RE: I renounce Christianity (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


Iamsemisweet -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 8:02:03 AM)

Read Christopher hitchens's amazing book, God is Not Great. It is an amazing defense of atheism. Not that atheism needed any defending.
A couple of years after writing it, the author was diagnosed with esophageal cancer. He continues to write articles about his atheism, in the face of his impending death. A true foxhole atheist.




TreasureKY -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 8:04:05 AM)

Cheri,

Not to attempt to persuade you, but to perhaps give you further insight for your journey, I'm going to give you an outline of my own beliefs.

I don't profess to have any great understanding or insight.  I consider myself a Christian, but I don't think I'm a particularly good one.  I grew up in a fairly religious environment, but I honestly had trouble understanding or agreeing with the things I was taught.  What I came to understand may not be correct.  It might not be perfect or able to withstand debate... but it is what I am able to believe.

God created man and gave him free will.  Free will to choose what to believe.  Free will to choose right from wrong... good from bad.  God could have created man with no choice.  We could have been kept like ignorant pets... unable to think what he did not wish, do what he did not want us to do, living out our lives with the sole purpose of praising and worshiping Him.  But I don't believe God wanted that. 

Why, you ask?  I don't know.  Do people have children with the idea that they will always do as the parents want... live their lives how the parents feel would be best... exist for the sole purpose of serving and revering the parents?

Maybe some do.    But, to me that sounds pretty boring. 

As an aside, although I can't (of course) say what Heaven is like, I personally doubt it is the idyllic setting where all we would do throughout eternity is sing praises to God.  What a bore that would be!  For man and for God.  If God wanted that, he could have created that to begin with.

So, man was given free will.  Like anything that begins perfect, once flaws are introduced, it can never be quite the same.  Original man (Adam and Eve, if you will) made a choice.  Some feel that the forbidden "apples" was a set up, but I think that in order for there to be true free will, there had to be temptation... there had to be an alternative choice.  Original man took that choice.

I don't think every child after that was born "sinful", but I think the concept is that every child born was born into a "flawed" world.  You cannot maintain perfection in a contaminated environment.  Our world became "contaminated" not with our free choices but with our poor choices... our mistakes.  And to be truly "free" will, there had to be the possibility of suffering consequences.

Ever play a computer game in "God mode"?  It's where your character cannot die.  No matter what you do, you aren't negatively affected.  You can face any danger, battle any demon, explore any realm without worrying about suffering any damage.  You always win.

It's great for a while.  But then it becomes boring.  The challenge is gone.  There are no risks, so there aren't any rewards.

If you could choose your risks... limit your consequences, it might help a little.  But in the end, it still wouldn't be the same as if you'd faced all the dangers on your own, without a safety net.  You'd not be able to finish knowing that you'd survived on your own skills and abilities.

I've digressed a bit, but having an understanding of the purpose for "bad things" happening in this world helps me to understand God, as well as the concept of prayer.  So many look at prayer as if it were a "get out of jail free" card in the game of life.  I don't think it is, though sometimes it might manifest itself that way.

If you have children, it's a bit easier to understand the dilemma faced when your child asks you for help.  There is the desire to save your child from every hurt and discomfort.  But there's also the knowledge that sometimes the hurt serves a greater purpose.  It isn't that we enjoy seeing our children suffer, but we know that if we were to swoop in every time they made a mistake or a bad choice, they wouldn't develop the ability to avoid those mistakes in the future.  They would become dependent upon us and would miss out on the satisfaction of knowing they "won the game" on their own merits.

There are also things outside of our control.  When your child is crying because a beloved pet dies, you wish you could spare them the grief and bring the pet back to life.  When they come home afraid of the classmate who bullies them, you wish you could make the bullying stop.  But you can't.  Our world has such things as death and bullying because we have free will.  Not just us, but every other man and woman.  We live in an environment where we must live with not only the consequences of our own actions, but of the actions of every other person who lives or has lived.  Good consequences and bad consequences.

But God could control these things... it's not beyond His power.  True.  But if God were to swoop in and save us from the consequences of living, He would be mucking with free will.  Interfering with the world we have created.

I do believe that occasionally God will answer a prayer and "lend a hand"... just as occasionally, as a parent, I will step in and "save" one of my sons from some misfortune.  I can't do it always, but when I'm able and I see that it will give them something beyond just a material rescue... a renewed hope and a brighter outlook, I will help.

Well, this is just how I see things.  I hope your journey brings you to a place of comfort and peace... where ever that is for you.

