Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


cloudboy -> Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 12:55:53 PM)

Here's a story that helps sum up the new American economy:

Popular Wrench Fights a Chinese Rival

Loyalty and "patriotism" are dead behind the alter of cheap workers, corporate greed, and bottomless profit motives.

Mr. Brown sees a broader issue than just the fate of his wrench. “Our situation is an example of why we’re not getting jobs out of innovation,” he said. “When people get the innovation, they go right offshore. What happened to me is what happened to so many people so many times, and we just don’t talk about it.”

Believe it or not, Bain Capital is player in the story as well.




SadistDave -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 4:33:11 PM)

The only thing Bain has to do with the story is that they are planning to buy the overseas company after the fact.

Which is to say that Bain really had absolutely nothing to do with the Bionic Wrench having it's design ripped off t be made overseas.

-SD-




cloudboy -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 4:41:27 PM)

Bain capital is besides the point, yes, but one clear thing stands out: Bain Capital was not helping the inventor and job creator -- and probably has a scant record of ever taking a pro-American position in the market.

After reading this, I feel I should boycott craftsman tools. What a bunch of slime balls. But then again, think how hard it is to buy anything that's not "made in China." God knows my APPLE computer was made there.




SadistDave -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 7:04:01 PM)

If Bain were beside the point then the article would not go out of it's way to mention the irrelevant connection to a story that happened long before Bain entered the picture, and you would not have gone out of your way to repeat the irrelevancy. Indeed, you went out of your way to repeat the point...

I think it's also pretty clear that Obama did not do anything to help the inventor and job creator either, so he is equally to blame in all of this. His involvement in the Bionic Wrench being ripped off and pirated overseas is precisely the same as Bains involvement was. After all, a lot of Oblamers stimulus money went overseas. This administration isn't really all that interested in the "Made in America" label either.

-SD-




tazzygirl -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 7:05:23 PM)

quote:

Oblamers


Who?




DesideriScuri -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 7:05:35 PM)

FR,

    quote:

    The company that makes the Max Axess wrench and other tools for Craftsman, the Apex Tool Group, is being acquired by Bain Capital, the company founded by Mitt Romney, in a $1.6 billion deal.

    Throughout the presidential campaign, Bain was criticized on the grounds that it encouraged outsourcing by companies it buys at the expense of American workers. Apex makes many of its tools overseas. A company spokesman referred all questions to Sears.


Absolutely no need to bring Bain Capital up at all. Guess we know if this blogger is biased now, eh?

To be sure, I'm shocked this hand tool is made over seas. Most of the hand tools are made by Danaher (which also makes Matco Tools, Allen brand, Armstrong, GearWrench, and a few others I don't remember any more). Gear Wrench is made in Taiwan, but Craftsman and Armstrong were made in the USA. Danaher either buys the innovations, or makes the innovations themselves, and then puts them to use in several of their brands. This may not be a Craftsman lawsuit, but one that gets put on Danaher or Apex.

Craftsman makes nothing. Nothing at all. Everything is made for them.




Owner59 -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 7:07:03 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SadistDave

After all, a lot of Oblamers stimulus money went overseas. 
-SD-


You`re lying.......




cloudboy -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 7:21:27 PM)

The company that makes the Max Axess wrench and other tools for Craftsman, the Apex Tool Group, is being acquired by Bain Capital, the company founded by Mitt Romney, in a $1.6 billion deal.

Throughout the presidential campaign, Bain was criticized on the grounds that it encouraged outsourcing by companies it buys at the expense of American workers. Apex makes many of its tools overseas. A company spokesman referred all questions to Sears.


