RE: Who gets to decide? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


LadyPact -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 6:17:12 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CynthiaWVirginia
Two cavemen worlds apart invents the wheel. Eventually each society evolves and goes out into space...(or on the internet)...and finally meet. One leather caveman says, "We invented the wheel first. You have to learn our secret knock code and earn our decoder ring if you're going to use the wheel in any way, shape or form, okay? Your wheel sizes are not labeled correctly, here, use our standard tape measure because you're doing it all wrong."

Former cave dude from the non-aligned world says, "No thanks. We've invented the wheel just fine without your help. If your size and shape labels work for you, that's great. We prefer how WE handle our own wheels...and btw, our planetary system spins around just fine too, so...thanks for your offer to fix us but we're doing fine on our own."



Except that it isn't quite correct.

While a number of BDSM folks rail about how they "did just fine on their own," it's not really the case. It was the leather community that opened certain doors that the BDSM community benefited from. Whether that be fighting to open clubs, starting cons for educational opportunities, and even often leather folks who have started groups that have welcomed all kinky folks. MAsT most certainly has leather roots and wouldn't exist if it hadn't been started by leathermen.

Most people want to ignore it, but the leather community has contributed a lot to the BDSM community.





frazzle -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 7:30:25 PM)

That might work in the USA, but it doesn't in the UK.

Oh and BDSM has been here just as long.




DesFIP -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 8:32:16 PM)

The gay leather culture has influenced many het people. It's driven away just as many seeing as it was primarily devoted to short term sexual relationships.

Having grown up seeing them in action, I shied as far away from it as possible. Because nowhere in that was there any example of a long term, loving, monogamous relationship.

The other thing about label is that it is relationship specific for many of us. We started as a non power relationship with a lot of play. We progressed to dom/sub. It took years before his authority became as widespread in my life as it now is.

If this relationship ended, I wouldn't enter into another power relationship. So my label has changed from bottom to sub to slave and could well change in another relationship to fuck buddy. Gazelles can't change their spots (to mix a metaphor). People, thank God, aren't gazelles.




CynthiaWVirginia -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 9:13:15 PM)



I think I went off on some tangent in my last post, so I'll try to just stick with these questions and answer them.


quote:

who decides on someone’s label? The person or the community? Do other people tell you what you are or do you get to tell them?

There is more than one community within the BDSM umbrella, and I believe that each community would decide if you were a zebra trying to pass yourself off as a lion. Within a Gorean community, I doubt labeling myself a Mistress who owns a slave would go over well. I have an uncle in Ohio and several other male relatives who are into the Christian male dominance thing, and my being in a relationship where I'm head of household doesn't go over well. Within leather...it was a dream I once had but the train has long since left the station. I'm almost 50, and would not uncollar my slave so I could go learn from the bottom up how to be a leather Master. Seeing me in a submissive role to anyone, even if just as a learning experience, would crush bo's spirit. He would see it as abusive, even if I assured him it wasn't. Driving him crazy and losing what we have...is not worth it. I will have to learn more on my own terms, at a pace that will not harm either of us.

So...we have to find out for ourselves who we are and where we fit into the lifestyle. The others within our BDSM communities...will also decide for themselves if they think we have labeled ourselves correctly. I like labels, because they give us a good starting point and can prevent misunderstandings, and anger and non-consensual violence.

I've already had someone get all judgmental on my boy at a low time in his life, saying that he wasn't really a slave. I get tired of all the "you must be a perfect submissive, never angry at life or at your owner or else you're not a real slave" attitude that goes around, and my protective instincts make me want to rip the offender a new ass.

I didn't respect the "slave" friend of his that attacked bo's slavehood. I judged the now ex-friend as a judgmental attention whore slave wannabe, with a huge side order of "Do me!" [sm=angel.gif] I've seen similar things going on in the groups we belong to, where folks don't agree on labels, whether self given or community given. Deciding who has mastered certain aspects of play is easy...compared with judging who is capable of mastering...the right human being.




CynthiaWVirginia -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 9:30:32 PM)



quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyPact

quote:

ORIGINAL: CynthiaWVirginia
Two cavemen worlds apart invents the wheel. Eventually each society evolves and goes out into space...(or on the internet)...and finally meet. One leather caveman says, "We invented the wheel first. You have to learn our secret knock code and earn our decoder ring if you're going to use the wheel in any way, shape or form, okay? Your wheel sizes are not labeled correctly, here, use our standard tape measure because you're doing it all wrong."

Former cave dude from the non-aligned world says, "No thanks. We've invented the wheel just fine without your help. If your size and shape labels work for you, that's great. We prefer how WE handle our own wheels...and btw, our planetary system spins around just fine too, so...thanks for your offer to fix us but we're doing fine on our own."



Except that it isn't quite correct.