Treasure




tazzygirl -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 9:09:56 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SuzeCheri

quote:

I hope you come to a sense of closure to your questions.
I pretty much have TJ, this thread was created because it seemed people wanted to debate my conclusions, and I didn't want to mess up LadyP's thread any further.


You seem to believe I wanted to debate this. There is no debate. I said discuss. They are different.




tazzygirl -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 9:18:35 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SuzeCheri

And there you go with irrelevancies, I have answered you over and over, and I have no intention of repeating myself.

Now it is your turn to answer some questions. Why does evil exist?






You would have to determine what evil is first to be honest. What is evil to our society may not be to anothers. Eating human flesh, to us, is evil and psychotic. But to the Korowai , its not evil or reprehensible... its just natural.




tazzygirl -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 9:24:40 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SuzeCheri

Thank you LadyP, I do appreciate all you've said.One thing in particular stood out, this part.
quote:

My best guess is that it really is all part of some kind of plan that hopefully something good will come out of it in the end.


This is an important point really, if it is part of a plan, then that means God wanted it to happen, and that is incompatible with the doctrine of free will. And without the excuse of free will, the blame falls squarely on the shoulders of God, which doesn't mesh with being good and just.




It is man who told you god was good and just.

It was man who told you being a lesbian was wrong.

It was man who has always decided good and evil.

As far as the "plan" goes... ever thought the plan was to design us and watch how we grow on our own?




tazzygirl -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 9:26:41 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SuzeCheri

quote:

unlike your thread seeking an answer to a very difficult issue she appears to want someone to simply argue with her about a decision that she has already made and has no intention of changing even if God brought her friend back to life.
Not quite the way it is. I made a post on her thread, I didn't try convince anybody of anything, and people wanted to argue with me, to try convince me to change my mind. In order to stop that from ruining her thread, which was on a very real and difficult issue, I created this thread so those people, like you, who wanted to tell me I was wrong could do so, and her thread would carry on without the interruption.

It is interesting how many will call it "just argument for argument's sake" when they start it, and cannot convince the other person of the correctness of their position. It is as if you only call it debate if the other person is convinced by your arguments.



Umm.. I wasnt arguing with you, dear. In fact, I pointed out that I was not. And since it was my posts you transferred from the other thread... be a woman and come right out and say it.




tazzygirl -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 9:29:53 AM)

quote:

So the question could be: Why did God invent evil?

Just a thought .....


Ying yang.... free will to chose which path you wish to follow....




Real0ne -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 9:42:11 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SpanishMatMaster

2. I said religion without morality, not society without morality. Learn to read.

Goodbye



the problem is that you always will go back if for no other reason by definition in the final analysis morality is your beliefs and of course your belief is your religion regardless what you want to label it.

Atheists hate it that atheism is in fact a religion.

To the best of my knowledge it was never taught that God in person physically did anything however God can be seen in the hearts of men where all acts visible to man are either of God or of the evil counterpart as can be seen through the acts of man.  <-- that is very difficult to cover all the bases in a one liner.

The problem is however that all law is built on this premise and you can argue forever that is not God, its secular and the Christian can  correctly argue that its God and not secular.  However theology will take you beyond secular humanism and all the subconstructs since most of this originated there in the first place.

That is a circle I do not bother running.

I asked her some very serious and specific questions illustrating the flaws in her logic, of that should have illustrated them.

She cannot explain her position. She chooses to err not on the side of caution moving forward before having reasonable answers to her own questions.

My purpose was not to argue the matter to convince her of anything as much as to point certain matters out with that respect as I am now.   Its her choice and she after all has to live with it and I am not here to convince her otherwise on such a complex matter as this. 

However I believe most people accept that damn the torpedos full speed ahead works well for heros, and of course most heros wind up dead in the process.

You may want ot capture the scope of morality and place it in its own litttle box, however others have also laid claim to it for their box.  now what?

How are you going to convince anyone that your claim is any more valid than there claim?

morality is no more detachable from religion,than life is detachable from living and I do not see anyway of getting around it.

btw firm treasure and edwin those were excellent posts.




StrangerThan -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 10:15:28 AM)

This is one of those threads I look at and think, ya know, stay away. You been there, know the thought process, the sometimes intense dislike or at least intense need to disassociate, and you know that anything coming across is, whether it's intended that way or not, somewhat antagonistic.