I'm sure Bain capital acquired Apex to boost its American workforce. Apex is the Company that provided Sears with the Chinese knock-off. That's the dovetail with the story. Bain is working with the dark forces against the laudable, American entrepreneur. [The Bionic Wrench was greeted with enthusiasm at trade shows and in industrial design competitions, and the company survived the downturn in 2008. Mr. Brown resisted overtures from large chain stores that wanted to sell the tool under their proprietary brand, he said, and rejected the lure of cheaper manufacturing in China. “I was raised a different way,” he said. ]

-------

This story is more about slimeball business practices (Sears assholes) and a rigged game that undercuts American companies. The story is a small metaphor for American manufacturers and the difficulties true job American job creators face in the global market. We are basically told that "free trade is a good thing," but if Americans lose their jobs to companies that pay slave wages and pollute the environment by outsourcing to China, it seems we might want to draft a new set market rules. I'm not an economist and don't have my hands on all the levers at play here, but this story really struck me as one of the big drivers of American unemployment.

“I’m in favor of free trade,” Mr. Brown said. “The person who’s out-innovated loses. But it’s destructive when someone competes but doesn’t out-innovate, they just produce it in a different market without regard to safety codes and human conditions.”




SadistDave -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 7:30:37 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Owner59

quote:

ORIGINAL: SadistDave

After all, a lot of Oblamers stimulus money went overseas. 
-SD-


You`re lying.......


No, you are apparently unaware that South Korea, Mexico, Japan, and Great Britain are foreign countries.

Maybe you would rather hear it direct from the horses ass...

You libs have a habit of being tragically uninformed...

-SD-




tazzygirl -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/11/2012 9:08:09 PM)

Politifact and Factchecker disagree with you. But, dont let that stop your rant.




SadistDave -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 10:18:24 AM)

Lets see... who to believe... Do I believe fact checkers that have been known to sugar coat (read "lie about") things that make their favorite politicians look good, or do I believe the administrations media mouthpiece? I mean, gosh, all Jay Carney did in that video clip was grudgingly admit to a room full of alleged journalists that there was money going overseas and that they designed the stimulus that way.

I suppose if the fact checkers were interested in facts, they would have looked into that a little better instead of deciding it wasn't factually correct based on the inconvenient fact that it IS factually correct.

In their "final analysis" of a claim that 2 billion dollars of the stimulus was spent in China, they decided that over 2 billion dollars of stimulus money went to companies overseas, but they stilled ruled it a false claim. Why? Because less than the 2 billion went to China.

Their breakdown in debunking the claim that 2 billion dollars went to China for wind power. This is just the wind power claim that can be found here.

quote:

For the curious, here is the national breakdown for the number of turbines installed in the U.S. from 2009 to 2011, according to the American Wind Energy Association and the Congressional Research Service:

United States - GE, Clipper - 49 percent
Germany - Siemens, RePower, Nordex -15 percent
Denmark - Vestas - 15 percent
Spain - Gamesa - 7 percent
India - Suzlon - 6 percent
Japan - Mitsubishi - 6 percent
All others - 2 percent

Our ruling

The Americans for Tax Reform flyer said the Obama administration funneled about $2 billion in "green" stimulus money to foreign companies, with particular benefits for China.

On the dollars, the claim understates the amount that went to foreign owned companies. It was certainly more than $2 billion, which would bolster the group’s claim.


Then Politifact went on to say that they just didn't like the way that sounded. They felt that since people in Americans were getting jobs and profits here in America as a result of investing billions of dollars going to Germany, Denmark, Spain, etc., then it shouldn't be counted as stimulus money being spent overseas.

In the loony leftist Politifact world, it only counts as a negative when private companies like Bain invest money overseas and bring profits and jobs home to America. If you take tax money and give it to other countries, it is perfectly acceptable. The unfortunate fact remains that while disproving the claim that China received exceptionally large amounts of stimulus money to develop wind power, Politifact points out that over 50% of the money slated to wind power went to overseas interests.

-SD-




thompsonx -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 10:33:04 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SadistDave

The only thing Bain has to do with the story is that they are planning to buy the overseas company after the fact.

Which is to say that Bain really had absolutely nothing to do with the Bionic Wrench having it's design ripped off t be made overseas.

-SD-


So you are in favor of this sort of rip off or not?




