Aswad -> RE: Mental Health (7/20/2011 4:22:17 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: LadyConstanze Try to put yourself in a position where you stare at the same walls for maybe 10 years or more, wouldn't you be willing to cooperate with wardens and regulations for the tiniest bit of change? We had a tour of the nearest prison back in junior high. The prospect of spending any significant period of time in there, even with normal privileges, was not enticing to anyone. And having spent some time in confinement, though not in jail, I'm pretty sure I would go stir fry crazy in jail after about 3-4 years with full privileges. Cut that down to 6-8 months in solitary confinement. I expect most people would comply. In general, people are trained to comply in that way from childhood, as part of the domestication of the human species, and the vast majority bow readily to authority. Prison plays on both those factors. If you cage a wild animal, most of them will submit after a time if their treatment remains porportional to the desireability of their behavior and the cause-effect relation is within their mental ability to grasp. There are a few exceptional species, and exceptional individuals within species, but that is far from a norm in this regard. One of my aunts has been a prison guard for a few years now, and relates that even the 'hardened' criminals tend to be reasonably compliant overall. This, of course, is also a function of the culture in the prison system, as antagonism can provide a vehicle for resisting the resocialization process (adaptation to life in an institution, like a prison). When allowed to go unchecked, a prison can devolve from a confinement unit to a breeding pit for crime and a battleground between guards and inmates. That's why we take the approach we do up here (well, east north-east, relative to you). The counterexample would be the Soviet prison camps, which spawned the Russian mafia. quote:
Most people would possibly beg and be willing to offer a limb just for anything that's mentally stimulating. Been a while ago that I stumbled over a study regarding education in prisons, the people who got on the education programs (especially for long term prisoners) were eager to comply with orders, less likely to violate rules and regulations just to not lose that bit of mental stimulation. It's an accurate assessment. Education programs, exercise programs, voluntary labor and so forth are effective in pacifying inmates and easing the transition back to outside life when their sentence has been served. Adapting to a life away from society is more productive for all parties than having no life to live at all. And speaking of begging, I imagine it would probably be a pretty interesting form of edge play, too. quote:
it also seems to be pretty much like torture If you don't provide a life to live, albeit behind bars, it is. quote:
I was still pretty shaken because I never experienced anything like that. I honestly can't imagine a worse place and that was only a holding cell. Finding worse is trivial. But it is a valuable experience, in terms of insight into the scale of the prison experience. People who are calling out for longer sentences without having spent any time in a cell carry no weight with me. Ignorance may be excused, as with children, but it's not a basis on which to grasp justice, or protect society. Nice to see someone argue with first hand experience under their belt for once. Health, al-Aswad.
|
|
|
|