DomYngBlk
Posts: 3316
Joined: 3/27/2006 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: gungadin09 quote:
ORIGINAL: LillyBoPeep http://news.blogs.cnn.com/2011/07/26/valedictorian-sues-school-was-she-snubbed-because-of-race/ that blog talks a bit more about the school's position, but they are choosing not to talk much because of the impending litigation. i can believe, though, that black students were discouraged from taking "difficult classes," because it very nearly happened to me at my high school. an old guidance counselor recommended to me and several other kids i knew that we not take biology in our freshman year because it would be "difficult;" we should instead take general science. well taking general science made it REALLY hard to qualify for a program that made scholarships easier to get. you had to take a specific 4-year track, and if you didn't take biology your freshman year, you were kinda screwed. i didnt listen because i rarely listened to guidance counselors, but a few of my friends did -- and these weren't dumb kids, these were kids who had been straight-A through middle and junior high school, kids who had always been at the top of the class. a few of them DID listen, unfortunately, but you know, when i asked white friends about it, they NEVER got that advice. nearly all of the kids who did were black. Lilly, that REALLY sucks. when i talked to my mom about it, she said that even when she was going to that school, that same guidance counselor (he was pretty old by the time i met him, yep, and he "retired" a few years later) had done similar things to kids in her classes, too. things like that CAN happen for generations, and when the people who are complaining are black people who no one cares about anyway, do you seriously think anyone listens to those complaints? i don't like the one-sided angling of all the articles on this, but i also REALLY don't like the willingness for people to act like things like this don't happen or they "would've been reported by now." they are being reported but people say "oh you're just playing the race card" when you're not. i believe it still happens. i just don't believe that the article demonstrated that it happened THIS time. It still may have, but the article did not make a good case, in my opinion. being valedictorian is important to people. you may not really understand why, but it takes a lot of really hard work (this student took boatloads of AP classes and worked her ass off to get her GPA) -- there's a such thing as a salutatorian, you know -- a title given for the 2nd highest GPA. why not use that for the white student? honestly, if it was the other way around, i'm sure that's how it would've gone. there would be no "co-valedictorian" for a white student. =p i really don't see anything wrong with going back and setting the record straight. she DID have the highest GPA. it's no different than going back in a baseball record and putting an asterisks next to someone's record to show that that person was later found to have used drugs; records are corrected all the time; there's nothing "prima donna" about it. What i'm trying to say is that i would like to make that judgement based on the facts, and i don't think we heard them all. That does NOT mean (and i thought i said this earlier, but maybe not)... that does NOT mean that if we were to hear all the facts, that they wouldn't prove your point, namely, that the facts might not really show that she WAS discriminated against because of race. She may well have been. But i can't determine that based on the information the article provides. i did not mean to say, she's definitely wrong and the school's right. i mean to say, it's wrong to judge the school based solely on these articles, which are presenting a biased view of the story, and it seems to me that too many people are doing just that. At my school, there were multiple valedictorians. i'm not sure how they were picked. If it could be shown that this school always names person with the highest GPA as valedictorian, and that in this case they changed their policy, that would be strong evidence against them. i just wish i knew that for a fact. pam Fuck that.....your nose could be in that particular pile of shit and you'd still say it had a hint of rose in it. Just admit what you are bitch
|