SadistDave -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 11:15:14 AM)

Before I answer that, I want to add this...

Apex Tool (the Chinese manufacturer) is owned by Armstrong Tool. Armstrong tool is an American company with a military contract that supplies tools made by Apex to the United States government.

So, I want to reiterate that the Federal Government does not give a damn about the Made in America label, and in this case it appears that the Obama administration is more guilty if aiding and abetting patent piracy than Bain has been.

Now... to your question:

I agree that patents should be protected to a degree. However, I do not think that improvements or adaptations of an idea or design should be punished because they are based on an existing design. Let's take this wrench. It utilizes a handle and a ratchet mechanism. I'm betting that handles and ratchet mechanisms existed long before this particular design, which means they are just an improvement on existing technology. So when someone comes along with an idea that improves the design of this wrench, they should not be penalized.

However, I think that a patent should have protections from blatant rip offs that offer no tangible improvements to a design. Reproducing a product that is less expensive, less functional, or poorly made should have penalties to a point. At some point designs need to become accessible to everyone though. Innovation rarely occurs without public domain.

Here, we're talking about a wrench. In most cases I will probably be able to use other tools to do exactly what this wrench does. In many cases I would probably use another kind of wrench. This is not groundbreaking technology and I don't think it really deserves the same sort of protections that should apply to life saving equipment, military technology or designs with scientific applications.

-SD-




cloudboy -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 4:24:09 PM)


Yes, I think 99% of all Americans can spot who is wearing the white hat here. This guy is like meeting someone who roots for the Empire and its use of the Death Star.




tazzygirl -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 4:36:04 PM)

quote:

Is our stimulus money paying for traffic lights on Chinese streets?

A TV ad running in eight states blames President Barack Obama for sending stimulus money overseas while Americans are out of work.

"Tell President Obama, American tax dollars should help American taxpayers," the narrator says. Instead, $2.3 billion in tax credits funded jobs in Mexico, Finland and China, the ad claims.


2.3 billion ,,, but you claim its all in China... yet Americans for Prosperity claim 2.3 went to Finland and Mexico as well.

Do let us know when you all have it figured out.

quote:

Here’s the string of claims, starting with an image of the president signing a bill:


Washington promised to create American jobs. We passed their stimulus. But that's not what happened. Fact: Billions of taxpayer dollars spent on green energy went to jobs in foreign countries. The Obama administration admitted the truth, that $2.3 billion of tax credits went overseas, while millions of Americans can't find a job. $1.2 billion to a solar company that's building a plant in Mexico. Half a billion to an electric car company that created hundreds of jobs in Finland. And tens of millions of dollars to build traffic lights in China.

We’ve rated two claims from the ad, about stimulus tax credits supposedly funding a plant in Mexico (Pants on Fire) and paying for jobs in Finland (False). In this fact-check, we’re examining if those tax credits included "tens of millions of dollars to build traffic lights in China."



quote:

Our ruling

We watched this ad and imagined Chinese street corners with shiny new American-funded traffic lights.

The reality is nearly the opposite: American cities, counties and states bought and installed new energy-efficient street and traffic lights with stimulus grants. Many of those lights contained foreign components, including some from China, but it’s simply not clear how much stimulus money went toward those parts during the eight months it was allowed.

The ad’s claim has a tiny sliver of truth, but it pairs words and images to create an altogether different impression. We’ll have to put the brakes on this traffic light claim, and rate it Mostly False.

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/may/03/americans-prosperity/ad-says-stimulus-tax-credits-funded-streetlights-c/

As I have previously posted, China owns 10% of our debt. The boogie man isnt over seas.




DesideriScuri -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 5:29:45 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SadistDave
I agree that patents should be protected to a degree. However, I do not think that improvements or adaptations of an idea or design should be punished because they are based on an existing design. Let's take this wrench. It utilizes a handle and a ratchet mechanism. I'm betting that handles and ratchet mechanisms existed long before this particular design, which means they are just an improvement on existing technology. So when someone comes along with an idea that improves the design of this wrench, they should not be penalized.
-SD-


Did you just say he didn't build that?!? [8D]




LookieNoNookie -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 7:36:05 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: cloudboy

Here's a story that helps sum up the new American economy:

Popular Wrench Fights a Chinese Rival

Loyalty and "patriotism" are dead behind the alter of cheap workers, corporate greed, and bottomless profit motives.

