to her life.




porcelaine -> RE: do you truely? (4/3/2011 10:09:31 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterSlaveLA

1.  You have to desire this type of dynamic -- i.e., it ain't nothin' you can fake.


i disagree. i think the desire for the dynamic is one of the root causes behind the problems many encounter when attempting to live in this fashion. It isn't the dynamic that should be paramount, but a want for him that exceeds hers to the degree where doing what he says is desired. That's a huge difference. Wanting to relinquish control is markedly different from possessing the ability to live with the consequences of that decision on a continual basis. The desire noted in your original comments does not proceed the want, but is a manifestation of her willingness to live as he prefers.

quote:

2.  You have to mentally accept this type of dynamic -- sometimes even to a point of leaving yourself no emotional/financial escape.


Acceptance often comes in stages. The individual takes steps forward and falls back on occasion. You're basing everything off the "dynamic" which i find a little peculiar, but to each his own. My experience of acceptance and those that i converse with had very little to do with the dynamic, but an internal embracing of their need to yield. That's merely one facet of the larger issue. There's the need to yield to him. And finally what the composition of those pressing factors will honestly imply. It's the way of life that she must accept but that doesn't arrive until the other pieces are firmly in place.

quote:

3.  You have to have chosen the one to own you very, very carefully.  There are no "limits"... the word "no" is no longer an option... you absolutely can (and will) be used in ways you may dislike... your absolute goal should is to be pleasing/useful to your Owner, no matter if you're being used in ways you may dislike -- but ultimately, you must know in your heart that no matter what, you belong to each other -- forever!!!  The two of you are cut from the same cloth... just from different ends.


i agree that ones selection is paramount. i don't subscribe to the idea of limits, but liken them to areas of discomfort. What i've seen in my own walk and noted in those i've mentored is the reality of the first factor and how it impacts everything else. Malleability on challenging subjects is highly influenced by who you're contorting for. What appears seemingly impossible for one can be readily assessed by another. Yet and still, there are those that prefer to have no fly zones in place that consciously seek partners that will permit them. Others pursue the opposite and willingly invite the challenge for a full submersion in the surrender they need.

my thoughts flow back to the Keeper. He's the gatekeeper in my mind and our interaction boils down to a fundamental commitment to the other that's rooted in trust. Without its presence there is no dominance or submission. At best it is theatrical roleplay that will inevitably hit a snag that cannot be surmounted. The goals noted are admirable and easy to articulate when you have the right components in place. It's much harder to put in play when that is not the case. As such, nailing down the first will provide the seeds one needs to generate the rest.

quote:

For some, this is the proverbial "doormat", where for others it is absolute bliss!!!  An important point to remember in this type of relationship/dynamic is:  Just because one can be an abusive tyrant, it does not mean one will be an abusive tyrant -- with "abuse", of course, being defined in whatever manner suits you.


i remember a comment which suggested that every slave is someone's doormat. i have to admit, i find the idea very accurate. At least where i'm concerned. One can look upon it in the negative as something that is horribly trampled upon, or see it in its benevolent light and recollect the invitation and welcoming spirit one senses when it's encountered. For some it is merely a place to wipe ones feet, and others view it as a comforting reminder of home. The latter is the perspective i take on the subject. i have no shame in being His doormat. It's an honorable position to hold.

quote:

In a way, the mental aspect is akin to being a parent... can you leave and abandon your kids?  Sure.  Would you?!!  It's kinda the same mental commitment.


Abandonment and dismantling of relationships is a real factor within BDSM. Candy coating it and providing a comforting fairy tale doesn't diminish the realities that most fail to continue in the manner noted. Nonetheless, there are some that prefer to include an extra layer of protection so to speak, that binds all parties to the relationship on several planes. There are those that don't require such things and they're firm in their commitment to the other and have no reason to believe it will ever alter. Others like myself, prefer the benefits that the impression provides. It is a useful tool and one that instills some measure of calm that i've come to appreciate. Not leaving merely says, he'll do whatever it takes to keep this thing afloat, but he is really we in disguise. We're both in this together and will fight tooth and nail to remain that way.

Namaste,

~porcelaine




MasterSlaveLA -> RE: do you truely? (4/3/2011 12:36:13 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: leadership527

quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterSlaveLA
You're welcome to "disagree"... I believe one has to desire to belong to another.

why? Why do you believe desire is so important to this concept of "belonging"??


A 'nilla does not "desire" to give complete control of their life to another... one interested in bedroom kink does not "desire" to give complete control of their life to another... one who's actively decided to self-identify as "sub" vs. "slave" has done so because they do not "desire" to give complete control of their life to another. 

Can this change, depending upon who they're with?  Sure... but then the "desire" for that "change" becomes present.


quote:


Carol absolutely desires to be "the woman in Jeff's life"... The whole "slave" gig is a big yawn to her


So then the "desire" to be a "slave", giving complete control of her life to another is not there -- for her.






Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875