Because I do know the thought process. For me, culmination occurred around the age of 18, though the process had been building for several years prior to that. You were raised Catholic. I was raised Pentecostal Holiness. Think... fundamentalist and all the bad stuff that can go along with it. I will say though, we never had the snake thing going. All the rest? Pretty much.

I started working, full time, at the age of 13 just to keep from going to church. I volunteered for the Sunday shifts, even for split shifts to avoid both morning and night services. I left home at 16, intending to hit up the military as soon as I could. In the details of that however, was something I didn't think about - namely needing parental permission at 17 to sign up. That's how I ended up with Pentecostal on my dog tags. My mom was insistent, and I had to have her consent.

So be it. Amen.

I left for boot camp 2 days after graduating high school and by the end of it, my dog tags read NONE next to religion. I didn't go home again for a long time. Maybe 6 or 7 years and that was to visit. It was 10 years before I moved back, and probably 20 before I stepped into another church. I didn't go because I wanted to go to church. I went because someone got married.

I was the bastard you didn't want to meet during that time if you were an evangelizer or proselytizer. I know a lot of people get bitter. I wasn't. I was just adamant. I threw a couple of pastor types off my porch, one figuratively, the other literally. After that one, I stopped them at the property line and said, wanna talk, talk from there. Another step means you're trespassing.

So what brought me back? Nothing that will make sense or matter, but mostly if you want to know, it was outgrowing the need to disassociate long enough to be able to look at both life and religion rationally in the sense of what they mean to me.

I can tell you though. The first step was to get off the blame game. God wasn't responsible for the things that happened in my life. People were. Learning that the Bible itself is a historical document that details the emergence of a people and a belief system was part of it too. Belief systems are just that. In denouncing one, you're adopting another. That means in terms of proof, what you have is your belief. To others, what you believe can and often is, meaningless.

What you sound like you are, is angry. I can understand that. I can understand needing and  finding things to blame. I can understand questioning all the things the church told you, cause I been there and half what they said doesn't make sense. What does make sense to me is that in looking at a historical document, it becomes pretty clear that once Jesus stepped into the arena, God pretty much took a hands off approach. I figure, he gave me a brain, two hands, two feet, and the will to see things through. Past that, if I need him, I'll holler. Other than that, I do believe he'll let me fuck up, fuck off, be an idiot, or just be what I can be all day long, cause in the end, it's me I have to answer for, and no one else.

There, I believe I've talked more about religion in the last two days, than I have in the last two years. What you won't find is me trying to talk you into coming back or convincing you that you're wrong. You are no more right, nor any more wrong than anyone else.

And by the way, God never really established himself as a loving god. Jesus is the one who pretty much brought that concept to earth, and a great many of his teachings were related to how we treat each other.

Later.





GreedyTop -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 10:21:36 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SpanishMatMaster

quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata
For the sake of crimson piscine creatures, neither religion nor spirituality require belief in a "God." [:D]

For the sake of Tutatis, Christianity does [;)]. This is funny! Your turn! For the sake of... the Knights of the Square Table? Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!



I already liked K, but now adding SMM to my list of liked folks :)




SpanishMatMaster -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 11:16:21 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Real0ne

quote:

ORIGINAL: SpanishMatMaster

2. I said religion without morality, not society without morality. Learn to read.



the problem is that you always will go back if for no other reason by definition in the final analysis morality is your beliefs and of course your belief is your religion regardless what you want to label it.


1. There is no problem.
2. I though I said clearly that I am not really interested on discussing with you.
3. Morality is not the same as beliefs. The belief in astrology, that Elvis lives, in UFOs or in the meaning of dreams does not belong to the morality of the most people which uphold it.
4. Beliefs is not the same as religion. The myth, the hierarchical structure, the rites, cosmogony and the theology are parts of a religion (not of all, but fundamental parts when they have them) and they are not part of its morality (even if they are related to it, of course, religion being a system and not a arbitrary set of components). On the other way, marxist, humanist, legalist or even taoist moralities are not religious. And some religious (few, but I can think on some examples like some kinds of deism) have no morality at all.
I am sorry if you disagree with the English language, but that is truly not my problem: consult the Merrian Webster or the Oxford Dictionary. I stopped reading your message at that point and I think I will stop at all reading you. I do not think that it helps neither of us to anything, so ... it is a waste of time for us both.

I set you on "hidden". I hope you understand. Neither of us wants to lose their time. I have been warned about you and I guess they were right. Best regards and good luck.




kalikshama -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 11:59:08 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Hillwilliam

Entering this one late but I will only add this (for now).