Mr. Brown sees a broader issue than just the fate of his wrench. “Our situation is an example of why we’re not getting jobs out of innovation,” he said. “When people get the innovation, they go right offshore. What happened to me is what happened to so many people so many times, and we just don’t talk about it.”

Believe it or not, Bain Capital is player in the story as well.


Wow...Bain Capital had absolutely zero to do with this event.

Stunning.




LookieNoNookie -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 7:43:03 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: cloudboy

The company that makes the Max Axess wrench and other tools for Craftsman, the Apex Tool Group, is being acquired by Bain Capital, the company founded by Mitt Romney, in a $1.6 billion deal.

Throughout the presidential campaign, Bain was criticized on the grounds that it encouraged outsourcing by companies it buys at the expense of American workers. Apex makes many of its tools overseas. A company spokesman referred all questions to Sears.


I'm sure Bain capital acquired Apex to boost its American workforce. Apex is the Company that provided Sears with the Chinese knock-off. That's the dovetail with the story. Bain is working with the dark forces against the laudable, American entrepreneur. [The Bionic Wrench was greeted with enthusiasm at trade shows and in industrial design competitions, and the company survived the downturn in 2008. Mr. Brown resisted overtures from large chain stores that wanted to sell the tool under their proprietary brand, he said, and rejected the lure of cheaper manufacturing in China. “I was raised a different way,” he said. ]

-------

This story is more about slimeball business practices (Sears assholes) and a rigged game that undercuts American companies. The story is a small metaphor for American manufacturers and the difficulties true job American job creators face in the global market. We are basically told that "free trade is a good thing," but if Americans lose their jobs to companies that pay slave wages and pollute the environment by outsourcing to China, it seems we might want to draft a new set market rules. I'm not an economist and don't have my hands on all the levers at play here, but this story really struck me as one of the big drivers of American unemployment.

“I’m in favor of free trade,” Mr. Brown said. “The person who’s out-innovated loses. But it’s destructive when someone competes but doesn’t out-innovate, they just produce it in a different market without regard to safety codes and human conditions.”


After the fact....and as you all may have read....."the company founded by Mitt Romney" is no longer run by Mitt Romney, nor is he involved in ANY decision making at same.

(Reading is fundamental).

By the way....FORD is no longer run by or managed by Henry Ford.

Chevrolet (later to become GM) is no longer run by a gentleman by the name of William Durant.

Dodge is no longer run by the Dodge brothers.....and....believe it or not....

Apple is no longer run by either of the two co-founders.

(I swear.....honest).




SadistDave -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 9:42:04 PM)

I know you don't have basic comprehension skills, but do try to keep up.

Read slowly.

Sound out words you don't understand.

If big words are too hard, skip them. I'll try not to use any that might confuse you more.

I said stimulus money was spent "overseas". You stated that Politifact and Factchecker disagree with me. Then I used a Politifact article on China to show you that, in fact, stimulus money was spent "overseas".

Savvy?

-SD-




tazzygirl -> RE: Sears pulls a Walmart on the Bionic Wrench (11/12/2012 11:41:19 PM)

Pst.... Your youtube link....

Jay Carney admits 2009 stimulus spent money to create jobs overseas

He never once said that during the while time.

Pst... Mexico is now "overseas"?

quote:

In their "final analysis" of a claim that 2 billion dollars of the stimulus was spent in China, they decided that over 2 billion dollars of stimulus money went to companies overseas, but they stilled ruled it a false claim. Why? Because less than the 2 billion went to China.


Now.. do try and follow along. I know its difficult for you... but do try.