While a number of BDSM folks rail about how they "did just fine on their own," it's not really the case. It was the leather community that opened certain doors that the BDSM community benefited from. Whether that be fighting to open clubs, starting cons for educational opportunities, and even often leather folks who have started groups that have welcomed all kinky folks. MAsT most certainly has leather roots and wouldn't exist if it hadn't been started by leathermen.

Most people want to ignore it, but the leather community has contributed a lot to the BDSM community.




I do see your point, LP, and I'm sure that many people who have benefited from leather people paving the way for greater acceptance and education, etc., wouldn't feel like they are separate and self-educated, away from the leather community.

Finding a MAsT group, after being at least eight years without any sign of leather people, has been nice. However, I have to drive three hours (on the toll freeway) each way to get there. If my starting point wasn't NOW from bo's house, only an hour and a half each way to MAsT, and if he wasn't paying for the gas...there is no way I would be able to attend.

Mainly I've been going...to show my support and to help the community get bigger. We can only count on one other couple being there, the host and his slave. On an average meetup, two other people show up. If we're very lucky, four others...for a grand total of eight.

Looking at the people listed in my town or nearby on CM's other side, it may seem like a lot of people are active in the r/t community. Hah. Yeah, for cybering or the occasional one on one session. Actually, I don't believe I've ever topped anyone from my own town. Neighboring towns, yes. From far far away, hell yes. Munches can't stay open for long without folding up. To my knowledge, there has never been a munch group in my county within the past ten years.

When I go to play parties...they are private parties. There are no BDSM groups that have dungeons and take responsibility for educating newbies. I haven't seen any benefits in my area, and I can only talk about my own personal experience. I've never been to a convention, never been to a dungeon. The only leather people I've met in r/t or known from online have been from CM and Fet, and yes, I have been envious of the places you've been and the things you have seen. None of the people I've met in my town, ones who visited me from neighboring towns or other states have had any r/t exposure to the leather community. Except for one person. A lady who met up with bo and I at a restaurant...and yelled out the word "VAGINA!" at least four dozen times.

You leather folk that I see online are the ones that represent the leather community to us hillbillies and rednecks stranded in the butt end of the universe. I also have to say again...that leather people had no part of helping me learn my way in BDSM and D/s. Until possibly recently, in the past two years.

MAsT groups cannot throw play parties to educate new members about BDSM safeties or else they would lose their charter.

I had to beg and plead at random, semi-appropriate times so that others in the Charleston and Cross Lanes area would organize and decide to give a demonstration. I've participated in a rope demo twice...and my dyslexia conquers all. I've been using restraints these past ten years and find some rope work hawt, but it's the end result I find arousing, not the grunt work. Especially when I mess up and my work is uneven. We haven't bought our own ropes yet and finances won't allow it for at least until after the holidays.

Part of one of the demos I saw was for electrical safeties. This was before we bought our own e-stim. I would like see what kinky others would do with one of these that we haven't discovered on our own yet. The regular flogging demo...I myself could have given it, BUT...being on my own all these years has given me something of a social phobia. I'm trying to get more comfortable with watching others do their thing, as well as trying to get used to having others watch while I scene. Back to the flogging thing. I am separating normal flogging, that I am used to, from Florentine demos. I saw someone (leather) demonstrating Florentine and it totally blew me away. She was AWESOME. So was the time I watched her use a whip. In ten years...I've only been able to see things that were way beyond my skill level twice. (If it were possible, I'd be watching stuff like this every weekend.)

In areas of the USA where leather communities have influence...yay. I envy them. I envy the passing on of skills. I envy them for having the freedom to open up clubs and have dungeons, because in my area...this is one of the most ignorant, bigoted and proud of it, areas of the bible belt. My slave is called "faggot" and pervert and is sometimes treated like sh*t by total strangers...and if they could get away with dragging him behind some pickup truck till he was dead, some drunken asshat would. (Nobody was surprised when that private, members only club, a titty bar, lol, that was too nearby to four churches burnt to the ground.)

All the freedoms leather people have worked so hard for, IMHO, haven't reached the four corners of the earth yet. I'm going to get too old to lift a flogger and will probably be dead before any significant leather community is established in my area of WV. [;)]

I guess I've been on my own for two long. If someone leather educates others and says, "In leather, we do it this way. These labels are very precise and mean this to us" I'd be standing up clapping my hands. It's when I feel any "this is THE right way" for the entire community, and especially the "we invented sadism/masochism/owner/property and you're doing it wrong"...um, that's when I growl softly under my breath.





SerWhiteTiger -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 10:14:28 PM)

I decide. And I have decided the following:

I am a Martian.
AdorkableAiley, you are Iranian
angelikaJ, you are subdominant
kalikshama, you are a giant duck
lilcracker, you're a big cracker now
TigressLily, you're cold as ice. You're willing to sacrifice our love.
LadyPact, you scare me a bit
poise, I agree that you are delightfully dirty
fucktoyprincess, you're hot blooded, check it and see
kiwisub12, you're a bird!
CynthiaWVirginia, you're a... pegacowsheepthing?
stef, you are a true something or other
frazzle, you're a Fraggle
Kana, you're a katana!
DesFIP, I'm getting bored and less and less original, are we done?




