Anaxagoras
Posts: 3086
Joined: 5/9/2009 From: Eire Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: farglebargle quote:
ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras quote:
ORIGINAL: farglebargle quote:
You stated before you accepted the common stance of ultra-orthodox Jews who are very strongly against the existence of Israel. CITATION REQUIRED. You're going to have to support that claim. LOL you stated it on at least two threads in the last few months, at least one of which was deleted. Many I am sure will recall you said the existence of the state was a sin against God's will as exemplified in the Torah. If you pretend you didn't then it won't help your cred! You also said similar religious BS about having full responsibility at the age of 13 when the issue of the Pope joining Hitler Youth at 14 was debated. So you have no citation to support your assertion that I, in your own words "stated before you accepted the common stance of ultra-orthodox Jews who are very strongly against the existence of Israel" As I said the last thread on Israel in July, which is now deleted, contained your assertions in the first few pages of the thread which I replied to and a discussion on the Torah ensued. If any of the mods read this perhaps they can confirm what I said is true? Besides which you actually confirmed what I said was true with this post: quote:
ORIGINAL: farglebargle ...and that I do believe that the State of Israel is doomed, since the Messiah hasn't come to us yet. quote:
Thank you for clarifying the fact that you made an unfounded assertion for everyone. I accept your apology and don't hold your "bearing false witness" against you, since you eventually told the truth. Wrong again, your very post on this thread quoted above indicates you hold the views I reminded you of. Besides which I wonder where you "interpreted" that I apologised? quote:
I *knew* when I called "bullshit" on your claim, you'd fold faster than Superman on laundry day. See, I don't call for Israel's destruction. I call for the Government of Israel to abandon its stupidity and embrace our cherished democratic principles. A written constitution. The Rule of Law. Equality Under the Law. One Human, One Vote, etc.... I *remarked* that the current situation is doomed, yes, that is true, but you really needed to stretch to get to me calling for it's destruction. Call it "Reformation" if you will. A ratification of a true constitution by all the administrative districts... We were talking about ultra-orthodox Jewish opinion (specifically Neturei Karta) being pro-Palestinian on the deleted Israeli thread. You went along with their hardline views about Israel, stating that Israel was against God's will. You are turning this thread off-topic with bullshit about the place. Seeking a one-state solution, as Islamists do, is essentially calling for its destruction. There is some discrimination due to the conflict but Arabs largely have equality in Israel. Arabic is one of only two official languages. Arabs have the vote and stand for election. A few Arab MKs have called for Israel's destruction in the Knesset but that is a topic for another debate so I'm sure we'll be chatting about that yet again.
< Message edited by Anaxagoras -- 8/31/2011 4:00:36 PM >
|