This is the claim....

quote:

The Obama administration admitted the truth, that $2.3 billion of tax credits went overseas, while millions of Americans can't find a job. $1.2 billion to a solar company that's building a plant in Mexico. Half a billion to an electric car company that created hundreds of jobs in Finland. And tens of millions of dollars to build traffic lights in China.


went overseas....

Mexico.. which isnt overseas...

The company didn’t get tax credits, but a $1.2 billion loan guarantee. What’s the difference? The Energy Department expects the loan to be paid back — with interest.

That loan guarantee wasn’t for the Mexico plant — a separate project with its own funding — but to build the California Valley Solar Ranch in San Luis Obispo, Calif. Construction on the California project has already started, with the Energy Department projecting 350 construction jobs and 15 permanent ones. Pacific Gas & Electric Co., the state’s largest utility, will ultimately buy the power.

Most of the solar panels for the California project will come from SunPower’s California manufacturing facility in Milpitas, though given the size of the project, they’ll also come from the company’s plants in Mexico and Asia, Wymer said.

SunPower no longer owns the California Valley Solar Ranch project. The solar project — and the loan guarantee — belong to New Jersey company NRG Energy. That’s the company that will get the federal loan money, and be responsible for repaying taxpayers.


So much for Mexico....

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/may/02/americans-prosperity/ad-says-stimulus-tax-credits-funded-solar-company-/

Finland....

The first clue something’s wrong is in that ABC News headline. A car company got a "U.S. loan." That’s not the same thing as a tax credit. Taxpayers expect to get loan money back, with interest. (Though, they don’t always. See: Solyndra.)

Things get even more wrong from there.

That U.S. loan program? It's the Advanced Technology Vehicles Manufacturing program through the Energy Department. And it's not funded by Obama’s stimulus bill — otherwise known as the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. It is, in fact, a program signed into existence by President George W. Bush in 2007 and first funded by legislation Bush signed in 2008.


http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/may/03/americans-prosperity/ad-says-stimulus-tax-credits-funded-jobs-finland/

So much for Finland....

China....

The traffic light fiasco is in my previous post.

Windmills in China

Windmills from China have something of a history when it comes to political messaging. The Romney campaign sent us supporting documents for this claim. Among the reports and articles the campaign cites, one refers to a massive project in Texas that was never built and will never receive stimulus money. Others stem from the Investigative Reporting Workshop, a nonprofit journalism project at American University.

The Investigative Reporting Workshop’s report backs the claim but paints a murkier picture than the Romney campaign would have you think. The author tallied $2.6 million in stimulus money going to Chinese makers of wind turbines. However, the reporter, Russ Choma, also says that none of the farms used turbines entirely built in China. Additionally, he couldn’t say for sure how much stimulus money made its way to China. "Some money definitely did, but it is safe to say more money went to creating jobs in the U.S. and Europe," he wrote.

To choose an example, let’s look at a wind farm going up in Alaska. The lead contractor is General Electric, the world’s third largest supplier of wind turbines and an American firm. But according to the Anchorage Daily News, "The blades are made in Brazil, the units that contain the generator come from Southern California, the connecting hubs from the Florida Panhandle and the towers are made in China."

We called the American Wind Energy Association, an industry trade group, to see if they knew of any Chinese turbines paid for with American stimulus dollars. They said they did. Their best guess is the number is six -- five in Texas and one in Iowa. But "that might not be exactly right," said Liz Salerno, director of industry data and analysis . "Because some of the blades and towers in Texas might have come from American firms."

If it is six, that represents a tiny fraction of all the turbines installed with stimulus dollars. Salerno says the program funded more than 12,000 turbine installations over three years. Chinese components might have shown up in various places, but if one is counting complete Chinese "windmills," then they account for less than 1 percent of the total.


http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/oct/11/paul-ryan/ryan-says-stimulus-dollars-paid-electric-cars-finl/

So the ad.. and the GOP... jumped on three places.. got two totally wrong.. and the last mostly wrong.. and you want a cookie?




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625