TigressLily -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 10:45:11 PM)


OMG, if you only knew! . . . Nobody's ever accused me of being cold as ice, or even a cold bitch.


quote:

ORIGINAL: SerWhiteTiger

I decide. And I have decided the following:

I am a Martian....

TigressLily, you're cold as ice. You're willing to sacrifice our love....


But you're a Martian--you should know by now I don't do ET Play. No exceptions.

_____________________________

* * * Not A Fetish/Kink Delivery System * * *




SerWhiteTiger -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/8/2013 11:02:30 PM)

Yep. You've sacrificed our love.




ChatteParfaitt -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 2:50:52 AM)

I agree with this:


quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyPact



People get to define themselves the way that they want, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the community is going to agree with that definition. I think it's also going to depend on which "community" that people are talking about. I find more often that the supposed "online community" is more likely to agree with any self imposed label that a person gives themselves. The "I'm a brand new Master with no experience" is more likely to get a pass on certain message boards. The same person walking into a leather event with the same proclamation isn't going to have the same kind of agreement with that statement. I've seen similar reactions happen on the Gorean forum when a male posts that he is a brand new Master, but he's never read a book.

Even in the mix that is the real life BDSM community, somebody coming to their first event, declaring their brand new Master status, but has no experience doesn't really go over very well. They do get welcomed, but there is also some eye rolling and whispers of "oh, great, another one who thinks they know what they are doing because they read stuff on the internet."



Labels, or people thinking others have to fit how they define a label can be confusing. For instance, the first time I met this friend of Himself's, he would give me very curious looks at times, obviously thinking I wasn't very 'sub.' Finally he asked me and I said switch. I could see the understanding in his face. Now I made sense to him.

I think one issue with brand new people is they try to fit the label, instead of spending some time exploring and self reflecting to determine what label best suits.





JeffBC -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 6:37:40 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: AdorkableAiley
What say you?

The least secure person decides.




SerWhiteTiger -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 8:46:09 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: JeffBC

quote:

ORIGINAL: AdorkableAiley
What say you?

The least secure person decides.



Okay, you decide.




DesFIP -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 10:28:29 AM)

I'll trade with Tigress Lily. Parts of me are cold as ice. I wear wool socks and heavy slippers and my feet are always frozen.

To be serious for a moment. It doesn't matter to me how many people give me a label. If it doesn't feel authentic for me, I'm not going to use it. I am not susceptible to peer pressure.




AaNiMaLl -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 11:25:05 AM)

How much control do I want someone else to have over me and mine? None. However, I must acknowledge that I am a social cultural conditioned creature animal so any labelling by someone else is going to have an effect. Everything that we do is shared with people around us and that is a good thing. It is the primary predictor of happiness. No man is an island. So the extent to which I am social, the labelling of others has power. The extent to which I am independent, the labels have no power. However, I have control over the way that I am labelled AND the way that other people label me. I am what I am what I am what I am what I ammm. ...I have control and I am controlled by my roles / labels. The part to pay attention to is not letting the labels of others control my life. I think this goes for submissives and dominants.




KnightofMists -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 3:53:11 PM)

A person can label himself anyway that he wants! I will still Label him a prick!





SerWhiteTiger -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 4:55:47 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: KnightofMists

A person can label himself anyway that he wants! I will still Label him a prick!




I'm a Martian prick.




TigressLily -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 5:35:27 PM)

Oh, so that's why it's green. [sm=alien.gif]

Allegedly.


quote:

ORIGINAL: SerWhiteTiger

I'm a Martian prick.


(Someone else was going to say that anyway!)

_____________________________

* * * Not A Fetish/Kink Delivery System * * *




littlewonder -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 8:24:25 PM)

people tell me all the time what I am.

At work some people call me an IT tech, others call me an admin, others call me a facilitator. Each one is actually different but similar in some ways. Does it bother me? No, and I don't bother correcting them either. It's just not worth the effort. It's just not important. It's annoying but not important. Nothing is going to change in my life because they gave me a different label.

Same goes for bdsm.




MalcolmNathaniel -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 8:44:40 PM)

I agree with Dave.

Unfortunately, Dave's not here man.




SerWhiteTiger -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 9:24:45 PM)

It's worth noting that if you're a slave, your Master decides your labels.




SerWhiteTiger -> RE: Who gets to decide? (10/9/2013 9:27:17 PM)

[image]http://www.totallyhonestreviews.com/images/kidhittingbeehive.gif[/image]




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3 4   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
4.699707E-02