RE: newty simultaneously panders,flip-flops,demagogues,... - 1/31/2012 8:32:18 AM
|
|
|
Owner59
Posts: 17033
Joined: 3/14/2006 From: Dirty Jersey Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: leonine It's worse than that: they also want a ban on anything developed with the use of stem cell research at any stage. That would not only pull a lot of important medicines off the shelves: as they themselves have noted, it would also ban Pepsi! OTOH, to be fair, if you believe that something is wrong in principle, the idea that it creates jobs is not going to change your stand. A lot of people want to see an end to the international arms trade, which indubitably supports some of the last major engineering industries left in the US. The argument is always that you don't shut the relevant industries down, you redirect them to making or doing something ethically acceptable. In the case of the arms factories, it might be wind and wave energy systems: in the case of biotech, research into making stem cells without using embryonic tissue. Which is indeed worth doing, and is going on, because embryonic tissue is a limited resource and uses for stem cells are increasing explosively. Great post and couldn`t agree more about principals,right/wrong and living with our choices. One point tho on the stem-cell research issue.The right-to-life crowd has latched onto stem cell research and claims it is a right to life issue,where nothing could be further from the truth. The stem cells left over from in vitro fertilization are what is at issue. These are left over eggs that will never become viable unless their owners(the parents) choose to have more kids and implant them. Otherwise they sit frozen,virtually forever. . Some arguments I`ve heard say,"well it`s human "life" right,and would be person if implanted and doesn`t die,right? With this logic,all left over eggs, after a couple was successful at getting prego,must also be made viable, otherwise we`re taking a life. Which is fucking ridiculous. Anyone who is against creating in vitro fertilized eggs for any reason,is against in vitro fertilization,period and is against the thousands of couples who have had kids with this method and ultimately,is against those thousands of kids who would otherwise,not be born.
< Message edited by Owner59 -- 1/31/2012 8:34:44 AM >
_____________________________
"As for our common defense, we reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals" President Obama
|
|
|