Christianity in and of itself is a great idea. The teachings of christ are the teachings of a truly good person and he should be emulated (possibly like Buddha?).

The problems occur when Christianity becomes organized. These organizations tend to lose sight of their goal of making mankind a more moral beast and slip to the goal of pure unadulterated POWER.

Religion is a force for good. Organized religion (which Jesus warned against) is where the evil comes in.


This pretty much sums up my thoughts on Jesus.




kalikshama -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 12:00:21 PM)

SpanishMatMaster,

Welcome to the forums!

[sm=welcomewave.gif]

Best,

KK




SpanishMatMaster -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 12:06:04 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kalikshama

SpanishMatMaster,

Welcome to the forums!

[sm=welcomewave.gif]

Best,

KK
Thank you, from the heart.




FirmhandKY -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 12:08:30 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SpanishMatMaster

quote:

ORIGINAL: Real0ne

quote:

ORIGINAL: SpanishMatMaster

2. I said religion without morality, not society without morality. Learn to read.


the problem is that you always will go back if for no other reason by definition in the final analysis morality is your beliefs and of course your belief is your religion regardless what you want to label it.


1. There is no problem.
2. I though I said clearly that I am not really interested on discussing with you.
3. Morality is not the same as beliefs. The belief in astrology, that Elvis lives, in UFOs or in the meaning of dreams does not belong to the morality of the most people which uphold it.
4. Beliefs is not the same as religion. The myth, the hierarchical structure, the rites, cosmogony and the theology are parts of a religion (not of all, but fundamental parts when they have them) and they are not part of its morality (even if they are related to it, of course, religion being a system and not a arbitrary set of components). On the other way, marxist, humanist, legalist or even taoist moralities are not religious. And some religious (few, but I can think on some examples like some kinds of deism) have no morality at all.
I am sorry if you disagree with the English language, but that is truly not my problem: consult the Merrian Webster or the Oxford Dictionary. I stopped reading your message at that point and I think I will stop at all reading you. I do not think that it helps neither of us to anything, so ... it is a waste of time for us both.

I set you on "hidden". I hope you understand. Neither of us wants to lose their time. I have been warned about you and I guess they were right. Best regards and good luck.

Damn.  This guy is smart.  He's got R0 pegged and handled in one thread! [:D]

Firm




Hillwilliam -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 12:51:02 PM)

I dunno, Firm. Figuring out wtf RO is thinking is like nailing jello to the wall.




Kirata -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 1:02:52 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: FirmhandKY

Damn. This guy is smart.

Give him time. [:D]

K.




ChatteParfaitt -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 1:27:08 PM)

Interesting discussion so far, and I am very much appreciating that it *is* a discussion (as opposed to a set of random name calling diatribes).

I, personally, do not see the need to correlate a rejection of Christianity (or all organized religion) and a rejection of God.

Do I think God is an old dude with a long white beard sitting up in "heaven?"

No, I do not. That is a very fundamentalist construct based on mankind's presumptions about who and what God is. He is never described as such in the actual Bible.

I think Cherie, this is a time to perhaps accept the message (JC's philosophy of "Love God as you love yourself" will live on for many more centuries, I am thinking) but feel free to reject the messenger (your organized religion of choice).

I am as far away from a fundamentalist adherent to religion as you can get, I am also as far away from being an atheist as you can get. The two are not mutually exclusive.










SuzeCheri -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 2:07:08 PM)

I have tried about 10 times to reply to what has been said, but it just ends up being a repetition of what I said before. I have little or nothing to add at this point, it's been a long 9 hours since I last posted.  Maybe I will think of something new to add later, but right now I'm tired and there just doesn't seem to be anything said here that I haven't already responded to.

I have asked several times why there is evil in the world and the only people who have attempted an answer say they don't know. Well I do. I know why.

Because God wants it that way. He wants wars, disease, suffering, murders, rapes, cancers, and all the other horrible things that exist. He even wants love to be a source of pain.

How do I know he wants it this way?

Because he made it this way.

Think about that for a while and then tell me how that goes along with a kind, loving, just god?




Moonhead -> RE: I renounce Christianity (9/30/2011 2:19:03 PM)

I suggest you google "theodicy" ladies: believe it or not, Christian churches have spent centuries making excuses for what you (quite rightly imo) see as God's negligence.




Page: <<   < prev  5 6 [7] 8 9   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.140625